Sections
project - Research and innovation
i2connect - Connecting advisers to boost interactive innovation in agriculture and forestry
i2connect - Connecting advisers to boost interactive innovation in agriculture and forestry
Kontext
In Europe, there are a good examples showing advisors active as innovation brokers and facilitators in "interactive innovation projects", but these examples are still limited in number. Rural Development programmes offer funding in European regions for EIP-AGRI Operational Groups aimed at stimulating such interactive processes for bridging the gap between practice and research. Farm and Forestry advisors are still considered to support the “linear knowledge transfer model”. There is still lack of understanding about what is behind the specific roles of advisors in the different stages of the process and the necessary competencies going along with it. Moreover, implications for advisory organisations for their managers and further AKIS decision makers to create an enabling environment for innovative advisors and innovation processes are unclear. This hampers the effectiveness of the EIP-AGRI programme and other interactive innovation initiatives in the EU.
However, there are many new and original cases of innovation support provided by farm and forestry advisors across Europe, induced by recent EU policies. Many of these examples have not been systematically exploited to update the advisors’ communities in a given country and even less to advisors in the wider EU contexts. Replicable best practices must be made available to other advisors through information, dedicated tools, formal training, peer-to-peer learning and networking activities. Furthermore, there is a need for awareness-raising of managers of advisory services and/or managing authorities at an EU-wide level, so as to develop an “innovation culture” among managers of advisory services and AKIS actors.
Objectives
i2connect aims to fuel the competencies of advisors who will support and facilitate interactive innovation processes responding to multiple challenges in European agriculture and forestry. i2connect focuses on i) creating a professional network of advisors aimed at mutual coaching and experience sharing; ii) strengthening their skills and competencies, through the identification of best practices of advice across Europe and developing of a targeted training program, peers networking and cross visits; iii) strengthening their role through a better understanding of National AKIS and iv) identifying tools that contribute to an enabling and inclusive environment for advisory services.
Objectives
see Objectives in English
Activities
The project is organised in 7 Work packages: - WP1: bases, frames & approaches for joint action (inc. the production of 30 National AKIS reports & the development of the AS Database)
- WP2: Identify & analyse best practices from a range of practical cases across Europe
- WP3: Develop tools, methods & didactical strategies to strengthen advisor’s capacity to support
interactive innovation
- WP4: Facilitate the innovation network through training sessions, cross-visits, pilot projects, networking activities & summer schools for future advisors
- WP5: Communication, dissemination & synergies
- WP6 & 7: involves the project management, coordination & Ethics issues
Activities
The same as previous version (English)
Project details
- Main funding source
- Horizon 2020 (EU Research and Innovation Programme)
- Type of Horizon project
- Multi-actor project
Ort
- Main geographical location
- Paris
EUR 4 999 943.00
Total budget
Total contributions including EU funding.
Project keyword
- Animal husbandry
- Animal welfare
- Biodiversity and nature
- Climate change (incl. GHG reduction, adaptation and mitigation, and other air related issues)
- Competitiveness/new business models
- Farm diversification
- Forestry
- Pest/disease control in plants
- Pest/disease control in animals
- Soil
- AKIS, incl. advice, training, on-farm demo, interactive innovation projects
Ressourcen
Links
- i2connect Facebook account
- i2connect Twitter account
- i2connect Linkedin account
- i2connect Youtube channel
- i2connect page in Cordis
- i2connect page in EIP-Agri website
- i2connect page in AC3A website
- APCA website
- AUA website
- ILVO website
- NAAS website
- EUFRAS website
- IALB website
- SEASN website
- ProAgria website
- ACTA website
- UHOH website
- NAK website
- CIRCA website
- TEAGASC website
- CREA website
- LLKC website
- LAAS website
- CDR website
- CONSULAI website
- MAPAMA website
- AGRIDEA website
- ZLTO website
- WR website
- SZE website
- SZE website
- SZE website
200 Practice Abstracts
In the Trust Walk exercise, a facilitator sets up a “minefield” using scattered objects in an open area. Participants are paired up, with one person blindfolded and the other sighted. The sighted partner guides the blindfolded through the minefield using only verbal instructions. This exercise highlights the critical roles of communication and trust, as the blindfolded partner must rely entirely on their partner's directions to avoid obstacles. After navigating the course, partners switch roles and repeat the process, enhancing their understanding of both leading and following roles.
This activity is part of the i2connect summer schools, where it is used to explore the dynamics between farmers (blindfolded) and advisors (guides), emphasizing co-creation, knowledge exchange, and the transfer processes. It underscores the importance of trust and clear communication in advisory relationships and provides a vivid, memorable experience that links directly to the challenges and necessities of effective advisory work. Participants reflect on their experiences to discuss the importance of guidance and cooperation, drawing parallels to real-world scenarios in agricultural advising.
In the Trust Walk exercise, a facilitator sets up a “minefield” using scattered objects in an open area. Participants are paired up, with one person blindfolded and the other sighted. The sighted partner guides the blindfolded through the minefield using only verbal instructions. This exercise highlights the critical roles of communication and trust, as the blindfolded partner must rely entirely on their partner's directions to avoid obstacles. After navigating the course, partners switch roles and repeat the process, enhancing their understanding of both leading and following roles.
This activity is part of the i2connect summer schools, where it is used to explore the dynamics between farmers (blindfolded) and advisors (guides), emphasizing co-creation, knowledge exchange, and the transfer processes. It underscores the importance of trust and clear communication in advisory relationships and provides a vivid, memorable experience that links directly to the challenges and necessities of effective advisory work. Participants reflect on their experiences to discuss the importance of guidance and cooperation, drawing parallels to real-world scenarios in agricultural advising.
This is a mime or a play without words. Two lines fairly wide apart are drawn on the floor in chalk to represent the banks of a river. String can also be used if one does not want to draw on the floor. Pieces of paper are used to represent stepping stones in the river and an island (a piece of newsprint) is put in the middle of the river.
Two men come to the river and look for a place to cross. The current is very strong and they are both afraid to cross.
A third man comes along and sees their difficulty. He leads them up the river and shows them the stepping stones. He encourages them to step on them but both are afraid, so he agrees to take one on his back. By the time he gets to the middle of the river, the man on his back seems very heavy and he has become very tired, so he puts him on the little island. The third man goes back to fetch the second who also wants to climb on his back. But the third man refuses. Instead he takes his hand and encourages him to step on the stones himself. Halfway across the second man starts to manage alone. They both cross the river. When they get to the other side, they are extremely pleased with themselves and they walk off together, completely forgetting about the first man, sitting alone on the island. He tries to get their attention, but they do not notice his frantic gestures for help. This exercise can be used in workshops or at the start of an EIP project to sensitise participants to the fact that learning can be achieved much better through their own actions than if others provide a lot of support and solve problems. This can even lead to the helpers themselves no longer having the strength to help.
The exercise was carried out in the summer schools to emphasise the commitment of the individual participants in the learning process. It also creates a relaxed atmosphere.
Dies ist eine Pantomime oder ein Spiel ohne Worte. Mit Kreide werden auf dem Boden zwei Linien (oder zeichenketten) gezeichnet, die ziemlich weit auseinander liegen und die Ufer eines Flusses darstellen. Mit Papierstücken werden Trittsteine im Fluss dargestellt und eine Insel (ein Stück Zeitungspapier) wird in die Mitte des Flusses gelegt. Zwei Männer kommen an den Fluss und suchen nach einer Stelle zum Überqueren. Die Strömung ist sehr stark und sie haben beide Angst, den Fluss zu überqueren. Ein dritter Mann kommt hinzu und sieht ihre Schwierigkeiten. Er führt sie den Fluss hinauf und zeigt ihnen die Trittsteine. Er ermutigt sie, auf die Steine zu treten, aber beide haben Angst, also erklärt er sich bereit, einen auf seinem Rücken zu tragen. Als er die Mitte des Flusses erreicht, scheint der Mann auf seinem Rücken sehr schwer zu sein, und er ist sehr müde, also setzt er ihn auf der kleinen Insel ab. Der dritte Mann geht zurück, um den zweiten zu holen, der ebenfalls auf seinen Rücken klettern will. Aber der dritte Mann weigert sich. Stattdessen nimmt er seine Hand und ermutigt ihn, selbst auf die Steine zu steigen. Auf halber Strecke beginnt der zweite Mann, es allein zu schaffen. Sie überqueren beide den Fluss. Als sie auf der anderen Seite ankommen, sind sie sehr zufrieden mit sich selbst und gehen gemeinsam weiter, wobei sie den ersten Mann, der allein auf der Insel sitzt, völlig vergessen. Er versucht, sie auf sich aufmerksam zu machen, aber sie bemerken seine verzweifelten Gesten um Hilfe nicht. Diese Übung kann im Rahmen eines Workshops oder zu Beginn eines EIP Projektes nützlich sein, um die Teilnehmer dafür zu sensibilisieren, dass Lernen durch eigenes Tun viel besser erreicht werden kann, als wenn andere viel Unterstützung geben und die Probleme lösen.
A prerequisite for fruitful collaboration is often a shared direction or vision. It is important for group members to have a sufficient level of agreement on their collaborative goals for the cooperation to feel meaningful and motivating. In a busy work environment, it can be difficult to generate these dreams. One practically proven method is to use modeling clay. Modeling clay is not commonly used in professional settings, which brings a certain playfulness and creativity to the process, opening up thinking. It is also a material with which few feel significantly more skilled than others, making collaborative work typically equal and natural. It also allows for abstract thinking, which again helps discussions about complex phenomena.
Utilizing this method is fairly simple. The group is tasked with envisioning an ideal situation for a particular topic, such as "What is the dream scenario for AKIS activities in our country?" Additionally, the group is asked to illustrate this with a three-dimensional model or prototype made from modeling clay. Once the model is complete, the group is asked to name it and write down its essential features. By explaining their dream to others, they simultaneously articulate it. The modeling clay model helps distill complex ideas and aids others in remembering the group's presentation.
Implementing the method requires sufficient amounts of modeling clay in various colors and quiet group workspaces. The facilitator must balance playfulness with the work's objectives to maintain creativity without the temptation to deviate from the task through excessive joking.
Hedelmällisen yhteistyön edellytyksenä on usein yhteisesti määritetty suunta tai visio. Ryhmän toimijoiden on tärkeä olla riittävän samaa mieltä, mihin he yhteistyöllään pyrkivät, jotta yhteistyö tuntuu merkitykselliselle ja motivoivalle. Kiireisessä työarjessa voi olla vaikea synnyttää näitä unelmia. Yksi käytännössä hyväksi havaittu tapa on käyttää tässä muovailuvahaa. Muovailuvaha ei ole työelämässä kovin käytetty materiaali ja jo tämä tuo työskentelyyn tiettyä leikillisyyttä ja luovuutta, joka vapauttaa ajattelua. Muovailuvaha on myös materiaali, jonka kanssa harva kokee olevansa muita erityisen paljon taitavampi, jolloin yhdessä työskentely on tyypillisesti tasapuolista ja luontevaa. Se myös mahdollistaa abstaktin ajattelun, jonka avulla kompleksisista ilmiöistä voidaan puhua. Hyödyntäminen on melko yksinkertaista. Ryhmälle annetaan tehtäväksi miettiä jonkin asian unelmatilanne esimerkiksi "Millaista AKIS-toiminta unelmissanne on?" Lisäksi ryhmää pyydetään havainnollistamaan tätä kolmiuloitteisella mallilla tai prototyypillä, jonka he tekevät muovailuvahasta. Kun malli on valmis ryhmää pyydetään vielä antamaan sille nimi ja kirjaamaan ylös sen olennaisimmat seikat. Kertoessaan muille unelmastaan, he samalla sanoittavat sen. Muovailuvahamalli tukee kompleksisen asian kiteytystä ja auttaa muita muistamaan ryhmän esityksen. Menetelmän toteutus vaatii useampaa eri väristä muovailuvahaa riittävät määrät sekä rauhalliset ryhmätyötilat. Fasilitoijan on tärkeää tasapainoilla leikillisyyden ja työn tavoitteellisuuden välillä, jotta työskentelyn luovuus säilyy ilman houkutusta irrottautua tehtäväksiannosta liiallisella vitsailulla.
This role-play exercise sensitizes students to advisory work through a scenario where two individuals hesitate to cross a river due to its strong current. A third person, the "carrier," guides them to stepping stones, demonstrating essential advisory strategies.
The exercise starts with experiential learning as participants enact the situation, enhancing retention through physical and emotional engagement. The "carrier" employs guided discovery by leading to stepping stones, promoting self-directed learning crucial in advisory roles.
Incremental support is showcased when the "carrier" adjusts assistance levels—carrying the first person halfway and only guiding the second by hand. This scaffolding builds confidence and fosters independence, reflecting an advisor’s role in encouraging autonomy.
Participants engage in problem-solving to navigate the river, boosting their critical thinking and decision-making skills. Role differentiation and perspective taking allow experiencing both giving and receiving help, deepening empathy and understanding diverse advisory roles.
The role-play concludes with participants reflecting on their successes after crossing the river, emphasizing the importance of reflection and self-assessment in understanding advisory impacts and fostering continuous growth.
This role-play effectively develops advisory skills, highlighting active participation, independence, and reflective practice.
This role-play exercise sensitizes students to advisory work through a scenario where two individuals hesitate to cross a river due to its strong current. A third person, the "carrier," guides them to stepping stones, demonstrating essential advisory strategies.
The exercise starts with experiential learning as participants enact the situation, enhancing retention through physical and emotional engagement. The "carrier" employs guided discovery by leading to stepping stones, promoting self-directed learning crucial in advisory roles.
Incremental support is showcased when the "carrier" adjusts assistance levels—carrying the first person halfway and only guiding the second by hand. This scaffolding builds confidence and fosters independence, reflecting an advisor’s role in encouraging autonomy.
Participants engage in problem-solving to navigate the river, boosting their critical thinking and decision-making skills. Role differentiation and perspective taking allow experiencing both giving and receiving help, deepening empathy and understanding diverse advisory roles.
The role-play concludes with participants reflecting on their successes after crossing the river, emphasizing the importance of reflection and self-assessment in understanding advisory impacts and fostering continuous growth.
This role-play effectively develops advisory skills, highlighting active participation, independence, and reflective practice.
The learner-centered approach is particularly effective for adult further training, such as introducing new working approaches to rural advisors. It places the learner at the heart of the educational process, tailoring training specifically to the unique needs and rich experiences that these professionals bring to the learning environment. This method emphasizes active participation to foster an engaging atmosphere, crucial for adult learning. The initial setting of a circle of chairs without tables signals a departure from traditional didactic methods, promoting interaction over passive listening. The training maintains a balance between essential content delivery and interactive elements, with a 20-80 orientation that dedicates 20 percent of the time to informational content and 80 percent to interactive, collaborative activities. Small group discussions, hands-on exercises like role-playing or simulations, and the use of media tools such as flipcharts and pinboards all support active participation. Additionally, regular feedback mechanisms are integrated to continuously adapt and improve the training content based on participant input, ensuring that it remains relevant and effective for introducing new concepts and practices to adult learners.
The learner-centered approach is particularly effective for adult further training, such as introducing new working approaches to rural advisors. It places the learner at the heart of the educational process, tailoring training specifically to the unique needs and rich experiences that these professionals bring to the learning environment. This method emphasizes active participation to foster an engaging atmosphere, crucial for adult learning. The initial setting of a circle of chairs without tables signals a departure from traditional didactic methods, promoting interaction over passive listening. The training maintains a balance between essential content delivery and interactive elements, with a 20-80 orientation that dedicates 20 percent of the time to informational content and 80 percent to interactive, collaborative activities. Small group discussions, hands-on exercises like role-playing or simulations, and the use of media tools such as flipcharts and pinboards all support active participation. Additionally, regular feedback mechanisms are integrated to continuously adapt and improve the training content based on participant input, ensuring that it remains relevant and effective for introducing new concepts and practices to adult learners.
The innovation analysis developed by FüAk follows a person-centered approach, focusing on the actors of an innovation and their networking activities.
The innovation analysis has two objectives
1. To understand interactive innovation: Innovation projects in agriculture are often complex.
However, there is the possibility to get a quick overview of the innovation project with well-structured analysis questions. The FüAk innovation analysis distinguishes
between five fields relevant to innovation:
1) The innovation itself
2) The innovation process
3) Actors and networking
4) Environment and dissemination
5) Required competencies
2. To provide suggestions and tips for improving the analyzed project:
The innovation analysis provides the project participants with hints on how to make the innovation project more effective and efficient. The key points developed in the
group are visualized on a poster and then fed back as suggestions to the project actors. Innovation analysis thus provides impulses for multi-actor projects
The Tool is used in Bavaria for learning interactively from practice innovation projects in trainings for advisors, multi-actor innnovation days, i2connect Cross-Visits and with students from agricultural colleges.
Die von der FüAk entwickelte Innovationsanalyse folgt einem personenzentrierten Ansatz, der sich auf die Akteure einer Innovation und deren Vernetzungsaktivitäten konzentriert.
Die Innovationsanalyse verfolgt zwei Ziele
1. Die interaktive Innovation zu verstehen:
Innovationsprojekte in der Landwirtschaft sind oft sehr komplex.
Die Innovationsanalyse der FüAk bietet die Möglichkeit, einen schnellen Überblick über ein Innovationsprojekt mit gut strukturierten Analyse-Fragen zu erhalten. Die FüAk-Innovationsanalyse unterscheidet zwischen fünf für die Innovation relevanten Feldern:
1) Die Innovation selbst
2) Der Innovationsprozess
3) Akteure und Vernetzung
4) Umfeld und Verbreitung
5) Erforderliche Kompetenzen
2. Anregungen und Tipps zur Verbesserung des analysierten
analysierten Projekts:
Die Innovationsanalyse gibt den Projektbeteiligten Hinweise, wie sie das Innovationsprojekt effektiver und effizienter gestalte könnenn. Die in der Gruppe erarbeiteten Eckpunkte werden auf einem Plakat visualisiert und als Anregungen an die Projektakteure zurückgegeben. Die Innovationsanalyse gibt so Impulse
für Multi-Akteurs-Projekte.
Das Tool wird in Bayern zum interaktiven Lernen aus Praxis-Innovationsprojekten in Beraterschulungen, Multi-Akteurs-Innovationstagen, i2c Cross-Visits und mit Studierenden landwirtschaftlicher Fachschulen eingesetzt.
In the various phases of an innovative project, particularly during the initial inspiration phase and the subsequent development phase, creativity plays a crucial role. To support and enhance creativity during these stages, several tools and techniques can be employed.
One effective method to foster creativity involves altering one’s perspective. For instance, performing a headstand allows an individual to view the world upside down, literally changing their perspective. This principle can be applied metaphorically by rephrasing questions to explore new angles. Instead of asking, “How could we best reach our customers?” one might ask, “What could we do to ensure we do not reach our customers at all?” By generating ideas based on this inverted question, and then converting these negative ideas into positive ones, new and innovative ways to reach customers may emerge. This approach aims to create a conducive environment for creativity.
Another technique to boost creativity involves seeking analogous inspirations. This can be achieved by examining different contexts with similar challenges and drawing lessons from them. Additionally, working with images and associations can serve as a source of inspiration.
The mind mapping technique involves creating a visual representation of ideas and their connections. By starting with a central concept and branching out to related topics, individuals can explore various dimensions of a problem and generate new insights.
In the various phases of an innovative project, particularly during the initial inspiration phase and the subsequent development phase, creativity plays a crucial role. To support and enhance creativity during these stages, several tools and techniques can be employed.
One effective method to foster creativity involves altering one’s perspective. For instance, performing a headstand allows an individual to view the world upside down, literally changing their perspective. This principle can be applied metaphorically by rephrasing questions to explore new angles. Instead of asking, “How could we best reach our customers?” one might ask, “What could we do to ensure we do not reach our customers at all?” By generating ideas based on this inverted question, and then converting these negative ideas into positive ones, new and innovative ways to reach customers may emerge. This approach aims to create a conducive environment for creativity.
Another technique to boost creativity involves seeking analogous inspirations. This can be achieved by examining different contexts with similar challenges and drawing lessons from them. Additionally, working with images and associations can serve as a source of inspiration.
The mind mapping technique involves creating a visual representation of ideas and their connections. By starting with a central concept and branching out to related topics, individuals can explore various dimensions of a problem and generate new insights.
The "Guiding the Blind" pedagogic exercise aims at raising awareness of the clients's and advisors' perspective in an advisory and interactive innovation process and challenges the "helper syndrom" of supporters and introduces the principle of non-directiveness. The exercise is best before clarifying the role of different actors in an advisory interaction.
How to guide the activity: Teams of two persons are formed, one person has to cover the eyes while the second acts as the guide. Without talkin to each other, the guide has to allow the blind person to make experiences (in the room, outside), after 8-10 min roles are swaped; after another 8-10 min, have the pairs change partners. Again, each partner in the newly formed pair acts as the blind person and the guide for 5 minutes. Then, everybody returns to the plenary for the debriefing.
Debriefing questions:
- quick "fire-round": How did you feel being blind? How did you feel being the guide? - open round
- What problems did you face a) as the guide; b) as the blind person? - answers are collected on cards, put on a pin board
- What is similar / different to advisory work an interactive innovation support? - to be handled in form of a group work, then presentation in plenary
- conclusions on type of support in interactive innovations, role of advisors in this process.
added value: it is an entertaining, ice-breaking activity with challenges own understanding of how support should (not) be provided while experiencing both, the supporter and the receiver side.
Die pädagogische Übung "Blindenführen" zielt darauf ab, das Bewusstsein für die Perspektive der Kunden und Berater in einem beratenden und interaktiven Innovationsprozess zu schärfen, das "Helfersyndrom" der Unterstützer in Frage zu stellen und das Prinzip der Nicht-Direktivität einzuführen. Die Übung eignet sich am besten, um die Rolle der verschiedenen Akteure in einer Beratungsinteraktion zu klären.
Durchführung: Es werden Zweierteams gebildet, wobei einer Person die Augen verbunden werden, während die zweite Person die Aufgabe des Blindenführens übernimmt. Ohne miteinander zu sprechen, muss der Blindenführer der blinden Person ermöglichen Erfahrungen zu machen (im Raum, draußen), nach 8-10 Minuten werden die Rollen getauscht; nach weiteren 8-10 Minuten tauschen die Paare die Partner. Auch hier übernimmt jeder Partner des neu gebildeten Paares für 5 Minuten die Rolle der blinden Person und des Führers. Dann kehren alle für die Nachbesprechung ins Plenum zurück.
Auswertung:
- Schnelle "Feuer-Runde": Wie habt ihr euch als Blinde gefühlt? Wie habt ihr euch in der Rolle des Fremdenführers gefühlt? - offene Runde
- Welche Probleme hatten Sie a) als Führer; b) als Blinde/r? - Antworten werden auf Karten gesammelt und an eine Pinnwand geheftet
- Was ist ähnlich/unterschiedlich zu Beratungsarbeit und interaktiver Innovationsförderung?
- Schlussfolgerungen zur Art der Unterstützung bei interaktiven Innovationen, Rolle der Berater in diesem Prozess.
Mehrwert: Es handelt sich um eine unterhaltsame, aktivierende Übung zum Einstieg, die das eigene Verständnis infrage stellt, wie Unterstützung (nicht) geleistet werden sollte, indem man sowohl die Seite des Unterstützers als auch die des Empfängers erfährt.
One of the facilitation methods used in i2connect train-the-trainer courses is the so-called ‘Head, Heart, Feet’. This method is used to create an inclusive and participatory learning space and to invite participants to reflect on what they have learnt and capitalise on it for the future. This approach is based on the idea that people learn and contribute to collaborative processes more effectively when three fundamental dimensions are taken into account: the head (Head), the heart (Heart) and the feet (Feet).
Head: represents the cognitive component, i.e. the acquisition and processing of information. In this phase, participants are asked to think about something new they learnt during the course. The facilitator stimulates critical thinking by asking questions that challenge the group to think more deeply.
Heart: This dimension deals with emotions and empathy. Participants are invited to connect emotionally with the subject matter, sharing feelings and concerns. This creates an environment in which everyone feels heard and respected, promoting emotional participation and personal involvement.
Feet (Feet): symbolises action. After exploring the cognitive and emotional aspect, we move on to putting it into practice. Participants are asked to identify concrete actions they can take. This phase is crucial for transforming reflections into tangible changes.
This method is most effective in small groups of about 6 to 8 people per table.
Uno dei metodi facilitazione utilizzati nei corsi di formazione dei formatori i2connect è il cosidetto "Head, Heart, Feet". Tale metodo viene utilizzato per creare uno spazio di apprendimento inclusivo e partecipativo e per invitare i partecipanti a riflettere su quanto appreso e la sua capitalizzazione per il futuro. Questo approccio si basa sull'idea che le persone apprendono e contribuiscono a processi collaborativi in modo più efficace quando si tengono in considerazione tre dimensioni fondamentali: la testa (Head), il cuore (Heart) e i piedi (Feet).
Testa (Head): rappresenta la componente cognitiva, ossia l'acquisizione e l'elaborazione delle informazioni. In questa fase, ai partecipanti viene richiesto di pensare a qualcosa di nuovo imparato durante il corso. Il facilitatore stimola il pensiero critico, ponendo domande che sfidano il gruppo a pensare in modo più approfondito.
Cuore (Heart): questa dimensione riguarda le emozioni e l'empatia. I partecipanti sono invitati a connettersi emotivamente con l'argomento trattato, condividendo sentimenti e preoccupazioni. Si crea così un ambiente in cui ognuno si sente ascoltato e rispettato, promuovendo la partecipazione emotiva e il coinvolgimento personale.
Piedi (Feet): simboleggia l'azione. Dopo aver esplorato l'aspetto cognitivo ed emotivo, si passa alla messa in pratica. I partecipanti sono chiamati a identificare azioni concrete che possono intraprendere. Questa fase è cruciale per trasformare le riflessioni in cambiamenti tangibili.
Per l'applicazione di tale metodo è maggiormente efficace in caso di piccoli gruppi di circa 6/8 persone per tavolo.
A useful model for advisors is the Cynefin framework, developed by Dave Snowden. Originally from management science, this framework is also highly applicable to agriculture, especially as the field grapples with intricate issues involving social contexts.
The Cynefin framework categorizes contexts into four types: simple, complicated, complex, and chaotic. Each context requires a different approach.
1. Simple Contexts: In these scenarios, best practices are effective. The relationship between cause and effect is clear, allowing for straightforward categorization, decision-making, and action.
2. Complicated Contexts: Although the relationship between cause and effect exists, it is not immediately obvious. This necessitates the involvement of experts or conducting research to determine the appropriate course of action.
3. Complex Contexts: Here, the cause-and-effect relationships are not discernible. The focus shifts to embracing diversity and integrating multiple perspectives. This involves observing the situation, experimenting with small steps, analyzing the outcomes, and iterating accordingly. Iterative processes are key in complex contexts.
4. Chaotic Contexts: These are crisis situations where immediate action is required. One must act promptly, observe the results, and adjust actions as necessary.
Understanding the Cynefin framework aids in deciding the appropriate course of action for various projects. It can be utilized individually or within a team. Additionally, if current methods are ineffective, re-evaluating the context through this framework may suggest more suitable strategies. For further information on the Cynefin model, refer to the links below.
A useful model for advisors is the Cynefin framework, developed by Dave Snowden. Originally from management science, this framework is also highly applicable to agriculture, especially as the field grapples with intricate issues involving social contexts.
The Cynefin framework categorizes contexts into four types: simple, complicated, complex, and chaotic. Each context requires a different approach.
1. Simple Contexts: In these scenarios, best practices are effective. The relationship between cause and effect is clear, allowing for straightforward categorization, decision-making, and action.
2. Complicated Contexts: Although the relationship between cause and effect exists, it is not immediately obvious. This necessitates the involvement of experts or conducting research to determine the appropriate course of action.
3. Complex Contexts: Here, the cause-and-effect relationships are not discernible. The focus shifts to embracing diversity and integrating multiple perspectives. This involves observing the situation, experimenting with small steps, analyzing the outcomes, and iterating accordingly. Iterative processes are key in complex contexts.
4. Chaotic Contexts: These are crisis situations where immediate action is required. One must act promptly, observe the results, and adjust actions as necessary.
Understanding the Cynefin framework aids in deciding the appropriate course of action for various projects. It can be utilized individually or within a team. Additionally, if current methods are ineffective, re-evaluating the context through this framework may suggest more suitable strategies. For further information on the Cynefin model, refer to the links below.
The purpose of the half-day workshop was to mature the idea from many different angles, even to the point of becoming a project idea. Initial ideas were generated by asking advisors about development issues that they identified as important and challenging among their clients. The advisor who was interested in the topic was invited to participate in the idea stream with the client in order to ensure that the voice of the farmer or rural entrepreneur was heard directly. They were joined by experts from educational institutions, financial instruments, agriculture and rural development to mature each initial idea. The workshop started with a brief introduction to interactive innovation. Then general rules about keeping confidetality and including primerly the people now working with the idea into a project in case one would be applied based on the work of the day. After this phase all participants were divided into small groups based on the topic they were intested in. The advisors of the groups were agreed to facilitate the brainstorming based on a recommended structure. In the smaller groups trust was build by getting to know each other with the help of pictures. After this the farmer/ entrepreneur told why the initial idea/ topic was important to her/him and this same was shared by each participant. From here the discussion flowed freely with the facilitators help. In the groups where someone clearly took the role of a leader the work has continued and project proposals are planned to be done or have been done. This is a practical way to initiate high quality multiactor operational groups.
Puolipäivää kestäneen työpajan tarkoituksena oli kypsyttää alkuperäistä ideaa monista eri näkökulmista, jopa niin pitkälle, että siitä voisi tulla projektiaihio. Alkuperäiset ideat löytyivät kysymällä neuvojilta kehitysaihioita, joita he pitivät tärkeinä ja haastavina asiakkaidensa keskuudessa. Neuvoja kutsuttiin osallistumaan ideointiprosessiin asiakkaansa kanssa. Näin halutiin varmistaa, että viljelijän tai maaseutuyrittäjän ääni kuului suoraan. Heidän lisäkseen ideoita kypsyttivät eri oppilaitosten, rahoituksen, maatalouden ja maaseutujen kehittämisen asiantuntijat.
Työpaja alkoi lyhyellä yhteisinnovoinnin johdannolla. Sitten kerrottiin yleisistä säännöistä, kuten luottamuksellisuuden säilyttämisestä ja siitä, että pääasiassa ne henkilöt, jotka nyt työskentelevät idean parissa, sisällytettäisiin projektiin, mikäli sellainen päätettäisiin toteuttaa työpajan tulosten perusteella. Tämän vaiheen jälkeen kaikki osallistujat jaettiin pienryhmiin heidän kiinnostuksen kohteidensa mukaan. Ryhmien neuvojat lupautuivat fasilitoimaan pienryhmien ideointia suositellun toteutuksen pohjalta. Ensiksi pienryhmissä luottamusta rakennettiin tutustumalla toisiin kuvien avulla. Tämän jälkeen viljelijä tai yrittäjä kertoi, miksi alkuperäinen idea tai aihe oli hänelle tärkeä, jonka jälkeen saman tekivät kaikki osallistujat. Tästä keskustelu jatkui vapaasti fasilitaattoreiden avustuksella. Ryhmissä, joissa joku otti selvästi johtajan roolin, työ on jatkunut ja projektisuunnitelmia ollaan valmistelemassa tai on jo tehty. Ideavirtaamo on käytännöllinen tapa käynnistää korkealaatuisia monitoimijaisia operatiivisia ryhmiä.
In i2connect, several practical cases have been identified to illustrate what co-creation and interactive innovation mean in practice. To allow an easy access to these cases audio-visual formats were realized. The format of commented slideshows used to combine pictures, video clips, and text into one video file is advantageous because it can be created by anyone without experience in filming and editing. Once a written report is available, the additional work is minimal. FiBL and IBLA were responsible in the project for producing these slideshows (editors). The workflow was as follows:
1. The case owner sends photos, video clips, and a text illustrating and describing the practical case to the editors. For a two-minute video, about 10-20 photos and a text of 250 words are needed.
2. If necessary, the editors revise the text by shortening sentences and providing practical recommendations, also using ChatGPT. Additional photos from open-source image databases (e.g. canva.com) and visual graphics were added if needed.
3. From the final text, artificial voices were generated using the online-software www.sonix.ai. This audio file is imported into a video editing program and forms the basis of the commented slideshow. Photos and videos are then placed on top of the audio track. Titles, subtitles, breaks, and music are added (fig. 1).
4. This first edition is uploaded to YouTube. After partners approval, subtitles are added on YouTube. If a corrected text is manually added in YouTube Studio, the quality of automated translation to all languages is very good (fig. 2).
Because of the universal understanding of pictures and the high-quality translations, this low-cost format is highly suitable for communication and dissemination in EU projects.
In i2connect, several practical cases have been identified to illustrate what co-creation and interactive innovation mean in practice. To allow an easy access to these cases audio-visual formats were realized. The format of commented slideshows used to combine pictures, video clips, and text into one video file is advantageous because it can be created by anyone without experience in filming and editing. Once a written report is available, the additional work is minimal. FiBL and IBLA were responsible in the project for producing these slideshows (editors). The workflow was as follows:
1. The case owner sends photos, video clips, and a text illustrating and describing the practical case to the editors. For a two-minute video, about 10-20 photos and a text of 250 words are needed.
2. If necessary, the editors revise the text by shortening sentences and providing practical recommendations, also using ChatGPT. Additional photos from open-source image databases (e.g. canva.com) and visual graphics were added if needed.
3. From the final text, artificial voices were generated using the online-software www.sonix.ai. This audio file is imported into a video editing program and forms the basis of the commented slideshow. Photos and videos are then placed on top of the audio track. Titles, subtitles, breaks, and music are added (fig. 1).
4. This first edition is uploaded to YouTube. After partners approval, subtitles are added on YouTube. If a corrected text is manually added in YouTube Studio, the quality of automated translation to all languages is very good (fig. 2).
Because of the universal understanding of pictures and the high-quality translations, this low-cost format is highly suitable for communication and dissemination in EU projects.
The training of i2connect trainers generated a significant impact at the Italian level, contributing to the professional growth of farm advisors and fostering an environment of continuous collaboration. The course involved a total of 45 participants, spread over two editions: 20 in the first and 25 in the second. Meetings were held face-to-face to ensure a high level of interaction and exchange between participants, strengthening the network of consultants.
One of the most significant effects was the creation of a cohesive group of professionals who, thanks to tools such as WhatsApp, continue to actively collaborate even after the course is over, sharing ideas, experiences and information in real time. This has allowed the consolidation of a community of practice capable of supporting each other and growing together.
Further recognition of the value of this training came with the adoption of the course by the Veneto Region, which integrated it into the Rural Development Plan and subsequently into the CAP Strategic Plan, within the interventions dedicated to the training of consultants. This virtuous example has inspired other Italian regions, which have expressed interest in replicating the course in their territories, especially in view of the new calls for proposals of the PEI AGRI Operational Groups. This shows how i2connect training is helping to strengthen the agricultural advisory system in Italy, promoting a model of collaborative learning and continuous exchange of skills.
La formazione dei formatori di i2connect ha generato un impatto significativo a livello italiano, contribuendo alla crescita professionale dei consulenti agricoli e favorendo un ambiente di collaborazione continua. Il corso ha coinvolto complessivamente 45 partecipanti, distribuiti in due edizioni: 20 nella prima e 25 nella seconda. Gli incontri si sono svolti in presenza per garantire un alto livello di interazione e scambio tra i partecipanti, rafforzando la rete di consulenti.
Uno degli effetti più rilevanti è stata la creazione di un gruppo coeso di professionisti, che, grazie a strumenti come WhatsApp, continua a collaborare attivamente anche dopo il termine del corso, condividendo idee, esperienze e informazioni in tempo reale. Questo ha permesso di consolidare una comunità di pratica capace di supportarsi e crescere insieme.
Un ulteriore riconoscimento del valore di questa formazione si è avuto con l'adozione del corso da parte della Regione Veneto, che lo ha integrato nel Piano di Sviluppo Rurale e successivamente nel Piano Strategico della PAC, all'interno degli interventi dedicati alla formazione dei consulenti. Questo esempio virtuoso ha ispirato altre regioni italiane, che hanno manifestato l'interesse a replicare il corso sui propri territori, specialmente in vista dei nuovi bandi dei Gruppi Operativi del PEI AGRI. Questo dimostra come la formazione i2connect stia contribuendo a rafforzare il sistema di consulenza agricola in Italia, promuovendo un modello di apprendimento collaborativo e di scambio continuo di competenze.
The agricultural sector in Greece is dominated by a large number of very small/ small family-farms with ageing farmers who are largely based on their experience and have limited access to knowledge and advice. However, up to date there has been no coherent policy concerning the provision of advisory services to the farmers in the country. Moreover, the implementation of important EU policies, such as the functioning of EIP-Operational Groups and a national Farm Advisory System, has not been achieved yet. Thus, farmers seek advice from private sector agronomists, working as either independent advisors or input sellers. Input sellers exert great influence in farmers’ decision making and the most dynamic supply shops have expanded their activities to advice provision. Independent advisors differ according to the range of services they offer and their scale of operation. Their majority are active at local level, supporting farmers’ access to EU projects/measures/grants. A small number of them provide specialized services at national level, forging alliances with dynamic Producers Groups, input industries and financial institutions while new partnerships (multi-stakeholder) emerge addressing digitization. In addition, the importance of the secondary and tertiary sectors is rising since they set the quality standards for the produces they buy and thus trigger the need for advice.
However, the national AKIS remains highly uncoordinated and the cooperation among different types of actors is marginal. Especially research often appears to be alienated from other AKIS actors’ reality. The current situation of AKIS leaves plenty of room for improvement provided the appropriate utilization of the new Common Agricultural Policy tools.
Ο αγροτικός τομέας της Ελλάδας χαρακτηρίζεται από μεγάλο αριθμό πολύ μικρών οικογενειακών εκμεταλλεύσεων, γερασμένο αγροτικό πληθυσμό και μικρό ποσοστό παραγωγών με πλήρη αγροτική εκπαίδευση, οι οποίοι έχουν μικρή πρόσβαση σε γνώση και συμβουλές. Παρόλα αυτά στην Ελλάδα δεν υπάρχει μια συνεκτική πολιτική ούτε υποστήριξη στην παροχή συμβουλών. Επιπλέον, η εφαρμογή σημαντικών Ευρωπαϊκών πολιτικών, όπως η εδραίωση Επιχειρησιακών Ομάδων και ενός εθνικού Συστήματος Γεωργικών Συμβουλών, δεν έχουν ακόμη επιτευχθεί. Έτσι οι παραγωγοί αναζητούν συμβουλές από ιδιώτες ανεξάρτητους συμβούλους είτε πωλητές εισροών. Οι πωλητές εισροών επηρεάζουν σημαντικά τις αποφάσεις των παραγωγών και οι πλέον δυναμικοί έχουν επεκτείνει τις δραστηριότητές τους στον τομέα των συμβουλών. Οι ανεξάρτητοι σύμβουλοι διαφέρουν ανάλογα με την εμβέλεια και το είδος των δραστηριοτήτων τους. Οι περισσότεροι δρουν τοπικά, παρέχοντας υποστήριξη για την ένταξη των παραγωγών σε Ευρωπαϊκά προγράμματα. Ένας μικρός αριθμός, ωστόσο, παρέχει εξειδικευμένες συμβουλές σε εθνικό επίπεδο, διαμορφώνοντας συνεργασίες ομάδων παραγωγών, εταιριών εισροών και χρηματοδοτικών οργανισμών. Νέες συμπράξεις αναδύονται με τη συμμετοχή μεγάλου αριθμού συνεταιρισμών. Συγχρόνως, η επίδραση του δευτερογενούς και τριτογενούς τομέα στην παροχή συμβουλών αυξάνει, ως συνέπεια του ρόλους τους στον καθορισμό των ποιοτικών προδιαγραφών των προϊόντων.
Παρόλα αυτά το Ελληνικό AKIS παραμένει ασυντόνιστο και η συνεργασία μεταξύ διαφορετικών δρώντων η ελάχιστη δυνατή. Ειδικά, οι ερευνητές συχνά δείχνουν αποκομμένοι από τους άλλους δρώντες. Η κατάσταση αυτή ενέχει την προοπτική σημαντικής βελτίωσης, εφόσον η εργαλειοθήκη της νέας Κοινής Αγροτικής Πολιτικής αξιοποιηθεί.
In Cyprus the Department of Agriculture is the main coordination mechanism of the country’s AKIS. It includes a public funded Extension Service and a research branch, the Agricultural Research Institute.
The Extension service is the main provider of advice and professional training to Cypriot farmers, collaborating closely with dynamic producers groups and cooperatives as well. However, it is not linked with private consultants and input suppliers, apart from the individual interactions developed locally among extensionists and agronomists working in the input supply industry due to personal acquaintances. The role of private independent consultants in rural Cyprus is limited and their further development is hindered by farmers’ reluctance to pay for such services.
The Department and its Extension Service function in an unfavorable context laid by a severe lack of staffing, as a consequence of the recent economic crisis, in combination with the ever-increasing tasks of advisors and the amount of bureaucracy involved. These facts hamper the effective interaction and trust between farmers and advisors, especially when the advisor also plays the role of controller/auditor or assessor. In parallel, researchers' responsiveness to both advisors' and farmers’ needs is considered unsatisfactory. Therefore, in Cyprus, despite the overall positive role of the Department of Agriculture and its Extension Service, there is an urgent need for focus more on farmers’ needs, the provision of training opportunities and farmers’ involvement in interactive initiatives. In addition further effort is needed to encourage collaborative research and the promotion/coordination of intense cooperation among the AKIS-actors at all levels.
Το Τμήμα Γεωργίας Κύπρου αποτελεί τον κύριο συντονιστικό μηχανισμό του Γεωργικού Συστήματος Γνώσης και Καινοτομίας. Σε αυτό περιλαμβάνονται οι Γεωργικές Εφαρμογές και το Ινστιτούτο Αγροτικής Έρευνας.
Οι Γεωργικές Εφαρμογές αποτελούν τον κύριο πάροχο συμβουλών και επαγγελματικής εκπαίδευσης, συνεργαζόμενες στενά με δυναμικές ομάδες παραγωγών και συνεταιρισμούς. Ωστόσο, λείπουν οι σύνδεσμοι με ιδιώτες συμβούλους και πωλητές εφοδίων, εξαιρουμένων των τοπικών συνεργασιών που βασίζονται στην προσωπική αλληλεπίδραση των δημόσιων λειτουργών και των γεωπόνων που εργάζονται σε καταστήματα και εταιρίες εισροών. Ο ρόλος των ιδιωτών, ανεξάρτητων συμβούλων είναι περιορισμένος, δεδομένου ότι οι παραγωγοί είναι γενικότερα απρόθυμοι να πληρώσουν τις υπηρεσίες τους. Συγχρόνως, το Τμήμα Γεωργίας και ο τομέας των Γεωργικών Εφαρμογών είναι εγκλωβισμένοι σε ένα δυσμενές περιβάλλον λειτουργίας, ως αποτέλεσμα της σοβαρής υπο-στελέχωσής τους, λόγω της οικονομικής κρίσης, των ολοένα αυξανόμενων καθηκόντων των συμβούλων και της συνεπακόλουθης γραφειοκρατίας. Αυτά εμποδίζουν την αποτελεσματική αλληλεπίδραση παραγωγών και συμβούλων, ιδιαίτερα όταν οι σύμβουλοι αναλαμβάνουν συγχρόνως ρόλο εκλεκτή/ εκτιμητή. Παράλληλα, οι ερευνητές αδυνατούν να ανταποκριθούν στο εύρος των αναγκών συμβούλων και παραγωγών.
Συνεπώς, παρά τον θετικό ρόλο των Γεωργικών Εφαρμογών, στην Κύπρο υπάρχει αδήριτη ανάγκη για επικέντρωση στις ανάγκες των παραγωγών, περισσότερες ευκαιρίες εκπαίδευσης και συμπερίληψη των παραγωγών σε διαδραστικές πρωτοβουλίες. Επιπλέον, απαιτούνται περισσότερες προσπάθειες για την ενθάρρυνση της συνεργατικής έρευνας και την προώθηση/ συντονισμό εντατικής συνεργασίας μεταξύ των δρώντων σε όλα τα επίπεδα.
The 'Thank you producer' grants support new innovations in cereal farming and the sharing of knowledge about them in Finland. The grant programme seeks innovative proposals from applicants that contribute to the production of quality cereals in a sustainable and economically viable way, taking into account the environment, climate and biodiversity. Applicants are also encouraged to share their production methods through peer support networks. In 2024, the 'Thank you producer' grants were selected for the sixth time. To date, 36 applicants have been awarded grants and a total of €297,000 has been distributed. In total, nearly 200 applications have been received. The grant recipients are selected by an expert jury consisting of representatives from Vaasan, ProAgria, K Group, MTK and Lantmännen Agro. The money raised from the sale of Vaasan's bread is distributed to Finnish farmers in the form of grants once a year. Vaasan's 'Thank you producer' products include Vaasan Ruispalat Tumma Herkku Tuottajalle Kiitos (5 cents) and Pirkka Setsuuri (20 cents).
Tuottajalle kiitos -stipendien kautta tuetaan viljanviljelyn uusia innovaatioita ja tiedon jakamista niistä. Stipendiohjelma etsii hakijoilta innovatiivisia ehdotuksia, jotka edistävät laadukkaan viljan tuotantoa kestävällä ja taloudellisesti kannattavalla tavalla, ottaen huomioon ympäristön, ilmaston ja luonnon monimuotoisuuden. Hakijoita kannustetaan myös jakamaan tuotantomenetelmiään vertaistukiverkostojen kautta. Tuottajalle kiitos -stipendejä valittiin vuonna 2024 kuudetta kertaa. Stipendejä on saanut tähän mennessä 36 hakijaa ja stipendeinä on jaettu kaikkiaan 297 000 euroa. Hakemuksia stipendeihin on tullut kaikkiaan lähes 200. Stipendinsaajat valitsee asiantuntijaraati, johon kuuluvat Vaasanin, ProAgrian, K-ryhmän, MTK:n ja Lantmännen Agron edustajat. Vaasanin leipien myynnistä kertyvä tukisumma jaetaan suomalaisille viljelijöille stipendien muodossa kerran vuodessa. Vaasanin Tuottajalle kiitos -tuotteita ovat esimerkiksi Vaasan Ruispalat Tumma Herkku Tuottajalle Kiitos (tuki 5 senttiä) ja Pirkka Setsuuri (tuki 20 senttiä).
One of the iniziatives analysed in i2connect is a project that consists of a crop farm in three different locations in Hungary that will undertake to grow sweet lupins for two years, to be used as feed on two pig farms. The project involves crop and feed trials. The steering group is composed of an expert advisor, a research centre, a feed company and several farmers. The aim is to obtain accurate results from the on-farm trials on the suitability of lupin for use in pig feeds adapted to different production groups and its effects on production results. As a first step, first year trials of lupin were started in three different agro-ecological districts, one of which was VIRAGZO OKO Ltd.
Based on preliminary test results, among the three sites, a favourable growth rate was observed in the Nógrád region, while a lower vegetative mass was observed in the Nyalka trial. The most favorable developmental rate was observed in the third tested region, Sabolcs, with respect to soil. Based on the results of the research conducted so far, it can be said that lupin yield is significantly determined by agroecological conditions, and soil quality is the most important determinant of vegetative development. Flowering Eco Ltd. is at the forefront of organic farming and the implementation of innovative ideas.
On their own farm they are constantly looking for new opportunities, new markets and are involved in projects that can bring extra profit and, in addition to profit, enable a sustainable form of farming that reduces the ecological footprint. Through sharing developments and innovations created through joint work, both nationally and internationally, the network of farmers is further expanded, which is a secondary product of innovative development.
Az operatív csoport egy szaktanácsadóból, egy kutatóhelyből, egy takarmányozási cégből, és több mezőgazdasági termelőből áll. A projekt lényege, hogy a Magyarország három különböző pontján lévő növénytermesztő gazdaság vállalja, hogy két éven keresztül édes csillagfürtöt termeszt, amelyet két sertéstartó gazdaságban használnak fel takarmányozásra. A projektben növénytermesztési és takarmányozási kísérletek folynak. A cél az, hogy a üzemi kísérletekkel pontos eredményeket kapjanak a csillagfürt különböző termelési csoportokhoz kialakított sertéstakarmányokban való felhasználhatóságára, illetve annak a termelési eredményre gyakorolt hatásairól. Első lépésben a csillagfürt első éves növénytermesztési kísérletei indultak meg három eltérő agroökológiai körzetben, ezek egyike volt nyalkai VIRAGZO OKO Ltd.
Az előzetes vizsgálati eredmények alapján a három helyszín közül kedvező fejlődési ütemet a nógrádi régióban, míg a Nyalkán lévő kísérletben kisebb vegetatív tömeget tapasztaltak. A legkedvezőbb fejlettséget a harmadik vizsgált régióban, szabolcsban tapasztaltak, a talajra vonatkozóan. Az eddigi kutatások eredményeképpen elmondható, hogy a csillagfürt termését az agroökológiai feltételek jelentős mértékben meghatározzák, és leginkább a talajminőség a meghatározó a vegetatív fejlődés során. A Virágzó Öko Kft. élenjár a biogazdálkodásban és az innovatív ötletek megvalósításában.
Saját gazdaságukban is folyamatosan keresik az új lehetőségeket, új piacokat és részt vesznek olyan projektekben, amelyek plusz profitot hozhatnak és a profit mellett fenntartható és az ökológiai lábnyomot csökkentő gazdálkodási formát tesznek lehetővé.
A regional initiative promotes local sourcing in school canteens to support agricultural developmen in France. A procurement platform streamlines logistics and secures contracts for farmers, aiming to reduce import dependency. Agricultural chambers collaborated in defining specifications of the agricultural product availables locally, training farmers in answering to public procurment and identifying local producers. The practice's interest lies in its collaborative approach, integrating agricultural perspectives and aligning tender processes with farmers' needs. Agricultural chambers played a pivotal role in facilitating farmer participation and tailoring solutions to local contexts. Implemented knowledge enhances local economies, reduces import reliance, and provides stable markets for farmers. End-users benefit from fresher, locally sourced produce, while practitioners gain insights into effective collaboration models for future projects, driving sustainable agricultural development. The logistic plateform is currently under construction and will make possible to manage large volume of products : 15 milions meals and 110 delivery points.
Une initiative régionale promeut l'approvisionnement local dans les cantines scolaires pour soutenir le développement agricole. Une plateforme d'approvisionnement rationalise la logistique et sécurise les contrats pour les agriculteurs, dans le but de réduire la dépendance aux importations.
Les chambres d'agriculture ont collaboré à la définition des spécifications des produits agricoles disponibles localement, à la formation des agriculteurs pour répondre aux appels d'offres publics et à l'identification des producteurs locaux. L'intérêt de la pratique réside dans son approche collaborative, intégrant les perspectives agricoles et alignant les processus d'appel d'offres sur les besoins des agriculteurs. Les chambres d'agriculture ont joué un rôle essentiel en facilitant la participation des agriculteurs et en adaptant les solutions aux contextes locaux.
La mise en œuvre des connaissances améliore les économies locales, réduit la dépendance aux importations et offre des marchés stables aux agriculteurs. Les utilisateurs finaux bénéficient de produits plus frais, provenant de sources locales, tandis que les praticiens acquièrent des idées sur les modèles de collaboration efficaces pour les projets futurs, favorisant un développement agricole durable. La plateforme logistique est actuellement en construction et permettra de gérer de grands volumes de produits : 15 millions de repas et 110 points de livraison.
Among the tools for advisory services providers, Spain promoted the implementation of the Spanish Inventory of Traditional Knowledge related to Biodiversity according to the law 42/2007, of December 13, on Natural Heritage and Biodiversity that recognizes the need to know, conserve and promote traditional knowledge and practices of interest to biodiversity. In its article 74, it indicates that public administrations must prepare inventories of traditional knowledge that allow progress in its knowledge and conservation.
In this sense, it is suggested that innovation should not imply forgetting traditional knowledge. Advisors should take this knowledge into consideration to avoid reinventing the wheel.
To complete the development of the inventory, this digital platform has been created: CONECT-e (Traditional Ecological Knowledge) is an interactive platform for the collection and transmission of traditional knowledge related to plants, animals, fungi, traditional varieties of crops or ecosystems. This platform aspires not only to be a place for consultation, but also a space for meeting and exchange. The CONECT-e platform presents a wiki format, with the aim that anyone can register and share through the web the traditional knowledge and practices that they have acquired from their elders by talking to them or seeing how they applied them on a daily basis.
In conclusion, we cannot think about the future without knowing our past.
Entre las herramientas para los proveedores de servicios de asesoramiento, España promovió la realización del Inventario Español de Conocimientos Tradicionales relacionados con la Biodiversidad según la ley 42/2007, de 13 de diciembre, del Patrimonio Natural y de la Biodiversidad que reconoce la necesidad de conocer, conservar y promover los conocimientos y prácticas tradicionales de interés para la biodiversidad. En su artículo 74, indica que las administraciones públicas deberán elaborar inventarios de conocimientos tradicionales que permitan avanzar en su conocimiento y conservación.
En este sentido, se sugiere que la innovación no implique el olvido de los conocimientos tradicionales. Los asesores deben tener en cuenta estos conocimientos para evitar reinventar la rueda.
La innovación no debe implicar olvidar el conocimiento tracicional. Los asesores deben tener en consideración estos conocimientos para evitar reinventar la rueda.
Para completar el desarrollo del inventario se ha creado esta plataforma digital: CONECT-e (CONocimiento ECológico Tradicional) es una plataforma interactiva de recogida y transmisión de conocimientos tradicionales relativos a plantas, animales, hongos, variedades tradicionales de cultivos o ecosistemas. Esta plataforma aspira no sólo a ser un lugar de consulta, sino también un espacio de encuentro e intercambio. La plataforma CONECT-e presenta un formato wiki, con el objetivo de que cualquier persona pueda registrarse y compartir a través de la web los conocimientos y prácticas tradicionales que han adquirido de sus mayores hablando con ellos o viendo cómo los aplicaban en el día a día.
Como conclusión, no se puede pensar en el futuro sin conocer nuestro pasado.
The Spanish AKIS Platform has been created by the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food with the purpose of facilitating the meeting point and exchange of knowledge between AKIS actors in Spain, promoting the transfer of knowledge, innovations and experiences and provide support to advisory entities and professionals.
It is quite versatile and has the following contents:
- Information of interest AKIS
- Discover what AKIS is.
- Observe the AKIS actors in each Autonomous Community and at the national level.
- Locate and contact the members of this ecosystem of knowledge and agri-food innovation through search engines: Advisors, Training Centers, Technology Centers, Networks and Platforms, Digital Innovation Hubs and AGROTECH Companies.
- Useful knowledge
- Access the latest news, events and courses and receive it periodically in your email.
- Learn about the innovations that are being promoted through the agri-food innovation project search engine.
- Put into practice the new knowledge incorporated in the Media Library.
Es una plataforma creada por el Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación con la finalidad de facilitar el punto de encuentro e intercambio de conocimiento entre los actores AKIS en España, para impulsar la transferencia de conocimientos, innovaciones y experiencias y dar soporte a las entidades y profesionales del asesoramiento.
Es bastante versátil y tiene los siguientes contenidos:
- Información de interés AKIS
- Descubre qué es el AKIS.
- Observa los actores AKIS de cada Comunidad Autónoma y a nivel nacional.
- Localiza y contacta a los miembros de este ecosistema de conocimiento y la innovación agroalimentaria a través de buscadores: Asesores, Centros formativos, Centros tecnológicos, Redes y Plataformas, Digital Innovation Hubs y Empresas AGROTECH.
- Conocimiento útil
- Accede a las últimas noticias, eventos y cursos y recíbelo periódicamente en tu e-mail.
- Conoce las innovaciones que se están impulsando a través del buscador de proyectos de innovación agroalimentaria.
- Pon en práctica los nuevos conocimientos incorporados en la Mediateca.
- Entorno colaborativo
- Participa en un Foro especializado con los últimos temas de interés.
- Forma parte de la Red Profesional Agroalimentaria (RPA).
- Comparte tus experiencias con el resto de actores AKIS.
- Consulta el listado de profesionales del asesoramiento agroalimentario y contacta con ellos.
- Ponte al día de las Ayudas y Subvenciones dirigidas al sector.
- Utiliza nuevas Herramientas Digitales que refuerzan la labor del asesoramiento.
- Benefíciate de un espacio especializado dirigido a dar Soporte al Asesoramiento.
En el actual contexto multiplataforma conviene contar con plataformas AKIS que compilen el conocimiento con un claro enfoque práctico.
Soils and water laboratory of LAAS is a result of an EIP project analysed in i2connect project.
Modern laboratory analyzes all soil samples taken from customers' farms, as well as water, sewage, manure, and other samples. The laboratory stands out from other market participants with the latest equipment, experienced chemists, accuracy of test results and promptness. The results are provided within seven working days.
Laboratory Information Management System (LIMS) is used in the laboratory.
The laboratory of LAAS cooperates with Eurofins Agro laboratory operating in Holland. The laboratories use the same methodology and some common databases.
Soil samples are analyzed all-year round.
Different soil testing packages are offered to customers focusing on climate-smart farming and supporting the transition to carbon-neutral agriculture.
Dirvožemio ir vandens tyrimų laboratorija yra EIP projekto rezultatas.
Modernioje laboratorijoje galite išsitirti dirvožemio sudėtį, mėšlą, srutas, nuotekų vandenį, paviršinį ir gruntinį vandenį. Laboratorija iš kitų rinkos dalyvių išsiskiria naujausiais įrenginiais, patyrusiais chemikais, tyrimų tikslumu ir operatyvumu. Tyrimų rezultatai pateikiami per 7 darbo dienas.
Laboratorinių tyrimų paslaugos teikiamos ūkininkams ir žemės ūkio bendrovėms, komercinėms ir ne žemės ūkio įmonėms, sodininkams, daržininkams ir sodininkų bendrijoms, taip pat viešajam sektoriui.
Laboratorijoje naudojama laboratorijos informacijos valdymo sistema LIMS (Laboratory Information Management System).
Laboratorija bendradarbiauja su Olandijoje veikiančia laboratorija Eurofins Agro. Abi laboratorijos naudojasi bendra metodika, kai kuriomis bendromis duomenų bazėmis.
Dirvožemis laboratorijoje tiriamas ištisus metus.
Klientams siūlomi skirtingi dirvožemių tyrimų paketai, orientuoti į klimato kaitai pažangų ūkininkavimą ir padedantys pereiti prie anglies požiūriu neutralaus žemės ūkio.
The Italian AKIS report developed under the project i2connect illustrated a new strategic tool for managing and monitoring forest resources in Italy: SINFor (Sistema Informativo Forestale Nazionale). The system is divided into two interconnected environments: The Forest Map of Italy and the Forest Database. Both play a key role in the forest knowledge and innovation system, promoting the exchange of information between institutions, technicians, researchers and public administrators.
The Forest Map of Italy offers a detailed cartographic representation of the national forest heritage, providing essential data on the distribution, type and health status of Italian forests. This tool enables more accurate planning of forest protection and management interventions. The Forest Database, on the other hand, collects information on silvicultural interventions, forest resources and sustainable management practices, providing an accessible and up-to-date database for all the actors involved.
SINFor represents an important tool at national level for the circulation of technical and scientific knowledge, facilitating the monitoring and sustainable management of Italian forests. Its integration with advanced technologies, such as GIS systems, makes it possible to analyse spatial data in real time, improving decision-making capacity for environmental management interventions. Thanks to its interconnected architecture, SINFor facilitates coordination between regions and promotes the adoption of innovative practices, improving the conservation and resilience of the national forest heritage.
Nell'ambito del rapporto italiano dell'AKIS i2connect è stato illustrato un nuovo strumento strategico di gestione e monitoraggio delle risorse forestali in Italia: il SINFor (Sistema Informativo Forestale Nazionale). Il sistema è articolato in due ambienti interconnessi: La Carta Forestale d'Italia e il Database Foreste. Entrambi giocano un ruolo chiave nel sistema di conoscenza e innovazione forestale, promuovendo lo scambio di informazioni tra istituzioni, tecnici, ricercatori e amministratori pubblici.
La Carta Forestale d'Italia offre una rappresentazione cartografica dettagliata del patrimonio boschivo nazionale, fornendo dati essenziali sulla distribuzione, tipologia e stato di salute delle foreste italiane. Questo strumento permette una pianificazione più accurata degli interventi di tutela e gestione forestale. Il Database Foreste, invece, raccoglie informazioni su interventi selvicolturali, risorse forestali e pratiche di gestione sostenibile, fornendo una base di dati accessibile e aggiornata a tutti gli attori coinvolti.
Il SINFor rappresenta un importante strumento a livello nazionale per la circolazione delle conoscenze tecniche e scientifiche, facilitando il monitoraggio e la gestione sostenibile delle foreste italiane. La sua integrazione con tecnologie avanzate, come i sistemi GIS, consente di analizzare dati territoriali in tempo reale, migliorando la capacità decisionale per interventi di gestione ambientale. Grazie alla sua architettura interconnessa, il SINFor facilita il coordinamento tra regioni e promuove l'adozione di pratiche innovative, migliorando la conservazione e la resilienza del patrimonio forestale nazionale.
The Rural Campus Program is an initiative developed by the Spanish Ministry for the Ecological Transition and the Demographic Challenge, in collaboration with the Ministry of Universities and the Conference of Rectors of Spanish Universities (CRUE), which allows university students of any official degree to carry out training practices in rural environments.
The program is committed to the potential of the territory, the promotion of young employment and the promotion of local talent, promoting the connection between the population of different areas with rural spaces, generating new forms of roots and ties, which promote activity and create opportunities of employment in the territory.
Students will receive a scholarship of 1,000 euros gross per month for accommodation and maintenance.
In this way, students will have the opportunity to get to know other places in Spanish geography, and to contribute to generating opportunities in rural areas by providing talent.
This program aims to lay the foundations for a new form of relationship between the young population and the rural environment, with greater contact with nature and the rural socioeconomic environment.
The objective is to achieve a more resilient and sustainable rural environment.
Any local administration, institution, organization, non-profit entity or legally constituted company that carries out its activity in Spanish municipalities with less than 5,000 inhabitants, which are the most affected by depopulation, can participate in this program. When they have requested their participation in the Program from the participating Universities and are accepted as a collaborating entity.
El Programa Campus Rural es una iniciativa desarrollada por el Ministerio para la Transición Ecológica y el Reto Demográfico, en colaboración con el Ministerio de Universidades y la Conferencia de Rectores de las Universidades Españolas (CRUE), que permite a los universitarios de cualquier titulación oficial realizar prácticas formativas en entornos rurales.
El programa apuesta por las potencialidades del territorio, la promoción del empleo joven y el impulso del talento local, fomentando la vinculación de la población de diferentes zonas con los espacios rurales, generando nuevas formas de arraigo y vínculo, que impulsen la actividad y creen oportunidades de empleo en el territorio.
Los estudiantes recibirán una beca de 1.000 euros brutos mensuales para alojamiento y manutención.
De esta forma los estudiantes tendrán la oportunidad de conocer otros lugares de la geografía española, y de contribuir a generar oportunidades en las áreas rurales aportando talento.
Este programa pretende sentar las bases de una nueva forma de relación entre la población joven y el entorno rural, con un mayor contacto con la naturaleza y el ámbito socioeconómico rural.
El objetivo es conseguir un entorno rural más resiliente y sostenible.
Puede participar en este programa cualquier administración local, institución, organismo, entidad sin ánimo de lucro o empresa legalmente constituidas, que desarrollen su actividad en municipios españoles de menos de 5.000 habitantes, que son los más afectados por la despoblación. Siempre que hayan solicitado su participación en el Programa a las Universidades adheridas y sean aceptados como entidad colaboradora.
Programa CULTIVA is a training resource promoted and financed by the Spanish Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (MAPA) in collaboration with national entities representing the agricultural sector as well as with the support of linked model farms with them.
Its goal is to offer young farmers and ranchers access to practical training and useful knowledge for the development of their own agricultural activity.
It is developed through training visits of 5 to 14 days in host model farms.
The following steps are followed:
- Publication of the call and start of the application period of aid for entities for the organization of the Programa CULTIVA.
- Publication of the Catalog of Training Stays on the Rural Youth portal of the MAPA website.
- Application deadline for visits for young farmers and ranchers.
- Allocation of aid and places in training visits.
The Program is designed to offer young farmers and ranchers the opportunity to:
- Know in situ the development of a viable agricultural holding.
- Acquire and consolidate in a practical and interactive way new technical and management concepts applicable to their farm.
- Learn other alternatives or management models for your activity as well as the use and application of new technologies.
- Know how farms are managed in other regions of the national territory.
- Establish contacts, share and exchange experiences with other professionals in the agricultural sector.
- Know the activities and functioning of other organizations, cooperatives or entities related to the agricultural sector.
El Programa CULTIVA es un recurso formativo impulsado y financiado por el Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación (MAPA) de España en colaboración con entidades de ámbito nacional representativas del sector agrario así como con el apoyo de explotaciones modelo vinculadas con las mismas.
Su objetivo es ofrecer a los jóvenes agricultores y ganaderos acceso a formación práctica y conocimientos útiles para el desarrollo de su propia actividad agraria.
Se desarrolla a través de estancias formativas de 5 a 14 días de duración en explotaciones modelo de acogida.
Se siguen los siguientes pasos:
- Publicación de la convocatoria e inicio del plazo de solicitud de las ayudas para las entidades para la organización del Programa CULTIVA.
- Publicación del Catálogo de Estancias Formativas en el portal de Jóvenes Rurales de la web del MAPA.
- Plazo de solicitud de las estancias para los jóvenes agricultores y ganaderos.
- Asignación de las ayudas y las plazas en las estancias formativas.
El Programa está diseñado para ofrecer a agricultores y ganaderos jóvenes la oportunidad de:
- Conocer in situ el desarrollo de una explotación agraria viable.
- Adquirir y consolidar de un modo práctico e interactivo nuevos conceptos técnicos y de gestión aplicables en su explotación.
- Aprender otras alternativas o modelos de gestión de su actividad así como el uso y la aplicación de nuevas tecnologías.
- Conocer cómo se gestionan las explotaciones en otras regiones del territorio nacional.
- Establecer contactos, compartir e intercambiar experiencias con otros profesionales del sector agrario.
- Conocer las actividades y funcionamiento de otros organismos, cooperativas o entidades relacionadas con el sector agrario.
One of the practical cases analysed in i2connect is the InnoTour Bayern. It is a Bavarian ‘roadshow’ on innovations in agriculture, forestry and nutrition, with the aim of stimulating and accelerating innovation. In each of the seven administrative districts, a one- to two-day event takes place on a farm/production site with an innovative character.
In addition to farmers and foresters, the target groups are interested companies and consumers, research and advisory services.
The focus is on sustainable, socially accepted and economically realisable ideas and concepts with added value and lighthouse character. A film documentation creates a ‘library of innovation’.
The focus is on illustrative solutions to current socio-political challenges. The main topics are biodiversity, value chains and diversification, emission reduction in animal husbandry, animal welfare, digitalisation, climate change and climate adaptation (e.g. in the choice of tree species), marketing, irrigation, innovative technology, sustainable arable and crop farming, etc.
The examples are intended to show possible solutions for a local problem and are then discussed with the participants. The solutions should be applicable to as many other farms as possible, i.e. deal with central problems. In this way, a wide range of benefits are created for the entire sector and society.
Die InnoTour Bayern ist eine bayerische "Roadshow" zu Innovationen in der Land- und Forstwirtschaft sowie Ernährung, um Innovationen anzuschieben und zu beschleunigen. In jedem der sieben Regierungsbezirke findet eine ein- bis zweitägige Veranstaltung auf einem Betrieb/einer Produktionsstätte mit Innovationscharakter statt.
Zielgruppen sind neben Land- und Forstwirten interessierte Unternehmen und Verbraucher, die Forschung und die Beratung.
Der Fokus liegt auf nachhaltigen, gesellschaftlich akzeptierten und ökonomisch realisierbaren Ideen und Konzepten mit Mehrwert und Leuchtturmcharakter. Durch eine filmische Dokumentation entsteht eine "Sachbibliothek zu Innovation".
Es geht um anschauliche Lösungen zu aktuellen gesellschaftspolitischen Herausforderungen. Die Schwerpunktthemen sind Biodiversität, Wertschöpfungsketten und Diversifizierung, Emissionsreduktion in der Tierhaltung, Tierwohl, Digitalisierung, Klimawandel und Klimaanpassung (z. B. bei der Baumartenwahl), Vermarktung, Bewässerung, innovative Technik, zukunftsfähiger Acker- und Pflanzenbau etc.
Die Beispiele sollen Lösungsmöglichkeiten für ein Problem vor Ort zeigen und werden im Anschluss mit den Teilnehmern diskutiert. Die Lösungen sollten auf möglichst zahlreichen weiteren Betrieben anwendbar sein, also zentrale Probleme behandeln. Auf diese Weise entsteht ein vielseitiger Nutzen für die gesamte Branche und die Gesellschaft.
The Applied Innovation Research and Results Information system (TITRIS) collects, publicizes, and compiles data on applied innovation research and results that can potentially contribute to more effecient, sustainable, and environmentally friendly farming.
The object of TITRIS is research and innovations created in practice that have and can have a lower or higher significance in the development of sustainable agricultural production.
Data on the results of applied research and innovation are provided to TITRIS by scientific institutions, farms, and other producers of specialized activities.
TITRIS is designed for farmers, advisers, and researchers to get acquainted with innovations in agriculture.
The system is of an open access.
Farmers and researchers are invited to publicize applied innovations and results in the system for free.
Information in TITRIS is available both in Lithuanian and English therefore, farmers and researchers from Lithuania and other countries can upload innovations and their results to TITRIS.
Taikomųjų inovacijų tyrimų ir rezultatų informacinėje sistemoje (TITRIS) renkami, viešinami ir kaupiami taikomųjų inovacijų tyrimų ir rezultatų duomenys, kurie naudingi, siekiant efektyvesnio, tvaresnio, aplinką tausojančio ūkininkavimo.
TITRIS objektas – mokslo tyrimai ir praktikoje sukurtos inovacijos, turintys ir galintys turėti mažesnį ar didesnį reikšmingumą, plėtojant tvarią žemės ūkio gamybą.
Duomenis apie taikomųjų tyrimų ir inovacijų rezultatus į TITRIS teikia mokslo institucijos, ūkiai, kiti specializuotos veiklos gamybininkai.
Sistema skirta ūkininkams, konsultantams ir mokslininkams susipažinti su žemės ūkio srityje sukurtomis inovacijomis.
Ūkininkai ir mokslininkai kviečiami sistemoje paviešinti inovacijas ir jų rezultatus nemokamai.
TITRIS yra atviros prieigos sistema.
Sistemoje informacija apie inovacijas ir jų rezultatus pateikiama lietuvių ir anglų kalbomis.
Sistemoje talpinamos mokslinės ir praktinės inovacijos.
One of the practical cases of i2connect was dedicated to the role of consultancy in the valorisation of Aglione della Valdichiana. This variety is similar to common garlic but with a more delicate flavour and better digestibility, and was the focus of an initiative launched by a farmer in Umbria. With the support of a consultant and a student who dedicated his thesis to this cultivar, a network of Tuscan and Umbrian farmers emerged to promote the garlic both in Italy and abroad.
One of the main challenges was the creation of a network between farmers and associations in the two regions. In 2019, an Operational Group, V.A.V., was started and received funding in 2022 from Measure 16.2 of the Tuscany region. The consultant facilitated communication between the groups, enabling innovative processes and sustainable practices.
The activities undertaken include university research, training courses and field visits, with the aim of registering the aglione in the regional genetic resources and initiating the process for a Protected Designation of Origin (PDO). Trust between advisors and farmers, together with the passion of the advisor, were key factors for success. This project demonstrated the importance of collaboration to revitalise a traditional and sustainable agricultural product.
Uno dei casi pratici di i2connect è stato dedicato al ruolo della consulenza nella valorizzazione dell'Aglione della Valdichiana. Tale varietà è simile all'aglio comune ma dal sapore più delicato e dalla migliore digeribilità, è stato al centro di un'iniziativa avviata da un agricoltore umbro. Con il supporto di un consulente e di uno studente che ha dedicato la sua tesi a questa cultivar, è emersa una rete di agricoltori toscani e umbri per promuovere l'aglione sia in Italia che all'estero.
Una delle sfide principali è stata la creazione di un network tra agricoltori e associazioni delle due regioni. Nel 2019, è stato avviato un Gruppo Operativo, V.A.V., che ha ricevuto finanziamenti nel 2022 dalla Misura 16.2 della regione Toscana. Il consulente ha facilitato la comunicazione tra i gruppi, permettendo processi innovativi e pratiche sostenibili.
Le attività intraprese includono ricerche universitarie, corsi di formazione e visite in campo, con l’obiettivo di registrare l'aglione nelle risorse genetiche regionali e avviare il processo per la Denominazione di Origine Protetta (DOP). La fiducia tra consulenti e agricoltori, insieme alla passione del consulente, sono stati fattori chiave per il successo. Questo progetto ha dimostrato l'importanza della collaborazione per rivitalizzare un prodotto agricolo tradizionale e sostenibile.
In Slovenia, we do not have an effective system of traceability and marketing of organic beef. Much organically raised meat continues its journey through the supply chain like conventional meat. By introducing new decentralized digital technologies into the organic food supply chain, we are creating an efficient traceability system that will ensure greater data integrity and transparency of the entire supply chain from barn to fork. It is based on state-of-the-art digital and decentralized technologies, such as the open-source decentralized OriginTrail protocol for data exchange and blockchain technology. The goal of the system is to connect and compare the data of various stakeholders on activities in the supply chain, thus enabling a comprehensive overview of what is happening from the barn to the fork. By using decentralized technologies, it's provided a higher level of integrity to the data exchanged in the system, which enables an increase in consumer confidence in the information about products that they obtain through such a system. With EKOPAKT traceability system, breeders and meat processors better position their organic products on the market and develop new marketing approaches and business models. Data collected through the traceability model is also used to improve cooperation between farmers and advisors. Advisors would use the collected data in discussion groups, to transfer knowledge, to increase quality, competitiveness and economy both in terms of cattle breeding and fodder production technology, maintaining soil fertility and biodiversity on the farm. It is also important for easier professional and advisory work that data for the farm is available in one place or system.
V Sloveniji nimamo zgrajenega učinkovitega sistema sledljivosti in trženja ekološkega govejega mesa. Veliko mesa vzrejenega na ekološki način nadaljuje pot po preskrbovalni verigi kot konvencionalno meso. Z vpeljevanjem novih decentraliziranih digitalnih tehnologij v ekološko preskrbovalno verigo s hrano ustvarjamo učinkovit sistem sledljivosti, ki bo zagotavljal večjo integriteto podatkov ter transparentnost celotne preskrbovalne verige od hleva do vilice. Temelji na najsodobnejših digitalnih in decentraliziranih tehnologijah, kot so odprtokodni decentraliziran protokol OriginTrail za izmenjavo podatkov in tehnologije veriženja podatkovnih blokov. Cilj sistema je povezovati in medsebojno primerjati podatke različnih deležnikov o dogodkih v preskrbovalni verigi ter tako omogočiti celosten pregled dogajanja od hleva do vilice. Z uporabo decentraliziranih tehnologij izmenjanim podatkom v sistemu zagotovimo višji nivo integritete kar omogoča povečanje zaupanja potrošnikov v informacije o proizvodih, ki jih preko takšnega sistema pridobijo. S pomočjo EKOPAKT rejci in predelovalci mesa boljše pozicionirajo svoje ekološke proizvode na trgu ter razvijajo nove trženjske pristope in poslovne modele. Podatki, ki se zbirajo v okviru modela sledljivosti, se uporabljajo tudi za izboljšano sodelovanje med kmeti in svetovalci. Kmetijski svetovalci bi v panožnih krožkih zbrane podatke uporabili za prenos znanja, za povečanje kvalitete, konkurenčnosti in ekonomičnosti tako na delu prireje govedi in tehnologije pridelave krme, ohranjanja rodovitnosti tal in biodiverzitete na kmetiji.
Pomembno za lažje strokovno in svetovalno delo je, da so določeni podatki za kmetijo na voljo na enem mestu oziroma sistemu.
Ancient wheat varieties are more robust against pests and diseases, tolerate poor soil and a damp, cold climate. Because they require a long dough process, they are not suitable for industrial production and offer artisan bakeries an opportunity to differentiate from standardized, mass-produced goods. The expansion of regular cereal cultivation to include additional varieties promotes biodiversity on agricultural land. Old varieties generally require fewer soil nutrients, which means that the use of synthetic fertilizers can be reduced. In addition, the higher resistance to plant diseases makes the use of fungicides less necessary. The expansion of regular cereal cultivation to include additional varieties promotes biodiversity on agricultural land. Old varieties generally require fewer soil nutrients, which means that the use of synthetic fertilizers can be reduced. This allows farmers to reduce their production costs and lowers the risk of groundwater contamination with nitrogen. Initially, certified organic farmers in Luxembourg were asked whether they would be interested in taking part in the project. The next step was to find suppliers of seeds. These were sown for variety testing on the IBLA trial plots to test the cultivation of these varieties in Luxembourg. In a next step, bakeries in Luxembourg were contacted and asked to participate in the project. As there is no certified organic mill in Luxembourg, mills in Germany, Belgium and France were contacted that could be considered for processing. This would make baked goods, but also pasta made from old grain varieties in organic quality, a product innovation on the Luxembourg market. Furthermore, other forms of processing are being tested, for example grain as a rice substitute.
„Janetzkis begrannter Dickkopf“, „Schwarzer Wintergrannendinkel“ oder „Roter Sächsischer Landweizen“…noch nie gehört? Kein Wunder, denn diese alten Weizensorten hat der modernen Zuchtweizen von den meisten Äckern verdrängt. Alte Weizensorten sind robuster gegen Schädlinge und Krankheiten, tolerieren karge Böden und feucht-kaltes Klima. Weil sie eine lange Teigführung benötigen sind sie nicht für die industrielle Produktion geeignet und bieten handwerkliche Betriebe eine Möglichkeit, sich von standardisierter Massenware abzugrenzen. Vor allem für Verbraucher mit Weizenunverträglichkeit sind Produkte aus alten Weizensorten besonders empfehlenswert. Aufgrund der enthaltenen Anthocyane können vor allem Rotweizensorten das Risiko einer Krebserkrankung senken. Im Rahmen des Projekts berät das IBLA ProduzentInnen von der Auswahl des Saatguts bis zur Ernte. Parallel wird eine Wertschöpfungskette errichtet, welche Produzenten, Mühlen und verschiedene Verarbeiter wie Bäckereien und Brauereien miteinander verbindet. Zusätzlich werden mehrere alte Weizensorten in einer Sortenprüfung angebaut. Für die teilnehmenden Betriebe wird eine Vermarktungskonzept erarbeitet, welches ein einheitliches Marketing von Produkten aus alten Weizensorten unterstützt.
Monesca is a practical case analysed in the i2connect project. Its name cames from ESCA a vine disease, which causes severed damages to the plant. At the beginning, the disease is not visible: the fungi are destroying the wood within the vine plant. After several year the plant shows symptoms. The leaves could show tigerstripes or the plant show death symptoms. It brings severe economics problems, the death plants have to be replaced. Nowadays it is not possible to combat the fungi through preparations neither in the organic viticulture nor in the conventional farming. Those disease is already known since Middle-Age in the mediterranean areal. Due to global warming, the disease expand until the Luxembourg wine region. Because the disease appear as pretty new in the region, it is a new challenge for the winegrowers which need to be solved. It was not know, which needs do have the winegrowers and how they could be helped through advisory organisations.
The project has two parts: monitoring of the disease through dronebased very high resolution monitoring and dissemination of current viticulture methods to prevent the disease and to heal the sick vines. IBLA did questionaires in order to know better the knowledge and experiences of the winegrowers and the needs of advisory they have. Several types of training courses were offered during the time of the project: gentle pruning, vine surgery and Reset-method. The issue was tackled through various approaches and to combine the theoritical research with a wide dissemination for the winegrowers.
Esca ist eine Rebkrankheit, die durch mehrere, holzzersetzende Pilze verursacht wird. Ihre weite und schnelle Ausbreitung in Luxemburg wird durch den Klimawandel begünstigt. Die Krankheit wurde in den 1990er Jahren für die Moselregion relevant und bis heute gibt es keine wirksame Kontrollbehandlung. Während des Projekts MonESCA1 ist es gelungen, Methoden zur Überwachung von Esca über drohnenbasierte Bilder zu entwickeln.
Das Hauptziel des MonESCA-Projekts liegt im Monitoring und Verständnis des Auftretens der Krankheit l, und in der Fortsetzung MonESCA2 wird ein besonderer Schwerpunkt auf den Wissenstransfer in die weinbauliche Praxis gelegt. Daher werden vom IBLA mehrere Workshops für Winzer zu Managementpraktiken zur ESCA-Prophylaxe und-Bekämpfung organisiert (Sanfter Rebschnitt, Reset-Methode, Rebchirurgie). Die zweite Aufgabe des IBLA im MonESCA2 Projekt besteht in der Erarbeitung eines Decision-Support-Systems, welches für die WinzerInnen ESCA-wirksame Maßnahmen bei unterschiedlichen Befallsintensitäten generiert.
Code of Good Agricultural Practice was established in Lithuania in 2000. It is still valid however, legislation, requirements and rules are constantly changing. Therefore, an EIP operational group was formed aiming at developing a public electronic service for farmers allowing them to get relevant information, make certain
calculations themselves, assess their farms, take part in distance learning and ensure that farmers are able to get information despite the size of their farms. In other words, principles of good agricultural practice are now available in electronic space and are available for users. Information is constantly updated. The
contents of the electronic service was also very important as information was provided and digital tools were developed.
An innovative electronic service was developed, i.e. Code of Good Agricultural Practice was digitalized. The service was integrated into already existing information system. The service has information search function and navigation system. The service includes interactive consultations for farmers. In addition, electronic
catalogues of plant diseases and pests as well as registered products for plant protection are available in the system.
Projekto tikslas – sukurti viešą elektroninę paslaugą žemdirbiams, kad pastarieji galėtų savarankiškai diegti Geros žemdirbystės praktiką ūkiuose pagal tematiką ir individualų atskiro ūkio poreikį.
Projekto metu sukurta inovatyvi elektroninė paslauga užtikrina žinių pasiekiamumą, prieinamumą, galimybę savarankiškai naudotis, taikyti pagal individualius poreikius. Informacija atnaujinama realiu laiku, yra realizuota praktinio taikymo ir nuotolinio mokymosi galimybė, skatinamas rezultatyvus bendradarbiavimas, apjungiant skirtingas kompetencijas: žinias, patirtį, praktinį darbą ir inovatyvias technologijas.
Projektu buvo siekiama, pasitelkiant žinias, sukurti algoritmus, IT sprendinius, kad būtų galima perkelti Geros žemdirbystės praktikos principus į elektroninę erdvę, užtikrinant jų pasiekiamumą, aktualumą, suprantamumą, patikimumą ir savarankišką praktinį naudojimą.
Reduced tillage methods, such as no-till, strip-till, and minimum tillage instead of ploughing, are an efficient way to conserve carbon in the soil. However, reduced tillage is not widely practiced in Latvia due to rather heavy soils and short growing seasons. The Latvian Rural Advisory and Training Centre motivated a group of farmers to test these soil cultivation methods on their farms. An experienced advisor initiated a farmer working group.
Initially, the advisor provided the farmers with the necessary knowledge to no-till technology, including a visit to Finland to see its application in a similar climate. As the project progressed, the farmers gained experience and began to share insights with each other, transitioning from learners to experts. The role of the advisor shifted from being the primary expert to facilitating the exchange of experiences among farmers.
After nearly five years, the transition from conventional to no-till farming has shown that yields were not negatively affected, even in the initial years. Engaging farmers in this change required minimal effort because the farmers themselves were motivated to experiment. The project allowed for flexible implementation, fostering a sense of ownership and innovation among participants. The project's success analysed in i2connect can be attributed to several factors:
1. Timing and Relevance: The initiative was introduced at the right time and place.
2. Practical Comparison: Farmers could test the new technology on their own fields and compare it with traditional methods.
3. Peer Learning: The collaborative environment allowed farmers to learn from each other.
4. Skilled Advisor: Competencies with reduced tillage, accepting his changing role during the project.
Reduced tillage methods, such as no-till, strip-till, and minimum tillage instead of ploughing, are an efficient way to conserve carbon in the soil. However, reduced tillage is not widely practiced in Latvia due to rather heavy soils and short growing seasons. The Latvian Rural Advisory and Training Centre motivated a group of farmers to test these soil cultivation methods on their farms. An experienced advisor initiated a farmer working group.
Initially, the advisor provided the farmers with the necessary knowledge to no-till technology, including a visit to Finland to see its application in a similar climate. As the project progressed, the farmers gained experience and began to share insights with each other, transitioning from learners to experts. The role of the advisor shifted from being the primary expert to facilitating the exchange of experiences among farmers.
After nearly five years, the transition from conventional to no-till farming has shown that yields were not negatively affected, even in the initial years. Engaging farmers in this change required minimal effort because the farmers themselves were motivated to experiment. The project allowed for flexible implementation, fostering a sense of ownership and innovation among participants. The project's success analysed in i2connect can be attributed to several factors:
1. Timing and Relevance: The initiative was introduced at the right time and place.
2. Practical Comparison: Farmers could test the new technology on their own fields and compare it with traditional methods.
3. Peer Learning: The collaborative environment allowed farmers to learn from each other.
4. Skilled Advisor: Competencies with reduced tillage, accepting his changing role during the project.
One of the practical case of the i2connect database is a project about an action plan for an area based approach for "green" and "blue" development. The Province of North Brabant faces complex challenges related to livestock emissions, desiccation, and declining biodiversity, all of which impact natural areas and available resources. Spatial developments such as housing, infrastructure, and the energy transition further strain the region. Cooperation among multiple stakeholders is essential to effectively address these issues. To understand farmers' perspectives, the Province tasked ZLTO with engaging farmers to gather insights about their operations and future aspirations.
The project employs a structured approach to bridge the knowledge gap regarding farmers’ futures and local sentiments. Experienced agricultural advisors conduct in-person interviews, fostering constructive dialogue between farmers and the government. The innovation lies in creating a safe space for open discussions and in the collaboration between agricultural organizations and specialized consultants. Key success factors include the advisors' expertise and the trust established with farmers. No unexpected failures occurred; instead, the process evolved through practical learning. Lessons learned encompass skills in information management and effective communication among stakeholders. Advisors play a crucial role, building trust and facilitating the collection of valuable information that informs the project.
One of the practical case of the i2connect database is a project about an action plan for an area based approach for "green" and "blue" development. The Province of North Brabant faces complex challenges related to livestock emissions, desiccation, and declining biodiversity, all of which impact natural areas and available resources. Spatial developments such as housing, infrastructure, and the energy transition further strain the region. Cooperation among multiple stakeholders is essential to effectively address these issues. To understand farmers' perspectives, the Province tasked ZLTO with engaging farmers to gather insights about their operations and future aspirations.
The project employs a structured approach to bridge the knowledge gap regarding farmers’ futures and local sentiments. Experienced agricultural advisors conduct in-person interviews, fostering constructive dialogue between farmers and the government. The innovation lies in creating a safe space for open discussions and in the collaboration between agricultural organizations and specialized consultants. Key success factors include the advisors' expertise and the trust established with farmers. No unexpected failures occurred; instead, the process evolved through practical learning. Lessons learned encompass skills in information management and effective communication among stakeholders. Advisors play a crucial role, building trust and facilitating the collection of valuable information that informs the project.
The OrtoBioStrip project is one of the practical cases analysed during i2connect. This project aims to sustainably manage hilly soils subject to erosion and loss of fertility, aggravated by deep ploughing and the abandonment of traditional crop rotations. The central innovation is strip cropping, which alternates crops in narrow bands to reduce erosion, competition from wild flora and promote synergies between crops. This approach is combined with other agro-ecological techniques: cover crops, heterogeneous genetic material and minimum tillage, with the aim of improving soil fertility and generating ecosystem services.
A key success factor of the project was the involvement of partner Arca srl Benefit, which provided technical and administrative support, facilitating dialogue between farmers, researchers and institutions. Innovation is distinguished on two levels: an agro-ecological redesign requiring new skills and business organisation, and a socio-technical innovation to overcome the bureaucratic barriers linked to CAP funding, which is still unsuitable for these practices.
Lessons learnt include the importance of administrative support to manage bureaucracy and the need for transversal skills to effectively coordinate project partners.
Il progetto OrtoBioStrip è uno dei casi pratici analizzati nel corso di i2connect. Tale progetto mira a gestire in modo sostenibile i suoli collinari soggetti a erosione e perdita di fertilità, aggravati dall'aratura profonda e dall'abbandono delle rotazioni colturali tradizionali. L'innovazione centrale è la coltivazione a strisce (strip cropping), che alterna colture in bande strette per ridurre l'erosione, la competizione della flora spontanea e favorire sinergie tra le colture. Questo approccio è combinato con altre tecniche agroecologiche: colture di copertura, materiale genetico eterogeneo e minima lavorazione, con l'obiettivo di migliorare la fertilità del suolo e generare servizi ecosistemici.
Un fattore chiave di successo del progetto è stato il coinvolgimento del partner Arca srl Benefit, che ha fornito supporto tecnico e amministrativo, facilitando il dialogo tra agricoltori, ricercatori e istituzioni. L'innovazione si distingue su due livelli: un ridisegno agroecologico che richiede nuove competenze e organizzazione aziendale e un'innovazione socio-tecnica per superare le barriere burocratiche legate ai finanziamenti PAC, ancora non adatti a queste pratiche.
Tra le lezioni apprese, emergono l'importanza del supporto amministrativo per gestire la burocrazia e la necessità di competenze trasversali per coordinare efficacemente i partner del progetto.
One of the new roles of the agricultural and forestry advisor is the provision of advice on digitalization. To do this an advisor must have adequate digital knowledge.
The Spanish Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (MAPA) subsidizes measures and interventions with a supra-regional approach and co-financed by the EAFRD.
During the CAP period 2014-2022, the beneficiaries of submeasure 2.1 offered the following pool of digitalization advisory services:
- General concepts about digitization.
- Digitalization in farm management.
- Digital communication with public administrations.
- Management of the digital farm notebook.
- E-commerce.
- Digitalization of extensive livestock farms.
- Digitalization of livestock farms stabled.
- Digitalization for the optimization of inputs in agriculture.
- Digitalization for efficient irrigation.
- Kit digital.
In this CAP period 2022-2027 there will be three types of digitalization advice in intervention 7202 with a very flexible framework:
- Comprehensive.
- Specific.
- Essential.
With a different number of visits to the farm and unit cost.
These digitalization advice will allow farmers and foresters to facilitate their digital transition process.
Uno de los nuevos roles del asesor agrario y forestal, es la prestación de asesoramiento en digitalización. Para hacer esto un asesor debe tener unos conocimientos digitales adecuados.
El Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación (MAPA) de España subvenciona medidas e intervenciones cofinanciadas con el FEADER y con un enfoque supra-autonómico.
Durante el período de la PAC 2014-2022, los beneficiarios de la submedida 2.1 ofrecieron la siguiente cartera de servicios de asesoramiento en digitalización:
- Conceptos generales sobre digitalización.
- Digitalización en la gestión de la explotación agraria.
- Comunicación digital con las administraciones públicas.
- Gestión del cuaderno digital de la explotación agraria.
- Comercio electrónico.
- Digitalización de explotaciones ganaderas extensivas.
- Digitalización de explotaciones ganaderas estabuladas.
- Digitalización para la optimización de insumos en la agricultura.
- Digitalización para un riego eficiente.
- Kit digital.
En este periodo de programación de la PAC 2022-2027 habrá tres tipos de asesoramiento en digitalización en la intervención 7202 con un marco muy flexible:
- Integral.
- Específico.
- Básico.
Con diferente número de visitas a la finca y distinto coste unitario.
Estos asesoramientos en digitalización permitirán a los agricultores y selvicultores facilitar su proceso de transición digital.
Globalization has facilitated the movement of pathogens, making surveillance and early warning systems, even more necessary. Its importance also increases due to climate change, both in relation to the introduction of new pests and to variations in the behaviour of the ones already present.
The INTIA’s Warning Station has been in operation since 1989 to provide a public crop health warning and control service in Navarra region (Spain), as well as specific recommendations.
The Station's operation has two phases: the first one consists of observing and monitoring more than a hundred pests and diseases in 300 control points covering 50 different crops. In case of a health problem, the second phase, consists of sending alerts to farmers in the affected area, making recommendations for treatments and monitoring the subsequent control of the pest or disease.
During these 35 years, the Warning Station has evolved thanks to the new technologies and collaboration among stakeholders. In 2016, this service was digitalised to create a public and collaborative Web-Sig Platform. The collaborative approach allowed the incorporation of new traps and pest monitoring points thanks to the participation of agribusiness and agricultural cooperatives, who could register information from their own monitoring points, which was validated afterwards by INTIA’s technicians. Anyone interested could consult descriptive information on crops and pathogens, on the situation during the season, historical data on pests, predictive models for various diseases and strategies and recommendations. Since 2022, a mobile application is available for immediate dissemination of alerts, to enable quicker solutions according to the areas, timing and existing problems.
La globalización ha facilitado la circulación de patógenos, lo que hace necesario los sistemas de vigilancia y alerta temprana. Su importancia aumenta debido al cambio climático, tanto en relación con la introducción de nuevas plagas como con las variaciones en el comportamiento de las ya presentes.
La Estación de Avisos de INTIA proporciona desde 1989, un servicio público de alerta y control sanitario de los cultivos en Navarra (España), así como de recomendaciones específicas.
Su funcionamiento tiene dos fases: la primera consiste en la observación y seguimiento de más de un centenar de plagas y enfermedades en 300 puntos de control abarcando 50 cultivos diferentes. Ante un problema sanitario, la segunda fase, enviaría alertas a los agricultores de la zona afectada, recomendaciones de tratamientos y realizaría el seguimiento del posterior control de la plaga o enfermedad.
Durante estos 35 años, la Estación ha evolucionado gracias a las nuevas tecnologías y a la colaboración del sector. En 2016, se digitalizó en una Plataforma Web-Sig pública y colaborativa. El enfoque colaborativo permitió incorporar nuevas trampas y puntos de monitoreo gracias a la participación de agroempresas y cooperativas agrícolas, que pudieron registrar la información de sus propios puntos de monitoreo, siendo validada posteriormente por los técnicos de INTIA. Los usuarios podían consultar información descriptiva de cultivos y patógenos, sobre la situación durante la campaña, datos históricos de plagas, modelos predictivos de diversas enfermedades y estrategias y recomendaciones. Desde 2022, se dispone de una aplicación móvil para la difusión inmediata de alertas, que permite soluciones más rápidas según las zonas, el momento y los problemas existentes.
One of the case studies analyzed during the i2connect pilot project is ADOPTAÉ. It aims to promote the use of plant cover in New Aquitaine and Occitania, based on 7 local test areas: 3 vineyard areas and 4 field crop/polyculture-breeding areas. Spearheaded by the Nouvelle-Aquitaine Regional Chamber of Agriculture and co-piloted with the Occitanie Regional Chamber of Agriculture, ADOPTAÉ involves a large number of local players, with around thirty structures from various advisory networks (Chambers of Agriculture, CUMAs, agricultural cooperatives and traders, organic network, TRAME, IFV, etc.) from the 2 regions. These diverse and complementary players from the same region will work together to draw up action plans tailored to local issues and needs. The actions will encourage exchanges between peers and the promotion of existing work, whether on cover crops or on the methodology for supporting the agro-ecological transition. The project's 3 main areas of work, all interacting with each other, are :
- Enhancing the methodological and agronomic skills of advisers, based on exchanges between peers and lessons learned from other projects;
- Deploying actions on the ground with advisers, farmers and teachers: implementing an action plan jointly devised by local players to raise the profile of plant cover crops and help farmers to adopt them, by means of local actions and exchanges;
- Assessing the adoption of plant cover crops in local areas: developing a method for assessing the introduction of plant cover crops and the uptake of this practice, and carrying out local inventories.
ADOPTAÉ vise à favoriser le déploiement de la pratique des couverts végétaux auprès en Nouvelle-Aquitaine et Occitanie en s’appuyant sur 7 territoires tests au niveau local : 3 zones Vigne et 4 zones Grandes cultures/Polyculture-élevage. Porté par la Chambre régionale d’agriculture Nouvelle-Aquitaine et co-piloté avec la Chambre régionale d’agriculture Occitanie, ADOPTAÉ implique de nombreux acteurs des territoires, avec une trentaine de structures issues de différents réseaux de conseil (Chambres d’agriculture, CUMA, Coopératives et négoces agricoles, réseau Bio, TRAME, IFV…) des 2 régions. Ces acteurs diversifiés et complémentaires d’un même territoire, vont co-construire des plans d’action, adaptés aux enjeux et besoins locaux. Les actions favoriseront l’échange entre pairs et la valorisation des travaux existants, que ce soit sur les couverts ou sur la méthodologie d’accompagnement à la transition agro-écologique. Les 3 axes de travail du projet, en interaction les uns des autres sont :
- La montée en compétences méthodologiques et agronomiques des conseillers, en s’appuyant sur l’échange entre pairs et les enseignements d’autres projets ;
- Le déploiement d’actions terrain auprès des conseillers, des agriculteurs et de l'enseignement : mise en œuvre d’un plan d’actions co-construit entre acteurs du territoire pour développer la visibilité et accompagner l’appropriation des couverts végétaux par les agriculteurs, via des actions de proximité et d’échanges ;
- L’évaluation de l’adoption des couverts végétaux, sur les territoires : construction d’une méthode d’évaluation de la mise en place des couverts et de l’appropriation de cette pratique, et réalisation d'états des lieux locaux.
One of the projects peer-reviewed under i2connect is the initiative Versailles of the North. The Netherlands is launching a new program for World Class National Parks, with the Van Gogh National Park in North Brabant as a key example. This initiative emphasizes quality of life, urban development, and community engagement while strengthening the economy. The park uniquely combines nature reserves, an appealing agricultural landscape, and Van Gogh’s cultural heritage.
To attain World Class status, collaboration among municipalities, water boards, social organizations, volunteers, and businesses is essential. A significant focus is on the many nurseries within the park, where an innovative landscape framework will enhance these areas for recreation, ecology, and water management. The province aims to plant 40 million trees over the next decade, addressing CO2 emissions while restoring a complex network of landscape elements.
The project employs a collaborative process involving stakeholders, including ZLTO as the process coordinator, to build support and ensure effective communication. GIS analyses and area visits help assess the landscape, culminating in a regional sketch design facilitated by West8.
Success relies on talented advisors and trust among stakeholders. While initial engagement required more time than anticipated, lessons learned include prioritizing the growers’ perspectives and effective stakeholder management to foster cooperation in regional development.
One of the projects peer-reviewed under i2connect is the initiative Versailles of the North. The Netherlands is launching a new program for World Class National Parks, with the Van Gogh National Park in North Brabant as a key example. This initiative emphasizes quality of life, urban development, and community engagement while strengthening the economy. The park uniquely combines nature reserves, an appealing agricultural landscape, and Van Gogh’s cultural heritage.
To attain World Class status, collaboration among municipalities, water boards, social organizations, volunteers, and businesses is essential. A significant focus is on the many nurseries within the park, where an innovative landscape framework will enhance these areas for recreation, ecology, and water management. The province aims to plant 40 million trees over the next decade, addressing CO2 emissions while restoring a complex network of landscape elements.
The project employs a collaborative process involving stakeholders, including ZLTO as the process coordinator, to build support and ensure effective communication. GIS analyses and area visits help assess the landscape, culminating in a regional sketch design facilitated by West8.
Success relies on talented advisors and trust among stakeholders. While initial engagement required more time than anticipated, lessons learned include prioritizing the growers’ perspectives and effective stakeholder management to foster cooperation in regional development.
The innovative service "Aero Remote Soil Analysis and Consultations" is a result of an EIP project analysed in i2connect. The main objective of the project was to develop a technology based on data of unmanned aerial vehicle and soil studies which would allow to provide farmers a service ensuring that crop problems were dealt with effectively and on time and optimal solutions for dealing with these problems were offered. Operation reliability of the algorithms was tested using programmes ArcGis, Agisoft, and eCognition. The innovative service developed allowed to remotely identify hummus content in soil, level of soil erosion, level of soil humidity, granulometric composition of soil, and aggregate soil structure using aero photo images made by unmanned aerial vehicles and terrestrial soil characteristics.
A methodology and a standard for provision of new service were prepared. A specialized aerial unmanned vehicle was purchased. Using the device, it was possible to monitor area radius of which is 2 kilometers and make photos of resolution of 14 megapixel. Seminars on farms (more than 22 farms) were organized to demonstrate applicability of project results on farms.
Inovatyvi paslauga "Dirvožemio aerodistanciniai tyrimai ir konsultacijos" yra EIP projekto rezultatas.
Projekto rezultatas - sukurta nepilotuojamais orlaiviais ir dirvožemio tyrimais paremta technologija, leidžianti teikti ūkininkams paslaugą, padedančią efektyviai ir operatyviai identifikuoti žemės ūkio naudmenų dirvožemio problemas, siūlanti optimalius būdus joms spręsti.
Įgyvendinant projektą, buvo naudota Lietuvoje dar netaikyta ir neišbandyta technologija, kurią taikant, gali būti užtikrinta dirvožemio panaudojimo nauda. Inovatyvi paslauga buvo sukurta, bendradarbiaujant žemdirbiams, mokslininkams ir konsultantams.
Sukurta inovatyvi paslauga padeda ūkininkams valdomose žemės ūkio naudmenose nuotoliniu būdu identifikuoti humuso kiekį armenyje, dirvožemio erozijos laipsnį, dirvožemio drėgnumo lygį, granuliometrinę dirvožemio sudėtį ir agregatinę struktūrą.
Interactive innovation requires a multi-actor approach. If you are an agricultural or forestry entity and are looking for partners: what do you need? A digital tool to see operational groups classified by themes and regions of Spain. In this way, by seeing the members of the operational groups, you have more options to promote co-creation processes and make an innovative project that is impactful. In the Spanish PAC network you can find this tool: a viewer of operational groups. This viewer is an essential tool for an advisor. Moreover, this viewer has a very useful search engine that classifies operational groups by sectors and themes. It is even possible to download a list once the search is done. With all the existing information, we can classify the viewer as a Digital Advisory Tool and Service (DATS). It is important to highlight the economic capacity to execute the budget of an operational group and its members. Therefore, in the viewer you can find the budget of each operational group. Interactive innovation arises from professional contacts, existing quality information and success stories from operational groups. In conclusion, with DATS as this viewer, the work of the interactive innovation advisor is facilitated and the formation of better operational groups is promoted.
La innovación interactiva requiere un enfoque multiactor. Si tú eres una entidad agraria o forestal y buscas socios: ¿qué necesitas? Una herramienta digital para ver grupos operativos clasificados por temáticas y por regiones de España. De esta manera viendo los miembros de los grupos operativos, tienes más opciones de favorecer procesos de co-creación y hacer un proyecto innovador que sea impactante. En la red PAC española puedes encontrar esta herramienta: un visor de grupos operativos. Este visor es una herramienta esencial para un asesor. Además, este visor tiene un motor de búsqueda muy útil que clasifica los grupos operativos por sectores y por temáticas. Incluso, es posible descargar un listado una vez hecha la búsqueda. Con toda la información existente, podemos clasificar al visor como una Herramienta y Servicio Digital de Asesoramiento (HSDA). Es importante resaltar la capacidad económica para ejecutar presupuesto de un grupo operativo y de sus miembros. Por ello en el visor se puede encontrar el presupuesto de cada grupo operativo. La innovación interactiva surge de los contactos profesionales, la información de calidad existente y los casos de éxito de grupos operativos. Como conclusión, con HSDA como este visor, se facilita el trabajo del asesor de innovación interactiva y se promueve la formación de mejores grupos operativos.
Interactive innovation requires more than a multi-actor approach. For agricultural or forestry advisor it is important to know in advance the best available practices. For instance, a digital tool to see good practices classified by themes and regions of Spain. In this way, by seeing who participate in these good practices, you have better chances to promote co-creation processes and make an innovative project that is impactful.
In the Spanish PAC network you can find this tool: a viewer of good practices. This viewer is an essential tool for an advisor. Moreover, this viewer has a very useful search engine that classifies good practices by sectors, regions and themes. It is even possible to download a list once the search is done. With all the existing information, we can classify the viewer as a Digital Advisory Tool and Service (DATS). It is important to highlight these good practices because they facilitate networking, testimonials and opportunities for innovation. Therefore, in the viewer you can find the financial fund involved in each good practice. Interactive innovation arises from professional contacts, existing quality information and success stories from the best available good practices. In conclusion, with DATS as this viewer, the work of the interactive innovation advisor is facilitated and boosting co-creation processes using good practices.
La innovación interactiva requiere más que un enfoque multiactor. Si eres asesor agrícola o forestal, debes conocer de antemano las mejores prácticas disponibles. Por ejemplo, una herramienta digital para ver buenas prácticas clasificadas por temáticas y regiones de España. De esta manera, al ver quiénes participan de estas buenas prácticas, tienes mejores posibilidades de promover procesos de cocreación y diseñar un proyecto innovador y de impacto.
En la red PAC española puedes encontrar esta herramienta: un visor de buenas prácticas. Este visor es una herramienta esencial para un asesor. Además, este visor cuenta con un buscador muy útil que clasifica las buenas prácticas por sectores, regiones y temáticas. Incluso es posible descargar una lista una vez realizada la búsqueda. Con toda la información existente, podemos clasificar al visor como una Herramienta y Servicio de Asesoramiento Digital (DATS).
Es importante resaltar estas buenas prácticas porque facilitan el networking, los testimonios y las oportunidades de innovación. Además, en el visor se puede encontrar el fondo financiero implicado en cada buena práctica.
La innovación interactiva surge de contactos profesionales, información de calidad existente y casos de éxito de las mejores buenas prácticas disponibles.
En conclusión, con DATS como este visor se facilita el trabajo del asesor de innovación interactivo y se impulsan procesos de cocreación utilizando buenas prácticas.
The operational groups selected annually in an assessment commission -among the beneficiary Operational Groups of each call- benefit from the expertise and technical mentoring of National Center for Technology and Food Safety (CNTA) experts until the end of the year. So far, 3 editions have taken place (2021, 2022 and 2023) and the following operational groups have participated: Fruitcare, Lúpulos de Calidad, Sensolive oil, Proteinleg, Tecnogar, Global Dimension Sensolive_Oil, Micoalga-Feed, GC4SHEEP, ESJARA, SALUDGIRASOL and VINGO.
These actions between the CNTA and the Spanish Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (MAPA) are part of an agreement for the execution of technological development and innovation actions in the agri-food sector, framed in the areas of support for the revitalization of the innovation ecosystem, promotion of the implementation of innovations and the bioeconomy.
Carry out studies for the valuation of rejection fractions of raspberries, models in relation to quality parameters of olive oil, chemical and chromatic characterization to predict the evaluations of panels of tasters, analytical characterization of wild hops, create algorithms to objectively categorize olive oils, encourage the consumption of quality vegetable proteins, promote the cultivation of different improved varieties of chickpeas or develop functional feed for animals, modernizing the rockrose harvesting activity, increasing the profitability of sheep farming, identifying the quality and health of soils for sunflower cultivation and developing management models for minority grape varieties, among the objectives of the mentored and technically advised Operational Groups.
Los GOs seleccionados anualmente en una comisión de valoración -entre los grupos beneficiarios de cada convocatoria- se benefician del conocimiento y experiencia mediante la mentorización técnica de los expertos del Centro Nacional de Tecnología y Seguridad Alimentaria (CNTA) hasta finales de año. Hasta el momento han tenido lugar 3 ediciones (2021, 2022 y 2023) y han participado los GOs: Fruitcare, Lúpulos de calidad, Sensolive oil, Proteinleg, Tecnogar, Global Dimension Sensolive_Oil, Micoalga-Feed, GC4SHEEP, ESJARA, SALUDGIRASOL y VINGO. Estas acciones entre el CNTA y el Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación (MAPA) se encuadran en un convenio para la ejecución de actuaciones de desarrollo tecnológico e innovación del sector agroalimentario, enmarcadas en las áreas de apoyo a la dinamización del ecosistema de innovación, impulso a la puesta en marcha de innovaciones y la bioeconomía. Hacer estudios para la valorización de fracciones rechazo de frambuesas, modelos en relación con los parámetros de calidad del aceite de oliva, caracterización química y cromática para predecir las valoraciones de paneles de catadores, caracterización analítica de lúpulos silvestres, crear algoritmos para objetivar la categorización de los aceites de oliva, fomentar el consumo de proteínas vegetales de calidad, promover el cultivo de diferentes variedades mejoradas de garbanzo o elaborar piensos funcionales para animales, modernizar la actividad de recolección de la jara, incrementar la rentabilidad de la ganadería ovina, identificar calidad y salud de los suelos para cultivo de girasol y desarrollar modelos de gestión de variedades minoritarias de uva, entre los objetivos de los grupos operativos mentorizados y asesorados.
One of the projects analised in i2connect is Management of Base of Lithunian Forage Grasses Using Satellite Data and Agricultural Innovations (LIPIN). The objective of the project was to develop an innovative interactive service allowing to effectively identify condition of grasslands and problems, offer recommendations for solving the problems, predict the increase in productivity of grasslands. An interactive database of public access was developed. The system allows advisers to evaluate remote monitoring of grassland. They can use information about development, maintenance, and usage of grassland which is accumulated in the database. Advisers can use automatically formed recommendations. They can use tools allowing to calculate standard productivity of grassland choosing different parameters and to make recommended mixtures of grasslands. The innovative service was developed applying a method which had not been used before when satellite and terrestrial data is processed and set of actions is provided.
Projekto metu buvo sukurta inovatyvi interaktyvi paslauga, pagrįsta erdvinių ir antžeminių tyrimų duomenimis.
Teikiant šią inovatyvią paslaugą, konsultantai galės: įvertinti ūkyje turimus žolynus (vietinius išteklius) pašarų gamybai, jų tinkamumą turimoms ūkio sąlygoms; paskaičiuoti prognozuojamą pasigaminti pašarų kiekį pagal produktyvumą; nustatyti optimaliausią žolyno pjovimo pašarams gaminti laiką; sudaryti žolynų mišinius, pritaikytus prie konkretaus ūkio sąlygų, ūkyje auginamų gyvulių rūšių; konsultuoti ūkį dėl atliekamų darbų efektyvumo, sumažinant darbo laiko sąnaudas bei išlaidas žolynų priežiūrai (sąnaudas trąšoms, išlaidas technikai, kurui, darbuotojams); naudotis interaktyviais įrankiais, kurie leis pagal pasirinktus parametrus paskaičiuoti standartinį žolynų produktyvumą, sudaryti rekomendacinius žolynų mišinius.
The Kipster project was discussed as part of the i2connect "Excellence Classes" as a leading example of sustainable agricultural innovation. Kipster is an innovative poultry farm in the Netherlands, launched in 2017, designed to be the most sustainable in the world. The farm focuses on animal welfare, reducing CO2 emissions, and resource efficiency. Kipster uses a circular farming model, feeding hens with surplus food from the food industry and ensuring egg production with minimal environmental impact. The farm operates on solar energy, and its design promotes natural behaviors for the hens, such as foraging and perching.
Kipster's eggs are sold as the first carbon-neutral eggs in major supermarkets, with the goal of making egg production more sustainable and transparent. The farm also avoids the culling of male chicks, which is a common practice in the poultry industry, by raising male chickens for meat.
Kipster is a leading example of innovation in the agri-food sector, demonstrating how technological advancements and a commitment to sustainability can transform traditional farming methods. Its model is attracting interest from other regions and countries seeking to adopt more sustainable agricultural practices. The farm's success has sparked discussions on food production’s future, focusing on environmental sustainability, animal welfare, and ethical food production.
The Kipster project was discussed as part of the i2connect "Excellence Classes" as a leading example of sustainable agricultural innovation. Kipster is an innovative poultry farm in the Netherlands, launched in 2017, designed to be the most sustainable in the world. The farm focuses on animal welfare, reducing CO2 emissions, and resource efficiency. Kipster uses a circular farming model, feeding hens with surplus food from the food industry and ensuring egg production with minimal environmental impact. The farm operates on solar energy, and its design promotes natural behaviors for the hens, such as foraging and perching.
Kipster's eggs are sold as the first carbon-neutral eggs in major supermarkets, with the goal of making egg production more sustainable and transparent. The farm also avoids the culling of male chicks, which is a common practice in the poultry industry, by raising male chickens for meat.
Kipster is a leading example of innovation in the agri-food sector, demonstrating how technological advancements and a commitment to sustainability can transform traditional farming methods. Its model is attracting interest from other regions and countries seeking to adopt more sustainable agricultural practices. The farm's success has sparked discussions on food production’s future, focusing on environmental sustainability, animal welfare, and ethical food production.
The grassland discussion group, led by a ProAgria expert, has been operating in Paimio since 2004. In order to maintain its attractivenness and usefullness, the group has had to constantly renew itself. New content and methods have been sought through training of the facilitator and methodological experiments. One of the new initiatives was to bring an international dimension to the group and thus to expose it to new ideas and experiences. In practice, the group started bi-annual visits abroad to other farmers' farms. Meeting and working with farmers from other countries opened the eyes of the group members. New ideas developed both the group's strategic and day-to-day thinking and activities. They also provided a place for renewal for the group facilitator. This enabled the group to achieve better results again, even after years of development.
ProAgrian asiantuntijan vetämä nurmipienryhmä on toiminut Paimolla vuodesta 2004. Jotta ryhmän pitovoima säilyy, sen on täytynyt uudistua jatkuvasti. Uutta sisältöä ja menetelmiä on haettu vetäjän kouluttautumisen ja menetelmäkokeilujen kautta. Yhtenä uutena aloitteena päätettiin ryhmään tuoda kansainvälinen ulottuus ja sen kautta uusille ajatuksille ja kokemuksille altistuminen. Käytännössä ryhmä aloitti puolivuosittaiset vierailut ulkomaille toisten viljelijöiden maatiloille. Muun maalaisten viljelijöiden tapaaminen ja heidän kanssaan yhdessä työskentely avasivat ryhmäläisten silmiä. Uudet ideat kehittivät niin ryhmän strategisia kuin päivittäisen työarjen ajatuksia ja toimintaa. Ne tarjosivat myös uudistumisen paikan ryhmän vetäjälle. Näin ryhmä ylsi vielä vuosien kehitystyön jälkeenkin uudelleen parempiin tuloksiin.
The interactive innovation model has been promoted by the EIP-Agri and the Horizon Europe multi-actor projects.
The Spanish Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (MAPA) manages the CAP supra-regional interventions for the transfer of knowledge and advisory services. These calls for aid have a high level of competitive competition among the main actors in the agri-food and forestry sector. For these reasons, it is important to clearly define the evaluation criteria for applications.
In the regulatory bases for aid for the transfer of knowledge and advisory services (mainly in digitalization), interactive innovation has been included as a criterion to be evaluated by experts.
Within the category of impact produced by the application, the following aspects will be assessed:
i) Support for business development, new models of enhanced business, strengthening of innovation ecosystem.ii) Presence of the interactive innovation.
These criteria favor the hiring of advisors who act as innovation brokers. In this way, applicants and operational groups will create proposals that include interactive innovation.
Desde la EIP-Agri y los proyectos multiactor Horizonte Europa se ha promovido el modelo de innovación interactiva.
El Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación (MAPA) de España gestiona las intervenciones de la PAC supra-autonómicas de transferencia de conocimiento y de servicios de asesoramiento. Estas convocatorias de ayudas tienen una elevada concurrencia competitiva entre los principales actores del sector agroalimentario y forestal. Por estos motivos, es importante definir bien los criterios de valoración de las solicitudes.
En las bases reguladoras de las ayudas a la transferencia de conocimiento y de los servicios de asesoramiento (principalmente en digitalización), se ha incluido la innovación interactiva como criterio a evaluar por expertos. Dentro de la categoría de impacto que produce la solicitud, se valorará lo siguiente:
i) Apoyo al desarrollo empresarial, nuevos modelos de negocio potenciados, fortalecimiento del ecosistema de innovación. ii) Presencia de la innovación interactiva.
Con estos criterios se favorece la contratación de asesores que actúen como agentes de innovación. Los solicitantes y las agrupaciones crearán propuestas que incluyan la innovacción interactiva.
I2CONNECT utilizes cross-visits as an educational method that facilitates advisors to realize the multiple perspectives of the actors involved in interactive innovations and to practice the tools learned in the respective training courses.
The cross-visit to Greece identified two challenges to achieve these goals:
First, the plurality and richness of information during interviews made it difficult for the participating advisors to assimilate it, as they needed more time to delve deeper into the considered innovation. Also, their intense interest about technologies and technical processes sometimes distracted them from staying focused on to the innovation process and network. This made the next step more difficult, when they had to utilize the tools and draw relevant conclusions.
Second, though the first day of the cross-visit included a brief presentation of the tools, this was not enough for the advisors to recall details on their best implementation. In some cases, the existence of a long lapse of time between the advisors' training and the cross visit deteriorated advisors’ ability to use the tools, as their knowledge had faded. Thus, though they understood the value of the tools, they also found them “too complicated to use in the real life”.
Therefore, a lesson concerns the compliance with the guideline on 'involving advisors in a cross-visit in a short time after their training', though it is recognized that this is difficult in practice. Moreover, the cross-visitors suggested the local advisors should be trained in the use of the tools and directly contribute their own perceptions to the cross-visit results. This would bring the local advisors more consciously into the role of reflective observers of their own innovation case.
Το I2CONNECT αξιοποιεί τις ανταλλαγές επισκέψεων για να διευκολύνει τους συμβούλους να συνειδητοποιήσουν τις πολλαπλές απόψεις των εμπλεκόμενων στις διαδραστικές καινοτομίες και να εξασκηθούν στα εργαλεία που διδάσκονται στα αντίστοιχα εκπαιδευτικά σεμινάρια του έργου.
Η επίσκεψη στην Ελλάδα εντόπισε δύο προκλήσεις για την επίτευξη αυτών των στόχων:
Πρώτον, ο πλουραλισμός και πλούτος των πληροφοριών δυσκόλεψε την αφομοίωσή τους από τους συμμετέχοντες συμβούλους, που χρειάζονταν χρόνο για να εμβαθύνουν στην υπό εξέταση καινοτομία. Επίσης, το ενδιαφέρον για τεχνολογίες και τεχνικές διαδικασίες τούς αποσπούσε από τη διαδικασία και το δίκτυο καινοτομίας και καθιστούσε δυσκολότερη την αξιοποίηση των εργαλείων και την εξαγωγή συμπερασμάτων.
Δεύτερον, αν και την πρώτη μέρα έγινε μια σύντομη παρουσίαση των εργαλείων, αυτή δεν ήταν αρκετή για να θυμηθούν οι σύμβουλοι λεπτομέρειες για τη βέλτιστη εφαρμογή τους. Επιπλέον, η ύπαρξη σημαντικού χρονικού διαστήματος μεταξύ της εκπαίδευσής τους και της επίσκεψης επιδείνωσε την ικανότητά τους να αξιοποιούν τα εργαλεία, καθώς οι γνώσεις τους είχαν ατονήσει. Έτσι, αν και συνειδητοποιούν την αξία των εργαλείων, τα θεώρησαν "πολύ περίπλοκα για να χρησιμοποιηθούν στην πραγματική ζωή". Ως εκ τούτου, η συμμετοχή των συμβούλων σε επίσκεψη σε σύντομο χρονικό διάστημα μετά την εκπαίδευσή τους, παρά τις πρακτικές δυσκολίες, πρέπει κατά το δυνατόν να τηρείται. Επίσης, οι σύμβουλοι πρότειναν οι εμπλεκόμενοι στην υπό εξέταση καινοτομία σύμβουλοι να εκπαιδεύονται στη χρήση των εργαλείων ώστε να συνεισφέρουν άμεσα στην ανάλυση της καινοτομίας, γεγονός που θα τούς καθιστούσε αναστοχαστικούς παρατηρητές της καινοτομίας τους.
GO FAGUS has been promoting the revaluation of beech wood through innovation in forest management and the technologisation of product classification and characterisation, thus creating a local bioeconomy.
This innovative project was coordinated by AGRESTA and CESEFOR with a great diversity in its membership: Föra, Madera+, CETEMAS, HAZI and Ademan. There were some contracted members: A couple of universities and a vocational school. And also had some public institutions collaboration in the development of the project.
AGRESTA and CESEFOR were acting as Innovation Support Services.
They assumed the main tasks and the development of the project.
The Spanish forestry sector does not have a public advisory service. Advice on innovation is usually given by private entities, technology centers and universities like in this project.
Main results:
- A nationally representative sample of beech stands has been quantitatively inventoried and surveyed.
- Development of tools for the calculation and classification of beech wood volumes according to the morphological characteristics of the standing
tree, based on the use of airborne and terrestrial LiDAR and photogrammetry.
- Standardise potential beech wood qualities according to desired products along the forest industry value chain.
- Create a new beech LVL product for use in structures.
- Develop of an interregional beechwood promotion round table with various stakeholders.
Finally, its main added value is the inspiration to improve wood industry results and the foundations to give continuity of this project with other funds like LIFE Program.
GO FAGUS viene impulsando la revalorización de la madera de haya a través de la innovación en la gestión forestal y de la tecnificación de la clasificación y caracterización de productos, creando así una bioeconomía local.
Este innovador proyecto fue coordinado por AGRESTA y CESEFOR con una gran diversidad de miembros: Föra, Madera+, CETEMAS, HAZI y Ademan. Había algunos miembros contratados: un par de universidades y una escuela de formación profesional. Y también contó con la colaboración de algunas instituciones públicas en el desarrollo del proyecto.
AGRESTA y CESEFOR actuaban como Servicios de Apoyo a la Innovación. Asumieron las tareas principales y el desarrollo del proyecto.
El sector forestal español no cuenta con un servicio público de asesoramiento. El asesoramiento en innovación suele ser dado por entidades privadas, centros tecnológicos y universidades como en este proyecto.
Resultados principales:
- Se ha inventariado y estudiado cuantitativamente una muestra representativa a nivel nacional de hayedos.
- Desarrollo de herramientas para el cálculo y clasificación de volúmenes de madera de haya según las características morfológicas del pie árbol, basado en el uso de LiDAR aéreo y terrestre y fotogrametría.
- Estandarizar las calidades potenciales de la madera de haya según los productos deseados a lo largo de la cadena de valor de la industria forestal.
- Crear un nuevo producto LVL de haya para uso en estructuras.
- Desarrollo de una mesa redonda interregional de promoción de la madera de haya con diversos actores.
Finalmente, su principal valor añadido es la inspiración para mejorar los resultados de la industria de la madera y las bases para dar continuidad a este proyecto con otros fondos como el Programa LIFE.
One of the Spanish AKIS actors is CNTA, that presents every year its Report on the FoodTech Opportunity Scenario Map, funded by MAPA.
These reports are the result of an observation and information curation process carried out daily throughout 2022 and 2023. To do this, the CNTA Vanguard team analysed the FoodTech news published in more than 100 information sources (both Spanish and international) and identified future scenarios which present transformation opportunities for the food industry.
WHAT DO WE CALL FOODTECH NEWS?
Information that covers innovative approaches to solving the challenges faced by society and the food industry which have a technological component and the potential to generate a transformative impact. The aim of this report is to present the FoodTech opportunity scenario map, a visual tool which shows the situation of the FoodTech industry on a two-dimensional plane. The map can help us understand what is being talked about and how much is being said, and reflects the stage of innovation or degree of maturity of a specific technology.
A macro scenario consists of a certain number of scenarios. In total in this analysis, there are 9 macro scenarios and 35 scenarios:
1. Alternative proteins, a macro scenario full of challenges.
2. Alternative foods and ingredients, proposals to improve flavor.
3. Sustainability, solutions to pollute less, without falling into greenwashing.
4. Process technologies: more scalability is needed.
5. Healthy foods: food as medicine.
6. The children's sector, athletes and seniors, in the focus of personalized nutrition.
7. Digitalization, AI floods everything.
8. Food Quality and Safety 4.0: bet on Nir, Hiperspectral and blockchain.
9. Clean label, more transparency.
CNTA presenta cada año Informes del Mapa de escenarios de Oportunidad Foodtech, financiado por el MAPA. Estos informes son el resultado de un proceso de observación y curado de información realizado en el 2022 y 2023.
Para realizarlo el equipo del CNTA analiza las noticias FoodTech publicadas en más de 100 fuentes de información (tanto nacionales como internacionales) e identifica los escenarios futuros que presentan oportunidades de transformación en industria alimentaria.
¿QUÉ DENOMINAMOS NOTICIAS FOODTECH?
Las informaciones que recogen novedades y su evolución para resolución de retos a los que se enfrenta la sociedad e industria alimentaria, con una componente tecnológica y con potencial de generar impacto transformador.
El objetivo es presentar el Mapa de escenarios de Oportunidad FoodTech. Una herramienta visual que ubica en un plano bidimensional de la situación de la industria FoodTech. El mapa ayuda a entender de qué se habla y cuánto se habla, así como el momento de innovación o grado de madurez de una tecnología.
Un escenario macro consta de un cierto nº de escenarios. En total en este análisis, hay 9 escenarios macro y 35 escenarios:
1. Proteínas alternativas, un macroescenario lleno de retos.
2. Alimentos e ingredientes alternativos, propuestas para mejorar el sabor.
3. La sostenibilidad, soluciones para contaminar menos, sin greenwashing.
4. Tecnologías de proceso: se necesita más escalabilidad.
5. Alimentos saludables: alimentos como medicina.
6. El sector infantil, los deportistas y las personas seniors, en el foco de la nutrición personalizada.
7. Digitalización, la IA lo inunda todo.
8. Calidad y Seguridad Alimentaria 4.0: apuesta por Nir, Hiperespectral y blockchain.
9. Clean label, más transparencia.
An innovative board game supports agricultural decision-making amidst projected climate and economic uncertainties by 2050. It addresses the diverse challenges farmers face daily, enhancing their capacity for multi-performance decision-making. This immersive approach offers unique training in agricultural business management. The game, tailored for farmers and students, allows solo or collaborative play, emphasizing achieving sustainability thresholds. Each three-year game cycle involves decision-making on cropping and farming practices, adapting to seasonal challenges, and analyzing results collaboratively. Deployment in 8 interventions with 12 trained facilitators yielded promising results. Additional sessions target farmer collectives and educational programs. Future considerations include game extensions and adaptations to various agricultural sectors and climatic contexts. Using game for training farmers gives another approach for the advisors to discuss adaptation and mitigation measures.
Un jeu de société innovant soutient la prise de décision agricole face aux incertitudes climatiques et économiques projetées d'ici 2050. Il aborde les défis variés auxquels les agriculteurs sont confrontés quotidiennement, renforçant leur capacité à prendre des décisions multifonctionnelles. Cette approche immersive offre une formation unique en gestion agricole. Le jeu, conçu pour les agriculteurs et les étudiants, permet de jouer en solo ou en collaboration, mettant l'accent sur l'atteinte de seuils de durabilité. Chaque cycle de jeu de trois ans implique la prise de décisions sur les cultures et les pratiques agricoles, l'adaptation aux défis saisonniers et l'analyse collaborative des résultats. Le déploiement dans 8 interventions avec 12 facilitateurs formés a donné des résultats prometteurs. Des sessions supplémentaires ciblent les collectifs d'agriculteurs et les programmes éducatifs. Les considérations futures incluent des extensions et des adaptations du jeu à différents secteurs agricoles et contextes climatiques. L'utilisation du jeu pour former les agriculteurs offre une autre approche aux conseillers pour discuter des mesures d'adaptation et d'atténuation.
In March 2024, 8 advisors trained in i2connect tools participated in a cross visit to Imathia, Greece, to analyse the introduction of Integrated Farming by peach producers’ groups. After interviewing the local actors, the cross-visitors formed groups and independently utilized the spiral of initiative and the co-creation triangle. Their findings were different but complementary, indicating the potential of the tools to bring out the multiple roles of actors and their contributions to an interactive process. However, realizing this potential depended on the advisors’ ability to draw conclusions by combining aspects and data.
Overall, the groups found that the involved advisory company acted as a manager and a free actor in the co-creation process, doing what was necessary to activate the network and keep things going. They also distinguished the multiple influence of producers, who contributed differently to the vitality of the network, taking over the role of:
a) initiator, held by pioneer producers,
b) free actor, held by the group of pioneer producers along with the advisor,
c) supplier, held by the producers who contributed resources to develop the innovation network
d) gatekeeper of the existence production system, by the producers opposed to the innovation.
Furthermore, a difficulty was to distinguish the impact of external actors and particularly of the market on the innovation network. The market was the driving force pushing the producers to change their production system. However, the pressure was not concretized to actions aimed at the transition to the new production system; thus, the market was not included in the internal actors responsible for the development of the innovation network.
Τον Μάρτιο του 2024, 8 εκπαιδευμένοι στα εργαλεία του I2CONNECT σύμβουλοι επισκέφτηκαν την Ημαθία για να διερευνήσουν την καινοτομία της εφαρμογής συστήματος ολοκληρωμένης διαχείρισης σε ροδακεώνες. Αφού πήραν συνεντεύξεις από τους τοπικούς δρώντες, οι επισκέπτες σχημάτισαν ομάδες και χρησιμοποίησαν ανεξάρτητα τα εργαλεία 'σπείρα της πρωτοβουλίας' και 'τρίγωνο της συνδημιουργίας'. Τα ευρήματά τους ήταν διαφορετικά, με συμπληρωματικό όμως τρόπο, υποδεικνύοντας τη δυνατότητα των εργαλείων να αναδεικνύουν τους ρόλους και τη συμβολή των δρώντων σε μια διαδραστική καινοτομία. Ωστόσο, η αξιοποίηση αυτής της δυνατότητας εξαρτήθηκε από την ικανότητα των συμβούλων να εξάγουν συμπεράσματα συνδυάζοντας, παρά αποκλείοντας, πτυχές και δεδομένα.
Οι ομάδες διαπίστωσαν ότι ο σύμβουλος των παραγωγών έπαιξε διπλό ρόλο στη συνδημιουργία της καινοτομίας, ενεργώντας ως 'διαχειριστής' και ως 'ελεύθερος δρών', κάνοντας ό,τι ήταν απαραίτητο για να ενεργοποιήσει και διατηρήσει το καινοτόμο δίκτυο. Επίσης, διέκριναν την πολλαπλή επίδραση διαφορετικών ομάδων παραγωγών, που ανέλαβαν ρόλο:
α) πρωτοπόρου στην εισαγωγή της καινοτομίας,
β.) 'ελεύθερου δρώντα' (μαζί με τον σύμβουλο),
γ) παρόχου πόρων που συνέβαλλαν στην ανάπτυξη του δικτύου,
δ.) 'φύλακα' του υπάρχοντος συστήματος παραγωγής, αντιτασσόμενου στην καινοτομία
Επιπλέον, μια δυσκολία αφορούσε στη διάκριση της επίδρασης εξωτερικών παραγόντων και ιδιαίτερα της αγοράς. Η αγορά ήταν η κινητήρια δύναμη που ώθησε στην αλλαγή του συστήματος παραγωγής χωρίς, όμως, φορείς της να αναλάβουν συγκεκριμένη δράση για την μετάβαση στο νέο σύστημα. Επομένως, η αγορά δεν περιλήφθηκε στους εσωτερικούς δρώντες που έχουν ευθύνη για την εξέλιξη του καινοτόμου δικτύου.
RAÍCES.info is a collaborative digital platform, promoted by UPA (a Spanish Farmer Based Organization), its mission is to help young men and women in their process of joining the agricultural and forestry sector, providing training and socialization elements that guide and motivate them, so that their performance be carried out in a more efficient and sustainable way. This platform was created through the Young Farmers in RED Operational Group, that has received an aid of € 598,402.28 co-financed 80% by the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD) and 20% by the Ministry of Agriculture Fisheries and Food (MAPA).
As a first output, this digital platform provides the following services: experiences, information, learning (training and demo farms), videos (testimonials and repository), social media, environmental sustainability, public consultations and a digital tool to calculate the CAP.
UPA wanted to expand RAÍCES.info and turn it into a digitalization advisory service. With the help of the digitalization package, RAÍCES.info, began to provide digitalization advisory services with an aid co-financed by EAFRD funds at 53% and by MAPA at 47%.
In this way, with the use of complementary aid, synergies are generated and the provision of digitalization advice is favored.
It is an example of win-win practice and how to take advantage of opportunities to work on innovation. The added value provided by the multi-actor approach of the EIP-Agri operational groups is proven. In addition, the AKIS is fully reinforced. And finally, the advisor finds a place where he can be trained, find information and - at the same time - provide advice.
RAÍCES.info es una plataforma digital colaborativa, impulsada por UPA, cuya misión es ayudar a los hombres y mujeres jóvenes en su proceso de incorporación al sector agrario y forestal, aportando elementos formativos y de socialización que los orienten y motiven para que el desempeño de su actividad se realice de una manera más eficiente y sostenible. Esta plataforma fue creada mediante el Grupo Operativo Jóvenes en RED, que ha recibido una ayuda de 598.402,28 € cofinanciada al 80% por el Fondo Europeo de Desarrollo Rural FEADER y al 20% por fondos del Ministerio de Agricultura, Pesca y Alimentación (MAPA).
Como primer resultado, esta plataforma digital proporciona los siguientes servicios: experiencias, información, aprendizaje (formación y actividades demostrativas), vídeos (testimonios y repositorio), social media, sostenibilidad medioambiental, consultas públicas y una herramienta digital para calcular la PAC.
UPA quiso ampliar RAÍCES.info y convertirla en un servicio de asesoramiento en digitalización. Con la ayudas del paquete de digitalización, RAÍCES.info, comenzó a prestar servicios de asesoramiento en digitalización con una ayuda cofinanciada al 53% con fondos FEADER y al 47% del MAPA.
De esta manera con la utilización de ayudas complementarias, se generan sinergias y se favorece la prestación de asesoramientos en digitalización.
Es un ejemplo de práctica en la que todos salen ganando y de como aprovecharse de las oportunidades para trabajar en innovación. Se prueba el valor añadido proporcionado por el enfoque multiactor de los grupos operativos de la AEI-Agri. Además, se refuerza integramente el AKIS. Y, el asesor encuentra un lugar donde puede formarse, encontrar información y -a la vez- prestar asesoramiento.
The DATAGRI Forum was created in 2018 with the aim of promoting the digital transformation process in the agri-food sector. Innovate, disseminate, cooperate and surprise are the four action verbs that mark the philosophy of this plural initiative.
- Annual meeting point of the agri-food network.
From the producer to the retailer. DATAGRI unites all the nodes of the agri-food network to present technological innovations, establish new synergies and generate business opportunities to work for sustainable, safe and quality agriculture.
- The technology is seen, and it is touched. It lasts two days: During the Forum Day you will be able to hear what projects research centers, universities and technology companies are immersed in. And thanks to Demo Day you will be able to experiment and connect directly with innovation.
- Leaders in digitalization in Southern Europe.
After 6 editions, DATAGRI Forum is a consolidated and benchmark event in Europe and Latin America to discover the next technological trends in the sector worldwide.
In summary, the objectives of the DATAGRI Forum are:
- BOOST Digital transformation in the agri-food chain.
- RAISE AWARENESS about success stories of digital transformation, technologies and innovation.
- CONTRIBUTE to reduce the barriers to implementing digital transformation, to create standards of good practice and opportunities for collaboration.
El Foro Datagri nace en 2018 con el objetivo de impulsar el proceso de transformación digital en el sector agroalimentario. Innovar, divulgar, cooperar y sorprender son los cuatro verbos de acción que marcan la filosofía de esta iniciativa plural.
- Punto de encuentro anual de la red agroalimentaria.
Desde el productor hasta el minorista. DATAGRI une a todos los nodos de la red agroalimentaria para presentar las novedades tecnológicas, establecer nuevas sinergias y generar oportunidades de negocio para trabajar por una agricultura sostenible, segura y de calidad.
- La tecnología se ve, y se toca. Tiene dos días de duración:
Durante el Forum Day podrás escuchar en qué proyectos están inmersos los centros de investigación, universidades y empresas tecnológicas. Y gracias al Demo Day podrás experimentar y conectar directamente con la innovación.
- Líderes en digitalización del Sur de Europa.
Tras 6 ediciones, Foro Datagri es un evento consolidado y referente en Europa y Latinoamérica para descubrir las próximas tendencias tecnológicas del sector a nivel mundial.
En resumen, los objetivos del Foro DATAGRI son:
- IMPULSAR. La transformación digital en la cadena agroalimentaria.
- SENSIBILIZAR. Sobre casos de éxito de transformación digital tecnologías e innovación.
. CONTRIBUIR. A reducir las barreras de implantación de transformación digital, a crear estándares de buenas práctica y oportunidades de colaboración.
The aim of the cross-visit is to welcome partners and European advisors trained in the tools and principles of interactive innovation in order to :
- discover a multi-stakeholder innovation project run by the Occitanie Regional Chamber of Agriculture in partnership with the regional AKIS;
- apply the tools and methods used during their national training courses.
To do this, the CRAO organised a cross-visit to the AGLAE system in the region. The aim of the AGLAE scheme (Farmers share their agro-ecological practices) is to create a repository of innovative agro-ecological practices in large-scale crop and livestock farming (GCPE), viticulture and arboriculture, qualified by experts and based on feedback identified locally by farmers in the Occitanie region. The process involves:
- Identifying innovative agro-ecological practices and acquiring technical references
- Identifying innovative practices, through farmer network leaders (GIEE, 30 000 groups, GOPEI, DEPHY networks) and project pilots;
- Capitalising on the results of research/experimentation work, by mobilising local research and development players.
The practices identified are then qualified by a committee of experts to produce reliable, tried-and-tested benchmarks that generate confidence and limit the risks involved. As far as possible, the aim is to:
- make advice more reliable;
- ensuring that the proposed levers are taken on board;
- sharing the risk between project stakeholders.
Qualified practices are described in testimonial sheets and videos distributed via various networks: Chamber website, GECO platform, Youtube channel, Facebook pages.
La cross-visit vise à acceuillir des partenaires des conseillers européens formés sur les outils et principes de l'innovation interactive pour:
- découvrir un project d'innovation multi-acteurs porté par la Chambre régionale d'agriculture d'Occitanie et en partenariat avec l'AKIS régional;
- appliquer les outils et méthodes utilisés lors de leurs formations nationales.
Le dispositif AGLAE (les Agriculteurs partaGent Leurs pratiques AgroÉcologiques) a pour objectif de créer un référentiel de pratiques agroécologiques innovantes en Grande Culture Polyculture Elevage (GCPE), Viticulture et Arboriculture, qualifiées par des experts et basées sur des retours d’expériences identifiés localement chez les agriculteurs de la région Occitanie. Le process assure:
- Repérage des pratiques agro-écologiques innovantes et acquisition de références techniques
- Identification des pratiques innovantes, par l’intermédiaire des animateurs de réseaux d’agriculteurs (GIEE, groupes 30 000, GOPEI, réseaux DEPHY) et des pilotes de projets;
- Capitalisation des résultats de travaux de recherche, grâce à la mobilisation des acteurs locaux de la recherche et du développement.
Les pratiques identifiées sont ensuite qualifiées par un comité d’experts afin de produire des références fiables et éprouvées, qui génèrent la confiance et limitent les risques encourus. Il s’agit, autant que possible, de:
- sécuriser le conseil;
- garantir l’appropriation des leviers proposés;
- partager le risque entre les acteurs du projet.
Les pratiques qualifiées sont décrites dans des fiches témoignages et des vidéos diffusées par différents réseaux : site internet Chambre, plateforme GECO, chaîne Youtube, pages Facebook.
The i2connect cross-visit at the Azienda Pitton offered a unique opportunity to explore the application of participatory innovation in the Italian agricultural sector. Located in the Veneto region, the Azienda Pitton is a virtuous example of organic vegetables production for direct marketing, with a strong orientation towards environmental sustainability and the adoption of innovative practices. Participating advisors were able to learn more about the farm that is one of the 12 regional pilot farms of the SISSAR (regional advisory system) for organic vegetable growing. In 2023, within SISSAR, the farm also hosted a demo activity facing the challenge of adapting winter vegetables harvesting type and quality to climate change.
Finally, Pitton is part of the AIAB FVG demo farm network and is also involved in educational initiatives for citizens/consumer. The i2connect tools were used to analyse the dialogue between the farm and the other AKIS actors. This highlighted how collaboration between farmers and technical advisors can improve production efficiency and quality, while ensuring economic and environmental sustainability. The visit ended with a collective reflection on how the collaborative innovation model adopted by the Pitton Company can be replicated in other Italian and European agricultural realities.
La cross visit di i2connect all'Azienda Pitton ha offerto un'opportunità unica per esplorare l'applicazione dell'innovazione partecipativa nel settore agricolo italiano. Situata in Veneto, l'Azienda Pitton è un esempio virtuoso nella coltivazione di ortaggi biologici per la commercializzazione diretta, con un forte orientamento alla sostenibilità ambientale e all'adozione di pratiche innovative. I consulenti partecipanti alla cross visit hanno potuto conoscere meglio l'azienda, che è una delle 12 aziende pilota regionali del SISSAR (sistema di consulenza regionale) per la coltivazione di ortaggi biologici. Nel 2023, nell'ambito del SISSAR, l'azienda ha ospitato anche un'attività dimostrativa sulla sfida di adattare il tipo e la qualità della raccolta degli ortaggi invernali ai cambiamenti climatici.
Infine, Pitton fa parte della rete di aziende dimostrative AIAB FVG ed è anche coinvolta in iniziative educative per i cittadini/consumatori.
Gli strumenti di i2connect sono stati utilizzati per analizzare il dialogo tra l'azienda agricola e gli altri attori di AKIS. Ciò ha evidenziato come la collaborazione tra agricoltori e consulenti tecnici possa migliorare l'efficienza e la qualità della produzione, garantendo al contempo la sostenibilità economica e ambientale. La visita si è conclusa con una riflessione collettiva su come il modello di innovazione collaborativa adottato dall'azienda Pitton possa essere replicato in altre realtà agricole italiane ed europee.
During the i2connect cross visit in Italy, the participants had the chance to deepen their kwoledge about organic farming also trought the experience of AIAB FVG, the regional branch of the Italian Association for Organic Farming (AIAB), representing organic farmers and advisors as well as consumers. AIAB FVG aims at consolidating and promoting the organic farming method, involving all stakeholders and collaborating with the regional institutions.
In 2023 AIAB FVG has been tasked by the Regional Administration to offer a free non-continuous technical advice to organic (or transitioning to organic) farms located in the region. The service is carried out by means of one or more visits to the farm, lasting a maximum of four hours and focusing on specific topics that differ depending on the crop or farm production orientation. At the end of each visit the farm simply has to countersign a declaration stating the intervention of the appointed technician. The crops covered by the organic advisory and technical assistance service are arable crops, horticulture, permanent fruit crops, viticulture. The technical advisory service promoted by AIAB FVG represents an example of innovation in the organic farming support system. In addition to guaranteeing quality technical support, the initiative contributes to the growth and spread of the organic method in Friuli Venezia Giulia, promoting the sustainability and resilience of local farms.
Durante la visita incrociata di i2connect in Italia, i partecipanti hanno avuto la possibilità di approfondire le loro conoscenze sull'agricoltura biologica anche attraverso l'esperienza di AIAB FVG. Si tratta della sezione regionale dell'Associazione Italiana per l'Agricoltura Biologica (AIAB), che rappresenta gli agricoltori biologici, i consulenti e i consumatori. AIAB FVG si propone di consolidare e promuovere il metodo dell'agricoltura biologica, coinvolgendo tutti i soggetti interessati e collaborando con le istituzioni regionali.
Nel 2023 AIAB FVG è stata incaricata dall'Amministrazione regionale di offrire una consulenza tecnica gratuita e non continuativa alle aziende agricole biologiche (o in fase di transizione verso il biologico) presenti sul territorio regionale. Il servizio si svolge attraverso una o più visite in azienda, della durata massima di quattro ore e incentrate su argomenti specifici che variano a seconda della coltura o dell'orientamento produttivo dell'azienda. Al termine di ogni visita l'azienda agricola deve semplicemente controfirmare una dichiarazione che attesti l'intervento del tecnico incaricato. Le colture coperte dal servizio di consulenza e assistenza tecnica biologica sono i seminativi, l'orticoltura, le colture frutticole permanenti, la viticoltura. Il servizio di consulenza tecnica promosso da AIAB FVG rappresenta un esempio di innovazione nel sistema di supporto all'agricoltura biologica. Oltre a garantire un supporto tecnico di qualità, l'iniziativa contribuisce alla crescita e alla diffusione del metodo biologico in Friuli Venezia Giulia, promuovendo la sostenibilità e la resilienza delle aziende agricole locali.
The i2connect cross-visit in Italy allowed participants to explore an excellent example of innovation in the conservation and enhancement of agricultural biodiversity. AVEPROBI is a regional association of organic producers and processors, which since more than a decade has devoted part of its activities to the on-farm conservation of local agrobiodiversity, catalysing energies and initiatives among groups operating on cultivated biodiversity in Veneto. A Community Seed Bank (CSB) has been set up to promote the development of innovative cereal-based value chains, both at the seed and the final food product level. Its governance and business model are based on participatory approaches in order to achieve operational effectiveness and stakeholders consensus.
Local farmers’ networks are called to reproduce the seeds, to foster and monitor their evolution and adaptation as well as to facilitate their sharing.
The Community Seed Bank is a novelty in the Veneto territory and the adaptation to the regional circumstances requires the identification of durable enabling conditions: linking up farmers and consumers (and dedicated processors in-between) around organically cultivated biodiversity makes the dynamic conservation of heritage seeds part of a larger social dynamic.
La cross visit di i2connect in Italia ha permesso ai partecipanti di esplorare un eccellente esempio di innovazione nella conservazione e valorizzazione della biodiversità agricola. AVEPROBI è un'associazione regionale di produttori e trasformatori biologici che da oltre un decennio dedica parte delle sue attività alla conservazione in azienda dell'agrobiodiversità locale, catalizzando energie e iniziative tra i gruppi che operano sulla biodiversità coltivata in Veneto. Per promuovere lo sviluppo di catene del valore innovative basate sui cereali, sia a livello di sementi che di prodotti alimentari finali, è stata creata una Banca dei Semi di Comunità (Community Seed Bank - CSB). La sua governance e il suo modello di business si basano su approcci partecipativi per raggiungere l'efficacia operativa e il consenso degli stakeholder.
Le reti di agricoltori locali sono chiamate a riprodurre i semi, a promuoverne e monitorarne l'evoluzione e l'adattamento e a facilitarne la condivisione.
La Banca Comunitaria dei Semi è una novità nel territorio veneto e l'adattamento alla realtà regionale richiede l'individuazione di condizioni abilitanti durature: il collegamento tra agricoltori e consumatori (e in mezzo i trasformatori dedicati) intorno alla biodiversità coltivata con metodo biologico rende la conservazione dinamica dei semi del patrimonio parte di una dinamica sociale più ampia.
Centre of Precision Farming Services and Competencies provides qualified advice that helps making an optimal use of the possibilities of receiving EU support while taking account of: planned time of return of investment and efficiency of a farm; financial possibilities of a farm to invest and develop production processes in time by fulfilling obligations that help making the right decisions which will influence the results of farm activity.
Services are provided to farmers, small businesses, self-employed entrepreneurs, large joint-stock companies and non-profit organizations that start or develop activities in agriculture, specialize in processing of agricultural products, forestry and alternative activities in rural areas.
Services provided by the Centre:
- services provided by a mobile animal husbandry laboratory;
- preparation of variable rate fertilizer plans;
- automated soil sampling and testing;
- services provided by the laboratory of the Centre which analyses soil composition, water, manure, and sewage.
Tiksliojo ūkininkavimo paslaugų ir kompetencijų centras teikia kvalifikuotas konsultacijas, padedančias optimaliai išnaudoti ES paramos gavimo galimybes, įvertinant planuojamų investicijų ūkyje atsipirkimo laiką, grąžą, efektyvumą; ūkio finansines galimybes investuoti ir plėtoti gamybinius procesus, laiku vykdant įsipareigojimus, padedančius priimti teisingus sprendimus, turėsiančius įtakos ūkio veiklos rezultatams.
Paslaugos teikiamos ūkininkams, mažoms įmonėms, individualiai dirbantiems verslininkams, didelėms akcinėms benrovėms, nepelno siekiančioms organizacijoms, kurios pradeda plėtoti ar plėtoja žemės ūkio produkcijos perdirbimo, miškininkystės, alternatyviosios veiklos kaime sektorių veiklą.
Tiksliojo ūkininkavimo paslaugų ir kompetencijų centro teikiamos paslaugos:
- kintamos normos tręšimo planų parengimas, paėmus ir ištyrus dirvožemio ėmimius;
- mobilios gyvulininkystės laboratorijos specialistų teikiamos paslaugos;
- laboratoriniai vandens ir dirvožemio tyrimai.
The Ezt-V-Edd project aims to search for solutions and innovations that support the work and sales processes of agricultural small-scale producers. The project started with in-depth research, which resulted in three main goals: (1) easing administrative burdens, (2) providing information necessary for building business strategies, and (3) alleviating other significant knowledge gaps. In Hungary, the agricultural small-scale sector is growing slowly, and the majority of traditional producers lack the knowledge and capital needed to sell high-value-added products through short supply chains. They face challenges in gathering and managing data required during raw material production, processing, and sales. The solutions find include: (1) organizing knowledge-sharing events for small-scale producers covering regulations, organization, logistics, marketing, business planning, and pricing; (2) creating films showcasing best practices and a publication; (3) developing an application called 'Felirom.hu' to assist data collection, during production and processing, as well as handling recipes, packaging materials, and sales. The collected data is readily available for potential inspections, ensuring traceability, food safety, and compliance with other official requirements. The collected data significantly aid in business planning. The project was implemented through close collaboration among producers, researchers, and some small-scale producers and NGOs focusing on short supply chains.
Az Ezt-V-Edd projekt célja olyan megoldások és innovációk keresése, melyek elősegítik a mezőgazdasági kistermelők munkáját és értékesítési folyamatait. A projektet mélyreható kutatással indítottuk, melynek eredményeként három fő célt tűztünk ki: (1) az adminisztratív terhek enyhítése, (2) az üzleti stratégia kialakításához szükséges információk biztosítása, valamint (3) más fontos tudáshiányok enyhítése.
Magyarországon a kistermelői élelmiszer szektor lassan növekszik, és a hagyományos termelők túlnyomó része nem rendelkezik megfelelő tudással és tőkével a magas hozzáadott értékű termékek értékesítéséhez rövid ellátási láncokon keresztül. Problémát jelent számukra az alapanyagtermelés, feldolgozás és értékesítés során szükséges adatok gyűjtése és nyilvántartása.
Megoldásaink közé tartozik: (1) kistermelői tudásnapok szervezése, melyek szabályozásról, szervezésről, logisztikáról, marketingről, üzleti tervezésről és árazásról adnak információkat. (2) jó gyakorlatokat bemutató filmek és egy kiadvány készítése; (3) 'Felirom.hu' néven egy adatgyűjtést segítő applikáció fejlesztése, mely a termelés, feldolgozás eseményei mellett recepteket, csomagolóanyagokat és eladásokat is kezel. Az adatok azonnal rendelkezésre állnak esetleges ellenőrzés esetén, biztosítva a nyomonkövethetőséget, élelmiszerbiztonságot és más hivatalos elvárások teljesítését.
Az összegyűjtött adatok jelentős segítséget nyújtanak az üzleti tervezéshez. A projekt szoros együttműködéssel valósult meg a termelők, kutatók, valamint néhány kistermelő és rövid ellátási láncokkal foglalkozó NGO-k között.
Avocado trees were introduced to Chania, Crete in 1968 by the Institute of Olive Tree, Subtropical Plants, and Viticulture. Between 1985 and 1995, efforts to promote avocado cultivation were largely unsuccessful owing to the reluctance of traditional olive and citrus growers to switch to avocados due to limited market demand at that time. A pivotal shift occurred in 2008 when the prices of olive oil and oranges plummeted, while global demand for avocados surged. This prompted local producers to expand avocado cultivation with the Local Cooperative of Organic Producers playing a significant role in this.
Despite some successes, avocado farmers in Chania still face several challenges such as the need for tailored agricultural solutions, vocational training, and effective knowledge transfer. Many farmers still rely on informal exchanges of information, which are insufficient given the diverse growing conditions.
The following areas for improvement were identified:
- Customize vocational training and seminars to meet the specific needs of avocado farmers, ensuring effective knowledge transfer and facilitating peer-to-peer learning.
- Develop a strategic plan for knowledge generation involving all relevant AKIS actors.
- Foster partnerships between farmers and advisors by establishing regular channels for information exchange.
Advocate national policies supporting innovation in the avocado farming.
By addressing these areas, avocado production in Chania could overcome current challenges and achieve sustainable growth. The collaboration between AKIS actors is crucial in driving this progress.
Avocado trees were introduced to Chania, Crete in 1968 by the Institute of Olive Tree, Subtropical Plants, and Viticulture. Between 1985 and 1995, efforts to promote avocado cultivation were largely unsuccessful owing to the reluctance of traditional olive and citrus growers to switch to avocados due to limited market demand at that time. A pivotal shift occurred in 2008 when the prices of olive oil and oranges plummeted, while global demand for avocados surged. This prompted local producers to expand avocado cultivation with the Local Cooperative of Organic Producers playing a significant role in this.
Despite some successes, avocado farmers in Chania still face several challenges such as the need for tailored agricultural solutions, vocational training, and effective knowledge transfer. Many farmers still rely on informal exchanges of information, which are insufficient given the diverse growing conditions.
The following areas for improvement were identified:
- Customize vocational training and seminars to meet the specific needs of avocado farmers, ensuring effective knowledge transfer and facilitating peer-to-peer learning.
- Develop a strategic plan for knowledge generation involving all relevant AKIS actors.
- Foster partnerships between farmers and advisors by establishing regular channels for information exchange.
Advocate national policies supporting innovation in the avocado farming.
By addressing these areas, avocado production in Chania could overcome current challenges and achieve sustainable growth. The collaboration between AKIS actors is crucial in driving this progress.
The interactive innovation tools of i2connect were the protagonists of a training moment during the study visit of the Permanent School for Cheesemakers, held in Sardinia from 13 to 15 May 2024. The School, now in its second edition, is realised by CREA ZA - Centre for Animal Husbandry and Aquaculture Research in Bella and CREA PB - Centre for Policy and Bio-economy Research, and aims to train valid cheesemakers, who preserve and continue to hand down traditions while also being open to innovation. During the visit, 9 young aspiring cheesemakers interviewed the Sardinian ‘Paschinres’ Operational Group PASCHINRES with the aim of applying the innovation spiral and identifying the various stages of the project's interactive process. The OG PASCHINRES was launched in 2023 to respond to the request for innovation of a group of companies in Northern Sardinia, to find innovative solutions able to increase business resilience and income through the reduction of variable production costs and the valorisation of production (milk and cheese). ISPAM CNR, a partner of the OG, participated in the event, answering the young students' questions and enabling them to analyse the process of bringing the partners together, the development of the innovative idea, and its dissemination. The discussion between the students and the OG was followed by a moment of group reflection by the students, who retraced the project's innovation spiral.
Gli strumenti per l'innovazione interattiva di i2connect sono stati protagonisti di un momento formativo nell'ambito della study visit della Scuola permanente del casaro, tenutasi in Sardegna dal 13 al 15 Maggio 2024. La Scuola, giunta alla sua seconda edizione, è realizzata dal CREA ZA - Centro di ricerca Zootecnia ed Acquacoltura di Bella e dal CREA PB - Centro di ricerca Politiche e Bio-economia e ha l'obiettivo di formare validi casari, che conservino e continuino a tramandare le tradizioni aprendosi anche alle innovazioni. Durante la visita, 9 giovani aspiranti casari hanno intervistato il Gruppo Operativo sardo "Paschinres" con l'obiettivo di applicare la spirale dell'innovazione e individuare le varie fasi del processo interattivo del progetto. Il GO PASCHINRES è stato avviato nel 2023 per rispondere alla richiesta di innovazione di un gruppo di aziende del Nord Sardegna, per trovare soluzioni innovative in grado di aumentare la resilienza ed il reddito aziendale mediante la riduzione dei costi variabili di produzione e la valorizzazione delle produzioni (latte e formaggio). L'ISPAM CNR, partner del GO, ha partecipato all'evento rispondendo alle domande dei giovani e consentendo di analizzare il processo di aggregazione dei partner, lo sviluppo dell'idea innovativa, e la sua diffusione. Al confronto tra i giovani e il GO, ha seguito un momento di riflessione di gruppo degli studenti che hanno ripercorso la spirale di innovazione del progetto.
One of the new actors in the Italian AKIS is ANARSIA (National Association of Regional Agencies for Agronomic and Forestry Development). Established in late 2022, the Association aims to share expertise and experience in the agricultural, forestry and fisheries sectors, promoting synergies on issues of common interest. Its main purposes include institutional representation, the development of strategic documents and the promotion of study, research and training initiatives, both for agency staff and external stakeholders. ANARSIA is committed to enhancing communication to raise awareness of the agencies' experimental and innovative activities and to developing relationships at the European level. Another key objective is to promote the use of decision support services to facilitate digital transformation in agriculture. Key activities include a cooperation agreement with leading agronomic and economic research institutions, the organisation of seminars on topics such as demonstration farms, as well as general assemblies and training meetings. ANARSIA aims to become a reference point for innovation in agriculture, promoting cooperation between regions and the advancement of the agro-forestry sector in Italy.
One of the new actors in the Italian AKIS is ANARSIA (National Association of Regional Agencies for Agronomic and Forestry Development). Established in late 2022, the Association aims to share expertise and experience in the agricultural, forestry and fisheries sectors, promoting synergies on issues of common interest. Its main purposes include institutional representation, the development of strategic documents and the promotion of study, research and training initiatives, both for agency staff and external stakeholders. ANARSIA is committed to enhancing communication to raise awareness of the agencies' experimental and innovative activities and to developing relationships at the European level. Another key objective is to promote the use of decision support services to facilitate digital transformation in agriculture. Key activities include a cooperation agreement with leading agronomic and economic research institutions, the organisation of seminars on topics such as demonstration farms, as well as general assemblies and training meetings. ANARSIA aims to become a reference point for innovation in agriculture, promoting cooperation between regions and the advancement of the agro-forestry sector in Italy.
AKIS policies in Spain have a clear strategic approach. Nowadays, AKIS is not a very popular acronym except among expert policy makers. To make our lives easier a simplification could be made by searching for the following terms: AKIS, digitalisation, advice, extension, and training; They can easily be found in very diverse and transversal strategies what affect AKIS in different ways.
This strategic approach acts on a multi-level basis (EU, National, Regional and Local).
This multilevel governance framework is influenced at the international level by the EU strategies, by the international agreements signed by Spain and by the jurisprudence emanating from the European Court of Justice.
The following strategies stand out for their importance for the Spanish AKIS:
- Strategic CAP Plan.
- Science, Technology and Innovation Strategy 2021-2027.
- Digitisation Strategy for the Agri-Food and Forestry Sector and Rural Areas.
- Agri-Food Training Strategy.
- Forestry Strategy horizon 2050.
- Circular Economy Strategy, Circular Spain 2030
- National Strategy against the Demographic Challenge.
- Long-Term Decarbonization Strategy.
- Digital Spain 2026.
- Connected Industry 4.0 Strategy.
- Generational replacement Strategy.
- National Hunting Management Strategy.
- National Artificial Intelligence Strategy.
- National Strategy of Food.
This strategic development at the national level is complemented by the consequent regional and local development. Furthermore, all strategies are developed through plans and programs, which are an indispensable part of tactical planning. Finally, the most operational planning is developed through various projects to be able to reach the sector in the short term.
Las políticas AKIS en España tienen un claro enfoque estratégico. AKIS no es un acrónimo muy popular excepto entre los expertos. Para facilitarnos la vida se puede simplificar buscando los siguientes términos: AKIS, digitalización, asesoramiento, extensión y formación; Se pueden encontrar fácilmente en estrategias muy diversas y transversales que afectan al AKIS de diferentes maneras. Este enfoque estratégico actúa a múltiples niveles. Este marco de gobernanza multinivel está influenciado a nivel internacional por las estrategias UE, por acuerdos internacionales firmados por España y por la jurisprudencia del Tribunal de Justicia de la UE. Destacan por su importancia para el AKIS español las siguientes estrategias:
- Plan Estratégico de la PAC.
- Estrategia de Ciencia, Tecnología e Innovación 2021-2027.
- Estrategia de Digitalización del Sector Agroalimentario, Forestal y del Medio Rural.
- Estrategia de Formación Agroalimentaria.
- Estrategia Forestal horizonte 2050.
- Estrategia de Economía Circular, España Circular 2030
- Estrategia Nacional frente al Reto Demográfico.
- Estrategia de Descarbonización a Largo Plazo.
- España Digital 2026.
- Estrategia Industria Conectada 4.0.
- Estrategia de relevo generacional.
- Estrategia Nacional de Gestión Cinegética.
- Estrategia Nacional de Inteligencia Artificial.
- Estrategia Nacional de Alimentación.
Este desarrollo estratégico a nivel nacional se complementa con su desarrollo regional y local. Además, todas las estrategias se desarrollan a través de planes y programas, que son parte indispensable de la planificación táctica. La planificación más operativa se desarrolla a través de diversos proyectos para poder llegar al sector en el corto plazo.
Topical insights on the impact of structures and governance affecting farm advisors in the support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. There were four new insights selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 june 2023 relating to structures and governance were reported. These were;
- Brokerage and facilitation (no "official" representation of advisors to participate in the national AKIS and certified advisors not being trained in brokerage/facilitation/networking and AKIS);
- Learning from success (performance, enjoyment, pride and success are relative to expectations, how interactive/bottom up innovation networks can be sustainable and successful is learned from doing and experimenting);
- Collaborative governance approaches for sustainability challenges (the need for the incorporation of reflective practice within collaborative governance for the socio-technical transition to a low-carbon society was supported);
- Using participatory network mapping to address local sustainability challenges (understanding complex policy networks; who can act as broker?; capitalising on the diversity of viewpoints and integrating network thinking into project planning and implementation. Within this analysis, themes of participatory justice, social learning and visualising complexity were explored.).
Topical insights on the impact of structures and governance affecting farm advisors in the support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. There were four new insights selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 june 2023 relating to structures and governance were reported. These were;
- Brokerage and facilitation (no "official" representation of advisors to participate in the national AKIS and certified advisors not being trained in brokerage/facilitation/networking and AKIS);
- Learning from success (performance, enjoyment, pride and success are relative to expectations, how interactive/bottom up innovation networks can be sustainable and successful is learned from doing and experimenting);
- Collaborative governance approaches for sustainability challenges (the need for the incorporation of reflective practice within collaborative governance for the socio-technical transition to a low-carbon society was supported);
- Using participatory network mapping to address local sustainability challenges (understanding complex policy networks; who can act as broker?; capitalising on the diversity of viewpoints and integrating network thinking into project planning and implementation. Within this analysis, themes of participatory justice, social learning and visualising complexity were explored.).
Topical insights on the impact of Communications and Knowledge Flows affecting farm advisors in the support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. There were two new insights selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 june 2023 relating to Communications and Knowledge Flows were reported. These were; 1. "Mentor breakfast” - an initiative for rural youth to support business development (LRATC has created a network of mentors which consists of business practitioners, farmers, university representatives, bank representatives, etc. who are coming together at the event called “mentor breakfast” organized for young rural entrepreneurs where to test their ideas, where they are challenged to think about the practical and financial aspects and the ways how to move forward); 2. NAK-AKIS Working Group for dissemination (innovation, digitalisation, knowledge transfer) Hungary (This AKIS working group, where actors (research institutes, universities, advisors, advisory service companies, public actors, etc.) are represented. Its aim is to share information on innovation, digitalisation, knowledge transfer (conferences, newsletters, calls for proposals, calls for tenders, sending questionnaires, etc.).
Topical insights on the impact of Communications and Knowledge Flows affecting farm advisors in the support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. There were two new insights selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 june 2023 relating to Communications and Knowledge Flows were reported. These were; 1. "Mentor breakfast” - an initiative for rural youth to support business development (LRATC has created a network of mentors which consists of business practitioners, farmers, university representatives, bank representatives, etc. who are coming together at the event called “mentor breakfast” organized for young rural entrepreneurs where to test their ideas, where they are challenged to think about the practical and financial aspects and the ways how to move forward); 2. NAK-AKIS Working Group for dissemination (innovation, digitalisation, knowledge transfer) Hungary (This AKIS working group, where actors (research institutes, universities, advisors, advisory service companies, public actors, etc.) are represented. Its aim is to share information on innovation, digitalisation, knowledge transfer (conferences, newsletters, calls for proposals, calls for tenders, sending questionnaires, etc.).
Topical insights on the skills and competencies of farm advisors in support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. There were seven insights selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 june 2023 relating to advisors skills and competence were reported. These were;
- Young advisors skills development (The insight highlight the lack of adequate methodological training of advisors at undergraduate level);
- Essential competences for advisors (from focus groups it appeared that the competencies describing Basic Disposition and Attitude (e.g. personal drive, self-awareness, emotional intelligence, etc.), are considered essential competencies for advisors, regardless of whether they take up a role of innovation advisor);
- The role of open-mindedness and flexibility in innovation support for farmers;
- Advisors selling digital tools (the idea was that advisors sell subscriptions to digital knowledge products. This did not work, advisors are not the resellers of knowledge products, even when it's their own knowledge);
- Age of innovators (a warning against ageist assumptions regarding innovation);
- Understanding the tools for analysing interactive innovation (achieving a common understanding of the tools and their use is a challenge for many);
- Agri Innovation Broker training : (good experience in preparation for the new CAP structure, the Ministry of Agriculture and the Hungarian Chamber of Agriculture established the AKIS working group).
Topical insights on the skills and competencies of farm advisors in support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. There were seven insights selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 june 2023 relating to advisors skills and competence were reported. These were;
- Young advisors skills development (The insight highlight the lack of adequate methodological training of advisors at undergraduate level);
- Essential competences for advisors (from focus groups it appeared that the competencies describing Basic Disposition and Attitude (e.g. personal drive, self-awareness, emotional intelligence, etc.), are considered essential competencies for advisors, regardless of whether they take up a role of innovation advisor);
- The role of open-mindedness and flexibility in innovation support for farmers;
- Advisors selling digital tools (the idea was that advisors sell subscriptions to digital knowledge products. This did not work, advisors are not the resellers of knowledge products, even when it's their own knowledge);
- Age of innovators (a warning against ageist assumptions regarding innovation);
- Understanding the tools for analysing interactive innovation (achieving a common understanding of the tools and their use is a challenge for many);
- Agri Innovation Broker training : (good experience in preparation for the new CAP structure, the Ministry of Agriculture and the Hungarian Chamber of Agriculture established the AKIS working group).
Topical insights on the skills and competencies of farm advisors in support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. There were seven insights selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 june 2023 relating to advisors skills and competence were reported. These were; 1. Young advisors skills development (The insight highlight the lack of adequate methodological training of advisors at undergraduate level); 2.Essential competences for advisors (from focus groups it appeared that the competencies describing Basic Disposition and Attitude (e.g. personal drive, self-awareness, emotional intelligence, etc.), are considered essential competencies for advisors, regardless of whether they take up a role of innovation advisor); 3.The role of open-mindedness and flexibility in innovation support for farmers; 4. Advisors selling digital tools (the idea was that advisors sell subscriptions to digital knowledge products. This did not work, advisors are not the resellers of knowledge products, even when it's their own knowledge); 5. Age of innovators (a warning against ageist assumptions regarding innovation); 6. Understanding the tools for analysing interactive innovation (achieving a common understanding of the tools and their use is a challenge for many); 7. Agri Innovation Broker training : (good experience in preparation for the new CAP structure, the Ministry of Agriculture and the Hungarian Chamber of Agriculture established the AKIS working group).
Topical insights on the skills and competencies of farm advisors in support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. There were seven insights selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 june 2023 relating to advisors skills and competence were reported. These were; 1. Young advisors skills development (The insight highlight the lack of adequate methodological training of advisors at undergraduate level); 2.Essential competences for advisors (from focus groups it appeared that the competencies describing Basic Disposition and Attitude (e.g. personal drive, self-awareness, emotional intelligence, etc.), are considered essential competencies for advisors, regardless of whether they take up a role of innovation advisor); 3.The role of open-mindedness and flexibility in innovation support for farmers; 4. Advisors selling digital tools (the idea was that advisors sell subscriptions to digital knowledge products. This did not work, advisors are not the resellers of knowledge products, even when it's their own knowledge); 5. Age of innovators (a warning against ageist assumptions regarding innovation); 6. Understanding the tools for analysing interactive innovation (achieving a common understanding of the tools and their use is a challenge for many); 7. Agri Innovation Broker training : (good experience in preparation for the new CAP structure, the Ministry of Agriculture and the Hungarian Chamber of Agriculture established the AKIS working group).
Some topical insights on the enabling environment for farm advisors in support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. Participants record insights based on their interaction with advisors and farmers and others. These insights were selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 June 2023, five new topical insights relating to enabling environment were reported. These were; 1. Role of AKIS coordination bodies (these bodies set up in the new CAP should help to support more bottom up innovation); 2. Work together to think about and plan the future. (The key insight is that while innovation will continue to happen in all planned future scenarios, longer term stainability is more likely in some where there is more societal involvement and interaction.); 3.From Character to Culture (The 24 character strengths documented by the VIA Institute website are relevant to paradigm shift to the culture of support for interactive innovation by advisors in different European contexts.); 4. Transfer to Digital Solutions - creation of a digital library (Can the efficiency gains achieved through digitalisation be leveraged to make time for more interactive innovation support); 5. New Roadmap to help organise innovation process in Occitanie (The Occitanie Chambers of Agriculture work with farmers to develop innovation supports through multi-partner R&D projects, groups of innovative farmers, living-labs and experimentation).
Some topical insights on the enabling environment for farm advisors in support of interactive innovation were documented in the h2020 i2connect project to ensure that the project was informed from practice and from the experiences of partners within or from outside of the project itself. The project focus is on increasing the role of farm advisors in supporting interactive innovation. Participants record insights based on their interaction with advisors and farmers and others. These insights were selected and catalogued, in deliverable 1.15 June 2023, five new topical insights relating to enabling environment were reported. These were; 1. Role of AKIS coordination bodies (these bodies set up in the new CAP should help to support more bottom up innovation); 2. Work together to think about and plan the future. (The key insight is that while innovation will continue to happen in all planned future scenarios, longer term stainability is more likely in some where there is more societal involvement and interaction.); 3.From Character to Culture (The 24 character strengths documented by the VIA Institute website are relevant to paradigm shift to the culture of support for interactive innovation by advisors in different European contexts.); 4. Transfer to Digital Solutions - creation of a digital library (Can the efficiency gains achieved through digitalisation be leveraged to make time for more interactive innovation support); 5. New Roadmap to help organise innovation process in Occitanie (The Occitanie Chambers of Agriculture work with farmers to develop innovation supports through multi-partner R&D projects, groups of innovative farmers, living-labs and experimentation).
Problem-based learning is particularly effective for adult further training, such as equipping rural advisors with new working approaches. This strategy centers on real-world problems to foster critical thinking and problem-solving skills, connecting trainees directly to their professional realities. Trainees engage with real-world project examples, using case studies and field visits to apply their knowledge in practical contexts, which enhances their ability to relate learning to their daily professional activities. Critical reflection exercises encourage trainees to analyze and think deeply about their experiences, enhancing understanding. Tools like the Circle of Coherence or the Triangle of Co-Creation help them tackle various situations effectively. Additionally, encouraging reflective competence enables continuous improvement through self-assessment, with debriefing sessions after activities to consolidate insights and share expertise. This approach not only deepens their practical skills but also fosters a collaborative learning environment where trainees can share their expertise and learn collectively.
Problem-based learning is particularly effective for adult further training, such as equipping rural advisors with new working approaches. This strategy centers on real-world problems to foster critical thinking and problem-solving skills, connecting trainees directly to their professional realities. Trainees engage with real-world project examples, using case studies and field visits to apply their knowledge in practical contexts, which enhances their ability to relate learning to their daily professional activities. Critical reflection exercises encourage trainees to analyze and think deeply about their experiences, enhancing understanding. Tools like the Circle of Coherence or the Triangle of Co-Creation help them tackle various situations effectively. Additionally, encouraging reflective competence enables continuous improvement through self-assessment, with debriefing sessions after activities to consolidate insights and share expertise. This approach not only deepens their practical skills but also fosters a collaborative learning environment where trainees can share their expertise and learn collectively.
The ProBio project aims to encourage producers to share their knowledge and experiences, particularly through working groups. These groups operate autonomously, deciding on their own topics and meeting frequencies. What sets ProBio apart is that these groups are not led by advisors but by producers who have received special training. This methodology, developed by Bio Suisse and entra Beratung agrar, has been adapted for French-speaking Switzerland by Agridea.
Training and the Role of the Facilitator
The two-day training course delves into the role of facilitators and provides simple, effective methods for energizing meetings, such as whisper, flash, and weather round. During the practical exercises, which include a field meeting, each participant takes turns being a facilitator, participant, and observer.
The ProBio facilitator plays a crucial role in preparing the meeting and facilitating the generation of ideas and development of solutions for the host farmer.
The Facilitation Cycle of a ProBio Meeting
ProBio meetings follow a clear structure, consisting of the following stages:
1. Introduction: Remind and clarify the meeting's objective.
2. Farm Visit: Understand the host's context and issues.
3. Group Work: Focus on a specific aspect, proposing solutions.
4. Self-Reflection: Reflect on what the discussions have brought to each participant.
Testimonials from Participants
- "Taking part in this course gives you confidence."
- "The facilitation tools learned enhance the quality of the farm visits."
- "The group's collective intelligence is used to tackle the host's problems."
Le projet ProBio vise à favoriser le partage de savoirs et d'expériences entre productrices et producteurs notamment à travers des groupes d'échanges. Ces groupes sont autonomes, décidant eux-mêmes des thèmes et de la fréquence des rencontres. La particularité de ProBio est que ces groupes ne sont pas animés par des conseillers, mais par des producteurs.trices spécialement formé.es à cet effet, grâce à une méthodologie développée par Bio Suisse et entra Beratung agrar, et adaptée en Suisse romande par Agridea.
Formation et rôle de l'animateur
La formation de deux jours explore le rôle des animateurs et fournit des méthodes simples et efficaces pour dynamiser les rencontres (murmure, flash, tour météo, etc.) Lors de la phase d’exercices pratiques, comprenant une rencontre sur le terrain, chacun.e sera tour à tour animateur, participant et observateur.
L’animateur ProBio joue un rôle clé : il prépare la rencontre et facilite la production d'idées ainsi que le développement de solutions pour l'exploitant qui accueille.
Cycle d’animation d’une rencontre ProBio
La rencontre suit une structure claire, constituée des étapes suivantes :
1. Introduction : Rappel et clarification de l'objectif de la rencontre.
2. Visite d'exploitation : Compréhension du contexte et des problématiques de l'hôte.
3. Travail de groupe : Focus sur un aspect spécifique à travailler, propositions de solutions
4. Auto-réflexion : Réflexion sur ce que les discussions ont apportées à chaque participant.
Quelques témoignages des participants
• Participer à ce cours met en confiance.
• Les outils d'animation appris enrichissent les visites des fermes.
• L'intelligence collective du groupe est mise au service des problématiques rencontrées par l'hôte.
To effectively engage in co-creation, or "Interactive Innovation" as termed by i2connect, it is essential to adopt the right mindset, rather than solely focusing on tools.
A fundamental principle is to approach situations with a posture of Not-Knowing. Even if you have potential solutions in mind, it is crucial to accept that your solution might not be suitable for others. In complex contexts, it is impossible to know the correct solution from the outset; it must be collaboratively developed.
The process is iterative, involving sequential steps of experimentation, testing, reflection, adaptation, and re-testing. This cyclical method encourages learning and collective growth.
Confidence in the creativity of both your group and yourself is also necessary. Iteration inherently involves learning from failures. This means being prepared to experiment, potentially fail, learn from those failures, and try again.
Courage is required to take risks and try new approaches, even without certainty of success.
Empathy and curiosity about others are vital. This involves a willingness to learn from others, connect with their realities and contexts, and be open to collaboration.
Frequently, you will encounter ambiguities and differing opinions. It is important to accept and work with these contradictions rather than trying to eliminate them.
Additionally, creating a framework that fosters open and trustful collaboration is crucial.
In summary, the right mindset for a successful co-creation process, includes the aspects of Not-Knowing, creativity, courage, empathy and curiosity, and establishing an environment for open and trustful collaboration.
To effectively engage in co-creation, or "Interactive Innovation" as termed by i2connect, it is essential to adopt the right mindset, rather than solely focusing on tools.
A fundamental principle is to approach situations with a posture of Not-Knowing. Even if you have potential solutions in mind, it is crucial to accept that your solution might not be suitable for others. In complex contexts, it is impossible to know the correct solution from the outset; it must be collaboratively developed.
The process is iterative, involving sequential steps of experimentation, testing, reflection, adaptation, and re-testing. This cyclical method encourages learning and collective growth.
Confidence in the creativity of both your group and yourself is also necessary. Iteration inherently involves learning from failures. This means being prepared to experiment, potentially fail, learn from those failures, and try again.
Courage is required to take risks and try new approaches, even without certainty of success.
Empathy and curiosity about others are vital. This involves a willingness to learn from others, connect with their realities and contexts, and be open to collaboration.
Frequently, you will encounter ambiguities and differing opinions. It is important to accept and work with these contradictions rather than trying to eliminate them.
Additionally, creating a framework that fosters open and trustful collaboration is crucial.
In summary, the right mindset for a successful co-creation process, includes the aspects of Not-Knowing, creativity, courage, empathy and curiosity, and establishing an environment for open and trustful collaboration.
Alongside established advisory services farmers need co-creations and co-innovation, where a multidisciplinary team supports the entrepreneur in developing and innovating their farm's operations. For the skills necessary to support multidisciplinary teams to develop at the individual level, organizational support is required through training, other forms of skill development, leadership work, collective self-management, network management, and strengthening AKIS collaboration. This, in turn, requires a sufficient understanding of co-innovation at the leadership level. Since this involves a broad change, the entire management group must understand the benefits of co-innovation. The best way to achieve this insight is through experiential learning. This can be facilitated by management group training that introduces the principles and methods of co-innovation, where the management group itself represents a multidisciplinary group and practically utilizes co-innovation in their actual development processes. To make the training as relevant as possible for the leaders, each training session must be tailored individually. The design must consider the available time, the state of the management team's collaboration, dynamics, current cases suitable for co-innovation, building a confidential atmosphere, and the follow-up or decision-making on issues raised during the training. Once the management group has collectively experienced the benefits of co-innovation, their ability to support their organization and experts in adopting and applying it will develop significantly.
Maatalousyrittäjät tarvitsevat vakiintuneiden neuvontapalveluiden rinnalle yhteiskehittämistä ja –innovointia, jossa moniammatillinen tiimi tukee yrittäjää tämän kehittäessä ja innovoidessa tilansa toimintaa. Jotta moniammatillisten tiimien tukemiseen tarvittavat osaamiset kehittyvät yksilötasolla, on niitä tuettava organisatorisesti kouluttamisen, muun osaamisen kehittämisen, esihenkilötyön, yhteisohjautuvuuden, verkostojohtamisen ja AKIS-yhteistyön vahvistamisen kautta. Tämä taas edellyttää riittävää yhteisinnovoinnin ymmärrystä johtajien tasolla. Koska kyse on laajasta muutoksesta on koko johtoryhmän oivallettava yhteinnovoinnin hyöty. Paras tapa oivalluksen syntymiseen on kokemuksellinen oppiminen. Tähän auttaa yhteinnovoinnin periaatteita ja menetelmiä avaava johtoryhmävalmennus, jossa johtoryhmä itsessään edustaa moniammatillista ryhmää ja käytännössä hyödyntää yhteisinnovointia omien ajankohtaisten kehitysprosessien työstämisessä. Jotta valmennus on johtajille mahdollisimman hyvin osuva, kukin valmennus on räätälöitävä erikseen. Suunnittelussa on huomioitava käytössä oleva aika, johtoryhmän yhteistyön tila, dynamiikka, yhteiseen kehittämiseen soveltuvat johtoryhmän ajankohtaiset caset, luottamuksellisen ilmapiirin rakentaminen ja valmennuksessa esiinnostettujen asioiden jatkotyöstö tai päättäminen. Kun johtoryhmä on yhteisesti kokenut yhteisinnovoinnin hyödyllisyyden, heidän mahdollisuudet tukea omaa organisaatiotaan ja asiantuntijoitaan sen omaksumisessa ja soveltamisessa kehittyvät merkittävästi.
Collaborative learning is an effective strategy for adult further training, particularly suited to introducing new working approaches to rural advisors. This approach leverages the collective knowledge and experience of the group, fostering a sense of community and shared purpose among trainees. It encourages active participation and interaction with a focus on group activities and peer-to-peer learning sessions to build a collaborative environment. Key strategies include team projects that require collaboration and collective problem-solving, enhancing practical application of new concepts. Peer reviews are structured to allow trainees to provide constructive feedback to one another, simulating real-world evaluation scenarios where they act as funders deciding on the merit of innovation initiatives using set criteria. Additionally, ample networking opportunities are planned to allow advisors to share experiences informally, further enriching the learning experience. This method not only promotes knowledge sharing but also critical thinking and the development of personal and professional networks, crucial for the effective implementation of innovative practices in rural advisory contexts.
Collaborative learning is an effective strategy for adult further training, particularly suited to introducing new working approaches to rural advisors. This approach leverages the collective knowledge and experience of the group, fostering a sense of community and shared purpose among trainees. It encourages active participation and interaction with a focus on group activities and peer-to-peer learning sessions to build a collaborative environment. Key strategies include team projects that require collaboration and collective problem-solving, enhancing practical application of new concepts. Peer reviews are structured to allow trainees to provide constructive feedback to one another, simulating real-world evaluation scenarios where they act as funders deciding on the merit of innovation initiatives using set criteria. Additionally, ample networking opportunities are planned to allow advisors to share experiences informally, further enriching the learning experience. This method not only promotes knowledge sharing but also critical thinking and the development of personal and professional networks, crucial for the effective implementation of innovative practices in rural advisory contexts.
Skills development programmes for rural advisors and consultants vary from country to country. The existing qualification measures are often more subject-specific and methodologically orientated. Under the umbrella of the IALB, standards for a competence development series for advisors in rural areas were developed in a four-year project phase. The CECRA certification consists of various methodological modules and can be completed with the basic certificate "CECRA Basics" and/or with the "CECRA Certificate" once all the requirements have been met. The modular competence development series is for advisors from the agricultural and home economics sector, as well as for all other actors in rural areas, such as regional or leader managers.
The path to CECRA certification:
- CECRA Basics:
After successfully completing five modules (two compulsory and three elective modules, at least one of which must be attended), an application for CECRA Basics can be submitted to the IALB or the EUFRAS CECRA Office. The basic certificate must be applied for within 5 years. - CECRA certificate:
After successful participation in five modules (two compulsory and three elective modules, at least one of which must be attended) and fulfilment of the accompanying requirements, the application for the CECRA certificate can be submitted to the regional CECRA recognition office. The application is checked by a second regional CECRA recognition centre. The CECRA certificate must be applied for within 7 years.
Target groups: All advisors in rural areas (not only from the agricultural and household sector, but also for other actors in rural areas, such as regional or leather managers).
Skills development programmes for rural advisors and consultants vary from country to country. The existing qualification measures are often more subject-specific and methodologically orientated. Under the umbrella of the IALB, standards for a competence development series for advisors in rural areas were developed in a four-year project phase. The CECRA certification consists of various methodological modules and can be completed with the basic certificate "CECRA Basics" and/or with the "CECRA Certificate" once all the requirements have been met. The modular competence development series is for advisors from the agricultural and home economics sector, as well as for all other actors in rural areas, such as regional or leader managers.
The path to CECRA certification:
- CECRA Basics:
After successfully completing five modules (two compulsory and three elective modules, at least one of which must be attended), an application for CECRA Basics can be submitted to the IALB or the EUFRAS CECRA Office. The basic certificate must be applied for within 5 years. - CECRA certificate:
After successful participation in five modules (two compulsory and three elective modules, at least one of which must be attended) and fulfilment of the accompanying requirements, the application for the CECRA certificate can be submitted to the regional CECRA recognition office. The application is checked by a second regional CECRA recognition centre. The CECRA certificate must be applied for within 7 years.
Target groups: All advisors in rural areas (not only from the agricultural and household sector, but also for other actors in rural areas, such as regional or leather managers).
Generally the forestry sector has not felt very integrated into CAP policies, especially in financial support. The A in AKIS, apparently, is not inclusive enough for the forestry sector. For these reasons, some authors propose using FOKIS instead of AKIS.
However, there is a more equidistant approach using AFKIS as in the i2connect glossary.
What acronym should we use?
According to the European Commission, the A in AKIS is NOT a restriction. All actors involved in agriculture, forestry and rural activities are automatically included. Also people related to the conservation of the environment, water, climate, biodiversity and landscape, consumers and citizens, agri-food and non-food systems and the transformation and distribution chain is included.
Another thing to take into account is the characteristics of the forestry sector in the nation or region to be considered. In many places in Europe, agroforestry and Non-wood forest products (NWFP) are very important. In this context, perhaps using AFKIS is the most appropriate and allows stakeholders to feel more comfortable.
On the other hand, it is worth not forgetting that there are regions and mountain areas where the main land use is forestry and they probably prefer to utilize FOKIS.
To be honest farmers and foresters have one thing in common, they still don't know the meaning of AKIS, AFKIS or FOKIS and most likely don't care about the acronym.
Finally, it is good to unify terminology and integrate policies to improve their results. That is why, continuing to use AKIS as a common meeting point is positive for all parties involved and makes extension, training, innovation, research and advice policies more visible.
En general, el sector forestal no se ha sentido muy integrado en las políticas de la PAC, especialmente en el apoyo financiero. La A de AKIS, aparentemente, no es lo suficientemente inclusiva para el sector forestal. Por esto, algunos autores proponen utilizar FOKIS en lugar de AKIS.
Sin embargo, existe un enfoque más equidistante que utiliza AFKIS, como en el glosario de i2connect.
¿Qué acrónimo debemos utilizar? Según la CE, la A en AKIS NO es una restricción. Se incluyen asì todos los agentes relacionados con agricultura, silvicultura y actividades rurales. También se incluye a las personas relacionadas con la conservación del medio ambiente, el agua, el clima, la biodiversidad y el paisaje, los consumidores y los ciudadanos, los sistemas agroalimentarios y no alimentarios y la cadena de transformación y distribución. Otra cosa a tener en cuenta son las características del sector forestal en la nación o región a considerar. En muchos lugares de Europa, la agrosilvicultura y los productos forestales no madereros (PFNM) son muy importantes. En este contexto, quizás utilizar AFKIS sea lo más apropiado y permita a las partes interesadas sentirse más cómodas. Por otro lado, no hay que olvidar que hay regiones y zonas de montaña en las que el principal uso del suelo es la silvicultura y probablemente prefieran utilizar FOKIS. Los agricultores y los silvicultores todavía no conocen el significado de AKIS, AFKIS o FOKIS y lo más probable es que no les importen las siglas. Es bueno unificar la terminología e integrar las políticas para mejorar sus resultados. Seguir utilizando AKIS como punto de encuentro común es positivo para todas las partes implicadas y hace más visibles las políticas de extensión, formación, innovación, investigación y asesoramiento.
During the i2connect training courses in Vienna and Rome, we used an exercise to explain the different decision-making methods that help groups make decisions. Each decision-making method is imperfect and each has pros and cons. When deciding which decision-making method to use, we have to take into account how this will affect the group dynamics.
In the exercise, the group of trainees is divided into three sub-groups and each of them is invited to draw their ideal evening on a blackboard sheet. The drawing facilitates cohesion and the raising of expectations. After about 15-20 minutes, the three groups are asked to explain their idea to the others. At the end of the presentation, the three ideas are put to the vote and the winning idea is announced.
The 'democratic' decision will satisfy the majority, but not everyone. A rope is laid out on the floor of the room with three positions: 'I really like this idea', 'I might like this idea', 'I don't like this idea at all'. The trainees are asked to take a position on one of these stations according to their preference.
The majority group is invited to ask the others what objections there are to not going ahead (e.g., "is there anything that might push you to change your idea?"). Between the preferences of the many and the objections of the few, there is an area of tolerance: if even the final solution is not the desired one, it has to be understood whether there is actually a reason to say no; then, it is possible to reach a consensus and move forward as a group. The exercise explains that focusing on the tolerance range offers many more options to work with. This will facilitate the group to make a decision.
Nei corsi di formazione i2connect di Vienna e Roma abbiamo utilizzato un esercizio per spiegare i diversi metodi decisionali che aiutano i gruppi a prendere decisioni. Ogni metodo decisionale è imperfetto e ognuno di essi ha pro e contro. Quando decidiamo quale metodo decisionale utilizzare, dobbiamo tenere conto di come questo influirà sulle dinamiche di gruppo.
Nell'esercizio, il gruppo dei discenti viene diviso in tre sottogruppi e ognuno di questi è invitato a disegnare su un foglio di lavagna la propria serata ideale. Il disegno facilita la coesione e l'innalzamento delle aspettative. Trascorso un tempo di circa 15-20 minuti, ai tre gruppi viene chiesto di esporre agli altri la propria idea. Alla fine dell'esposizione si procede a votare le tre idee e a decretare l'idea vincente.
La decisione “democratica” accontenterà la maggioranza, ma non tutti. Sul pavimento dell'aula viene stesa una corda con tre postazioni: “questa soluzione mi piace molto”, “questa soluzione potrebbe piacermi”, “questa soluzione non mi piace per niente”. Ai discenti viene chiesto di prendere posizione su una di queste postazioni in base alle loro preferenze.
Il gruppo di maggioranza viene invitato a chiedere agli altri quali obiezioni ci sono per non andare avanti (e.g., "c'è qualcosa che potrebbe spingervi a cambiare idea?”). Tra le preferenze dei molti e le obiezioni dei pochi, c'è un'area di tolleranza: se anche la soluzione finale non dovesse essere quella desiderata, bisogna capire se c'è effettivamente un motivo per dire di no; quindi, è possibile giungere ad un consenso e andare avanti come gruppo. L'esercizio spiega che lavorare sul range di tolleranza offre molte più opzioni con cui lavorare. In tal modo, sarà più facile per il gruppo prendere una decisione.
In the i2connect training, we used to carry out our sessions in a circle.
The use of this method of discussion fosters community and intimacy in traning activity, and can serve several purposes (i.e. academic, social and emotional). The circle is the basic form underlining all forms of participatory process, and it enables people to create a safe place in which they can feel that everyone become teacher and learner.
During the circle, communication takes place according to shared rules designed to promote active listening and participation by all.
This methodology helps to facilitate communication and mutual knowledge, to establish a favourable classroom climate, to recognise and manage one's own emotions and those of others (empathy), to stimulate the assumption of responsibility, to value individual resources and differences, and to educate for equality. It also enables the trainer to get to know the trainess better and the trainees to get to know each other better.
In the i2connect training, we used to carry out our sessions in a circle.
The use of this method of discussion fosters community and intimacy in traning activity, and can serve several purposes (i.e. academic, social and emotional). The circle is the basic form underlining all forms of participatory process, and it enables people to create a safe place in which they can feel that everyone become teacher and learner.
During the circle, communication takes place according to shared rules designed to promote active listening and participation by all.
This methodology helps to facilitate communication and mutual knowledge, to establish a favourable classroom climate, to recognise and manage one's own emotions and those of others (empathy), to stimulate the assumption of responsibility, to value individual resources and differences, and to educate for equality. It also enables the trainer to get to know the trainess better and the trainees to get to know each other better.
One of the methods used in i2connect training of the trainers is the "Postcard Game" approach. It is used to analyze people's ability to get to know each other, sharing tastes, preferences, feelings and dreams. The method consist of asking to the participants to make a postcard that reveals something personal, a preference, or they hope to accomplish. Photographs, images taken from magazines or downloaded from the Internet can be cut out and used.
Subsequently, on the back, the meaning of each chosen image is described. After the individual realization of the postcards, couples are organized to illustrate each other's work, the choices made and the reasons for these choices and to express comments and opinions on the choices of the partner.
In the last phase, groups of four are formed, bringing together two couples, for further sharing through the cooperative structure "Three-step interview": each one illustrates the work of his partner to the other couple.
One of the methods used in i2connect training of the trainers is the "Postcard Game" approach. It is used to analyze people's ability to get to know each other, sharing tastes, preferences, feelings and dreams. The method consist of asking to the participants to make a postcard that reveals something personal, a preference, or they hope to accomplish. Photographs, images taken from magazines or downloaded from the Internet can be cut out and used.
Subsequently, on the back, the meaning of each chosen image is described. After the individual realization of the postcards, couples are organized to illustrate each other's work, the choices made and the reasons for these choices and to express comments and opinions on the choices of the partner.
In the last phase, groups of four are formed, bringing together two couples, for further sharing through the cooperative structure "Three-step interview": each one illustrates the work of his partner to the other couple.
This game, which was played during the kickoff meeting of the ATTRACTISS project, can be used at the beginning of a course, workshop or meeting where people do not know or do not know each other very well, because it helps to break the ice, creating a friendly atmosphere, and at the same time to know something about the others.
In the “Getting to Know You” Bingo, each participant is given a sheet with various phrases on them. They must find another person who matches the phrase and have them sign the card in that space. There can be used phrases about family, favourite things, etc., but there can be created cards with whatever phrases the trainer like. Participants, walking around the room, have to introduce themselves to another person, even if they already know his or her name, and ask one of the questions. The purpose is just to practise small talk.
To make it shorter, have them just fill a row or column. When a participant ends - which means s/he has a name for each card, s/he says "Bingo"... then s/he can help others complete their bingo cards by indicating the person to ask.
This game can be played with a number of 20 to 50 participants.
Questo gioco, che è stato svolto durante il kickoff meeting del progetto ATTRACTISS, può essere usato all'inizio di un corso, di un workshop o di una riunione in cui le persone non si conoscono o non si conoscono bene, perché aiuta a rompere il ghiaccio, creando un clima disteso, e allo stesso tempo a conoscere meglio gli altri.
Nel Bingo "Conoscerti", ogni studente riceve un foglio con varie frasi. Gli studenti devono trovare un'altra persona che corrisponda alla frase e farle firmare la scheda in quello spazio. Si possono usare frasi sulla famiglia, sulle cose preferite, ecc. ma si possono creare schede con qualsiasi frase piaccia all'insegnante. I partecipanti, girando per la stanza, devono presentarsi ad un'altra persona, anche se conoscono già il suo nome e porgere una delle domande. Lo scopo è quello di comunicare. Per accorciare i tempi, basta far riempire una riga o una colonna. Quando un partecipante finisce - il che significa che ha un nome per ogni carta, esclama "Bingo"... poi potrà aiutare gli altri a finire le loro carte da bingo indicandogli la persona a cui chiedere informazioni.
Questo gioco può essere giocato con un numero variabile fra 20 e 50 partecipanti.
The fish bowl technique, which was used during the general assembly of i2connect, enables the facilitation of large group dialogue.
A large group can be difficult to handle and often only benefits a few active participants.
The idea is that rather than having a large group discussing about something, which can be difficult to handle and often only benefits a few active participants, it is better to focus on a small group discussion in an inner circle(ideally 3 – 6 people) while the rest of the group (maximum of 50 people) listens and observes without interrupting from an outer circle. Facilitation is focused on the core group discussion, that is easier to facilitate.
Sometimes the discussion is a “closed conversation” among a specific group, but more often, one or more chairs are open to “visitors” (i.e., members of the audience) who alternate asking questions or making comments.
Fishbowl can help build an inclusive and supportive learning environment by providing all participants both a speaking and listening role and a stake in the discussion, . The observation aspect of the activity allows people to identify appropriate ways to participate in discussions.
La tecnica del fish bowl, che è stata utilizzata durante l'assemblea generale di i2connect, consente di facilitare il dialogo tra gruppi numerosi.
Un gruppo di grandi dimensioni può essere difficile da gestire e spesso ne beneficiano solo alcuni partecipanti attivi.
L'idea è che piuttosto che avere un gruppo numeroso che discute di qualcosa, che può essere difficile da gestire e che spesso porta benefici solo a pochi partecipanti attivi, è meglio concentrarsi su una discussione di piccolo gruppo in un cerchio interno (idealmente da 3 a 6 persone) mentre il resto del gruppo (massimo 50 persone) ascolta e osserva senza interrompere da un cerchio esterno. La facilitazione si concentra sulla discussione del gruppo centrale, che è più facile da facilitare.
A volte la discussione è una "conversazione chiusa" tra un gruppo specifico, ma più spesso una o più sedie sono aperte ai "visitatori" (cioè ai membri del pubblico) che si alternano a fare domande o commenti.
Il fishbowl può aiutare a costruire un ambiente di apprendimento inclusivo e solidale, fornendo a tutti i partecipanti un ruolo di parola e di ascolto e una partecipazione alla discussione. L'aspetto di osservazione dell'attività permette alle persone di identificare i modi più appropriati per partecipare alle discussioni.
The triangle of facilitation is an i2connect tool, that helps to analyze the role performed by the facilitator of an innovation process.
The network (client, operational group, etc.) formulates its ambitions and wishes which are leading, even though these might change in the course of the process. This is the mandate within which the facilitator is invited to assist.
The facilitator serves the network. In the terminology of the Triangle of Co-creation, facilitators are suppliers.
The Facilitation Triangle shows different ways in which this serving role can be performed.
- Moderators provide structure for the process: they make agenda’s and time tables, bring in methods for exchange and discussion, lead meetings, etc.
- Animators stimulate people in the network to become involved and active. They focus on enthusiasm and removing barriers for collaboration, boosting energy.
- Facilitators make it easy for people in the network to participate and to give their contributions. They do whatever is needed for allowing participants to concentrate of the contents of their joint endeavour. They act like the travel agency that ensures that their clients can enjoy without any worries. In practice facilitators will do things that belong to each of the corners, however this tools enables facilitators to understand their position in the triangle and what can be done to improve the performance of the network.
The triangle of facilitation is an i2connect tool, that helps to analyze the role performed by the facilitator of an innovation process.
The network (client, operational group, etc.) formulates its ambitions and wishes which are leading, even though these might change in the course of the process. This is the mandate within which the facilitator is invited to assist.
The facilitator serves the network. In the terminology of the Triangle of Co-creation, facilitators are suppliers.
The Facilitation Triangle shows different ways in which this serving role can be performed.
- Moderators provide structure for the process: they make agenda’s and time tables, bring in methods for exchange and discussion, lead meetings, etc.
- Animators stimulate people in the network to become involved and active. They focus on enthusiasm and removing barriers for collaboration, boosting energy.
- Facilitators make it easy for people in the network to participate and to give their contributions. They do whatever is needed for allowing participants to concentrate of the contents of their joint endeavour. They act like the travel agency that ensures that their clients can enjoy without any worries. In practice facilitators will do things that belong to each of the corners, however this tools enables facilitators to understand their position in the triangle and what can be done to improve the performance of the network.
Among the training methods used in i2connect project's activities, the double diamond method is helpful to stay focussed in a group discussion, and to work systematically towards possible solutions to a problem.
A common pitfall in many discussions is that participants are so eager to jump into solutions that a good assessment of the problem is not being made.
Following the Double Diamond technique you first focus on a proper understanding of the problem. Once there is agreement on a clear understanding of what is at stake, the second part of the discussion focusses on possible solutions.
In each section of the discussion, you first let the discussion diverge until the ‘crunch zone’: a stage in which different views and opinions might compete with each other. Then you converge towards a common understanding of the problem (first diamond) or solution (second diamond).
Sometimes in the second diamond new insight appears for which it is necessary to go back to the first one. Then it is important to clearly mark this and get agreement of the group for doing so. This method allows separating problem space from solutions space.
Among the training methods used in i2connect project's activities, the double diamond method is helpful to stay focussed in a group discussion, and to work systematically towards possible solutions to a problem.
A common pitfall in many discussions is that participants are so eager to jump into solutions that a good assessment of the problem is not being made.
Following the Double Diamond technique you first focus on a proper understanding of the problem. Once there is agreement on a clear understanding of what is at stake, the second part of the discussion focusses on possible solutions.
In each section of the discussion, you first let the discussion diverge until the ‘crunch zone’: a stage in which different views and opinions might compete with each other. Then you converge towards a common understanding of the problem (first diamond) or solution (second diamond).
Sometimes in the second diamond new insight appears for which it is necessary to go back to the first one. Then it is important to clearly mark this and get agreement of the group for doing so. This method allows separating problem space from solutions space.
The Contract Triangle is one of the diagnostic tools provided by the i2connect toolbox that have been designed to reflect on ongoing interactive processes, to know the current position in a proccess and the next steps to be done. The contract triangle is useful to advisors to understand positions in an advisory activity and the different contractual relations. It is possible to identify three positions in an advisory activity: 1) Manager: who controls the conditions under which the advisor does his/her work. This can be the team leader, the employer, or the agency that pays for a project or programme within which the advisor operates.
2) Client: who receives a service from the advisor. This can be an advise, guidance in certain activities, assistance in linking the client to other actors, etc; 3) The advisor: who provides services to clients (e.g. farmers, producers, etc.). These positions can correspond to different contractual relations:
1) Contract of work: This is the mandate within which the advisor does his/her work. Probably he/she has a task- or job description, or maybe a Terms of Reference if he/she is contracted for a specific job in a project; 2) Contract of business: These are the conditions for the transaction between advisor and client. Costs or cost calculation. Time and period. What happens if things deviate from plan? 3) Contract of objectives: What does the client expect from the advisor? For what question does (s)he seek assistance? When will the client be satisfied?. Considering that an advisor is always functioning in a field with different contractual relationships, this tool can be useful to gain information about these aspects of advisory services.
The Contract Triangle is one of the diagnostic tools provided by the i2connect toolbox that have been designed to reflect on ongoing interactive processes, to know the current position in a proccess and the next steps to be done. The contract triangle is useful to advisors to understand positions in an advisory activity and the different contractual relations. It is possible to identify three positions in an advisory activity: 1) Manager: who controls the conditions under which the advisor does his/her work. This can be the team leader, the employer, or the agency that pays for a project or programme within which the advisor operates.
2) Client: who receives a service from the advisor. This can be an advise, guidance in certain activities, assistance in linking the client to other actors, etc; 3) The advisor: who provides services to clients (e.g. farmers, producers, etc.). These positions can correspond to different contractual relations:
1) Contract of work: This is the mandate within which the advisor does his/her work. Probably he/she has a task- or job description, or maybe a Terms of Reference if he/she is contracted for a specific job in a project; 2) Contract of business: These are the conditions for the transaction between advisor and client. Costs or cost calculation. Time and period. What happens if things deviate from plan? 3) Contract of objectives: What does the client expect from the advisor? For what question does (s)he seek assistance? When will the client be satisfied?. Considering that an advisor is always functioning in a field with different contractual relationships, this tool can be useful to gain information about these aspects of advisory services.
One of the aims of i2connect toolbox is to provide complex information and concepts in an easy way. Following this goal, the card "Working on projects or in networks" explain the differences and characteristics of projects and networks. The first one is characterized by the presence of a client that defines the success or failure of the initiative. Product is central in projects as well as structure that leads the activities. The main focus is on tasks and agreements, that are supervised hierarchycally. The reporting on results is carried on using indicators. The second one - the networks - differs from the previous because the success is defined by the initiatiors. They are voyages of discovery, undertaken by voluntary travellers. The ambition has a crucial role and the focus is on relationships and energy. Not the structure leads but the creative processes and opportunities. There are not supervisors but mentoring that helps in discovering paths. Such networks require energy regulation and also accountability through stories about what is learned (storytelling). This card is very useful for advisors and trainers during training courses.
One of the aims of i2connect toolbox is to provide complex information and concepts in an easy way. Following this goal, the card "Working on projects or in networks" explain the differences and characteristics of projects and networks. The first one is characterized by the presence of a client that defines the success or failure of the initiative. Product is central in projects as well as structure that leads the activities. The main focus is on tasks and agreements, that are supervised hierarchycally. The reporting on results is carried on using indicators. The second one - the networks - differs from the previous because the success is defined by the initiatiors. They are voyages of discovery, undertaken by voluntary travellers. The ambition has a crucial role and the focus is on relationships and energy. Not the structure leads but the creative processes and opportunities. There are not supervisors but mentoring that helps in discovering paths. Such networks require energy regulation and also accountability through stories about what is learned (storytelling). This card is very useful for advisors and trainers during training courses.
One of the participatory tools of i2connect toolbox is the peer consultation. This simple and effective method helps a storyteller to study a case together with colleagues.
Such coaching between peers allows for sharing resources and competences of all, and enhances the the group spirit. Infact in a trusted environment, colleagues probably see more that what you were aware of. This can be very helpful, even if it takes time to do so. There is not just one best method for peer-to-peer coaching, however there can be identify some steps to be followed to develop an effective peer consultation. 1) Formulating the question: the narrator explains just enough so that the participants understand what the question is about; 2) Gathering information: The participants ask questions until they know enough to start the analysis; 3) Analysis: select and use network tool(s) to understand what might be happening; 4) Reformulating the question: the narrator rephrases the question to have suggestions; 5) Advice: The participants tell what they would do if they were in the position of the narrator, without a discussion about it; 6) Conclusions: The narrator tells what advices are most useful to him/her, and why. The final stage is a Wrapping up during which each participant shares with the others main learnings from this consultation. If applicable, a new appointment is set.
One of the participatory tools of i2connect toolbox is the peer consultation. This simple and effective method helps a storyteller to study a case together with colleagues.
Such coaching between peers allows for sharing resources and competences of all, and enhances the the group spirit. Infact in a trusted environment, colleagues probably see more that what you were aware of. This can be very helpful, even if it takes time to do so. There is not just one best method for peer-to-peer coaching, however there can be identify some steps to be followed to develop an effective peer consultation. 1) Formulating the question: the narrator explains just enough so that the participants understand what the question is about; 2) Gathering information: The participants ask questions until they know enough to start the analysis; 3) Analysis: select and use network tool(s) to understand what might be happening; 4) Reformulating the question: the narrator rephrases the question to have suggestions; 5) Advice: The participants tell what they would do if they were in the position of the narrator, without a discussion about it; 6) Conclusions: The narrator tells what advices are most useful to him/her, and why. The final stage is a Wrapping up during which each participant shares with the others main learnings from this consultation. If applicable, a new appointment is set.
One of the tools of i2connect toolbox is the Learning History. It combines observations and perceptions with an analysis, based on theory. Particularly, it captures the lessons learned during a network process over a certain period of time. While the Timeline reflects the perceptions of participants, the Learning History adds analysis and conclusions, in terms of lessons learned and eventual future action.
In this process the perceptions are non-negotiable, because these are the ways participants have experienced things. This means that opinions may differ however on the way these perceptions should be understood, depending on the theory-in-use of the one analysing the story that results from the Timeline.
The value of the Learning History added to the Timeline is twofold: it makes analysis explicit and provides a relatively concise and easily readable account. The procedure can be explained in the six following steps:
1. Capture the narrative story: The Timeline method is very useful for doing so as well as using interviews. The narrative does not need to be complete, but it should contain the elements that matter most in the perception of the actors involved. If there are different perceptions about the same events, they should be included in the story.
2. Divide the story into scenes
3. Add newspaper headlines
4. Analyse the scenes involving all the actors
5. Look at the history as a journey of the hero
6. Draw conclusions
A Learning History differs from other types of documentation about processes (such as scientific articles, popular articles, brochures, pamphelet
One of the tools of i2connect toolbox is the Learning History. It combines observations and perceptions with an analysis, based on theory. Particularly, it captures the lessons learned during a network process over a certain period of time. While the Timeline reflects the perceptions of participants, the Learning History adds analysis and conclusions, in terms of lessons learned and eventual future action.
In this process the perceptions are non-negotiable, because these are the ways participants have experienced things. This means that opinions may differ however on the way these perceptions should be understood, depending on the theory-in-use of the one analysing the story that results from the Timeline.
The value of the Learning History added to the Timeline is twofold: it makes analysis explicit and provides a relatively concise and easily readable account. The procedure can be explained in the six following steps:
1. Capture the narrative story: The Timeline method is very useful for doing so as well as using interviews. The narrative does not need to be complete, but it should contain the elements that matter most in the perception of the actors involved. If there are different perceptions about the same events, they should be included in the story.
2. Divide the story into scenes
3. Add newspaper headlines
4. Analyse the scenes involving all the actors
5. Look at the history as a journey of the hero
6. Draw conclusions
A Learning History differs from other types of documentation about processes (such as scientific articles, popular articles, brochures, pamphelet
One of the tools of i2connect toolbox is the Energy Timeline. This is an easy-to-use method for joint evaluation in a network. It visualises the history of the network process and it provides a basis for discussion about the process, insights which emerged from it, and how the network may wish to move forward. The defining feature of this method is the focus on energy and on critical moments as perceived by the participants. The procedure consists of the following steps:
1. Prepare the timeline: Prepare a large wallpaper, dividing it in three rows:
Upper row: moments that gave energy
Middle row: moments that took energy
Lower row: moments of new insights or opportunities
Vertical lines divide the timeline in periods with milestones that are recognisable for all. E.g. periods in time, important events or meetings.
2. Explain the purpose of the activity
3. Write sticky notes for every moment that matters: Ask all participants to write sticky notes for moments in the process they remember as significant. One note for each moment. Facilitators write notes too. Once ready, they stick them where they belong on the Timeline, in time (horizontal) and in energy (vertical).
4. Look at the general picture: The final picture tells about the energy levels throughout the process, and give some insights about possible relation between difficult moments and breakthrough moments at the lower row.
5. Pay attention for details that need attention: during this phase it important to think about cards that require explanation or opposing perceptions
6. Draw conclusions: the final stage of the method allow to tell about the process the network has gone through and if it will lead to actions for the future.
One of the tools of i2connect toolbox is the Energy Timeline. This is an easy-to-use method for joint evaluation in a network. It visualises the history of the network process and it provides a basis for discussion about the process, insights which emerged from it, and how the network may wish to move forward. The defining feature of this method is the focus on energy and on critical moments as perceived by the participants. The procedure consists of the following steps:
1. Prepare the timeline: Prepare a large wallpaper, dividing it in three rows:
Upper row: moments that gave energy
Middle row: moments that took energy
Lower row: moments of new insights or opportunities
Vertical lines divide the timeline in periods with milestones that are recognisable for all. E.g. periods in time, important events or meetings.
2. Explain the purpose of the activity
3. Write sticky notes for every moment that matters: Ask all participants to write sticky notes for moments in the process they remember as significant. One note for each moment. Facilitators write notes too. Once ready, they stick them where they belong on the Timeline, in time (horizontal) and in energy (vertical).
4. Look at the general picture: The final picture tells about the energy levels throughout the process, and give some insights about possible relation between difficult moments and breakthrough moments at the lower row.
5. Pay attention for details that need attention: during this phase it important to think about cards that require explanation or opposing perceptions
6. Draw conclusions: the final stage of the method allow to tell about the process the network has gone through and if it will lead to actions for the future.
The Eco analysis is an extension of the Network Analysis, and analyses the quality of the relationships. This allows for assessing in more detail what it takes to move towards collaborative relations. It is based on the idea that all living creatures have three basic needs: safety, nutrition and reproduction. This is also true for initiative networks.
Safety: Some factors can provide safety to the “We” network” of initiators (e.g. project management), while others might be threatening (concurrence).
Nutrition: All resources needed for the initiative (e.g. expertise, information, money, human power, etc.)
Reproduction: This is the contribution to the world when the initiative yields success. What will become visible? And how will the movement carry on? In ecosystems, organisms relate to each other in different ways. Relations can be symbiotic or destructive for at least one party. Can be identify five types of relationships: i) Partner: There is balance between give and take; ii) Symbiosis: both partners profit; iii) Predator – Prey: There is unbalance between give and take. Predator profits at the cost of the prey; iv) Parasite: Breaks in and causes disease; v) Plague: Overwhelms and destroys. The challenge is to curb relationships towards complementarity.
Dealing with partners: cherish good relationships, and keep on investing in vitality.
Dealing with predators: gain strength and negotiate for mutual gain.
Dealing with preys: bring balance in give and take for a long lasting relationship.
Dealing with Parasites: fix the hole in your defence, and find out what these actors are telling you from a systems perspective.
Dealing with Plagues: seek rescue in your warm network, and make yourself ready for new opportunities that will emerge.
The Eco analysis is an extension of the Network Analysis, and analyses the quality of the relationships. This allows for assessing in more detail what it takes to move towards collaborative relations. It is based on the idea that all living creatures have three basic needs: safety, nutrition and reproduction. This is also true for initiative networks.
Safety: Some factors can provide safety to the “We” network” of initiators (e.g. project management), while others might be threatening (concurrence).
Nutrition: All resources needed for the initiative (e.g. expertise, information, money, human power, etc.)
Reproduction: This is the contribution to the world when the initiative yields success. What will become visible? And how will the movement carry on? In ecosystems, organisms relate to each other in different ways. Relations can be symbiotic or destructive for at least one party. Can be identify five types of relationships: i) Partner: There is balance between give and take; ii) Symbiosis: both partners profit; iii) Predator – Prey: There is unbalance between give and take. Predator profits at the cost of the prey; iv) Parasite: Breaks in and causes disease; v) Plague: Overwhelms and destroys. The challenge is to curb relationships towards complementarity.
Dealing with partners: cherish good relationships, and keep on investing in vitality.
Dealing with predators: gain strength and negotiate for mutual gain.
Dealing with preys: bring balance in give and take for a long lasting relationship.
Dealing with Parasites: fix the hole in your defence, and find out what these actors are telling you from a systems perspective.
Dealing with Plagues: seek rescue in your warm network, and make yourself ready for new opportunities that will emerge.
The Network Analysis is one of the diagnostic tools used during i2connect training of trainers courses. It helps to analyse which actors are needed to make change possible, and to what degree they are involved.
This analysis leads to set priorities for working on improving relationships. Using this approach implies answering to the following questions about the initiative; the carriers; the factors; the actors and the link: i) What is the shared ambition of the “We” network? ii) Which persons feel responsible for bringing the initiative further? iii) Which factors could determine success? iv) Who needs to move? Which actors have influence over the key factors? v) Which persons are approachable for carriers to make connection to these actors?. It is important to consider that institutions and positions of power play a role in any innovation process, but people are not equal to the institutions they represent.
The network analysis seeks opportunities to build warm networks between people who eventually can make things move from the inside.
It is therefore important to identify persons instead of institutions. These persons might be interesting for the initiative because of the position they have within their institutions. Things will move when formal decisions are being taken after the cold process. But prior to this, the warm process needs to take place for making a chance for success. For applying the network analysis is reccomended to follow the next steps: i) Take a large flipchart or wall paper; ii) Use Post-Its or carton cards in the colours as indicated above; iii) Fill in the cards following the questions, and place them on the flipchart as indicated in the picture; iv) Discuss who can approach which links in the near future.
The Network Analysis is one of the diagnostic tools used during i2connect training of trainers courses. It helps to analyse which actors are needed to make change possible, and to what degree they are involved.
This analysis leads to set priorities for working on improving relationships. Using this approach implies answering to the following questions about the initiative; the carriers; the factors; the actors and the link: i) What is the shared ambition of the “We” network? ii) Which persons feel responsible for bringing the initiative further? iii) Which factors could determine success? iv) Who needs to move? Which actors have influence over the key factors? v) Which persons are approachable for carriers to make connection to these actors?. It is important to consider that institutions and positions of power play a role in any innovation process, but people are not equal to the institutions they represent.
The network analysis seeks opportunities to build warm networks between people who eventually can make things move from the inside.
It is therefore important to identify persons instead of institutions. These persons might be interesting for the initiative because of the position they have within their institutions. Things will move when formal decisions are being taken after the cold process. But prior to this, the warm process needs to take place for making a chance for success. For applying the network analysis is reccomended to follow the next steps: i) Take a large flipchart or wall paper; ii) Use Post-Its or carton cards in the colours as indicated above; iii) Fill in the cards following the questions, and place them on the flipchart as indicated in the picture; iv) Discuss who can approach which links in the near future.
The Triangle of Co-Creation helps to analyse how actors position themselves in the process, and how they can be stimulated to contribute. Particularly, there are positions (i.e. what someone does in reality in the perception of others in the network) that contribute to co-creation such as Initiators, Managers and Suppliers. The first ones feel the ambition for change and go for it. Their energy can be contagious. Managers feel responsible for the structure as it is, and have the power to change it. Suppliers contribute within the limits of the structure. On the other hand, there are actors that do not contribute to co-creation and they are in positions outside the vital space. They are
Gatekeepers that control structures and do not permit change; Survivors that don’t have space to run risks and Activists that seek change but don’t care about the structure. Finally, Free Actors exercise their freedom to do whatever it takes to make and keep the network healthy and creative. Others appreciate them for doing so, even if they scribble outside the lines when necessary. Some key questions for analysing a case using the Triangle of co-creation are:
[1] Who are key actors in this case?
[2] What positions do these actors take in the Triangle?
[3] Are the four positions within the Triangle taken? If not, which one is vacant?
[4] For each actor outside the Triangle: why do you think (s)he takes this position?
Keep in mind that actors can have good and legitimate reasons for staying outside.
[5] What would (s)he need before moving towards a contributing position?
[6] Who can take action to take away barriers?
The Triangle of Co-Creation helps to analyse how actors position themselves in the process, and how they can be stimulated to contribute. Particularly, there are positions (i.e. what someone does in reality in the perception of others in the network) that contribute to co-creation such as Initiators, Managers and Suppliers. The first ones feel the ambition for change and go for it. Their energy can be contagious. Managers feel responsible for the structure as it is, and have the power to change it. Suppliers contribute within the limits of the structure. On the other hand, there are actors that do not contribute to co-creation and they are in positions outside the vital space. They are
Gatekeepers that control structures and do not permit change; Survivors that don’t have space to run risks and Activists that seek change but don’t care about the structure. Finally, Free Actors exercise their freedom to do whatever it takes to make and keep the network healthy and creative. Others appreciate them for doing so, even if they scribble outside the lines when necessary. Some key questions for analysing a case using the Triangle of co-creation are:
[1] Who are key actors in this case?
[2] What positions do these actors take in the Triangle?
[3] Are the four positions within the Triangle taken? If not, which one is vacant?
[4] For each actor outside the Triangle: why do you think (s)he takes this position?
Keep in mind that actors can have good and legitimate reasons for staying outside.
[5] What would (s)he need before moving towards a contributing position?
[6] Who can take action to take away barriers?
One of the tools of i2connect toolbox used during the training of trainers courses is the Circle of Coherence. It shows patterns of interaction that can occur within a network and gives insight into different ways to encourage vitality. It is based on the idea that people always balance between hope and fear:
Hope that collaboration will bring benefit, meaningfulness and protection; Fear that collaboration will lead to loss of autonomy and abuse of trust. It can be defined according to dimensions: Similarities/Differences and ME/WE. Between the poles Similarities/Differences people make connections with each other based on shared ambition and curiosity. Between the poles ME/WE people become actively involved and coortinate their efforts with each other. In doing so, they cater to their own interests, as well as to the intention of the network. At the center of these poles ther is the vital space: this is the space for curiosity and creativity, that generates energy, whereas the space outside drains energy. Inside it people dare to make mistakes and learn. Within the circle of coherence, it is possible to identify three type of patterns: constructive patterns - that enhance vitality and coherence; defensive patterns: that indicate people acting out for a sense of thier own security; destructive patterns: that escalate from bad to worse, and force the network apart. If fear outweighs hope, defensive patterns take over.
One of the tools of i2connect toolbox used during the training of trainers courses is the Circle of Coherence. It shows patterns of interaction that can occur within a network and gives insight into different ways to encourage vitality. It is based on the idea that people always balance between hope and fear:
Hope that collaboration will bring benefit, meaningfulness and protection; Fear that collaboration will lead to loss of autonomy and abuse of trust. It can be defined according to dimensions: Similarities/Differences and ME/WE. Between the poles Similarities/Differences people make connections with each other based on shared ambition and curiosity. Between the poles ME/WE people become actively involved and coortinate their efforts with each other. In doing so, they cater to their own interests, as well as to the intention of the network. At the center of these poles ther is the vital space: this is the space for curiosity and creativity, that generates energy, whereas the space outside drains energy. Inside it people dare to make mistakes and learn. Within the circle of coherence, it is possible to identify three type of patterns: constructive patterns - that enhance vitality and coherence; defensive patterns: that indicate people acting out for a sense of thier own security; destructive patterns: that escalate from bad to worse, and force the network apart. If fear outweighs hope, defensive patterns take over.
One of the diagnostic tools of i2connect toolbox is the Spirale of initiatives, that helps to analyse where you are in the process and what needs to be done to enter the following phase. Innovation proccesses follow a curly road, rather than a straight line from idea to realisation. Thus, initivatives, evolve through different phases, each with different actors and activities. The Spiral distinguishes seven different steps with different:
- Key actions to be taken;
- Actors to involve;
- Typical pitfalls to avoid. The first phase is the INITIAL IDEA carried out by the pioneers, people able to look outside the box. The next is the INSPIRATION. Supporters of the idea trying to get other people on board, mobilising a warm network. The PLANNING step is a negotiating space for experimentation, involving managers and financers. The next phase is the DEVELOPMENT, in which experts and suppliers try to introduce new practices, that will be observed working in the REALISATION phase, when the safe space of development stage is over. In case it works out well, then there will be other people interested anad take it over, in the DISSEMINATION step. If many people take it over the structure and the people who are responsible for the structure adapt to it, getting different rules. That is the EMBEDDING phase. Initiative do not always evolve through these phases in this order. People regularly step back within the spiral, and some phases are passed through more than once.
One of the diagnostic tools of i2connect toolbox is the Spirale of initiatives, that helps to analyse where you are in the process and what needs to be done to enter the following phase. Innovation proccesses follow a curly road, rather than a straight line from idea to realisation. Thus, initivatives, evolve through different phases, each with different actors and activities. The Spiral distinguishes seven different steps with different:
- Key actions to be taken;
- Actors to involve;
- Typical pitfalls to avoid. The first phase is the INITIAL IDEA carried out by the pioneers, people able to look outside the box. The next is the INSPIRATION. Supporters of the idea trying to get other people on board, mobilising a warm network. The PLANNING step is a negotiating space for experimentation, involving managers and financers. The next phase is the DEVELOPMENT, in which experts and suppliers try to introduce new practices, that will be observed working in the REALISATION phase, when the safe space of development stage is over. In case it works out well, then there will be other people interested anad take it over, in the DISSEMINATION step. If many people take it over the structure and the people who are responsible for the structure adapt to it, getting different rules. That is the EMBEDDING phase. Initiative do not always evolve through these phases in this order. People regularly step back within the spiral, and some phases are passed through more than once.
The warm and cold proccesses approach is one of the tools of i2connect toolkit. It is grounded on the assumption that networks around initiatives differ from projects of organisations. The main idea is that projects and organisations have goals and targets. In initiative-based networks people are connected through ambitions they share.
Managers and project leaders assign tasks to employees. In networks people drop out when they run out of energy. So, it is possible to distinguish processes into cold and warm according to the level of energy. The cold process is about who does what, when, how, and with what instruments and competences. It is also about being accountable to others. The warm process is about people with ambitions. When they connect, this releases energy because it feeds the hope that together they can do more.
Both processes need each other, like the flow in the river needs a bedding. But if the warm process is overlooked, the cold process leads to nothing. The people who find each other in something they want to achieve is called the warm network.
Such a network is always informal, and it can cross the borders of teams, institutions or cultural groups.
The warm and cold proccesses approach is one of the tools of i2connect toolkit. It is grounded on the assumption that networks around initiatives differ from projects of organisations. The main idea is that projects and organisations have goals and targets. In initiative-based networks people are connected through ambitions they share.
Managers and project leaders assign tasks to employees. In networks people drop out when they run out of energy. So, it is possible to distinguish processes into cold and warm according to the level of energy. The cold process is about who does what, when, how, and with what instruments and competences. It is also about being accountable to others. The warm process is about people with ambitions. When they connect, this releases energy because it feeds the hope that together they can do more.
Both processes need each other, like the flow in the river needs a bedding. But if the warm process is overlooked, the cold process leads to nothing. The people who find each other in something they want to achieve is called the warm network.
Such a network is always informal, and it can cross the borders of teams, institutions or cultural groups.
During i2connect training courses, one of the aspects trained is the communication, which plays a crucial role in advisory skills. It is useful to distinguish different communication approaches and each of them has its value. To reach the right target of communication, it is important to know which approach fits into which situation. It is possible to identify three approaches: 1) Transfer: The desired outcome is fixed. You are successful if others understand and do what you wish them to do; 2) Exchange: The outcome is the result of negotiations. You want something, but others want something in return for their collaboration; Co-creation: The outcome is a surprise. You have a reason to seek allies. You share an ambition for which you embark on the discovery journey. Where the journey will lead to cannot be known at the start. The first one is applied if the message is precisely what the others are looking for. However the tisk is meeting resistance, because people feel pushed into a direction they do not want. This can result in fighting over solutions, limiting the options for satisfactory outcomes. The second one, is suitable if you cannot expect others to join you unless you offer them something in return. The main risk is to not reach all targets. The third one fits if you need allies to get things done. The focus is on ambitions you share, rather than the outcome you have in mind. Co-creation can lead to results that are better than you could have imagined beforehand.
During i2connect training courses, one of the aspects trained is the communication, which plays a crucial role in advisory skills. It is useful to distinguish different communication approaches and each of them has its value. To reach the right target of communication, it is important to know which approach fits into which situation. It is possible to identify three approaches: 1) Transfer: The desired outcome is fixed. You are successful if others understand and do what you wish them to do; 2) Exchange: The outcome is the result of negotiations. You want something, but others want something in return for their collaboration; Co-creation: The outcome is a surprise. You have a reason to seek allies. You share an ambition for which you embark on the discovery journey. Where the journey will lead to cannot be known at the start. The first one is applied if the message is precisely what the others are looking for. However the tisk is meeting resistance, because people feel pushed into a direction they do not want. This can result in fighting over solutions, limiting the options for satisfactory outcomes. The second one, is suitable if you cannot expect others to join you unless you offer them something in return. The main risk is to not reach all targets. The third one fits if you need allies to get things done. The focus is on ambitions you share, rather than the outcome you have in mind. Co-creation can lead to results that are better than you could have imagined beforehand.
i2connect toolbox is a set of cards dealing with tools for diagnosis, methods for training, methods for monitoring and evaluation and AKIS related concepts that have been used during i2connect Training of Trainers courses, carried out all over Europe. One of the mentioned cards provides information about the conceptual definition of "Interactive Innovation". This is a crucial concept in the AKIS policies and projects, so the card added value is to summarize the key characteristics of such a complex notion. Particularly, it explains with the support of infographics, the differences between interactive innovation processes, technology transfer and production processes. In a technology transfer experts define desired results and the advisor transfers the research outputs to the user. In the production process client define the result in a process where there is an order, a project and a deliverable. Finally, in an interactive innovation process the outcome is the result of the efforts of a variety of actors who bring in relevant knowledge and experience. Such a process can be defined as a discovery journey, whose main characteristics are i) to address a real challenges and problems faced by farmers/foresters to which there is no simple solution; ii) to be multi-actor based, bringing together diverse people from various sectors; iii) requires collaboration and frequent interactions among the partners throughout the process where members actively share their knowledge, skills and expertise; iv) requires sharing power and responsability in recognition of the different areas of expertise.
i2connect toolbox is a set of cards dealing with tools for diagnosis, methods for training, methods for monitoring and evaluation and AKIS related concepts that have been used during i2connect Training of Trainers courses, carried out all over Europe. One of the mentioned cards provides information about the conceptual definition of "Interactive Innovation". This is a crucial concept in the AKIS policies and projects, so the card added value is to summarize the key characteristics of such a complex notion. Particularly, it explains with the support of infographics, the differences between interactive innovation processes, technology transfer and production processes. In a technology transfer experts define desired results and the advisor transfers the research outputs to the user. In the production process client define the result in a process where there is an order, a project and a deliverable. Finally, in an interactive innovation process the outcome is the result of the efforts of a variety of actors who bring in relevant knowledge and experience. Such a process can be defined as a discovery journey, whose main characteristics are i) to address a real challenges and problems faced by farmers/foresters to which there is no simple solution; ii) to be multi-actor based, bringing together diverse people from various sectors; iii) requires collaboration and frequent interactions among the partners throughout the process where members actively share their knowledge, skills and expertise; iv) requires sharing power and responsability in recognition of the different areas of expertise.
In the framework of the I2Connect project, a complete set of analysis tools have been designed to help advisors, or whoever is involved in innovation processes, to recognise patterns that are behind these complex systems, to understand their logic, and to see options to act effectively in the situation.
Innovation processes are unpredictable in nature, as they develop on uncertain patterns and involve people with different needs and expecations.
Yet, there are certain patterns that frequently occur. A set of 5 diagnostic tools have been therefore developed in order acknowledge them, go back on the right track when they are diverging form it and recognise actors and their role in each step.
The main aim is to provide easy to use method for keeping a network vital so that co-creation could happen. The topics adressed by the tools are:
- Development of the content: from idea to realisation and further (-> the spiral of innovation)
- Analysis of interaction patterns: how to feed energy in the network? (-> the circle of coherence)
- Analysis of involvement of actors: whom to connect with, how and when? (-> the network analysis)
- Analysis of quality of relationships: What to do to create a healthy human ecosystem? (-> the Eco analysis)
- Analysis of positions: how to create complementary positions for co-creation? (-> the triangle of co-creation)
Nell'ambito del progetto i2Connect, è stata progettata una serie completa di strumenti di analisi per aiutare i consulenti, o chiunque sia coinvolto nei processi di innovazione, a riconoscere gli schemi che sono alla base di questi sistemi complessi, a comprenderne la logica e a vedere le opzioni per agire efficacemente nella situazione.
I processi di innovazione sono di natura imprevedibile, poiché si sviluppano su schemi incerti e coinvolgono persone con esigenze e aspettative diverse.
Tuttavia, ci sono alcuni modelli che si verificano frequentemente. È stata quindi sviluppata una serie di 5 strumenti diagnostici per riconoscerli, tornare sulla strada giusta quando se ne discostano e riconoscere gli attori e il loro ruolo in ogni fase.
L'obiettivo principale è quello di fornire un metodo facile da usare per mantenere una rete vitale in modo che la co-creazione possa avvenire:
- Sviluppo dei contenuti: dall'idea alla realizzazione e oltre (-> la spirale dell'innovazione)
- Analisi dei modelli di interazione: come alimentare l'energia nella rete? (-> il cerchio della coerenza)
- Analisi del coinvolgimento degli attori: con chi connettersi, come e quando? (-> l'analisi della rete)
- Analisi della qualità delle relazioni: Cosa fare per creare un ecosistema umano sano? (-> l'analisi Ecologica)
- Analisi delle posizioni: come creare posizioni complementari per la co-creazione? (-> il triangolo della co-creazione).
During i2connect training courses, the technique of Role Playing is often used.
Role Playing involves trainees playing the professional roles that are addressed by the training course (e.g. setting up/managing a network/multi-actor partnership) or other roles, with the aim of letting trainees practice soft skills and transversal competences (e.g. communication, problem solving, ability to work in a team, mediation, etc.) related to them.
In order to be effective, Role Playing must recreate, as truthfully as possible, the real professional situation that is being played out.
Role Playing is structured in 3 phases: 1) Briefing: the trainer explains, as clearly as possible, what the learners will have to do and why; it is important that everyone understands the importance and educational value of the playing; 2) Carrying out the Simulation: the participants engage in the game using all the necessary methodologies, techniques, tools and skills that they have acquired for the particular professional situation being performed; 3) Debriefing: the trainer stimulates reflections from both the trainees who were involved in the Role Playing and from the learners who watched the simulation. Finally, the trainer "evaluates" the performance with the aim of deepening the key points related to the competences at stake.
Durante i corsi di formazione di i2connect è spesso usata la tecnica del Role Playing.
Il Role Playing consiste nel far interpretare ai corsisti i ruoli professionali oggetto dell’intervento formativo (e.g., formare / gestire un network / partenariato multiattore) o altri ruoli, con lo scopo di far mettere in pratica soft skills e competenze trasversali legate ad esso (es. comunicazione, problem solving, capacità di lavorare in gruppo, mediazione, ecc.) legate ad esso.
Per garantire l’efficacia, il Role Playing deve ricreare, nel modo più verosimile possibile, la reale situazione professionale che viene messa in scena.
Il Role Playing si struttura in 3 fasi: 1) Briefing: il formatore spiega, nel modo più chiaro possibile, cosa gli allievi dovranno fare e perché; è importante che tutti capiscano l’importanza e il valore didattico dell’interpretazione; 2) Svolgimento della Simulazione: i partecipanti si mettono in gioco utilizzando tutte le metodologie, le tecniche, gli strumenti e le competenze necessarie che avranno acquisito per la particolare situazione professionale messa in scena; 3) Debriefing: il formatore stimola le riflessioni da parte dei discenti protagonisti del Role Playing e da parte degli allievi che hanno assistito alla simulazione. Infine, il formatore “valuta” la performance con l’obiettivo di approfondire gli aspetti fondamentali legati alle competenze in gioco.
The Sound ball is an icebreaker game energising participant, that can also be used for debriefing learning points, increase teamwork and decrease the tendency to think ahead instead of listening. The activity, used in the i2connect traininig course in Italy, involves participants throwing imaginary ball(s) to each other in increasing pace.
Instructions:
The trainer asks trainees to stand in a circle and “shows” an imaginary ball, while telling everyone that they will be throwing this ball around.
S/He explains that s/he is going to throw the ball to a trainee, after making a special sound.
Everyone is instructed to keep their eyes on the ball and get ready to catch it, taking care to make the same sound as he made.
The trainer makes a sound and “throw” the ball to someone, making sure that this player makes the same sound and catches the ball.
The trainer explains that the catcher can now throw the player to another player, making a new sound as the ball is thrown. The receiving player repeats the sound, catches the ball and throws it to another player, making a new sound.
Once the ball is being thrown around at a fairly brisk pace, another imaginary ball can be introduced and throw.
Debriefing:
When the group gets into a flow and many of the participants are engaged and having more fun the activity can be stopped. The trainer conducts a debriefing discussion eliciting and emphasizing ground rules for creative collaboration.
Pay attention to the present, don't think ahead. Build on the ideas of others: make the next obvious sound. Embrace failure: don't censor your behavior.
Make your partner look good, play to team-win. All ideas are ok, this is an opportunity to practice “throwing out” ideas or sounds without worrying about whether they are crazy or stupid.
La palla sonora, utilizzata nel corso di formazione i2connect in Italia, prevede che i partecipanti si lancino l'un l'altro una o più palle immaginarie a ritmo crescente. È un gioco rompighiaccio ed energizzante che può essere utilizzato riepilogare l'apprendimento, aumentare il lavoro di squadra e diminuire la tendenza a pensare in anticipo invece di ascoltare.
Istruzioni:
Il formatore chiede ai partecipanti di mettersi in cerchio e "mostra" una palla immaginaria, spiegando che tutti la lanceranno. Lui inizierà il gioco lanciando la palla a un partecipante, dopo aver emesso un suono speciale. Tutti devono tenere gli occhi sulla palla e prepararsi a prenderla, facendo attenzione a ripetere il suono.
Il formatore spiega che il giocatore che prende la palla (e ripete il suono) può lanciarla a un altro giocatore, emettendo un nuovo suono. Il giocatore che riceve ripete il suono, prende la palla e la lancia a un altro giocatore, emettendo un nuovo suono.
Una volta che la palla viene lanciata a un ritmo abbastanza sostenuto, si può introdurre e lanciare un'altra palla immaginaria.
Debriefing:
Quando il gruppo entra in sintonia e molti dei partecipanti sono impegnati e si divertono, l'attività può essere interrotta. Il formatore conduce una discussione di debriefing per sottolineare le regole per la collaborazione creativa: Prestare attenzione al presente, non pensare al futuro. Costruite sulle idee degli altri: fare in modo che la prossima idea sia ovvia. Accogliere il fallimento: non criticare il proprio comportamento. Far fare bella figura al vostro partner, giocate per vincere in squadra. Tutte le idee vanno bene, questa è un'opportunità per esercitarsi a "buttare fuori" idee o suoni senza preoccuparsi se sono folli o stupidi.
What are the motivations behind people's actions and reactions? What motivates people to act? In the i2connect training course in Italy, we used the ABC’s of Motivation to understand how to motivate people. This is a simple framework according to which, when people feel that they have some control and choice, feel as though they belong to a group and are recognized for their competencies, they are more likely to be enthusiastic and motivated. Autonomy, Belonging and Competence are the ABC’s.
Having autonomy means doing something because you WANT to, not because you have to. Obligations do not support autonomy and can inhibit intrinsic motivation. Therefore, in a training course/workshop/network/project it is important to provide opportunities for people participation in decision making, as well as in designing and defining shared responsibilities, ask for input, facilitate higher level discussions, plan for self-directed activities, etc.
The sense of belonging is reflected in the degree to which people feel that they are respected and connected to others. Therefore, it is important to stimulate participation, cooperative learning, active listening.
Feeling competent happens when someone experiences pride in seeing their accomplishments and notices their own improvement. For achieving Competence, it is important to encourage problem solving, consider language and timing of feedback, include people in a cycle of observation, practice, applying skills in real-life situations and reflection, acknowledge perspectives without judgement.
The ABC’s are intricately connected. The more these three psychological needs are encouraged and satisfied, the more engaged people become and the more long-term learning will occur.
Quali sono le motivazioni che stanno alla base delle azioni e delle reazioni delle persone? Cosa spinge le persone ad agire? Nel corso di formazione i2connect in Italia, abbiamo usato l'ABC della motivazione per capire come motivare le persone. Secondo questo approccio, quando le persone sentono di avere un certo controllo e una certa possibilità di scelta, di appartenere a un gruppo e sono riconosciute per le loro competenze, è più probabile che siano entusiaste e motivate. Autonomia, appartenenza e competenza sono gli ABC.
Avere autonomia significa fare qualcosa perché si vuole, non perché si deve. Gli obblighi possono inibire la motivazione. Pertanto, in un corso di formazione/workshop/rete/progetto è importante fornire opportunità di partecipazione al processo decisionale, così come alla progettazione e alla definizione di responsabilità condivise, chiedere contributi, facilitare discussioni, pianificare attività autogestite, ecc.
Il senso di appartenenza si riflette nel grado in cui le persone sentono di essere rispettate e connesse agli altri. Pertanto, è importante stimolare la partecipazione, l'apprendimento cooperativo e l'ascolto attivo.
Ci si sente competenti quando si prova orgoglio nel vedere i propri risultati e si nota il proprio miglioramento. Per raggiungere la competenza è importante incoraggiare la risoluzione dei problemi, considerare il linguaggio e i tempi del feedback, stimolare l'applicazione delle abilità in situazioni reali e la riflessione, riconoscere le prospettive senza giudicare.
Gli ABC sono strettamente connessi. Più questi tre bisogni psicologici vengono incoraggiati e soddisfatti, più le persone si impegnano e più si verifica un apprendimento a lungo termine.
This exercise, which was testing in the i2connect 'Train the Trainers' course in Vienna, is a true experiential game that can be used during a course or workshop as a team-building activity since it helps participants relate and build a strategy together.
Game instructions:
Place a number of chairs in the room corresponding to the number of participants + 1 in two concentric circles, with the seats facing each other (participants sitting on the two circles can see each other's faces). There should be space between the two circles to allow one person (the trainer) to pass through. The external circle will not be completely closed to allow the trainer to enter.
The trainer makes the participants sit down: one chair will remain empty (at a point opposite the passage).
The trainer explains that his task is to sit in the empty chair and that the people sitting down will have to hinder him/her by studying a strategy.
The group will have a couple of minutes to agree on it.
After the time expires, the trainer enters the circle walking normally towards the chair. The seated persons will move to prevent him/her from sitting down, among general laughter, but they will always leave an empty chair that can be occupied.
If, after 1/ 2 minutes the trainer has not been able to sit down, he/she will applaud the group.
If, on the other hand, the group has not succeeded in preventing the trainer from sitting down, they may be given 1 / 2 further opportunities to repeat the game. This game can be played with a number of 20 to 30 participants.
Questo esercizio, che è stato eseguito nel corso i2connect ‘Train the trainer’ in Vienna, è un vero e proprio gioco che può essere usato durante un corso o un workshop come attività di team-building poiché aiuta i partecipanti a relazionarsi e costruire insieme una strategia.
Istruzioni per il gioco:
Si dispongono nell’aula un numero di sedie pari al numero dei partecipanti + 1 in due cerchi concentrici, con le sedute poste l’una di fronte all’altra (i partecipanti seduti sui due cerchi possono vedersi in faccia). Fra i due cerchi dovrà esserci lo spazio per consentire il passaggio di una persona (il formatore). Il cerchio esterno non sarà completamente chiuso, ma dovrà avere un passaggio per permettere a questa persona di entrare.
Il formatore fa sedere i partecipanti: una sedia rimarrà libera (in un punto opposto al passaggio).
Il formatore spiega che il suo compito è quello di occupare la sedia vuota e che le persone sedute dovranno impedirglielo studiando una strategia.
Il gruppo avrà a disposizione un paio di minuti per accordarsi.
Passato il tempo, il formatore entra nel cerchio camminando normalmente, dirigendosi verso la sedia. Le persone sedute si sposteranno per impedirgli di sedere, fra le risate generali, ma lasceranno sempre una sedia vuota che potrà essere occupata.
Se, trascorsi 1/ 2 minuti il formatore non sarà riuscito a sedere, farà un bell’applauso al gruppo, che è riuscito a trovare una strategia.
Se, invece, il gruppo non sarà riuscito ad impedire al formatore di sedere, potranno essere date 1 / 2 ulteriori occasioni per ripetere il gioco. Il gioco può essere svolto con un numero di circa 20/30 partecipanti
i2connect is a H2020 project whose main mandate is to create a momentum of change in innovation support services by ‘empowering advisors as well as their organisations to engage and support farmers and foresters in interactive innovation processes. To support partners to learn from project experiences and to capitalise on these learnings at the project level, a light reflection tool was developed. The tool offers a simple, non-threatening support (a template with a list of questions) to structure own reflections and draw conclusions for learning at the individual and project level. The three main questions asked are: 1) What are your observations and learning insights on "interactive innovation"? (2) Which of these insights would you like to discuss with others in i2connect? (3) What conclusions do you draw from your insights for (a) a next event within i2connect and (b) for your professional work? It is expected that at the individual level, repeated reflections on different events related to interactive innovations help the reflecting person to become more aware of the complex setting around an interactive innovation and better understand own actions and the reactions they prompt. At the project level, such systematic and structured reflections help to identify commonalities and differences, synergies and conflicts in the individual reflections for drawing broader implications at the project level.
i2connect ist ein H2020-Projekt, dessen Hauptaufgabe darin besteht, eine Dynamik des Wandels bei Unterstützungsdiensten im Bereich Innovation zu schaffen, indem Berater und ihre Organisationen befähigt werden, Land- und Forstwirte in interaktive Innovationsprozesse einzubinden und zu unterstützen. Um die Partner dabei zu unterstützen, aus den Projekterfahrungen zu lernen und diese Erkenntnisse auf Projektebene zu nutzen, wurde ein Reflexionsinstrument entwickelt. Das Tool bietet eine einfache, harmlose Unterstützung (eine Vorlage mit einer Liste von Fragen), um die eigenen Überlegungen zu strukturieren und Schlussfolgerungen für das Lernen auf individueller und Projektebene zu ziehen. Die drei Hauptfragen lauten: 1) Was sind Ihre Beobachtungen und Lernerfahrungen in Bezug auf "interaktive Innovation"? (2) Welche dieser Erkenntnisse würden Sie gerne mit anderen in i2connect diskutieren? (3) Welche Schlussfolgerungen ziehen Sie aus Ihren Erkenntnissen für (a) eine nächste Veranstaltung im Rahmen von i2connect und (b) für Ihre berufliche Arbeit? Es wird erwartet, dass auf der individuellen Ebene wiederholte Reflexionen über verschiedene Veranstaltungen im Zusammenhang mit interaktiven Innovationen der reflektierenden Person helfen, sich des komplexen Umfelds einer interaktiven Innovation bewusster zu werden und die eigenen Handlungen und die dadurch ausgelösten Reaktionen besser zu verstehen. Auf der Projektebene helfen solche systematischen und strukturierten Überlegungen, Gemeinsamkeiten und Unterschiede, Synergien und Konflikte in den individuellen Überlegungen zu erkennen, um daraus weiterreichende Konsequenzen für die Projektebene zu ziehen.
Timely tracking and keeping log of the provision of advisory services at farm level is extremely relevant for managing, controlling, monitoring the implementation of measure 2 of the RDP 2014-2020.
As well, the collection of relevant data and qualitative information allows assessing the functioning, effects and satisfaction about advisory services at farm and system levels.
All this, in a system perspective is crucial, because means providing evidence about the state of art and the performances of the advisory services within the AKISs.
The “Management and Monitoring Tool for Advisory Services” (MMT4AS) was developed under the responsibility of Campania Region for all these purposes.
The functionalities of MMT4AS are set to allow the managing authority to keep log of all administrative and advisory activities and being constantly in contact one to each other, since the selection of the advisory organization until the final payment. The web application allows sharing: advisory plans and the reports on the services provided for each beneficiary farm; details and timing of the advisory activities and methods; farmers’ satisfaction questionnaires; controls’ procedures; requests of payments.
Farm advisors report benefits in terms of simplification of the administrative procedures.
The tool is demonstrating its usefulness also for planning the interventions on the use and the enhancement of advisory services for the CAP 2023-2027 because it’s providing relevant baseline information to define, for example, simplified costs, timing and methods to foresee for the different advisory services in relation to the CAP topics.
Il monitoraggio tempestivo e la tenuta di un registro della fornitura di servizi di consulenza a livello di azienda è estremamente importante per la gestione, il controllo e il monitoraggio dell'attuazione della misura 2 del PSR 2014-2020.
Inoltre, la raccolta di dati rilevanti e di informazioni qualitative permette di valutare il funzionamento, gli effetti e la soddisfazione dei servizi di consulenza a livello aziendale e di sistema. Tutto questo, in una prospettiva di sistema è cruciale, perché significa fornire prove sullo stato dell'arte e sulle prestazioni dei consulenti all'interno degli AKIS. Il "Management and Monitoring Tool for Advisory Services" è stato sviluppato sotto la responsabilità della Regione Campania per tutti questi scopi.
Le funzionalità sono impostate per consentire all'AdG di tenere un registro di tutte le attività amministrative e di consulenza ed essere costantemente in contatto con loro, dalla selezione dell'organizzazione di consulenza fino al pagamento finale. L'applicazione web permette di condividere i piani di consulenza e le relazioni sui servizi forniti per ogni azienda agricola beneficiaria; i dettagli e i tempi delle attività e dei metodi di consulenza; i questionari di soddisfazione degli agricoltori; le procedure di controllo; le richieste di pagamento. I consulenti agricoli riportano benefici in termini di semplificazione delle procedure amministrative. Lo strumento sta dimostrando la sua utilità anche per la pianificazione degli interventi sull'uso e potenziamento dei servizi di consulenza per la PAC 2023-27, fornendo informazioni di base rilevanti per definire, ad es. costi semplificati, tempi e modalità da prevedere per i diversi servizi di consulenza in relazione ai temi della PAC.
The “AKIS Meeting Place”, organised by the Swedish Rural Network, is the large meeting of the year for actors and organizations being part of the entire agricultural knowledge and innovation system (AKIS) and members of the AKIS-network. The last edition provided the participants with deliberations concerning definitions of AKIS, presentations of various knowledge hubs within the innovation system, tools for improving communication and marketing, and young farmers presented their thoughts on the AKIS systems and their future needs. The meeting ended with the arrangement of an interactive workshop and smaller participants working groups. The workshop's mission was to encourage the members to develop an action plan about: How actors and organizations working within the entire knowledge and innovation system should go from words to actions. The participants identified and prioritized the three most necessary actions and needs, which will guide the work in the coming year. The Innovation Coach kept track of and facilitated the work within the network, and together with the members, they designed activities for fulfilling the needs, organize workshops, follow-up events, and create interactive activities enabling various members of the network to initiate multi-actor collaborations. The advantages for the members and participants in the annual meeting are the receival of external monitoring, description of the current situation, and the opportunity to express their needs. The network is members-driven creating participation and ownership. According to the actions and needs defined at the annual meeting, 4-5 physical activities will be organized around Sweden. Each activity has a specific theme based on the actions and needs listed.
The “AKIS Meeting Place”, organised by the Swedish Rural Network, is the large meeting of the year for actors and organizations being part of the entire agricultural knowledge and innovation system (AKIS) and members of the AKIS-network. The last edition provided the participants with deliberations concerning definitions of AKIS, presentations of various knowledge hubs within the innovation system, tools for improving communication and marketing, and young farmers presented their thoughts on the AKIS systems and their future needs. The meeting ended with the arrangement of an interactive workshop and smaller participants working groups. The workshop's mission was to encourage the members to develop an action plan about: How actors and organizations working within the entire knowledge and innovation system should go from words to actions. The participants identified and prioritized the three most necessary actions and needs, which will guide the work in the coming year. The Innovation Coach kept track of and facilitated the work within the network, and together with the members, they designed activities for fulfilling the needs, organize workshops, follow-up events, and create interactive activities enabling various members of the network to initiate multi-actor collaborations. The advantages for the members and participants in the annual meeting are the receival of external monitoring, description of the current situation, and the opportunity to express their needs. The network is members-driven creating participation and ownership. According to the actions and needs defined at the annual meeting, 4-5 physical activities will be organized around Sweden. Each activity has a specific theme based on the actions and needs listed.
ProAgria in Finland has set up a network of facilitators to share experiences of leading, managing and facilitating discussion groups and to learn from each other. The group is led by Anu Ella, an advisor/facilitator who also provides training for facilitators. Anu realised early on that the discussion group facilitators needed training. While her own background is in agriculture and teaching, she recognised the need to undertake training in psychology to broaden her skills.
In ProAgria, a mentoring approach is used to train and develop new discussion group facilitators. New facilitators take on the role of assistant facilitators at discussion group meetings as part of their training. A new facilitator can be an assistant facilitator for up to two years where they act as an apprentice and the experienced facilitator acts as their mentor. By acting as assistant at discussion group meetings they become familiar with the process.
The network provides the facilitators with a safe space to practice their facilitation techniques and to reflect on and share their experiences. This group meets two or three times per year and the meetings are very motivating for the new facilitators. They use WhatsApp and MS Teams to share information or ask questions. They also have a book on facilitation skills that is shared with the new facilitators. A key part of the training for facilitators is to participate in study trips and to observe discussion groups abroad.
ProAgria ha creato una rete di facilitatori, per condividere le esperienze di conduzione, gestione e facilitazione dei gruppi di discussione e apprendere gli uni dagli altri. Il gruppo è guidato da Anu Ella, una consulente/facilitatrice che provvede anche alla formazione dei facilitatori. Anu ha capito subito che i facilitatori dei gruppi di discussione avevano bisogno di formazione. Anche se il suo background è nell'agricoltura e nell'insegnamento, ha riconosciuto la necessità di intraprendere formazione in psicologia per ampliare le sue competenze.
In ProAgria in Finlandia viene usato un approccio di mentoring per formare e sviluppare nuovi facilitatori di gruppi di discussione. I nuovi facilitatori assumono il ruolo di assistenti alle riunioni dei gruppi di discussione come parte della loro formazione. Un nuovo facilitatore può essere un facilitatore assistente per un massimo di due anni dove agisce come apprendista e il facilitatore esperto agisce come mentore. Assumendo il ruolo di assistenti alle riunioni dei gruppi di discussione essi acquisiscono familiarità con il processo.
La rete dei facilitatori rappresenta uno spazio sicuro per praticare le loro tecniche di facilitazione e per riflettere e condividere le loro esperienze. Il gruppo si incontra due o tre volte all'anno e gli incontri sono molto motivanti per i nuovi facilitatori. Usano WhatsApp e MS Teams per condividere informazioni o fare domande. Hanno anche un libro sulle abilità di facilitazione che viene condiviso con i nuovi facilitatori. Una parte fondamentale della formazione dei facilitatori è la partecipazione ai viaggi di studio e l'osservazione dei gruppi di discussione all'estero.
i2connect coaching is an activity complementary to the i2connect 3day innovation support method training, that lasts a period of 6 months after the training. The goal is to offer a target-tailored support to the rural advisors in their individual innovation projects and processes. The coaching period intents to improve the transfer of the training content into practice. A stand-alone training can give an impulse, offering additional coaching to the participants can increase the chance that new behaviour and problem-solving strategies are adopted.
The i2connect aims at a shifting towards the co-creation mode, offering a space for a common learning and co-creation experience. The focus is on positively strengthening the coachee's autonomy and self-control powers. The goal is making it a habit to reflect on actions for facilitating group processes for innovation. In the i2c context, the coaching topic is usually the participants’ innovation processes where they are involved.
Partly, in group coaching or collegial coaching sessions, the focus can also be on deepening the training contents (innovation support tools and approaches), mainly by - applying one of the tools from the seminar (like the spiral or story telling),
- introducing a further tool for dealing with difficult situations in innovation processes) or
- story telling (for deeper reflection of an innovation process and for dissemination of best practice of innovation support work). The i2 connect coaching activities has been helding online, in three modes: i) Individual coaching, ii) Peer coaching in small groups; iii) Collegial coaching with the seminar group.
i2connect coaching is an activity complementary to the i2connect 3day innovation support method training, that lasts a period of 6 months after the training. The goal is to offer a target-tailored support to the rural advisors in their individual innovation projects and processes. The coaching period intents to improve the transfer of the training content into practice. A stand-alone training can give an impulse, offering additional coaching to the participants can increase the chance that new behaviour and problem-solving strategies are adopted.
The i2connect aims at a shifting towards the co-creation mode, offering a space for a common learning and co-creation experience. The focus is on positively strengthening the coachee's autonomy and self-control powers. The goal is making it a habit to reflect on actions for facilitating group processes for innovation. In the i2c context, the coaching topic is usually the participants’ innovation processes where they are involved.
Partly, in group coaching or collegial coaching sessions, the focus can also be on deepening the training contents (innovation support tools and approaches), mainly by - applying one of the tools from the seminar (like the spiral or story telling),
- introducing a further tool for dealing with difficult situations in innovation processes) or
- story telling (for deeper reflection of an innovation process and for dissemination of best practice of innovation support work). The i2 connect coaching activities has been helding online, in three modes: i) Individual coaching, ii) Peer coaching in small groups; iii) Collegial coaching with the seminar group.
Considering the different types of farming systems and farmers, proposals should examine how farmers make their decisions and who influences them most. The aim of the activities is to analyze the role of advisor in the AKISs. Considering the impact of face-to- face interaction, projects should identify the key factors in the creation of trust between farmer and advisor to enable effective knowledge transfer and exchange. Explore the relationship between advisors and researchers and between advisors and farmers, identifying the main elements facilitating the flow of information in both directions. Particular attention is related to advisors' potential to boost innovation, focusing on practice needs into research activities, participating and intermediating in farmer- to-farmer learning processes and interactive innovation projects. A network within AKIS may permit increase knowledge, development of relationships amongst the people sharing professional interests. A strong relationship within a network can be challenging for advisors, through a constant availability to other actors, and consequently the need to continuously update skills and knowledge to satisfy clients by anticipating their needs and demands, thus gaining respect and trust. Challenges may occur in the ability to anticipate the needs of other people, especially farmers who may have a lack of time in keeping up to date. This good practice has been shown to enhance the processes of inspiration, idea generation, and motivation of the actors within an innovation project. With the use of this good practice, farmers argue that there are different levels of learning from the enhancement of knowledge, which makes farmers think differently about the future of farming.
Considering the different types of farming systems and farmers, proposals should examine how farmers make their decisions and who influences them most. The aim of the activities is to analyze the role of advisor in the AKISs. Considering the impact of face-to- face interaction, projects should identify the key factors in the creation of trust between farmer and advisor to enable effective knowledge transfer and exchange. Explore the relationship between advisors and researchers and between advisors and farmers, identifying the main elements facilitating the flow of information in both directions. Particular attention is related to advisors' potential to boost innovation, focusing on practice needs into research activities, participating and intermediating in farmer- to-farmer learning processes and interactive innovation projects. A network within AKIS may permit increase knowledge, development of relationships amongst the people sharing professional interests. A strong relationship within a network can be challenging for advisors, through a constant availability to other actors, and consequently the need to continuously update skills and knowledge to satisfy clients by anticipating their needs and demands, thus gaining respect and trust. Challenges may occur in the ability to anticipate the needs of other people, especially farmers who may have a lack of time in keeping up to date. This good practice has been shown to enhance the processes of inspiration, idea generation, and motivation of the actors within an innovation project. With the use of this good practice, farmers argue that there are different levels of learning from the enhancement of knowledge, which makes farmers think differently about the future of farming.
The Chamber of Agriculture and Forestry of Slovenia (part of the SEASN network) organized the first "Cross Visit" within the i2connect project. The "Cross Visits" made for the agricultural consultants who have attended the i2connect training course on network analysis tools in interactive innovation processes. The "Cross-Visits" is an opportunity for selected consultants to go abroad and increase their knowledge from the training course by using it in practice together with colleagues from different parts of Europe, exploring examples of practical cases of interactive innovation. During the "Cross Visit" to Slovenia the participants analyzed an EIP project on sustainable grape production in vineyards. Find a suitable practical case of interactive innovation is probably the most important and also the most difficult step to do when organizing a "Cross-Visit", as the selected case is the heart of the whole event. The key players prepare a presentation of the practical case (project) and also a demonstration of the innovation in the field. After the presentation, the main focus was on understanding the interactive innovation process in this project, which is analyzed through interviews with key players. The result of the workshops are visual presentations (posters) of the practical case in the form of tools for network analysis. At the end, the participants also do a SWOT analysis of the case. The lessons learned from the case study and from the cross-visit itself are very valuable. The main objective is that the participants take home what they have learned, use this knowledge in their daily work and also transfer it to their colleagues.
The Chamber of Agriculture and Forestry of Slovenia (part of the SEASN network) organized the first "Cross Visit" within the i2connect project. The "Cross Visits" made for the agricultural consultants who have attended the i2connect training course on network analysis tools in interactive innovation processes. The "Cross-Visits" is an opportunity for selected consultants to go abroad and increase their knowledge from the training course by using it in practice together with colleagues from different parts of Europe, exploring examples of practical cases of interactive innovation. During the "Cross Visit" to Slovenia the participants analyzed an EIP project on sustainable grape production in vineyards. Find a suitable practical case of interactive innovation is probably the most important and also the most difficult step to do when organizing a "Cross-Visit", as the selected case is the heart of the whole event. The key players prepare a presentation of the practical case (project) and also a demonstration of the innovation in the field. After the presentation, the main focus was on understanding the interactive innovation process in this project, which is analyzed through interviews with key players. The result of the workshops are visual presentations (posters) of the practical case in the form of tools for network analysis. At the end, the participants also do a SWOT analysis of the case. The lessons learned from the case study and from the cross-visit itself are very valuable. The main objective is that the participants take home what they have learned, use this knowledge in their daily work and also transfer it to their colleagues.
In Campania region an advisory monitoring system tool has been used to verify the conformity of the advisory activities carries out. For the purposes of the monitoring activity, the advisory body is required to process and make available data useful for the assessment and control of the advisory service provided: farm visits, advisory modules actually delivered, technical deliverables and additional reporting outputs. The technical documentation available for controls tends to demonstrate the efficiency of the advisory activities carried out and their consistency with the specific rules governing the area in which they are carried out. By accessing the Campania Region portal at the following address:
"http://psrgarem2.regione.campania.it/Pages/ElencoOrganismi", the authenticated user accesses the service.For each farm, advisors/organization of advisors are required to fill the dates of the farm visits and to upload the outputs. Once the output has been uploaded, the platform gives the opportunity to download the customer satisfaction form, which must be completed and signed by the advising farm and uploaded back into the system. All data on the platform can be viewed and downloaded, in real time, by the Campania Region. This advisory monitoring system has been analyzed during i2connect activities because it gives the opportunity to assess the quality of the advisory services and the activities carried out. Moreover, data collect have been used for the definition of the semplified costs options for the CAP Stragetic Plan interventions.
Nella regione Campania è stato implementato uno strumento di monitoraggio del sistema di consulenza per verificare la conformità delle attività realizzate. Ai fini dell'attività di monitoraggio, l'organismo di consulenza è tenuto a elaborare e rendere disponibili i dati utili alla valutazione e al controllo del servizio di consulenza erogato: visite aziendali, moduli di consulenza effettivamente erogati, elaborati tecnici e reportistica aggiuntiva. La documentazione tecnica disponibile per i controlli tende a dimostrare l'efficacia delle attività di consulenza svolte e la loro coerenza con le norme specifiche che regolano il territorio in cui vengono svolte. Accedendo al portale della Regione Campania al seguente indirizzo:
"http://psrgarem2.regione.campania.it/Pages/ElencoOrganismi", l'utente autenticato accede al servizio.Per ogni azienda agricola, i consulenti/organizzazione di consulenti sono tenuti a compilare le date delle visite aziendali e a caricare gli output. Una volta caricati gli output, la piattaforma offre la possibilità di scaricare il modulo di soddisfazione del cliente, che deve essere compilato e firmato dall'azienda agricola consulente e caricato nuovamente nel sistema. Tutti i dati presenti sulla piattaforma possono essere visualizzati e scaricati, in tempo reale, dalla Regione Campania. Questo sistema di monitoraggio della consulenza è stato analizzato durante le attività di i2connect perché offre l'opportunità di valutare la qualità dei servizi di consulenza e delle attività svolte. Inoltre, i dati raccolti sono stati utilizzati per la definizione delle opzioni di costo semplificate per gli interventi del Piano Stragetico della PAC.
Laimburg Integrated Digital Orchard - LIDO is an open-air laboratory for fruit-growing and viticulture created by the Laimburg Research Centre to promote innovation in the field of digitisation and robotics in agriculture.
LIDO, realised with the contribution of the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF), was inaugurated in October 2022 and is available to companies, research institutes and farms who can use the laboratory to test and demonstrate existing and new technologies to the public. In this way, the Laimburg Experimentation Centre promotes digital innovations in agriculture and enables local farms to actively participate in the digital transformation.
Specifically, LIDO allows the testing and promotion of automated irrigation and fertilisation systems, innovative crop management methods, integration of sensor technologies, stationary application of plant protection products, as well as forecasting models and advanced decision-making systems.
The fruit lab is located in an apple orchard, which has an area of 0.65 hectares, while the viticulture lab is located in a 0.4-hectare vineyard. Both facilities are equipped with optical fibres and electricity to ensure power supply and fast data transmission. In addition, a workstation container is equipped to control and monitor the devices directly on the fields. The data collected by the different sensors is fed into a common database, which enables a better understanding of the complex relationships between them.
Laimburg Integrated Digital Orchard – LIDO è un laboratorio a cielo aperto per la frutticoltura e la viticoltura realizzato dal Centro di Sperimentazione Laimburg per promuovere l’innovazione nel campo della digitalizzazione e della robotica in agricoltura.
LIDO, realizzato con il contributo del Fondo Europeo di Sviluppo Regionale (FESR), è stato inaugurato nell’ottobre 2022 ed è a disposizione di aziende e istituti di ricerca che possono utilizzare il laboratorio per testare e dimostrare al pubblico tecnologie esistenti e nuove. In questo modo, il Centro di Sperimentazione Laimburg promuove le innovazioni digitali in agricoltura e consente alle aziende agricole locali di partecipare in maniera attiva alla trasformazione digitale.
In pratica, LIDO consente di testare e promuovere sistemi di irrigazione e fertilizzazione automatizzati, metodi innovativi di gestione delle colture, integrazione delle tecnologie dei sensori, applicazione stazionaria di prodotti fitosanitari, nonché modelli di previsione e sistemi decisionali avanzati:
Il laboratorio di frutticoltura si trova in un meleto, che ha una superficie di 0,65 ettari, mentre quello di viticoltura si trova in un vigneto di 0,4 ettari. Entrambe le strutture sono dotate di fibre ottiche ed elettricità per garantire l’alimentazione e la trasmissione veloce dei dati. Inoltre, è presente un container con una postazione di lavoro direttamente nelle strutture, attrezzato per controllare e monitorare i dispositivi nei campi. I dati raccolti dai diversi sensori confluiscono in un database comune, che consente di comprendere meglio le relazioni complesse tra dati.
AgriTech Makeathon is one of the i2connect's supported 13 pilot projects. These are short projects, offering the opportunity to the participants of the i2connect training program to put their training into practice. Particularly, Agritech Makeathon is an workshop which aims to create new, viable, state-of-the-art technology-based, innovation-driven ideas for a topical issue in agriculture, fisheries, forestry or food sector within 48 hours. The event took place in Latvia and was organized by LRATC (Latvian Rural Advisory and Training Centre). The main idea was bringing together different actors where some are creating the environment for others to create and thus helping to address real challenges in agriculture, fishery, forestry, and food sector. During the event, participants looked for creative solutions to specific issues ending up with projects and products. In order to achieve the desired results, participants were supported by professional mentors and had the opportunity to use Latvia University of Life Sciences and Technologies (LULST) technical equipment. Farmers, fishermen, foresters, advisors, scientists, engineers, programmers, entrepreneurs, marketers, designers, students, business and finance professionals, local government representatives participated in the Makeathon. Each Team owned, without limitation, the intellectual property rights of the content of the Product created, invented and/or developed. Participants were facilitated by the coordinators who have participated in i2connect national trainings, that used methods from the i2connect toolbox, such as the Spiral of Initiatives, the Triangle of Co-creation, Network Analysis, Energy Timeline and peer-to-peer consultation.
AgriTech Makeathon is one of the i2connect's supported 13 pilot projects. These are short projects, offering the opportunity to the participants of the i2connect training program to put their training into practice. Particularly, Agritech Makeathon is an workshop which aims to create new, viable, state-of-the-art technology-based, innovation-driven ideas for a topical issue in agriculture, fisheries, forestry or food sector within 48 hours. The event took place in Latvia and was organized by LRATC (Latvian Rural Advisory and Training Centre). The main idea was bringing together different actors where some are creating the environment for others to create and thus helping to address real challenges in agriculture, fishery, forestry, and food sector. During the event, participants looked for creative solutions to specific issues ending up with projects and products. In order to achieve the desired results, participants were supported by professional mentors and had the opportunity to use Latvia University of Life Sciences and Technologies (LULST) technical equipment. Farmers, fishermen, foresters, advisors, scientists, engineers, programmers, entrepreneurs, marketers, designers, students, business and finance professionals, local government representatives participated in the Makeathon. Each Team owned, without limitation, the intellectual property rights of the content of the Product created, invented and/or developed. Participants were facilitated by the coordinators who have participated in i2connect national trainings, that used methods from the i2connect toolbox, such as the Spiral of Initiatives, the Triangle of Co-creation, Network Analysis, Energy Timeline and peer-to-peer consultation.
The AKIS analytical tool is one of the tools provided in i2connect project. This is a threefold tool devoted to support managing authorities, evaluators and other experts to analyse the AKISs, through gathering relevant data and information on both the contextual situation of the overall AKIS, particularly on advisory service, and of its interplays. The tool includes (a) a guideline for a comprehensive analysis and reporting of the AKIS; (b) a questionnaire, for interviewing privileged AKISs actors, aimed at investigating relevant aspects that allow characterizing a specific AKIS (policy strategies, instruments and bodies, R&I infrastructures, advisory services, etc) and, (c) a relational matrix for the rapid assessment of the interconnections within a specific AKISs. This tool addresses a general lack of practical and ready-to-use methods and tools for analysing AKIS and their functioning, at levels relevant to end-users (national/regional/sub-regional), and is therefore particularly valuable in view of profiling/characterising AKIS for the design of strategies and/or interventions.
Specifically, it allows outlining the most important areas of investigation and reporting about the state, functioning and components (actors and flows) of the AKIS and diagnosing or assessing the state of interactions among the different types of AKISs’ actors. The three components of this tool can be used, jointly or separately, during ex-ante, ongoing and ex-post analyses of the AKISs. As they are proposed, their systematic use allows consolidating data at relevant levels, conducting comparative assessments, between countries and over periods and creating a cross-cutting baseline for future studies.
Il tool dell'AKIS è uno degli strumenti forniti dal progetto i2connect. Si tratta di un triplice strumento dedicato a supportare le autorità di gestione, i valutatori e altri esperti nell'analisi degli AKIS, attraverso la raccolta di dati e informazioni rilevanti sia sulla situazione dell'AKIS nel suo complesso, con particolare riferimento ai servizi di consulenza, sia sulle interazioni tra gli attori. Lo strumento comprende (a) una linea guida per l'analisi dell'AKIS; (b) un questionario, per intervistare gli attori privilegiati dell'AKIS, volto a indagare gli aspetti rilevanti di uno specifico AKIS (strategie politiche, strumenti e organismi, infrastrutture di R&I, servizi di consulenza, ecc) e (c) una matrice relazionale per una rapida valutazione delle interconnessioni all'interno di uno specifico AKIS. Questo strumento risponde alla generale mancanza di strumenti pratici e pronti all'uso per l'analisi degli AKIS e del loro funzionamento, con un livello di dettaglio rilevante per gli utenti finali (nazionale/regionale/sub-regionale), ed è quindi particolarmente prezioso in vista della profilazione degli AKIS per la progettazione di strategie e/o interventi. In particolare, consente di delineare le aree più importanti di indagine e di reporting sullo stato, il funzionamento e le componenti (attori e flussi) degli AKIS e di diagnosticare o valutare lo stato delle interazioni tra i diversi tipi di attori. Le tre componenti di questo strumento possono essere utilizzate, congiuntamente o separatamente, durante le analisi ex-ante, in corso ed ex-post. Il loro uso sistematico consentirebbe di consolidare i dati, di condurre valutazioni comparative tra Paesi e di creare una base di riferimento trasversale per studi futuri.
In the frame of the i2connect project, over 30 partners from 27 countries compiled their respective country’s Agricultural Knowledge and Innovation Systems (AKIS) inventory in 2020/2021. To kick start the process, the task coordinator outlined a simple “hypothetical AKIS diagram” that deconstructed the AKIS concept. This helped all authors of the AKIS reports to have a common understanding of the concept and task at hand.
The hypothetical AKIS diagram presented five categories of AKIS actors (public authorities, research and education, farmer-based organisations, NGOs and private companies) labelled by five different colours. Additionally, the diagram presented linkages between the identified actors either with a solid straight line (strong linkage) or a broken line (weak linkage).
Inspired by the hypothetical diagram, respective AKIS inventory authors drafted their own AKIS country diagram based on literature and their own knowledge. Then they used their drafted diagram as a visualisation tool to interview experts about AKIS actors at the national, regional or local level as well as their linkages. Based on the results from the expert interviews, the authors revised their AKIS diagram, which they incorporated in the final report. Visualising AKIS actors and knowledge flows with the diagram assisted authors to summarise their country’s AKIS situation in a clear and precise way. Furthermore, the diagram served as a good entry point for further exploration of actors’ roles and complex linkages that gave a comprehensive understanding of AKIS at a national/regional/local level.
Im Rahmen des i2connect-Projekts erstellten über 30 Partner aus 27 Ländern eine Bestandsaufnahme der landwirtschaftlichen Wissens- und Innovationssysteme (AKIS) ihres jeweiligen Landes im Zeitraum 2020/21. Um den Prozess in Gang zu bringen, skizzierte der Aufgaben-Koordinator ein einfaches "hypothetisches AKIS-Diagramm". Dies half allen Autoren der AKIS-Berichte, ein gemeinsames Verständnis des Konzepts und der Aufgabe zu entwickeln. Das AKIS-Diagramm zeigte fünf Kategorien von AKIS-Akteuren, die durch fünf verschiedene Farben gekennzeichnet waren. Zusätzlich stellte das Diagramm die Verbindungen zwischen den identifizierten Akteuren entweder mit einer durchgezogenen geraden Linie (starke Verbindung) oder einer gestrichelten Linie (schwache Verbindung) dar. Inspiriert durch das hypothetische Diagramm entwarfen die jeweiligen Autoren des AKIS-Berichts ihr eigenes AKIS-Länderdiagramm auf der Grundlage der Literatur und ihres eigenen Wissens. Anschließend nutzten sie ihr entworfenes Diagramm als Visualisierungsinstrument, um Experten zu AKIS-Akteuren auf nationaler, regionaler oder lokaler Ebene sowie zu deren Verbindungen zu befragen. Auf der Grundlage der Ergebnisse aus den Experteninterviews überarbeiteten die Autoren ihr AKIS-Diagramm, das sie in den Abschlussbericht aufnahmen. Die Visualisierung der AKIS-Akteure und Wissensflüsse mit Hilfe des Diagramms half den Autoren, die AKIS-Situation in ihrem Land klar und präzise zusammenzufassen. Darüber hinaus diente das Diagramm als guter Einstiegspunkt für die weitere Untersuchung der Rollen der Akteure und der komplexen Verknüpfungen, die ein umfassendes Verständnis von AKIS auf nationaler/regionaler/lokaler Ebene ermöglichten.
Within the Agroinnowacja EIP project, sowing a catch crop for forage has enabled the six partner farmers to improve higher gross margins and cattle performance. Each of the six farmers participating in the project act as ambassadors to spread results. They share their experiences, changes made to their farm and results achieved, with other farmers in the producer groups to which they participate. Each producer group has approximately 20 farmers, which are going to be influenced by the ambassador farmer. At Producer Group meetings the advisor presents the idea to the group and the ambassador farmer shares his/her insights and experience of implementing that idea and getting results. This is an effective method for influencing other farmers and showing them what is possible. The dissemination of the success and results achieved in this project has had a real impact on the other members of the producer groups. The farmers are now approaching the advisor to ask if they can be part of a project and are willing to co-operate and work with others to develop and implement new solutions.
An interesting channel that has become very effective for marketing and promoting the results of innovative research and development projects is You Tube. High quality and well-produced videos are created to showcase the project and the results and then put on YouTube. These videos are then shared/promoted by agricultural influencers who are successfully using the solutions. When an agricultural influencer shares the video, it results in thousands of views by people in the target audience. The success of this effective marketing approach has shown the advisor that it is not necessary to have more than six farmers involved in a project in order to have an impact.
Nell'ambito del progetto Agroinnowacja, la semina di una coltura di recupero per il foraggio ha permesso ai sei agricoltori partner di migliorare i margini lordi e le prestazioni del bestiame. Ognuno dei sei agricoltori che hanno partecipato al progetto agisce come ambasciatore per diffondere i risultati. Condividono le loro esperienze, i cambiamenti apportati alla loro azienda e i risultati ottenuti, con altri agricoltori nei gruppi di produttori a cui partecipano. Ogni gruppo di produttori ha circa 20 agricoltori, che sono influenzati dall'agricoltore ambasciatore. Alle riunioni del gruppo di produttori il consulente presenta l'idea al gruppo e l'agricoltore ambasciatore condivide le sue intuizioni e la sua esperienza nell'attuazione di quell'idea e nell'ottenimento dei risultati. La diffusione del successo e dei risultati ottenuti in questo progetto sta avendo un impatto reale sugli altri membri dei gruppi di produttori. Gli agricoltori ora si avvicinano ai consulenti per chiedere se possono far parte di un progetto e sono disposti a cooperare e lavorare con gli altri per sviluppare e implementare nuove soluzioni. Un canale interessante che è diventato molto efficace per commercializzare e promuovere i risultati dei progetti innovativi di ricerca e sviluppo è You Tube. Video di alta qualità e ben prodotti sono creati per mostrare il progetto e i risultati e poi messi su YouTube. Questi video sono poi condivisi da influencer agricoli che stanno usando con successo le soluzioni proposte, traducendosi in migliaia di visualizzazioni da parte delle persone target. Il successo di questo approccio di marketing ha dimostrato al consulente che non è necessario avere più di sei agricoltori coinvolti in un progetto per avere un impatto.
The i2connect partners IDELE France developed an interesting way for analysing networks using the tool Map of actors, inspired by by ASIRPA (INRAe) and ImpresS (CIRAD). The idea behind the so-called Map of Actors is to identify three different types of actors. The important actors: those who are really involved in the project and those we think of right away. The second type of actors are the influent actors. They are not involved in the project directly, but they can give support, they can give ideas, they can give money. And the third type of actors is maybe the most important. They are the impacted actors. Those who will change at the end, who will be transformed by the project. In the last step, the advisor is reflecting on his/her own position and mission in this map, in this network. This tool supports advisors to become more interactive and innovative in their networks and projects.
The i2connect partners IDELE France developed an interesting way for analysing networks using the tool Map of actors, inspired by by ASIRPA (INRAe) and ImpresS (CIRAD). The idea behind the so-called Map of Actors is to identify three different types of actors. The important actors: those who are really involved in the project and those we think of right away. The second type of actors are the influent actors. They are not involved in the project directly, but they can give support, they can give ideas, they can give money. And the third type of actors is maybe the most important. They are the impacted actors. Those who will change at the end, who will be transformed by the project. In the last step, the advisor is reflecting on his/her own position and mission in this map, in this network. This tool supports advisors to become more interactive and innovative in their networks and projects.
During the i2connect project, starting from the idea to analyse different types of innovation processes, there have been organized several field visits to put into practice some methodologycal aspects of innovative proccesses. One of this visits involved the Operational Group of fruit growers called ArboNovateurs, that has been analysed using a tool called the Spiral of Innovation (Spiral of Initiatives). Interactive innovation emphasizes cooperation among various actors, the sharing of knowledge and effective intermediation between actors along the value chains and at different territorial levels considering the innovation in fruit growers. The analysis showed that key for interactive innovation is knowledge which is included whereby end-users and farmers are not only involved as study objects but their entrepreneurial skills and practical knowledge are used for developing the solution or opportunity, thereby creating co-ownership. The purpose of such analysis is to find key factors of success in an innovation process, to discover patterns in what functions well, and to identify the challenges.
During the i2connect project, starting from the idea to analyse different types of innovation processes, there have been organized several field visits to put into practice some methodologycal aspects of innovative proccesses. One of this visits involved the Operational Group of fruit growers called ArboNovateurs, that has been analysed using a tool called the Spiral of Innovation (Spiral of Initiatives). Interactive innovation emphasizes cooperation among various actors, the sharing of knowledge and effective intermediation between actors along the value chains and at different territorial levels considering the innovation in fruit growers. The analysis showed that key for interactive innovation is knowledge which is included whereby end-users and farmers are not only involved as study objects but their entrepreneurial skills and practical knowledge are used for developing the solution or opportunity, thereby creating co-ownership. The purpose of such analysis is to find key factors of success in an innovation process, to discover patterns in what functions well, and to identify the challenges.
TRAS.IRRI.MA is an operational group that focuses on how to facilitate the introduction of improved irrigation management models in fruit production. The idea behind the project was to spread knowledge from the European initiative "EIP-water". The issue of water scarcity for agricultural purposes is so widespread in the Basilicata region that all AKIS actors were interested to implement the project.
In the first year, meetings were organised to gather farmers’ needs and agree on objective. The University (involved in EIP-water) provided specific training for advisors (technical advisors from Asso Fruit organisation, private advisors and advisors from public extension service), which act as a connection between researchers and farmers and facilitate the transfer of field work to the farmers who are not involved in the project by organising open events. With the acquired knowledge, advisors were able to advise which solution for water management would be most appropriate for a specific problem and adapt it based on characteristic of the farm. But the knowledge flow goes in the other direction too, so the goal is also to collect knowledge and experiences from farmers, who use innovative technologies for water management. Based on the tests made on farms, the best water management models were selected and open field visits on farm were organised. Field visits are open and free for everybody in the Region. In this way other farmers/advisors can also come and learn which water management tools exist, how they work, what are their advantages and how to use them. They can also see other farmers while using the technology and, at the same time, discuss about how to improve irrigation with advisors, technician and researchers.
Glavni cilj projekta TRAS.IRRI.MA je izboljšati upravljanje z vodo in povečati trajnostnost v pridelavi sadja z uvedbo inovativne in okolju prijazne tehnike. Ker je cilj projekta zagotoviti, da znanje o inovativnih pristopih pri upravljanju z vodo doseže čim več kmetov, je diseminacija najpomembnejši del projekta, pri čemer imajo kmetijski svetovalci glavno vlogo. Med projektom je bila na testnih kmetijah preizkušena cela paleta sodobne tehnologije za upravljanje z vodo. Po testnem obdobju so bili izbrani najboljši modeli upravljanja z vodo oz. kmetije z najboljšimi rezultati. Na teh kmetijah se izvajajo brezplačne demonstracije, kjer se lahko kmetje in svetovalci naučijo, katera orodja za upravljanje voda obstajajo, kako delujejo, kakšne so njihove prednosti in kako jih uporabljati. Tehnologijo lahko vidijo med uporabo, hkrati pa lahko izmenjajo izkušnje in pridobijo znanje od kmetov in svetovalcev, vključenih v projekt. Učinek takšnega načina razširjanja je že dokazan, saj številni kmetje prosijo svetovalce za pomoč pri nakupu tovrstne tehnologije in uporabi na terenu. Svetovalci pravijo, da so nekateri kmetje odprti za inovacije, zato je z njimi enostavno vzpostaviti dialog; izziv so predvsem tisti kmetje, ki so manj pripravljeni na inovacije in potrebujejo več podpore s strani svetovalcev, da začnejo razmišljati bolj inovativno. V ta namen so svetovalci v sodelovanju z raziskovalci za kmete izdelali smernice in protokole upravljanja z vodo, katerih namen je izboljšati ozaveščenost kmetov o potrebi prilagajanja podnebnim spremembam. Cilj je doseči čim več kmetov, ne samo v regiji Basilicata, ampak tudi v drugih regijah Italije.
ASSAM - Agency for Agri-Food Sector Services of Marche Region (IT), is a public body reorganized in 1997 and well embedded within the local AKIS since decades that acts as a local focal point of connection between farming systems and scientific research.
It provides a multitude of back-office and services to agricultural operators: agrochemical laboratory and sensorial analyses on products; technical assistance; research and dissemination; vocational training for students, advisors and farmers; product certification and traceability, irrigation and wastewater planning; phytosanitary and agro-meteorological services and; innovation brokering.
Under the RDP 2024-2020, ASSAM was delegated to apply the role of public innovation broker to help the emersion of problems/needs from the field, performing territorial animation to facilitate the dialogue between relevant actors (e.g. info days, research and innovation days) and disseminating innovative solutions (e.g. open days), until supporting the setting up of the operational groups (OGs) at regional level and the exchange of experiences with others at interregional and European levels (e.g. networking days).
The web portal www.innovamarche.it is mainly used as a working tool for providing and sharing scientific, technical and dissemination information.
ASSAM is partner in 12 out of 42 of regional OGs in Region Marche, where its functions range from research and application of farming practices and techniques to laboratorial analyses until communication and dissemination of the results.
ASSAM - Agenzia per i Servizi al Settore Agroalimentare delle Marche (IT), è un ente pubblico riorganizzato nel 1997 e ben inserito all'interno dell'AKIS locale da decenni che funge da punto focale locale di collegamento tra sistemi agricoli e ricerca scientifica.
Fornisce una moltitudine di back-office e servizi agli operatori agricoli: laboratorio agrochimico e analisi sensoriali sui prodotti; assistenza tecnica; ricerca e divulgazione; formazione professionale per studenti, consulenti e agricoltori; certificazione e tracciabilità dei prodotti, pianificazione dell'irrigazione e delle acque reflue; servizi fitosanitari e agrometeorologici e; intermediazione dell'innovazione.
Nell'ambito del PSR 2024-2020, l'ASSAM è stata delegata ad applicare il ruolo di broker pubblico dell'innovazione per aiutare l'emersione di problemi/bisogni dal campo, svolgendo un'animazione territoriale per facilitare il dialogo tra gli attori rilevanti (ad esempio, info day, giornate di ricerca e innovazione) e diffondere soluzioni innovative (ad esempio, open day), fino a sostenere la costituzione di gruppi operativi (OG) a livello regionale e lo scambio di esperienze con altri a livello interregionale ed europeo (ad esempio, giornate di networking).
Il portale web www.innovamarche.it è utilizzato principalmente come strumento di lavoro per fornire e condividere informazioni scientifiche, tecniche e di divulgazione.
ASSAM è partner in 12 delle 42 OG regionali della Regione Marche, dove le sue funzioni vanno dalla ricerca e applicazione di pratiche e tecniche agricole alle analisi di laboratorio fino alla comunicazione e diffusione dei risultati.
i2connect strives to empower advisors and organizations in the realm of innovation support services by fostering interactive innovation processes. To achieve this, i2connect utilizes a multi-level networking and peer-to-peer learning approach, incorporating field reviews, training repertoires, and cross visits. These activities provide valuable learning opportunities and the chance to test different approaches.
To ensure that lessons learned are not forgotten and have a greater impact, i2connect has developed an online reflection tool. It guides partners through a structured process, consisting of four key questions:
- What event or occasion triggered your reflection?
- What observations and learning insights have you gained?
- Which insights do you want to discuss with others in the project?
- What conclusions can you draw for new project events and your professional work?
The reflections collecteed are not only valuable in themselves but also serve as a foundation for continuous project learning. These reflections are regularly screened for emerging patterns and common themes that are then summarised. Through this process, the project gains a deeper understanding of the challenges, successes, and practices that emerge along project activitie. The collective insights are then fed back into project activities and discussions. Such a feedback loop ensures that the knowledge and lessons learned are actively applied to enhance the project's effectiveness and impact.
In summary, reflection and capitalisation, when organised as a visible practice that is supported by tools and processes, can facilitate the transformation of individual experiences into shared knowledge that can support continuous learning within a project.
i2connect strives to empower advisors and organizations in the realm of innovation support services by fostering interactive innovation processes. To achieve this, i2connect utilizes a multi-level networking and peer-to-peer learning approach, incorporating field reviews, training repertoires, and cross visits. These activities provide valuable learning opportunities and the chance to test different approaches.
To ensure that lessons learned are not forgotten and have a greater impact, i2connect has developed an online reflection tool. It guides partners through a structured process, consisting of four key questions:
- What event or occasion triggered your reflection?
- What observations and learning insights have you gained?
- Which insights do you want to discuss with others in the project?
- What conclusions can you draw for new project events and your professional work?
The reflections collecteed are not only valuable in themselves but also serve as a foundation for continuous project learning. These reflections are regularly screened for emerging patterns and common themes that are then summarised. Through this process, the project gains a deeper understanding of the challenges, successes, and practices that emerge along project activitie. The collective insights are then fed back into project activities and discussions. Such a feedback loop ensures that the knowledge and lessons learned are actively applied to enhance the project's effectiveness and impact.
In summary, reflection and capitalisation, when organised as a visible practice that is supported by tools and processes, can facilitate the transformation of individual experiences into shared knowledge that can support continuous learning within a project.
In recent years interest around Biodistricts has greatly increased, in Italy, also thanks to recent regulatory initiatives, that recognize them as "Local production systems characterized by the presence of strong organic supply chains" and to the mounting interest around territorial approaches to agro-environmental measures spurred by upcoming CAP. It can be defined as a locally rooted multifunctional project based on the values of organic farming. They involve farms, institutions, supply chain actors and consumers, as well as any other actor that wish to be engaged. Each of them could be the promoter of initiatives that will lead to the elaborations of activities that, staring from local food supply chains, will meet the needs of the territory. The objectives are the development of local organic agriculture, the shortening of agro-food supply chains and their integration with other sectors (i.e.: HO.RE.Ca.), food education and continuous training for operators. The wider scope is to generate income through local agriculture, so to benefit local society as a whole. Biodistricts can take a variety of corporate forms, and whenever compliant with law requirements, can access specific funding. Given their multiactor nature, they have already proved to be able to connect different subjects around shared objectives. Their nature of aggregating entity facilitates the connection of farmers to training bodies and upstream actors of the supply chain and foster communication along it. Their presence is therefore a value added in OGs (eg. TERRITORI BIO in Veneto,specifically aimed at providing qualified technical assistance to organic farmers), or in Cooperation initiatives to the benefit of local producers (e.g. Biodistretto della Val di Vara)
Negli ultimi anni l'interesse intorno ai Biodistretti è aumentato, in Italia, anche grazie alle recenti iniziative normative, che li riconoscono come "Sistemi produttivi locali caratterizzati dalla presenza di forti filiere biologiche" e al crescente interesse intorno agli approcci territoriali alle misure agro-ambientali stimolato dalla prossima PAC. Un Biodistretto può essere definito come un progetto multifunzionale radicato a livello locale e basato sui valori dell'agricoltura biologica. Coinvolgono aziende agricole, istituzioni, attori della catena di approvvigionamento e consumatori, così come qualsiasi altro attore che desideri essere coinvolto. Ognuno di essi potrà essere promotore di iniziative che porteranno all'elaborazione di attività che, partendo dalle filiere alimentari locali, soddisfino le esigenze del territorio. Gli obiettivi sono lo sviluppo dell'agricoltura biologica locale, l'accorciamento delle filiere agroalimentari e la loro integrazione con altri settori (es.: HO.RE.Ca.), l'educazione alimentare e la formazione continua degli operatori. Lo scopo più ampio è quello di generare reddito attraverso l'agricoltura locale, in modo da beneficiare la società locale nel suo complesso. I biodistretti possono assumere diverse forme societarie e, se conformi ai requisiti di legge, possono accedere a finanziamenti specifici. La loro natura di soggetto aggregatore facilita il collegamento degli agricoltori con gli enti di formazione e gli attori a monte della filiera e favorisce la comunicazione lungo questa. La loro presenza è quindi un valore aggiunto nei GO (es. TERRITORI BIO), o nelle iniziative di Cooperazione a beneficio dei produttori locali (es. Biodistretto della Val di Vara).
Cross visits (CVs) are one of the key activities in i2connect project, aiming at bringing together advisors from different parts of Europe to learn about different realities in terms of interactive innovation through studying interesting cases of innovation. This will facilitate sharing of experiences (peer to peer learning) from different contexts between fellow trainees with the main goal to understand the background of the innovation process, role of advisors in it and to transfer this knowledge to their work environment and beyond. After all, CVs are meant to serve as an inspiration that provides insights, tools and “language”, that become valuable when advisors are back on the job and encounter difficulties. During CVs advisors get opportunity to use the knowledge about the tools for network analysis, gathered through previous i2connect training course on interactive innovation, in an ongoing innovation processes in multi-actor groups. Each CV lasts 3 days in which a team of advisors from different parts of Europe and with different backgrounds, preferably gender balanced, visit an interesting interactive innovation case with the aim to learn from it and at the same time to assess each other contexts, practices and motivations. Visiting team consists of advisors, trained by i2connect trainers in the training courses. A total of eight CVs are planned in the period of 2 years (2022 - 2024) with approximately 15-20 participants per CV. Each CV is organized in 8 steps: STEP1: Kick off; STEP 2: Field visit - demonstration of innovation in the field; STEP 3: Workshop - applying tools in practice; STEP 4: Reflection on the case; STEP 5: Social activity; STEP 6: Feedback session; STEP 7: Sharing of experiences between participants; STEP 8: Wrap up.
Cross visits (CVs) are one of the key activities in i2connect project, aiming at bringing together advisors from different parts of Europe to learn about different realities in terms of interactive innovation through studying interesting cases of innovation. This will facilitate sharing of experiences (peer to peer learning) from different contexts between fellow trainees with the main goal to understand the background of the innovation process, role of advisors in it and to transfer this knowledge to their work environment and beyond. After all, CVs are meant to serve as an inspiration that provides insights, tools and “language”, that become valuable when advisors are back on the job and encounter difficulties. During CVs advisors get opportunity to use the knowledge about the tools for network analysis, gathered through previous i2connect training course on interactive innovation, in an ongoing innovation processes in multi-actor groups. Each CV lasts 3 days in which a team of advisors from different parts of Europe and with different backgrounds, preferably gender balanced, visit an interesting interactive innovation case with the aim to learn from it and at the same time to assess each other contexts, practices and motivations. Visiting team consists of advisors, trained by i2connect trainers in the training courses. A total of eight CVs are planned in the period of 2 years (2022 - 2024) with approximately 15-20 participants per CV. Each CV is organized in 8 steps: STEP1: Kick off; STEP 2: Field visit - demonstration of innovation in the field; STEP 3: Workshop - applying tools in practice; STEP 4: Reflection on the case; STEP 5: Social activity; STEP 6: Feedback session; STEP 7: Sharing of experiences between participants; STEP 8: Wrap up.
Star’Terre project is an example of facilitating and guiding innovative project. Using a call for application, innovative project are project leader are invited to explain the concept of their project. These applications are evaluated and selected by a jury study, according to the possible integration of the applicant project in the Star’Terre process and their development (only early stage initiatives can be selected).
Through their activity, the Star’Terre team supported and coached 16 projects and 88 projects have applicate.
As part of the support, the selected projects receive individual coaching. But also the not selected projects can benefit of collective advices through cluster workshops or meetings of 30 minutes of free advice.
The coaching support of the selected projects by Star’Terre team is for a maximum of 3 years and in a limited budget. The first step consists in the assessment of support needs and in fixing together the objectives of the support and the different miles stones to go forward and likely to contribute to the development and success of the project. The projects benefit from the approach according to their needs in all senses (legal, financial, technical, methods, tools, meditation…). At the end of the coaching, project holders have an end-meeting to identify learnings, appreciate the coaching process (what worked well and what could be improved) and what are the perspectives.
The idea is, that project holders will be enabled to develop their project as long as it makes sense for the 2 parties to collaborate. Once the project owners feel ready (sufficiently skilled) to continue on their own or if they fulfil the conditions to be taken over by other supports organisations, the support by Star’Terre will be finished.
Le projet Star'Terre se distingue, car il n'est pas seulement un projet agricole, il relie l'agriculture, l'alimentation, l'entrepreneuriat et l'innovation. Cette plateforme intercantonale d'innovation agroalimentaire vise à créer un écosystème pour valoriser la production et le savoir-faire agroalimentaire du territoire en rapprochant les secteurs agricoles et non agricoles. Cela se fait en favorisant la collaboration entre les organismes publics et privés au sein des différents écosystèmes ; en effet, il ne s'agit pas seulement de conseillers agricoles ou d'agriculteurs, mais d'acteurs de l'ensemble du système agroalimentaire du territoire. L'idée ici est de soutenir les porteurs d'initiatives et de projets de consommation locale qui ont besoin de ressources ciblées pour émerger et rester viables et de créer des synergies entre les soutiens entrepreneuriaux et agricoles pour plus de valeur ajoutée aux producteurs, ainsi que de mettre à disposition du secteur agricole des soutiens et des outils peu connus. La plateforme a été développée lors d'un projet pilote (PHR - consommation locale dans la région lémanique) mis en œuvre avec le soutien du Secrétariat d'Etat à l'économie (SECO) dans le cadre du programme PHR-Economie, un instrument de la Nouvelle politique régionale (NPR) suisse. L'objectif était de créer des incitations au développement économique régional, de tester et de renforcer les échanges économiques et les flux alimentaires entre les zones urbaines et rurales de la Suisse. L'idée, après l'expérimentation de cet instrument, était de pérenniser la démarche.
The "Talking Postcards" approach has been used in some Operational Groups from Emilia Romagna region (Italy). The idea is to create a postcard with a QRcode that allow people to learn about the main objectives and results of the projects in a easy way, just by listening a short audio. Each postcard lasts about one minute. This communication tool enables to reach a large number of actors and aim at informing using simple words the partners and the stakeholders of the OGs. Moreover, mixing non-scientific language and ICT, it might help engaging farmers, civil society and young people in innovation projects.
L'approccio delle "cartoline parlanti" è stato utilizzato in alcuni Gruppi Operativi della regione Emilia Romagna (Italia). L'idea è quella di creare una cartolina con un QRcode che permetta alle persone di conoscere i principali obiettivi e risultati dei progetti in modo semplice, semplicemente ascoltando un breve audio. Ogni cartolina dura circa un minuto. Questo strumento di comunicazione permette di raggiungere un gran numero di attori e di informare con parole semplici i partner e gli stakeholder del GO. Inoltre, combinando un linguaggio non scientifico con le TIC, può aiutare a coinvolgere gli agricoltori, la società civile e i giovani nei progetti di innovazione.
A cross-analysis of 29 country reports on Agricultural Knowledge and Innovation Systems (AKIS) in Europe was conducted between 2021 and 2022 in the frame of the i2connect project. The objective of the study was to provide an overview of the AKIS landscape in Europe by examining key elements such as AKIS actors, policy and funding, coordination mechanisms, and linkages between member states. The analysis involved qualitative descriptions and comparisons of these elements.
A quantitative analysis was performed to characterize agricultural and forestry advisory service providers in the countries. Data from 27 member states was collected through the online survey platform "EUSurvey." The survey questions were based on previous work from the PRO AKIS project, covering aspects such as advisory service provider types, main clients, advisory topics and methods, human resources, funding, and linkages with other AKIS actors. The survey targeted two main categories of advisory service providers: independent advisors and advisory organizations dedicated to providing advice, either fully or partially.
To ensure accessibility, the survey questions were translated into the national languages of European countries using machine translation. National AKIS experts, proofread the translations and distributed the survey based on availability and access to advisory service providers. The use of a common online survey platform offering national language translation facilitated centralized data collection. Then, the collected quantitative data was analyzed using descriptive statistics. The results were shared with project partners and made publicly available through a report, as well as disseminated through workshops and conferences.
A cross-analysis of 29 country reports on Agricultural Knowledge and Innovation Systems (AKIS) in Europe was conducted between 2021 and 2022 in the frame of the i2connect project. The objective of the study was to provide an overview of the AKIS landscape in Europe by examining key elements such as AKIS actors, policy and funding, coordination mechanisms, and linkages between member states. The analysis involved qualitative descriptions and comparisons of these elements.
A quantitative analysis was performed to characterize agricultural and forestry advisory service providers in the countries. Data from 27 member states was collected through the online survey platform "EUSurvey." The survey questions were based on previous work from the PRO AKIS project, covering aspects such as advisory service provider types, main clients, advisory topics and methods, human resources, funding, and linkages with other AKIS actors. The survey targeted two main categories of advisory service providers: independent advisors and advisory organizations dedicated to providing advice, either fully or partially.
To ensure accessibility, the survey questions were translated into the national languages of European countries using machine translation. National AKIS experts, proofread the translations and distributed the survey based on availability and access to advisory service providers. The use of a common online survey platform offering national language translation facilitated centralized data collection. Then, the collected quantitative data was analyzed using descriptive statistics. The results were shared with project partners and made publicly available through a report, as well as disseminated through workshops and conferences.
Within the Agroinnowacja EIP project, sowing a catch crop for forage has enabled the six partner farmers to produce high-quality forage and keep more cattle on their land, improving higher gross margins and cattle performance, while providing environmental benefits. Strip-till technology is used to sow maize on the day the catch crop is harvested thus maximising land use. Co-operation among different actors (advisors, farmers, researchers from university, agricultural input suppliers and one entrepreneur) was critical to the success of the project. The idea for this project came from the farmers in producer groups and finalised with advisors basing on the experience of Germany farmers. Since the advisor was acknowledged about a mixture for a catch crop to be used as a source of animal feed developed by the University, he decided to create the EIP project. The leading advisor is the president of a private agricultural advisory that organises and provides services to producer groups in Poland. AgroIntegracja advisors have been working with the farmers in the producer groups for many years and have built up a significant level of trust, which enable them to quickly identify problematic issues. At the same time, co-operating with outstanding experts enables them to effectively advise producer groups. The advisor would have liked to involve the University at an earlier stage to ensure that the correct research methodology was outlined when planning the project. However, at the beginning, he encountered difficulties in co-operating with the University due to formal procedures that had to be followed. It was much easier to engage with the University on subsequent projects because the co-operation had been formalised.
Nell'ambito del progetto Agroinnowacja, la semina di una coltura di cattura per il foraggio ha permesso ai sei agricoltori partner di produrre foraggio di alta qualità e di tenere più bestiame sulla loro terra, migliorando i margini lordi e le prestazioni del bestiame, fornendo al contempo benefici ambientali. Viene utilizzata la tecnologia strip-till per seminare il mais il giorno in cui viene raccolto il raccolto, massimizzando così l'uso della terra. La cooperazione tra diversi attori (consulenti, agricoltori, ricercatori, fornitori di input e un imprenditore) è stata fondamentale per il successo del progetto. L'idea del progetto è venuta dagli agricoltori nei gruppi di produttori ed è stata finalizzata con i consulenti sulla base dell'esperienza degli agricoltori tedeschi. Poiché il consulente era a conoscenza di una miscela per una coltura di cattura da utilizzare come fonte di alimentazione animale sviluppata dall'Università, ha deciso di creare il progetto. Il consulente principale è presidente di una società privata di consulenza agricola che organizza e fornisce servizi ai gruppi di produttori in Polonia. I consulenti di AgroIntegracja lavorano con gli agricoltori dei gruppi di produttori da molti anni e hanno costruito un livello significativo di fiducia, che permette loro di identificare rapidamente le problematiche. Al contempo, la collaborazione con esperti di spicco permette loro di consigliare efficacemente i gruppi di produttori. Il consulente avrebbe voluto coinvolgere l'Università in una fase precedente per essere sicuro di definire la corretta metodologia di lavoro al momento della pianificazione del progetto. Tuttavia, ci sono state difficoltà nel cooperare con l'Università a causa delle procedure formali.
Living Labs (LLs) are a promising tool for the agricultural sector. They were used in the context of ROADMAP to reduce the risk of antimicrobial resistance through reduced antimicrobial use. This is a complex issue, and it requires many stakeholders to be involved. LLs are user-centered, open innovation ecosystems based on a systematic user co-creation approach integrating research and innovation processes in real-life communities and settings. LLs are of participatory nature as every participant’s expertise is actively brought into the process. End users are directly involved in developing innovations. They can be farmers, advisors, citizens, or authorities. They represent a wider community of end users making it easier to overcome barriers due to technical, social, or economic asymmetry of information or interactions between stakeholders.
The use of antimicrobials in animal husbandry across Europe differs, but there is still room for reduction. EU and national regulations have been improving for years and livestock sectors have already been tackled with one-size-fits-all solutions. Further reduction can especially be achieved with locally and often societal-adapted solutions. By implementing 12 living labs in different countries and value chains, we aimed at developing and evaluating locally adapted solutions for the prudent use of antimicrobials.
In ROADMAP, LLs are used to develop, discuss and test comprehensive approaches at different levels (individual farms, production systems, supply chains, sectors, advisory services) in a participatory way involving different kinds of actors, knowledge, and skills.
They contribute to conceiving and assessing the proposed product, tool, or indicator in their daily routine.
Living Labs (LLs) are a promising tool for the agricultural sector. They were used in the context of ROADMAP to reduce the risk of antimicrobial resistance through reduced antimicrobial use. This is a complex issue, and it requires many stakeholders to be involved. LLs are user-centered, open innovation ecosystems based on a systematic user co-creation approach integrating research and innovation processes in real-life communities and settings. LLs are of participatory nature as every participant’s expertise is actively brought into the process. End users are directly involved in developing innovations. They can be farmers, advisors, citizens, or authorities. They represent a wider community of end users making it easier to overcome barriers due to technical, social, or economic asymmetry of information or interactions between stakeholders.
The use of antimicrobials in animal husbandry across Europe differs, but there is still room for reduction. EU and national regulations have been improving for years and livestock sectors have already been tackled with one-size-fits-all solutions. Further reduction can especially be achieved with locally and often societal-adapted solutions. By implementing 12 living labs in different countries and value chains, we aimed at developing and evaluating locally adapted solutions for the prudent use of antimicrobials.
In ROADMAP, LLs are used to develop, discuss and test comprehensive approaches at different levels (individual farms, production systems, supply chains, sectors, advisory services) in a participatory way involving different kinds of actors, knowledge, and skills.
They contribute to conceiving and assessing the proposed product, tool, or indicator in their daily routine.
The project aims to set up an innovative mechanism for consultation between partners who contribute to the development of innovative and agro-ecological practices implemented by farmers in southern Aveyron. It aims to promote the emergence, design and development of local agro-ecological innovations based on "the feed autonomy" of farms. The project seizes the opportunity to bring together several agricultural and regional actors for cooperation and thus to intensify the common exchange. DIAL is a multi-skilled approach to serve the agro-ecological transition with partners, farmers and other invited experts. The challenge is to develop innovative and agro-ecological techniques in cooperation with various actors in research, extension and agricultural practice, to evaluate and discuss them, optimize them and disseminate those using appropriate methods. The objective is to jointly develop and implement innovative and agro-ecological solutions. In this way, farm emissions and certain aspects of biodiversity should be increasingly balanced. Results are the knowledge sharing and technical activities:
• A regular sharing of each partner's productions and observations (Results of trials, observation of farming systems, learnings from trainings)
• The organisation of joint events
• Several field trials, demonstrations and technical seminars
The role of extension: The project manager/advisor had an important role as a contact person, communicator, networker, organiser, facilitator, mediator of ideas, etc; The senior advisor and researcher were coaches of the overall project, facilitating the exchange of actors enables the project community to move forward and achieve a higher level of common understanding and action.
Ce projet vise à mettre en place un dispositif innovant de concertation entre partenaires qui contribuent à développer les pratiques innovantes et agro écologiques mises en œuvre par des agriculteurs du Sud Aveyron. Il vise à favoriser l'émergence, la conception et le développement d'Innovations agro écologiques locales en s'appuyant sur une première thématique : "l'autonomie alimentaire".
Le projet réunit plusieurs acteurs agricoles et régionaux. Le défi consiste à développer des techniques innovantes et agro écologiques en coopération avec plusieurs acteurs, à les évaluer, discuter, optimiser et diffuser à l'aide de méthodes appropriées.
L'objectif est de mettre en œuvre conjointement des solutions innovantes et agro-écologiques. L'approche consiste à aborder et à mettre en œuvre les problèmes dans le cadre d'un projet équilibré, en particulier avec la participation des agriculteurs. Les résultats sont le partage des connaissances et les activités techniques :
- Un partage régulier des productions et observations de chaque partenaire (Résultats des essais, observations des systèmes agricoles, apprentissages des formations).
- L'organisation d'événements communs
- Plusieurs essais sur le terrain, démonstrations et séminaires techniques
Le rôle de la vulgarisation : Le chef de projet/conseiller a eu un rôle important en tant que personne de contact, communicateur, réseauteur, organisateur, facilitateur, médiateur d'idées; Le conseiller et le chercheur principal ont été des coachs de l'ensemble du projet ; La facilitation des échanges entre agriculteurs, conseillers et chercheurs a permis à la communauté du projet d'avancer et d'atteindre un niveau supérieur de compréhension et d'action communes.
"Digital farmer" is a Telegram channel created and administered by a farmer (winemaker) and exclusively addressed to farmers to inform them, in real time, about available innovations, including the results of operational groups, or about webinars and online workshops through which they can keep up to date. Since December 2019, Giuliano Preghenella has been sharing news that he considers interesting for the toolbox of an agricultural entrepreneur and that, according to him, are underestimated by the media in the sector.
The tool immediately raised interest, and grew on its own thanks to the tam tam of subscribers and the sharing on other social networks (Twitter, LinkedIn and Facebook). According to the creator, the ideal "Digital farmer" reader prefers to receive only one news item per day, preferably always published at the same time (around 8 am, peak time for visits during the day), from Monday to Saturday. The news is re-posted via social networks and a website, thus multiplying the circulation of knowledge. The channel has around 650 subscribers, including university and agricultural schools students, who find the news published interesting for their studies. Through public and private interactions, subscribers ask to exchange views or learn more about specific issues.
In the past two years, the channel has provided the opportunity to transfer expertise from researchers and advisors to farmers, thus facilitating the transfer of successful experiences and the creation of a network that, thanks to the facilitated and continuous learning stimulated by "Digital farmer", promotes professional development, bottom-up innovation and the bringing between research and practice.
"Digital farmer" is a Telegram channel created and administered by a farmer (winemaker) and exclusively addressed to farmers to inform them, in real time, about available innovations, including the results of operational groups, or about webinars and online workshops through which they can keep up to date. Since December 2019, Giuliano Preghenella has been sharing news that he considers interesting for the toolbox of an agricultural entrepreneur and that, according to him, are underestimated by the media in the sector.
The tool immediately raised interest, and grew on its own thanks to the tam tam of subscribers and the sharing on other social networks (Twitter, LinkedIn and Facebook). According to the creator, the ideal "Digital farmer" reader prefers to receive only one news item per day, preferably always published at the same time (around 8 am, peak time for visits during the day), from Monday to Saturday. The news is re-posted via social networks and a website, thus multiplying the circulation of knowledge. The channel has around 650 subscribers, including university and agricultural schools students, who find the news published interesting for their studies. Through public and private interactions, subscribers ask to exchange views or learn more about specific issues.
In the past two years, the channel has provided the opportunity to transfer expertise from researchers and advisors to farmers, thus facilitating the transfer of successful experiences and the creation of a network that, thanks to the facilitated and continuous learning stimulated by "Digital farmer", promotes professional development, bottom-up innovation and the bringing between research and practice.
In Finland, farmers participate in ‘basic groups’ discussion in which they share knowledge and practices, focusing on a specific production topic. The members of the basic groups can also participate in other short-term discussion groups focused on other topics of interest such as human resources, or financial management, in which results and farm data are compared and analysed. They can also participate in study trips abroad and be a member of an international group. The average number of farmers in a group is 8-10, although some are smaller and some larger. One group member is selected as the ‘monitor farmer’ for the year to help maintaining cohesion among the group members. Most of the group meetings are held on the monitor farm. Each year the group sets targets and decides which issues to observe and focus on for the year ahead.
A key feature of the discussion group model in Finland is that it uses two facilitators or one facilitator and one working pair, that is an advisor with the technical/subject matter knowledge for the topic of the group. The benefit of having two facilitators/advisors is that they learn from one another and each brings a different perspective to the group. One facilitator takes on the role of organising the discussion group meeting and setting up the WhatsApp group while the other facilitates the discussion. After every discussion group meeting the facilitators reflect on the meeting to identify what worked well and what could be improved for next time. Either the facilitator or the working pair changes regularly.
The EU funding covers the costs of planning discussion groups, developing the discussion group model, the advisors costs and 2/3 of farmers' costs for participation.
In Finlandia, gli agricoltori partecipano a "gruppi base" di discussione in cui condividono conoscenze e pratiche, concentrandosi su uno specifico argomento. I membri dei gruppi possono anche partecipare ad altri gruppi di discussione a breve termine incentrati su altri argomenti di interesse come le risorse umane o la gestione finanziaria, in cui vengono confrontati e analizzati i risultati e i dati dell'azienda. Possono anche partecipare a viaggi di studio all'estero ed essere membri di un gruppo internazionale. Il numero medio di agricoltori in un gruppo è di 8-10. Un membro del gruppo viene scelto come "agricoltore monitor" per l'anno per aiutare a mantenere la coesione tra i membri del gruppo. La maggior parte delle riunioni del gruppo si tengono nell'azienda agricola dell'agricoltore monitor. Ogni anno il gruppo stabilisce degli obiettivi e decide su quali questioni osservare e concentrarsi per l'anno successivo. Una caratteristica chiave del modello di gruppo di discussione in Finlandia è che utilizza due facilitatori o un facilitatore e una coppia di lavoro (consulente). Il vantaggio di avere due facilitatori è che imparano l'uno dall'altro e ognuno porta una prospettiva diversa al gruppo, oltre ad avere diversi stili di facilitazione. Un facilitatore assume il ruolo di organizzare la riunione e di impostare il gruppo WhatsApp, mentre l'altro conduce la discussione. Un aspetto critico della metodologia è la riflessione e dopo ogni incontro del gruppo i facilitatori riflettono sull'incontro per identificare cosa ha funzionato e cosa potrebbe essere migliorato. I costi di pianificazione dei gruppi, lo sviluppo del loro modello, i costi dei consulenti e 2/3 dei costi di partecipazione degli agricoltori sono coperti con fondi UE.
Functional communication channels between research and advise are crucial in ensuring that the required knowledge will reach the farmers in the right way. In this sense, a close collaboration between research and advice is the key to provide farmers with up-to-date knowledge. Both of them are necessary to transfer knowledge to farmers. On one hand, researchers create innovative solutions, on the other hand, advisors can transfer them and interpret the farmers response, as they understand best the "language of farmers".
Considering that, some good elements to have an efficient flow of information between researchers and advisors are: i) feeding a constant and continuous flow of knowledge; ii) building long-term relationships, outside of funded projects and fully integrated advisory and research projects; iii) using support mechanisms/actions (e.g. enabling continuous exchange between research and advisory, internal newsletters, podcasts, videos, workshops and team meetings, vouchers, etc.); iv) having clear visions and clear divisions of tasks between advisors and researchers and v) trusting in each other's work.
Functional communication channels between research and advise are crucial in ensuring that the required knowledge will reach the farmers in the right way. In this sense, a close collaboration between research and advice is the key to provide farmers with up-to-date knowledge. Both of them are necessary to transfer knowledge to farmers. On one hand, researchers create innovative solutions, on the other hand, advisors can transfer them and interpret the farmers response, as they understand best the "language of farmers".
Considering that, some good elements to have an efficient flow of information between researchers and advisors are: i) feeding a constant and continuous flow of knowledge; ii) building long-term relationships, outside of funded projects and fully integrated advisory and research projects; iii) using support mechanisms/actions (e.g. enabling continuous exchange between research and advisory, internal newsletters, podcasts, videos, workshops and team meetings, vouchers, etc.); iv) having clear visions and clear divisions of tasks between advisors and researchers and v) trusting in each other's work.
Having a strong network as an advisor is an important aspect of knowledge transfer and exchange. In fact, networking of advisors is important both for advisors and for farmers. For the former the networking and cooperation in the partnership deliver better results than working on their own and enable opportunities for new ideas/solutions to arise. For the latter (as end-users of advice), it means that the service provided in this way is based on a broader professional and methodological basis and that the advisor can interact with others bringing in new knowledge and experience. It is important to create this environment to enable advisors to
i)create and build a broad network; ii) use new and better communication channels to expand existing networks; iii) improve advisors' time management (especially advisors' ability to network in addition to their daily work); iv) create opportunities to network outside their own work area, avoiding isolation; v) raising awareness of the importance of networking; vi) provide soft skills training and involve advisors in meetings, webinars, info days, demo events, using social media and group messaging.
Also advisory organizations can play a crucial role in supporting networking and providing the necessary supportive environment.
Having a strong network as an advisor is an important aspect of knowledge transfer and exchange. In fact, networking of advisors is important both for advisors and for farmers. For the former the networking and cooperation in the partnership deliver better results than working on their own and enable opportunities for new ideas/solutions to arise. For the latter (as end-users of advice), it means that the service provided in this way is based on a broader professional and methodological basis and that the advisor can interact with others bringing in new knowledge and experience. It is important to create this environment to enable advisors to
i)create and build a broad network; ii) use new and better communication channels to expand existing networks; iii) improve advisors' time management (especially advisors' ability to network in addition to their daily work); iv) create opportunities to network outside their own work area, avoiding isolation; v) raising awareness of the importance of networking; vi) provide soft skills training and involve advisors in meetings, webinars, info days, demo events, using social media and group messaging.
Also advisory organizations can play a crucial role in supporting networking and providing the necessary supportive environment.
The "Project Manager Meeting" is an annual event run by the Swedish Rural Network and at the beginning of the year. The meeting is organized to bring together experienced managers of previously EIP-Agri-supported projects and managers of newly approved projects. Researchers, innovation financiers, and other actors involved in the innovation system in Sweden attend the meeting to network and initiate collaborations.
Information is provided about the general purpose of EIP-Agri, the funding opportunities, and the various supporting channels for applicants throughout the application process. Previously funded innovation project managers are invited to inspire and motivate managers of recently accepted project. They present their innovation project, the journey from an idea to a product or service in the market, raise the advantages and disadvantages within the process, the challenges and difficulties, explain how certain things were managed and implemented, and answer questions and concerns. Every year around 80-90 participants attend the Project Manager Meeting.
The Annual Project Manager meeting serves as an effective dissemination activity, and it is a good practice for enabling an environment for interactive innovation. Furthermore, the annual meeting is a mean to support managers of recently accepted projects in their expectations about the EIP-Agri and functions as a preparation for the application process. It is an opportunity for sharing knowledge and experiences, and a possibility for networking. It strengthens the self-confidence of managers of recently accepted project managers and supports them in not falling into typical pitfalls during the application process.
The "Project Manager Meeting" is an annual event run by the Swedish Rural Network and at the beginning of the year. The meeting is organized to bring together experienced managers of previously EIP-Agri-supported projects and managers of newly approved projects. Researchers, innovation financiers, and other actors involved in the innovation system in Sweden attend the meeting to network and initiate collaborations.
Information is provided about the general purpose of EIP-Agri, the funding opportunities, and the various supporting channels for applicants throughout the application process. Previously funded innovation project managers are invited to inspire and motivate managers of recently accepted project. They present their innovation project, the journey from an idea to a product or service in the market, raise the advantages and disadvantages within the process, the challenges and difficulties, explain how certain things were managed and implemented, and answer questions and concerns. Every year around 80-90 participants attend the Project Manager Meeting.
The Annual Project Manager meeting serves as an effective dissemination activity, and it is a good practice for enabling an environment for interactive innovation. Furthermore, the annual meeting is a mean to support managers of recently accepted projects in their expectations about the EIP-Agri and functions as a preparation for the application process. It is an opportunity for sharing knowledge and experiences, and a possibility for networking. It strengthens the self-confidence of managers of recently accepted project managers and supports them in not falling into typical pitfalls during the application process.
The Operational Group Oleocolza was born from a need detected by rural advisors working together with farmers. The Portuguese biodiesel industry, was interested in obtaining rape seeds for their factory, and were buying seeds from all over Europe. However, they knew that this crop would have great potential in Portugal, namely in the vast fields of the Alentejo. It turned out that Portuguese farmers were unaware of this crop and its specificities. So a multi-actor group was set up, composed of the industry, which shared its needs, necessary specifications and know-how, a group of rural advisors, farmers from the Alentejo and researchers.
And this is one of the key points of this project: how it was possible to engage all the value chain actors in interactive Innovation. The openness, transparency, sharing and commitment of all actors of the chain, from production, advisors, researchers and the industry, for a common good was decisive: to evaluate the impact of different varieties on the production capacity of COLZA in the Alentejo and test it as a rotation crop.
Regarding the interactive innovation methods, the role of the advisors was determinant, promoting discussion forums, with special focus on knowledge exchange, which had a much greater impact than the knowledge transfer, that is, the sharing of experiences and cultural methods was valued more than the knowledge coming from the academy. On the other hand, the role of advisors was fundamental as facilitators and Innovation brokers.
O Grupo Operacional Oleocolza nasceu de uma necessidade detetada pelos advisors junto dos agricultores. A indústria Portuguesa do biodiesel, estava interessada em obter sementes de colza para a sua fábrica, e estava a comprar sementes de toda a Europa. No entanto, sabiam que esta cultura teria grande potencial em Portugal, nomeadamente nos vastos campos do Alentejo. Verificou-se que os agricultores portugueses desconheciam esta cultura e as suas especificidades. Assim, foi criado um grupo multiactor, composto pela indústria, que partilhava as suas necessidades, especificações necessárias e know-how, um grupo de advisors, agricultores do Alentejo e investigadores.
E este é um dos pontos-chave deste projeto: envolver todos os atores da cadeia de valor na Inovação interativa. A transparência, partilha e empenho de todos os atores da cadeia, desde a produção, consultores, investigadores e a indústria, para um bem comum: avaliar o impacto das diferentes variedades na capacidade de produção da COLZA no Alentejo e testá-la como cultura de rotação.
Quanto à inovação interativa, o papel dos advisors foi determinante, promovendo fóruns de discussão, com troca de conhecimentos, que teve um impacto muito maior do que a transferência de conhecimentos, ou seja, a partilha de experiências e métodos culturais foi mais valorizada do que os conhecimentos provenientes da academia. Por outro lado o papel dos advisors foi fundamental como facilitadores e impulsionadores de inovação.
Field peer reviews carried out within the i2connect project show how important the involvement of farmers and foresters in all project decisions and activities is, as they can make a difference and enable agricultural innovation to go further. When partners listen to each other, without imposing their own vision/solution, sharing their views on the problem to be addressed and the goals to be achieved, the ideas of individuals are reformulated, resulting in a new shared understanding and framework for action, which leads to a common sense of ownership of the problem, and it contributes to strengthening the commitment of actors and increasing the possibility of producing positive action and results. In some reviewed cases, farmers took risks on a personal and economic level since the proposed solution from research was not reasonable form them and they tried to find a different solution. As an example, in Agrosyl operational group, researchers wanted to impose their solution, but the farmer was not equipped to apply it. There were misunderstanding among farmers and researchers and communication difficulties. Researcher did not understand the farmer's need to make the innovative solution more feasible in the field. The Chamber of Agriculture play the role of mediator inviting partners to interact and become aware of other's ideas. In Futter Nova 11 case, the farmers were steering the project, looking for an appropriate solution and were willing to try new ideas. Where advisors encourage farmers to take lead roles in the project, this has a huge knock-on effect for the group and other farmers.
Field peer reviews carried out within the i2connect project show how important the involvement of farmers and foresters in all project decisions and activities is, as they can make a difference and enable agricultural innovation to go further. When partners listen to each other, without imposing their own vision/solution, sharing their views on the problem to be addressed and the goals to be achieved, the ideas of individuals are reformulated, resulting in a new shared understanding and framework for action, which leads to a common sense of ownership of the problem, and it contributes to strengthening the commitment of actors and increasing the possibility of producing positive action and results. In some reviewed cases, farmers took risks on a personal and economic level since the proposed solution from research was not reasonable form them and they tried to find a different solution. As an example, in Agrosyl operational group, researchers wanted to impose their solution, but the farmer was not equipped to apply it. There were misunderstanding among farmers and researchers and communication difficulties. Researcher did not understand the farmer's need to make the innovative solution more feasible in the field. The Chamber of Agriculture play the role of mediator inviting partners to interact and become aware of other's ideas. In Futter Nova 11 case, the farmers were steering the project, looking for an appropriate solution and were willing to try new ideas. Where advisors encourage farmers to take lead roles in the project, this has a huge knock-on effect for the group and other farmers.
In the state of Baden-Württemberg in Germany, agricultural advisory services are offered in the form of modules by private advisory organisations and co-financed by the public sector. However, there are still many, often small, farms whose managers do not make use of professional advisory services. In order to arouse their interest and to lower the inhibition threshold towards privately organised and costly advisory services, the Ministry of Agriculture has developed the instrument of the 'farm check'. This makes it possible for all farms to receive a free assessment of their farm's current situation and decision-making support for the development of the farm in the form of approximately 15 hours of professional advice. Since 2015, up to 100 farms have participated each year, and a survey shows a high level of satisfaction among the farmers with the neutral view from independent advisors and their feedback on farm management plans and decisions. Nevertheless, the prompt implementation of recommended follow-up steps and the use of further advice remain limited to a minority of those taking part in this public support service. It can be assumed that the assessment of the impact and added value of this low-threshold instrument can only be better assessed after a few years of operation.
Im Bundesland Baden-Württemberg in Deutschland werden Beratungsdienstleistungen in Form von Modulen durch private Beratungsorganisationen angeboten und durch die öffentliche Hand ko-finanziert. Allerdings gibt es immer noch viele, häufig kleine Betriebe, deren Betriebsleiter*innen keine professionelle Beratung in Anspruch nehmen. Um deren Interesse zu wecken und die Hemmschwelle gegenüber einer privatwirtschaftlich organisierten und kostenverursachenden Beratung zu senken, hat das Landwirtschaftsminiterium das Instrument des 'Betriebs-Checks' entwickelt. Dieses ermöglicht es allen Betrieben, eine kostenlose Standortbestimmung und Entscheidungshilfe für die Betriebsentwicklung in Form einer ca 15h professionellen Beratung zu erhalten. Seit 2015 haben jedes Jahr bis zu 100 Betriebe teilgenommen, und eine Befragung zeigt eine große Zufriedenheit mit dem neutralen Blick von außen und der Einschätzung von Richtungsentscheidungen. Beratungsergebnissen. Dennoch bleiben die zeitnahe Umsetzung der empfohlenen Folgeschritte und die Inanspruchnahme weiterer Beratung auf eine Minderheit der Beratungsnehmenden beschränkt. Es ist anzunehmen, dass die Einschätzung der Wirkung und des Mehrwerts dieses niedrigschwelligen Instruments erst nach einigen Jahren Laufzeit besser ermessen werden kann.
The Field Peer Review consists of the review of a practical case innovation process, with a particular focus on innovation support functions, by colleagues (peers: farmers, advisors, researchers, etc.) from another innovation case, with the purpose of experiencing and reflecting about approaches, methods and tools, as well as enabling norms, rules and practices that facilitate active participation, interaction and cooperative learning between different actors, thus stimulating innovation and change. A Field Peer Review methodology was set up and tested within the i2connect project.
Field Peer Review is carried out through field visit, observation and interviews carried out by peers with different actors’ groups of an interactive innovation case. A clear procedure and an analytical framework have been developed to allow the reviewers to focus on well-defined aspects (support services, effectiveness of innovation support, internal and external conditions that enable specific actors to play support functions) that are hardly addressed, going far beyond a mere exchange of practices.
The Field Peer Review could be implemented by managing authorities, advisory systems and organisms, networks (e.g the CAP networks) to: i) analyse the role of different actors in innovation processes, especially innovation support service providers, ii) implement an effective (peer-to-peer) M&E system for interactive innovation processes, iii) implement a system of continuous peer-to-peer learning that will empower relevant actors to discover innovative ideas and enable their uptake in a co-creative way.
La Field Peer Review consiste nella revisione di un processo di innovazione di un caso pratico, con particolare attenzione alle funzioni di supporto all'innovazione, da parte di colleghi (pari: agricoltori, consulenti, ricercatori, ecc.) di un altro caso di innovazione, con lo scopo di riflettere su approcci, metodi e strumenti, nonché norme, regole e pratiche abilitanti che facilitano la partecipazione attiva, l'interazione e l'apprendimento cooperativo tra diversi attori, stimolando così l'innovazione e il cambiamento. Nell'ambito del progetto i2connect è stata istituita e testata una metodologia di Field Peer Review.
La Field Peer Review viene effettuata attraverso la visita sul campo, l'osservazione e le interviste effettuate dai pari con diversi gruppi di attori di un caso di innovazione interattiva. Una procedura chiara e un quadro analitico sono stati sviluppati per permettere ai revisori di concentrarsi su aspetti ben definiti (servizi di supporto, efficacia del supporto all'innovazione, condizioni interne ed esterne che permettono a specifici attori di svolgere funzioni di supporto) che sono difficilmente considerati, andando oltre quello che può essere un semplice scambio di pratiche. La Field Peer Review potrebbe essere implementata da AdG,organismi di consulenza, reti (ad es. le reti della PAC) per: i) analizzare il ruolo dei diversi attori nei processi di innovazione, in particolare i fornitori di servizi di supporto all'innovazione, ii) implementare un efficace sistema di M&E (peer-to-peer) per processi di innovazione interattivi, iii) implementare un sistema di apprendimento continuo tra pari che permetta agli attori rilevanti di scoprire idee innovative e consentirne l'adozione in modo co-creativo.
The "FILòS IN BUS" initiative is an interactive communication approach carried out during the PRATI_CO "Parmigiano Reggiano: Agrotecnica organic carbon footprint" Operational Group (OG) project. The name 'filòs' evokes relaxing moments spent in conversation between neighbours, relatives and friends. The FILòs IN BUS journey re-proposed this concept aimed at a collective experience in which about thirty participants, including advisors, researchers, farmers, and journalists travel together by a bus during a one-day-visits to the farms which are partner of the OG. The travel at the farms represents also the occasion to share knowledge on territories, local products and other local actors which are implied in the supply chain of Parmiggiano Reggiano. During the travel on bus, the partners of the OG discuss on project activities and results, by focusing on common matters of interests (soil fertility, carbon footprint, carbon sequestration, …) around which they share practice and scientific knowledge. This process supported team building within the OG, through a major coordination and interaction among the partners, the development of collective knowldge and common understanding on-going achieviements of the project and of its results. Moreover, the cross visits on farms supported peer-to-peer processes among the farmers. This type of tool might help overcoming barriers/hesitations /regrets in dialogue and it allows to the open discussion among a multitude of actors.
L'iniziativa "FILÒS IN BUS" è un approccio di comunicazione interattiva realizzata nell'ambito del progetto del Gruppo Operativo (GO) PRATI_CO "Parmigiano Reggiano: L'impronta di carbonio biologica dell'Agrotecnica". Il nome "filòs" evoca momenti di relax trascorsi in conversazione tra vicini, parenti e amici. Il viaggio FILòs IN BUS ha riproposto questo concetto finalizzato a un'esperienza collettiva in cui una trentina di partecipanti, tra cui consulenti, ricercatori, agricoltori e giornalisti, viaggiano insieme in autobus durante una visita di un giorno alle aziende agricole partner del GO. Il viaggio presso le aziende agricole e le visite aziendali rappresentano anche l'occasione per condividere conoscenze sui territori, sui prodotti locali e sugli altri attori locali coinvolti nella filiera del Parmiggiano Reggiano. Durante il viaggio in autobus, i partner del GO hanno modo di discutere le attività e i risultati del progetto, concentrandosi su questioni di interesse comune (fertilità del suolo, impronta di carbonio, sequestro di carbonio, ...) attorno alle quali condividono pratiche e conoscenze scientifiche. Questo processo ha favorito la creazione di un team all'interno del GO, attraverso un maggiore coordinamento e interazione tra i partner, lo sviluppo di conoscenze collettive e la comprensione comune dei risultati in corso del progetto e dei suoi risultati. Inoltre, le visite incrociate nelle aziende agricole hanno sostenuto i processi peer-to-peer tra gli agricoltori. Questo tipo di strumento può aiutare a superare le barriere/esitazioni/ritardi nel dialogo e consente una discussione aperta tra una moltitudine di attori.
The project FInAL "Promotion of Insects in Agricultural Landscapes" is a large nationwide project with different project promoters at different locations. The project was developed in Rottal (Lower Bavaria), in Lower Saxony, in the Elm and in Brandenburg in the Havelländisches Luch. In terms of measures, farmers in the landscape laboratory have so far implemented 15 different measures on 181 hectares of these 900 hectares in the landscape laboratory. In addition to measures such as flowering areas or hedges, production-integrated measures are of course also very popular with farmers. That means insect-promoting catch crops in different varieties. But also, for example, cultivating maize-bean mixtures, growing legumes, and expanding crop rotation. This is a big issue because our area is very much dominated by maize. Maize causes problems in terms of erosion, and farmers are challenged from several sides to think about erosion, about biodiversity, about insect promotion. In projects like FInAL, it is clear the potential for building the capacity of farmers and improving their knowledge. So, they can become the leaders of innovation in their region.
The project FInAL "Promotion of Insects in Agricultural Landscapes" is a large nationwide project with different project promoters at different locations. The project was developed in Rottal (Lower Bavaria), in Lower Saxony, in the Elm and in Brandenburg in the Havelländisches Luch. In terms of measures, farmers in the landscape laboratory have so far implemented 15 different measures on 181 hectares of these 900 hectares in the landscape laboratory. In addition to measures such as flowering areas or hedges, production-integrated measures are of course also very popular with farmers. That means insect-promoting catch crops in different varieties. But also, for example, cultivating maize-bean mixtures, growing legumes, and expanding crop rotation. This is a big issue because our area is very much dominated by maize. Maize causes problems in terms of erosion, and farmers are challenged from several sides to think about erosion, about biodiversity, about insect promotion. In projects like FInAL, it is clear the potential for building the capacity of farmers and improving their knowledge. So, they can become the leaders of innovation in their region.
In Sweden, the EIP-Agri support is divided into Group Support and Project Support and characterized by frequent decision-making rounds and the absence of targeted application periods. Meaning innovative ideas can be submitted for assessment at any time of the year. The separation of support creates flexibility for applicants, as they can apply for one or both supports. The division facilitate the entry into the EIP-Agri support system, because less documentation is required. The whole application processes can become an administrative burden for a small farm seeking support for an innovative idea, because the application for Project Support is high demanding for the applicant. The Swedish Board of Agriculture assesses the applications for Group Support approximately once a month. The Operational Group must consist of at least two of the following actors: researchers, advisers, or entrepreneurs within the industry, to be funded. Project support is intended to assist in the implementation of an innovative idea and the management of an innovation project. Assessment rounds occur approximately 4-6 times per year by an External Advisory Committee (RÅK). The Committee does not have a decision-making mandate but an advisory mission. The recognized strengths of the division are the facilitation of the formation of OGs with complementary knowledge and expertise and encouraging the Operational Groups to start working on a common purpose and developing a joint plan for reaching the goal. The Group Support application makes the Operational Group more prepared and experienced in writing applications and facilitates the production of the more complex application for the Project Support and the realization and execution of the innovative idea.
In Sweden, the EIP-Agri support is divided into Group Support and Project Support and characterized by frequent decision-making rounds and the absence of targeted application periods. Meaning innovative ideas can be submitted for assessment at any time of the year. The separation of support creates flexibility for applicants, as they can apply for one or both supports. The division facilitate the entry into the EIP-Agri support system, because less documentation is required. The whole application processes can become an administrative burden for a small farm seeking support for an innovative idea, because the application for Project Support is high demanding for the applicant. The Swedish Board of Agriculture assesses the applications for Group Support approximately once a month. The Operational Group must consist of at least two of the following actors: researchers, advisers, or entrepreneurs within the industry, to be funded. Project support is intended to assist in the implementation of an innovative idea and the management of an innovation project. Assessment rounds occur approximately 4-6 times per year by an External Advisory Committee (RÅK). The Committee does not have a decision-making mandate but an advisory mission. The recognized strengths of the division are the facilitation of the formation of OGs with complementary knowledge and expertise and encouraging the Operational Groups to start working on a common purpose and developing a joint plan for reaching the goal. The Group Support application makes the Operational Group more prepared and experienced in writing applications and facilitates the production of the more complex application for the Project Support and the realization and execution of the innovative idea.
Having a diversity of actors in an interactive innovation project group is important, it provides an added interest and improved learning environment. Diversity can be achieved through age, gender, race, educational background, experience, attitude and many other qualitative personal traits and social and demographic point of difference. Diversity adds value to a multi-actor group by helping to provide a wider perspective on a problem or to bring new energy to group. The inclusion of a range of relevant actors in projects also supports innovation through improved ownership among the actors and their cohorts. It also brings a broader and deeper perspective, with more knowledge and potential to find solutions. This diversity amongst actors may allow for a social learning environment and may prevent or to avoid cognitive, information, managerial, or system gaps within an interactive innovation project or group. Advisors as facilitators of groups need to ensure that acceptance of diversity is cultured and valued by actors by incorporating activities which overcome unconscious bias and promote equality and inclusion. The advisors may need training to deal with diversity related issues and to demonstrate the value of diversity in terms of interactive innovation support.
Having a diversity of actors in an interactive innovation project group is important, it provides an added interest and improved learning environment. Diversity can be achieved through age, gender, race, educational background, experience, attitude and many other qualitative personal traits and social and demographic point of difference. Diversity adds value to a multi-actor group by helping to provide a wider perspective on a problem or to bring new energy to group. The inclusion of a range of relevant actors in projects also supports innovation through improved ownership among the actors and their cohorts. It also brings a broader and deeper perspective, with more knowledge and potential to find solutions. This diversity amongst actors may allow for a social learning environment and may prevent or to avoid cognitive, information, managerial, or system gaps within an interactive innovation project or group. Advisors as facilitators of groups need to ensure that acceptance of diversity is cultured and valued by actors by incorporating activities which overcome unconscious bias and promote equality and inclusion. The advisors may need training to deal with diversity related issues and to demonstrate the value of diversity in terms of interactive innovation support.
'In i2connect project partners reviewed 9 practical cases and identified, categorised and described 18 good practices.
This good practice may allow actors to see or hear or read about an innovation in a similar situation and can offer information on feasibility and actual returns of investment. It is similar to benchmarking. This may be done by a desk-based review of written/video cases, or by visiting real life examples. It may show the consequences, both positive and negative, of the innovation for the operations and for the business model.
Advisors and farmers need to take into account that each innovation project is unique with its own set of variables. This requires openness about the pros and cons of the innovation. Also, this practice was seen to be successful when farmers and other entrepreneurs can relate the innovation project to their own situation and draw realistic consequences from that. This good practice may reassure entrepreneurs about the possible consequences of an innovation, reduce their fear of risk and contribute to the decision making process.
'In i2connect project partners reviewed 9 practical cases and identified, categorised and described 18 good practices.
This good practice may allow actors to see or hear or read about an innovation in a similar situation and can offer information on feasibility and actual returns of investment. It is similar to benchmarking. This may be done by a desk-based review of written/video cases, or by visiting real life examples. It may show the consequences, both positive and negative, of the innovation for the operations and for the business model.
Advisors and farmers need to take into account that each innovation project is unique with its own set of variables. This requires openness about the pros and cons of the innovation. Also, this practice was seen to be successful when farmers and other entrepreneurs can relate the innovation project to their own situation and draw realistic consequences from that. This good practice may reassure entrepreneurs about the possible consequences of an innovation, reduce their fear of risk and contribute to the decision making process.
'The i2connect project aims at empowering advisors to support interactive innovation, among others by providing them with a range of inspiring “good practices”. So far, partners reviewed 9 practical cases and identified, categorised and described 18 good practices. The active involvement of farmers in research and experimentation is a strong way of giving them ownership of the whole innovation process and increases their likelihood of adopting a solution and influencing other farmers.
This practice puts the farmers in the centre of the innovation project: at initial stage, the advisor establishes a dialogue with farmers to identify their ideas and needs; during implementation phase, farmers are involved in decision-making (research protocols, steering committees…) and eventually in the dissemination of results.
This requires various attitudes and skills from advisors: be open-minded and take into account ideas from farmers; accept to change research protocols according to farmers' needs and constraints; play the role of mediator between farmers and researchers; be highly responsive, as farmers need quick answers to their questions.
Farmers may gain more knowledge by being actively involved in the project, and learn by doing, seeing and advocating for a workable solution. This good practice may increase the farmers’ sense of ownership to the project and the solutions tested.
'The i2connect project aims at empowering advisors to support interactive innovation, among others by providing them with a range of inspiring “good practices”. So far, partners reviewed 9 practical cases and identified, categorised and described 18 good practices. The active involvement of farmers in research and experimentation is a strong way of giving them ownership of the whole innovation process and increases their likelihood of adopting a solution and influencing other farmers.
This practice puts the farmers in the centre of the innovation project: at initial stage, the advisor establishes a dialogue with farmers to identify their ideas and needs; during implementation phase, farmers are involved in decision-making (research protocols, steering committees…) and eventually in the dissemination of results.
This requires various attitudes and skills from advisors: be open-minded and take into account ideas from farmers; accept to change research protocols according to farmers' needs and constraints; play the role of mediator between farmers and researchers; be highly responsive, as farmers need quick answers to their questions.
Farmers may gain more knowledge by being actively involved in the project, and learn by doing, seeing and advocating for a workable solution. This good practice may increase the farmers’ sense of ownership to the project and the solutions tested.
Some practical cases that we analysed through the field peer review (Finland Discussion Groups, Dan Tehnike, Hungarian Gray Cattle and SUAS) show that It is important that effort and time is put into building and supporting relationships between advisors and farmers, as this is how trust and mutual respect is earned and maintained.
Issues may occur in keeping farmers motivated and continue attending meetings, sharing their ideas and to experiment on their farms.
Trust and respect is key to overcoming this for an advisor and to sufficiently support their individual clients and groups.
There needs to be an enhancement of networks between advisors and farmers which enables lead actors for
innovation projects to emerge. The challenge may be that advisors can be “too disconnected” with a target group and find it difficult to identify these relevant actors. Ensuring an active, responsible role for all partners enhances the sense of ownership of the network and boosts the critical thinking of the participants.
For this good practice to be transferable, advisors and their organisations must engage with a strong network of farmers and listen to their needs. They must have sufficient soft skills such as leadership,
communication, facilitation, and group/network behaviour, to build a trusting relationship with farmers. It is vital that as a facilitator, the advisor understands, empathises with and is motivated by the needs of the group. They should create and environment which develops a level of sharing amongst the participants of minor and major difficulties they may be facing. There must be a sharing of interests between advisor/facilitator and participants, so that an idea may be understood, enhanced and nurtured by all parties.
Some practical cases that we analysed through the field peer review (Finland Discussion Groups, Dan Tehnike, Hungarian Gray Cattle and SUAS) show that It is important that effort and time is put into building and supporting relationships between advisors and farmers, as this is how trust and mutual respect is earned and maintained.
Issues may occur in keeping farmers motivated and continue attending meetings, sharing their ideas and to experiment on their farms.
Trust and respect is key to overcoming this for an advisor and to sufficiently support their individual clients and groups.
There needs to be an enhancement of networks between advisors and farmers which enables lead actors for
innovation projects to emerge. The challenge may be that advisors can be “too disconnected” with a target group and find it difficult to identify these relevant actors. Ensuring an active, responsible role for all partners enhances the sense of ownership of the network and boosts the critical thinking of the participants.
For this good practice to be transferable, advisors and their organisations must engage with a strong network of farmers and listen to their needs. They must have sufficient soft skills such as leadership,
communication, facilitation, and group/network behaviour, to build a trusting relationship with farmers. It is vital that as a facilitator, the advisor understands, empathises with and is motivated by the needs of the group. They should create and environment which develops a level of sharing amongst the participants of minor and major difficulties they may be facing. There must be a sharing of interests between advisor/facilitator and participants, so that an idea may be understood, enhanced and nurtured by all parties.
The participation in the i2connect Train the Trainers (TTT) program in Portugal proved to be a transformative experience for 20 national advisors, as they delved into the realm of interactive innovation and co-creation. The TTT offered numerous advantages, empowering the advisors with valuable knowledge and skills that they could apply in their professional roles.
One significant advantage of participating in the TTT was the opportunity to learn from fellow advisors. The collaborative environment allowed for the exchange of diverse perspectives, experiences, and best practices. This diverse group of participants fostered a rich learning atmosphere, challenging each other to think creatively and develop innovative approaches.
The TTT introduced advisors to a range of interactive tools and facilitation techniques, equipping them with practical methods to engage stakeholders and foster effective collaboration. Through interactive exercises and real-life case studies, the advisors gained hands-on experience in applying these tools, enhancing their ability to facilitate productive group dynamics and drive meaningful outcomes.
In conclusion, the participation in the i2connect TTT in Portugal brought numerous advantages and lessons learned for the advisors. The program empowered them with new skills, insights, and a supportive network, enabling them to embrace interactive innovation approaches in their advisory roles. This not only enhances their effectiveness as advisors but also contributes to fostering a culture of collaboration, co-creation, and innovation in the agricultural sector.
A participação no programa i2connect Train the Trainers (TTT) em Portugal revelou-se uma experiência transformadora para 20 consultores e técnicos de aconselhamento nacionais, que mergulharam no domínio da inovação interativa e da co-criação. O TTT ofereceu inúmeras vantagens, dando aos consultores conhecimento e competências valiosos que poderão aplicar nas suas funções profissionais.
Uma vantagem significativa da participação no TTT foi a oportunidade de aprender com outros técnicos. O ambiente de colaboração permitiu a troca de diversas perspetivas, experiências e melhores práticas. Este grupo diversificado de participantes promoveu uma atmosfera de aprendizagem rica, desafiando-se mutuamente a pensar de forma criativa e a desenvolver abordagens inovadoras.
O TTT apresentou aos consultores uma série de ferramentas interativas e técnicas de facilitação, partilhando métodos práticos para envolver as partes interessadas e promover uma colaboração eficaz. Através de exercícios interativos e de estudos de casos reais, os técnicos de aconselhamento adquiriram experiência prática na aplicação destas ferramentas, melhorando a sua capacidade de facilitar dinâmicas de grupo produtivas e de obter resultados significativos.
Em conclusão, a participação no i2connect TTT em Portugal trouxe inúmeras vantagens e lições aprendidas para os participantes. O programa capacitou-os com novas competências, conhecimentos e uma rede de apoio, permitindo-lhes adotar abordagens de inovação interativa nas suas funções de consultoria. Isto não só aumenta a sua eficácia como consultores, mas também contribui para promover uma cultura de colaboração, co-criação e inovação no sector agrícola.
During the i2connect project's Cross Visit to Portugal, a group of trainees who had completed their interactive innovation training embarked on a journey to explore Portuguese agriculture and apply their newfound knowledge. The focus was on analyzing the "Segunda Via" project, which aims to create a modern agricultural management model that combines profitability with ecological conservation and restoration practices.
An essential lesson learned during the cross visit was the importance of balancing agricultural profitability with ecological sustainability. The "Segunda Via" project showcased the potential to develop environmentally responsible farm models that leverage the natural capital available on their grounds.
The participants gained practical experience in applying interactive innovation and co-creation methods. The visit demonstrated how interactive exercises and facilitation tools can be employed to manage groups effectively and foster productive networks.
Overall, the i2connect cross visit to Portugal offered trainees invaluable lessons and experiences. They witnessed the successful integration of profitability and ecological practices in the "Segunda Via" project, emphasizing its potential for replication on a larger scale. Collaboration and the application of interactive innovation methods were evident, highlighting the importance of interdisciplinary teamwork and knowledge sharing. Equipped with these lessons, the trainees are ready to apply their knowledge and experiences in their advisory roles, promoting interactive and innovative approaches to benefit farmers and the environment.
Durante a Cross Visit do projeto i2connect em Portugal, um grupo de formandos, que já tinha concluído a sua formação em inovação interativa, embarcou numa jornada para explorar a agricultura portuguesa e aplicar os seus novos conhecimentos. O objetivo foi analisar o projeto "Segunda Via", que pretende criar um modelo moderno de gestão agrícola que combina lucro com práticas de conservação e restauração ecológica.
Uma lição essencial aprendida durante a visita foi a importância de equilibrar o lucro agrícola com a sustentabilidade ecológica. O projeto "Segunda Via" demonstrou o potencial de desenvolver explorações ambientalmente responsáveis que aproveitam o capital natural disponível nas suas terras.
Os participantes tiveram a oportunidade de aplicar na prática os métodos de inovação interativa e co-criação que tinham aprendido. A visita demonstrou como exercícios interativos e ferramentas de facilitação podem ser utilizados para gerir grupos de forma eficaz e promover redes produtivas.
No geral, a Cross Visit do i2connect em Portugal ofereceu aos formandos experiências inestimáveis. Eles testemunharam a integração bem-sucedida de práticas lucrativas e ecológicas no projeto "Segunda Via", enfatizando seu potencial de replicação em maior escala. A colaboração e a aplicação de métodos de inovação interativa foram evidentes, destacando a importância do trabalho em equipas interdisciplinares e da partilha de conhecimento. Equipados com essas lições, os formandos estão prontos para aplicar os seus conhecimentos e experiências ños seus papéis de consultoria e aconselhamentos, promovendo abordagens interativas e inovadoras para beneficiar os agricultores e o meio ambiente.
In Hungary, advisory service supported the development of a long lasting and long-distance solution based on IoT technology, in order to monitor the motion, geolocation and other environmental parameters of Hungarian Grey Cattle wandering around large areas of the Hungarian Kiskunság Puszta. The innovation is not only achieved at the technical level, but rather by the mode of delivery, as the solution is offered as part of a farm advisory service package, which includes an online software for real time visualizing several parameters of the tracked animal, integrated with a breeding management information system and a farm logbook platform, connected to the national bovine identification registry.
The project is a classic example of multi-actors cooperation involving a private agricultural advisory services owned by public partner, animal production farm managed by farmer, commercial IT companies involved in development of the monitoring system design and establishment, market actors, administrative bodies.
The advisory service played a major role throughout all the project phases, embedding the farmer, with his own need, in a network of well-established partners aiming at an increase of competitiveness of farms.Two specific aspects are very relevant for a holistic approach to agricultural advisory services provision: a) IT services are a part of commercial advisory package, not separate services requiring some additional payment; b) there is a combination of public policy instruments with provision of high quality agricultural advisory services at an individual farmer/client level: the costs of commercial advisory package are covered in 90% by support for farm advisory provided by RDP 2014-2021
In Hungary, advisory service supported the development of a long lasting and long-distance solution based on IoT technology, in order to monitor the motion, geolocation and other environmental parameters of Hungarian Grey Cattle wandering around large areas of the Hungarian Kiskunság Puszta. The innovation is not only achieved at the technical level, but rather by the mode of delivery, as the solution is offered as part of a farm advisory service package, which includes an online software for real time visualizing several parameters of the tracked animal, integrated with a breeding management information system and a farm logbook platform, connected to the national bovine identification registry.
The project is a classic example of multi-actors cooperation involving a private agricultural advisory services owned by public partner, animal production farm managed by farmer, commercial IT companies involved in development of the monitoring system design and establishment, market actors, administrative bodies.
The advisory service played a major role throughout all the project phases, embedding the farmer, with his own need, in a network of well-established partners aiming at an increase of competitiveness of farms.Two specific aspects are very relevant for a holistic approach to agricultural advisory services provision: a) IT services are a part of commercial advisory package, not separate services requiring some additional payment; b) there is a combination of public policy instruments with provision of high quality agricultural advisory services at an individual farmer/client level: the costs of commercial advisory package are covered in 90% by support for farm advisory provided by RDP 2014-2021
Given the pluralistic situation of advisory services in the EU, which is reflected in the heterogeneous interests and needs of individual advisors, and a particular trend towards small-scale entrepreneurial units driven by privatization, the challenge of designing an attractive, user-friendly and professional database that meets all needs is quite significant. The i2connect AS database is an EU-wide directory of professional advisory organisations and individual actors that provide knowledge services to actors in agriculture, forestry, horticulture and related fields along the agro-food value chain, as well as to other related actors in rural areas. It aims to (a) provide information on existing practical cases and training opportunities across Europe, (b) identify advisory service providers in agriculture and forestry, and (c) exchange and networking among advisors engaged in interactive innovation. Moreover, it is a good opportunity for advisors or organizations to make themselves visible within an EU-wide network of innovation advisors, to be connected and develop synergies with other advisors and organizations, develop their professional capacity being updated about opportunities taking place across Europe.
Given the pluralistic situation of advisory services in the EU, which is reflected in the heterogeneous interests and needs of individual advisors, and a particular trend towards small-scale entrepreneurial units driven by privatization, the challenge of designing an attractive, user-friendly and professional database that meets all needs is quite significant. The i2connect AS database is an EU-wide directory of professional advisory organisations and individual actors that provide knowledge services to actors in agriculture, forestry, horticulture and related fields along the agro-food value chain, as well as to other related actors in rural areas. It aims to (a) provide information on existing practical cases and training opportunities across Europe, (b) identify advisory service providers in agriculture and forestry, and (c) exchange and networking among advisors engaged in interactive innovation. Moreover, it is a good opportunity for advisors or organizations to make themselves visible within an EU-wide network of innovation advisors, to be connected and develop synergies with other advisors and organizations, develop their professional capacity being updated about opportunities taking place across Europe.
The complex challenges that agriculture and forestry sector have been facing request new approaches for advisors. Yet, even when an advisor recognizes the importance of interaction innovation and knows how to realise successful interactive innovation projects, it needs an enabling environment, i.e., the backup of his or her organisation. The managers in advisory organisations are important actors in the enabling environment. Therefore, i2connect organized two days Excellence Class meetings for managers with the aim of developing a bottom up process including:
• Human resource aspects, i.e., the skills and competences that their advisors need for interactive innovation;
• Organisational aspects, i.e., the consequences of interactive innovation for the work organization;
• Financial aspects, i.e., the impact that interactive innovation will have on the organisation’s business model and continuity.The Excellence Class meetings contents have been decided through surveys and interviews to managers of advisory services. In total i2connect project will involve 80 managers from all over Europe.
The complex challenges that agriculture and forestry sector have been facing request new approaches for advisors. Yet, even when an advisor recognizes the importance of interaction innovation and knows how to realise successful interactive innovation projects, it needs an enabling environment, i.e., the backup of his or her organisation. The managers in advisory organisations are important actors in the enabling environment. Therefore, i2connect organized two days Excellence Class meetings for managers with the aim of developing a bottom up process including:
• Human resource aspects, i.e., the skills and competences that their advisors need for interactive innovation;
• Organisational aspects, i.e., the consequences of interactive innovation for the work organization;
• Financial aspects, i.e., the impact that interactive innovation will have on the organisation’s business model and continuity.The Excellence Class meetings contents have been decided through surveys and interviews to managers of advisory services. In total i2connect project will involve 80 managers from all over Europe.
The first i2connect Summer School, aiming at strengthening the capacity of the future rural advisors to support interactive innovation, took place in July 25-29, 2022 at the Mediterranean Agronomic Institute of Chania. An international group of 26 MSc and PhD students attended a full of activities course, covering crucial topics concerning the facilitation of interactive innovation, such as the Agricultural Knowledge and Innovation Systems (AKIS), networks and facilitation.
A variety of interactive exercises was used by the team of facilitators to mobilize students’ participation and sensitize them to the role(s) and the competences of advisors. The participants were familiarized with methodological tools, such as the “spiral of innovations” and the “triangle of Co-creation”, useful in the analysis of networks and actors’ navigation through innovative ecosystems, further practiced in the field visit. The participants enjoyed their active involvement in group work and kept their energy high throughout the whole course. According to their evaluation, the Summer School was a true co-learning experience that surpassed their expectations with interactive activities fulfilling their expectations. The students benefited not only from their interaction with each other but the inspiration and feedback they got from the facilitators as well and overall they bade farewell to the Summer School with positive feelings.
Nevertheless, certain improvements were recommended for the next Summer School in Hohenheim in 2023. More time should be devoted to more detailed exploration of certain concepts and competence activities, such as AKIS, facilitation techniques and the field visit, which, overall, suggest a longer duration of the course.
Το πρώτο Καλοκαιρινό Σχολείο του I2CONNECT με στόχο την υποστήριξη των γεωργικών συμβούλων και των διαδραστικών καινοτομιών πραγματοποιήθηκε στο Μεσογειακό Αγρονομικό Ινστιτούτο Χανίων το διάστημα 25-29 Ιουλίου 2022. Είκοσι έξι διδακτορικοί και μεταπτυχιακοί σπουδαστές παρακολούθησαν ένα γεμάτο δραστηριότητες πρόγραμμα, που κάλυπτε κρίσιμα θέματα, όπως τα Γεωργικά Συστήματα Γνώσης και Καινοτομίας (AKIS), τα δίκτυα, ο συντονισμός δρώντων.
Οι εκπαιδευτές/ διευκολυντές αξιοποίησαν ποικίλες διαδραστικές ασκήσεις, προκειμένου να ενεργοποιήσουν και να ευαισθητοποιήσουν τους σπουδαστές για τους ρόλους και τις απαραίτητες δεξιότητες των συμβούλων. Οι σπουδαστές εξοικειώθηκαν με μεθοδολογικά εργαλεία, όπως το «σπιράλ καινοτομίας» και το «τρίγωνο της συν-δημιουργίας», χρήσιμα για τη διερεύνηση καινοτόμων δικτύων και οικοσυστημάτων, τα οποία εφάρμοσαν κατά την επίσκεψή τους σε αγροτική εκμετάλλευση. Οι σπουδαστές συμμετείχαν ενεργά σε ομαδικές εργασίες, διατηρώντας τον ενθουσιασμό τους καθ’ όλη τη διάρκεια της εκπαίδευσης. Σύμφωνα με την αξιολόγησή τους, το Καλοκαιρινό Σχολείο τούς πρόσφερε αυθεντική εμπειρία συμμετοχικής μάθησης πέρα από τις προσδοκίες τους και συνολικά οι διαδραστικές ασκήσεις στις οποίες συμμετείχαν εκπλήρωσαν τους σκοπούς τους. Οι σπουδαστές επωφελήθηκαν τόσο από την μεταξύ τους αλληλεπίδραση όσο και την καθοδήγηση και ανατροφοδότηση των διευκολυντών, συνολικά αποκομίζοντας πολύ θετικές εντυπώσεις. Παράλληλα πρότειναν ορισμένες βελτιώσεις εν όψη του Καλοκαιρινού Σχολείου στο Hohenheim το 2023, όπως περισσότερο χρόνο για εμβάθυνση στο AKIS, τις τεχνικές διευκόλυνσης και την επίσκεψη σε εκμετάλλευση, υποδεικνύοντας εντέλει την ανάγκη χρονικής επέκτασης της εκπαίδευσης.
Systemic thinking claims that the process of innovation is messy and complex with the successful development and implementation of innovations requiring the engagement of multiple actors working in networks to achieve the desired outcomes. According to that, in an innovation initiative, the engaged actors are the owners of the same problematic situation, though from different angles. They are also the sources of complementary knowledge, diverse perspectives, values, interests, and practices that -if put together- can lead to innovative solutions. However, this diversity entails the need for new ways of actors’ mobilization and coordination, facilitating social learning. This means that a new set of Innovation Support Services functions emerges compared to the ‘conventional’ advisory services. The new functions include vision building, diagnosis, foresight, strategic network formation and facilitation, technical backstopping, mediation of conflicts and capacity building. As a result, new tasks emerge for advisors, who need new knowledge and skills to facilitate interactive processes and new methodological tools to provide advisory services tailored to their client’s needs. In this framework, the I2CONNECT project set up three summer schools for the period 2022-2024. These adopt a non-directive, participant, and problem-solving-oriented training approach, aiming to support trainees in their own learning about the principles and methods appropriate for interactive innovation, using participatory methods and examples.
Σύμφωνα με τη συστημική σκέψη η καινοτόμος διαδικασία είναι δύδκολη και πολύπλοκη και η επιτυχής ανάπτυξη και εφαρμογή των καινοτομιών απαιτεί τη συμμετοχή πολλαπλών δρώντων, που σχηματίζουν δίκτυα προκειμένου να επιτύχουν τους σκοπούς τους. Επίσης, υποστηρίζει ότι σε μια καινοτομίας οι εμπλεκόμενοι φορείς είναι όλοι ιδιοκτήτες της προβληματικής κατάστασης που τους απασχολεί, αν και από διαφορετικές οπτικές γωνίες. Είναι επίσης πηγές συμπληρωματικής γνώσης, διαφορετικών προοπτικών, αξιών, συμφερόντων και πρακτικών που -αν συνδυαστούν- μπορούν να οδηγήσουν σε καινοτόμες λύσεις. Ωστόσο, αυτή η ποικιλομορφία συνεπάγεται την ανάγκη για νέους τρόπους κινητοποίησης και συντονισμού των δρώντων, που διευκολύνουν την κοινωνική μάθηση. Αυτό σημαίνει νέες λειτουργίες για τις υπηρεσίες υποστήριξης της καινοτομίας σε σύγκριση με τις "συμβατικές" συμβουλευτικές υπηρεσίες όπως: την οικοδόμηση οράματος, τη διάγνωση, την πρόβλεψη, το σχηματισμό, τη διευκόλυνση δικτυώσεων, την τεχνική υποστήριξη, τη διαμεσολάβηση σε συγκρούσεις, την ανάπτυξη ικανοτήτων. Συγχρόνως, δημιουργούν νέα καθήκοντα για τους συμβούλους, οι οποίοι χρειάζονται νέες γνώσεις και δεξιότητες για να διευκολύνουν τις διαδραστικές διαδικασίες και νέα μεθοδολογικά εργαλεία για να παρέχουν συμβουλευτικές υπηρεσίες προσαρμοσμένες στις ανάγκες του πελάτη τους.Στο πλαίσιο αυτό, το έργο I2CONNECT δημιούργησε τρία θερινά σχολεία για την περίοδο 2022-2024. Αυτά υιοθετούν μια μη-κατευθυντική, συμμετοχική και προσανατολισμένη στην επίλυση προβλημάτων εκπαιδευτική προσέγγιση, με στόχο την υποστήριξη της μάθησης των εκπαιδευομένων πάνω στις αρχές και τις μεθόδους της διαδραστικής καινοτομίας, αξιοποιώντας συμμετοχικές μεθόδους.
It is common knowledge that awareness of multi actor innovation processes should start in the education of future advisors. In this respect, i2connect summer schools aim at creating facilities to make formal/vocational education profit from what the project delivers. Moreover, this project activity aspires to create further opportunities for teachers and future advisors to connect with the network of professionals in innovation support, and to stimulate active involvement in multi actor innovation processes. In the framework of the i2connect project, three summer schools will be held, organized by AUA (Greece), UHOH (Germany) and Teagasc (Ireland) in the summertime of 2022, 2023 and 2024, respectively. It is foreseen that each summer school will host 20 participants of a 3-day duration, plus two online events (introductory and closing). Participants comprise students, coming from all over Europe and being at various levels of their studies, mainly at agronomy and rural development–related Higher Educational Institutes. At the end of the training, the Summer Schools participants will be able to: distinguish between different innovation and advisory approaches; describe their role as advisor, especially in an interactive innovation process; select among communication methods/tools that promote interactive innovation; give examples of the steps of an innovation process; portray the different actors’ roles in an innovation process/network; practice some networking/facilitation skills; and learn how networking can effectively lead to change.
It is common knowledge that awareness of multi actor innovation processes should start in the education of future advisors. In this respect, i2connect summer schools aim at creating facilities to make formal/vocational education profit from what the project delivers. Moreover, this project activity aspires to create further opportunities for teachers and future advisors to connect with the network of professionals in innovation support, and to stimulate active involvement in multi actor innovation processes. In the framework of the i2connect project, three summer schools will be held, organized by AUA (Greece), UHOH (Germany) and Teagasc (Ireland) in the summertime of 2022, 2023 and 2024, respectively. It is foreseen that each summer school will host 20 participants of a 3-day duration, plus two online events (introductory and closing). Participants comprise students, coming from all over Europe and being at various levels of their studies, mainly at agronomy and rural development–related Higher Educational Institutes. At the end of the training, the Summer Schools participants will be able to: distinguish between different innovation and advisory approaches; describe their role as advisor, especially in an interactive innovation process; select among communication methods/tools that promote interactive innovation; give examples of the steps of an innovation process; portray the different actors’ roles in an innovation process/network; practice some networking/facilitation skills; and learn how networking can effectively lead to change.
In interactive innovation support it is vital to create a common understanding of the real needs of farmers who are both actors and target participants. Advisors and their organisation must continuously identify and review needs of these farmers. Advisors goals, activities and planned outcomes should address the real short and long term needs, while recognising that the needs of farmers may differ from person to person and group to groups. This practice is supported by advisors who listen, record and report the changing needs and do not assume that they know the needs already; asking farmers to express their needs regularly. The advisor should ensure that the solutions are practical and meet the real needs of the farmers for a successful uptake of the solution. Advisors are skilled in consultancy, however in interactive innovation support requires skills in listening, questioning and in participatory management. Visuals, on-farm trials and practical demonstrations support and energise interactive learning and adoption. Assumptions about the real needs of farmers are dangerous and should be evidence based. Participants are likely to have a mix of the knowledge, skills, resources and motivation needed to solve the problem, the challenge for the advisor is to get them to work as a team. It requires needs analysis exercises that should form part or all formal advisor training.
An interactive innovation project should have clearly expressed needs, goals and actions agreed by participants and owned by the group. Adviser should use warm participatory approach (e.g. brainstorm) to identify and record the needs of the group and to prioritise needs and agree steps to find solutions, plan actions and work together as a group.
In interactive innovation support it is vital to create a common understanding of the real needs of farmers who are both actors and target participants. Advisors and their organisation must continuously identify and review needs of these farmers. Advisors goals, activities and planned outcomes should address the real short and long term needs, while recognising that the needs of farmers may differ from person to person and group to groups. This practice is supported by advisors who listen, record and report the changing needs and do not assume that they know the needs already; asking farmers to express their needs regularly. The advisor should ensure that the solutions are practical and meet the real needs of the farmers for a successful uptake of the solution. Advisors are skilled in consultancy, however in interactive innovation support requires skills in listening, questioning and in participatory management. Visuals, on-farm trials and practical demonstrations support and energise interactive learning and adoption. Assumptions about the real needs of farmers are dangerous and should be evidence based. Participants are likely to have a mix of the knowledge, skills, resources and motivation needed to solve the problem, the challenge for the advisor is to get them to work as a team. It requires needs analysis exercises that should form part or all formal advisor training.
An interactive innovation project should have clearly expressed needs, goals and actions agreed by participants and owned by the group. Adviser should use warm participatory approach (e.g. brainstorm) to identify and record the needs of the group and to prioritise needs and agree steps to find solutions, plan actions and work together as a group.
External factors such as climate change, technological development, global pandemic, and digitalization change farms are faster than ever before all over the world. Remote services become a routine for majority of us. Certain part of LAAS' services was transferred to electronic space.
IKMIS is a system of integrated plant protection information, consulting, and training consisting of four electronic services for farmers, advisers, researchers, and everyone interested in agriculture. Electronic services are free of charge. IKMIS was developed by specialists of LAAS in cooperation with researchers. The aim of the system is to create conditions for Lithuanian agricultural sector entities to monitor plant diseases and pests more efficiently and at lower cost, improve skills, and make optimal decisions on the use of plant protection products as IKMIS promotes both the sustainable use of plant protection products and the use of non-chemical integrated pest control methods.
It was stated by European Court of Auditors that IKMIS is an example of good practice of the sustainable use of plant protection products in Lithuania. It is a digital tool enabling farmers to carry out more efficient and environmentally friendly agricultural activities.
Electronic services provided by IKMIS are innovative because:
1. it is a network of insect traps and online meteorological stations with integrated mathematical modules for prediction of spread of plant diseases and pests
2. there is a possibility to connect meteorological stations operated by other countries (possibility of transmission of data)
3. it is a tool for assessment of level of harmfulness of spread of harmful organisms in agricultural plants
4. it provides disease and pest catalogues
IKMIS / Integruotos augalų apsaugos informavimo, konsultavimo ir mokymų informacinė sistema
IKMIS sudaro 4 elektroninės paslaugos, kuriomis nemokamai gali naudotis turintys augalininkystės, sodininkystės, daržininkystės ūkius, konsultantai ir visi žemės ūkio entuziastai. IKMIS sukurtas, bendradarbiaujant Lietuvos žemės ūkio konsultavimo tarnybos (LŽŪKT) specialistams ir mokslininkams. Lietuvos hidrometeorologijos tarnybos stočių duomenys integruojami į LŽŪKT meteorologinių stočių tinklą, susiejami su ligų ir kenkėjų prognozavimo moduliais ir matematiniu būdu apskaičiuojama ligų ar kenkėjų pasireiškimo tikimybė. Augalų apsaugos produktų, ligų, kenkėjų ir piktžolių kataloguose vartotojui prieinama aukštos kokybės vaizdinė medžiaga, padedanti greičiau atpažinti ligą, kenkėją, lengviau pasirinkti juos naikinančius Lietuvoje registruotus augalų apsaugos produktus.
Vegetacijos metu ūkininkų pasėlius stebi, augalų apskaitas pagal mokslininkų parengtą metodiką atlieka, duomenis ir rekomendacijas kas savaitę teikia LŽŪKT augalininkystės konsultantai.
Vartotojams yra galimybė naudotis ir IKMIS mobiliąja aplikacija, pritaikyta visoms išmaniųjų telefonų operacinėms sistemoms.
IKMIS pateikiama augalų apsaugos produktų duomenų bazė, į kurią informacija gaunama tiesiai iš Valstybinės augalininkystės tarnybos prie ŽŪM informacinės sistemos.
Europos audito rūmų atstovai, 2019 m. vertinę Integruotos kenksmingųjų organizmų direktyvos reikalavimų įgyvendinimą Lietuvoje, pateikė išvadą, jog IKMIS yra puikus pavyzdys, kaip stebint pasėlius, prognozuojant kenkėjų ir ligų plitimą, informuojant apie tai ūkininkus, gilinti jų žinias, didinti galimybes taikyti integruotą augalų apsaugą.
Only knowledge applied in practice becomes innovation. LAAS in co-operation with Lithuanian study and research institutions as well as experimental farms established an EIP operational group and agreed on the launch of a project.
Complex results were achieved after the project finished. A centre Innovation gate was established. It consists of Innovation Support Service, Centre of Services of Precision Farming and Competencies with a pavilion for demonstration of technologies and a laboratory, an information system of applied innovation research and results. A network of experimental farms was also formed.
Innovation Support Service is a division of LAAS which collects, organizes and stores information about the need for innovations, innovations already applied and their results. It works as a mediator where innovation projects are initiated and funds are looked for after the need for innovation is clarified.
TITRIS is the first specialized digital database of innovations that can directly be applied in agricultural production. The database is of open access and free. Object of TITRIS is non-commercial scientific research and innovations developed by practitioners that have or might have influence on sustainable agricultural production.
Soil analysis is carried out in the laboratory. Analysis of soil composition, slurry, manure, sewage water, ground and surface water is performed in the laboratory.
The simulation display of precision farming is used to show clients the full cycle of precision farming and to encourage farmers to use innovative technologies on their farms.
Tik įdiegtos žinios tampa inovacijomis, todėl itin svarbi trišalė partnerystė: ūkis, konsultavimas, mokslas. Blogai, jei žinios lieka tik akademinėje bendruomenėje. LŽŪKT kartu su pagrindinėmis šalies žemės ūkio mokslo, studijų institucijomis ir žemės ūkio eksperimentinę veiklą vykdančiais ūkiais įkūrė EIP veiklos grupę ir priėmė sprendimą įgyvendinti projektą.
Įgyvendinus projektą, pasiekti kompleksiniai rezultatai: įkurtas centras Inovacijų vartai, kurį sudaro Inovacijų paramos tarnyba, Tiksliojo ūkininkavimo paslaugų ir kompetencijų centras su technologijų demonstravimo paviljonu bei laboratorija, taikomųjų inovacijų tyrimų rezultatų informacinė sistema TITRIS (https://titris.lzukt.lt/); suformuotas eksperimentinių ūkių tinklas.
Inovacijų paramos tarnyba - LŽŪKT struktūrinis vienetas, kuris renka, kaupia ir sistemina informaciją apie inovacijų poreikį, įgyvendintas inovacijas, jų rezultatus. Ji atlieka mediatoriaus funkciją - surinkus poreikį inovacijoms, inicijuoja inovacijų projektus, ieško projektams finansavimo šaltinių, organizuoja bendradarbiavimą.
TITRIS - nemokama, atvira taikomųjų inovacijų tyrimų ir rezultatų informacinė sistema, kurios objektas - nekomerciniai mokslo tyrimai ir praktikų sukurtos inovacijos, turinčios įtakos tvariai žemės ūkio gamybai.
Laboratorijoje atliekami dirvožemio tyrimai: dirvožemio sudėtis, mėšlas, srutos, nuotekų vanduo, paviršinis ir gruntinis vandenys.
Įsigytas mobilus tiksliosios žemdirbystės technologijų demonstravimo stendas leidžia klientams pademonstruoti visą tiksliojo ūkininkavimo ciklą ir paskatinti ūkininkus drąsiau taikyti inovatyvias technologijas ūkiuose.
Institutions may act as a support for interactive innovation projects with the increasing recognition of the roles of various types of intermediaries within these types of projects. Innovation brokers/ facilitators (advisors) may seek assistance from institutions at all stages innovation projects. It is the role of the advisors to advocate the support from institutions and to facilitate this for their clients to help create an enabling environment. The enabling environment of a project plays a key success factor in the support of interactive innovation. Without the support of institutions, advisors are maybe less able to work efficiently and creatively. Advisors may have a broad and vast knowledge of agriculture, yet some innovation projects may be specialized and require very specific knowledge or skills. Advisors must acknowledge that assistance may be required for specialist project where advisors may naturally not have access to the resources required for this project. Advisors may need assistance in terms of knowledge, development techniques, testing strategies and implementation of the innovation product. Participants and individual actors are likely to have a variety of skills, knowledge, attitudes and viewpoints on the direction of the project, but are unlikely to have all these which are needed for the innovation. A strong institutional involvement provides a depth of resources, relationship support and knowledge back-up, though this may fall apart due to lack of communication, unclear roles and tasks or clarity of ownership of responsibilities. The advisor must act as a facilitator and assist both clients and specialists to efficiently communicate and support an enabling environment where ideas may develop and grow
Institutions may act as a support for interactive innovation projects with the increasing recognition of the roles of various types of intermediaries within these types of projects. Innovation brokers/ facilitators (advisors) may seek assistance from institutions at all stages innovation projects. It is the role of the advisors to advocate the support from institutions and to facilitate this for their clients to help create an enabling environment. The enabling environment of a project plays a key success factor in the support of interactive innovation. Without the support of institutions, advisors are maybe less able to work efficiently and creatively. Advisors may have a broad and vast knowledge of agriculture, yet some innovation projects may be specialized and require very specific knowledge or skills. Advisors must acknowledge that assistance may be required for specialist project where advisors may naturally not have access to the resources required for this project. Advisors may need assistance in terms of knowledge, development techniques, testing strategies and implementation of the innovation product. Participants and individual actors are likely to have a variety of skills, knowledge, attitudes and viewpoints on the direction of the project, but are unlikely to have all these which are needed for the innovation. A strong institutional involvement provides a depth of resources, relationship support and knowledge back-up, though this may fall apart due to lack of communication, unclear roles and tasks or clarity of ownership of responsibilities. The advisor must act as a facilitator and assist both clients and specialists to efficiently communicate and support an enabling environment where ideas may develop and grow
The aim of the Hungarian i2connect cross visit was that the advisors learn how to identify and analyse interactive innovation processes using the example of a Hungarian EIP-AGRI operational group (coperation between farmers). This Operational Groups called “lupine dream” aims at using sweet lupine produced in different growing regions as an alternative protein source in pig feeding and to investigate its economics. The group consists of an advisor, a research centre, a feed company and several agricultural producers. One of the producers hosted the foreign advisors as part of the i2connect cross-visit and shared its experiences in the project. The partners in the group found that the yield of lupine is significantly determined by the agroecological conditions. The quality of the soil is the most decisive factor during the vegetative development.
By sharing the developments and innovations at domestic and international level, the network of the farmers continues to expand. This is a secondary benefit for all partners. The sharing of experiences during Cross-Visits and the use of specific analysis methods make it possible to get acquainted with the results in different European countries. This allows all participants continuous development and joint learning.
The aim of the Hungarian i2connect cross visit was that the advisors learn how to identify and analyse interactive innovation processes using the example of a Hungarian EIP-AGRI operational group (coperation between farmers). This Operational Groups called “lupine dream” aims at using sweet lupine produced in different growing regions as an alternative protein source in pig feeding and to investigate its economics. The group consists of an advisor, a research centre, a feed company and several agricultural producers. One of the producers hosted the foreign advisors as part of the i2connect cross-visit and shared its experiences in the project. The partners in the group found that the yield of lupine is significantly determined by the agroecological conditions. The quality of the soil is the most decisive factor during the vegetative development.
By sharing the developments and innovations at domestic and international level, the network of the farmers continues to expand. This is a secondary benefit for all partners. The sharing of experiences during Cross-Visits and the use of specific analysis methods make it possible to get acquainted with the results in different European countries. This allows all participants continuous development and joint learning.
The collaboration between CREA (Council for Agricultural Research and Economics) and CONAF (Council of the National Order of Agronomists and Foresters) is pluriannual and set by Memoranda of understanding (MoU) within which CONAF and each Research Centres of CREA (12) undertake specific activities of exchange of expertise and knowledge and collaboration. Within the framework of the National Rural Development Network (NRN) 2014-2020 and of some European research H2020 (i2connect) and Erasmus+ (RAMONES-PL) projects, of which CREA is partner, this collaboration implies: the collection of information for the assessment of AKIS and advisory services; joint informative and training events on specific technical-scientific and economic aspects of farming practices and on the CAP; webinar-series that allow the participant agronomists/foresters to gain training credits, as they are integrated within the binding life-long learning. A joint working group conducts systematic exchange of knowledge and experience for the co-definition of a methodological framework for monitoring and evaluating the performance, of a methodology for simplified costs, and for the identification of relevant practices of innovation support and dissemination of advisory services. A network of researchers and advisors aims at collecting, based on transparent and scientific methodologies, up-to-date information on land assets and rents for the estimation and analyses of relevant structural and socio-economic indicators and for the provision of advisory services. Benefits for CREA and CONAF regard the increased evidence and impact-based orientation of research and the enhanced capabilities of advisors to better interact within the AKISs and the CAP.
La collaborazione tra il CREA (Consiglio per la Ricerca e l'Economia Agraria) e il CONAF (Consiglio dell'Ordine Nazionale degli Agronomi e Forestali) è pluriennale e stabilita da protocolli d'intesa all'interno dei quali il CONAF e i Centri di Ricerca del CREA (12) intraprendono attività specifiche di scambio di competenze e conoscenze e di collaborazione. Nel quadro della RRN 2014-2020 e di alcuni progetti europei H2020 (i2connect) ed Erasmus+ (RAMONES-PL), di cui il CREA è partner, questa collaborazione implica: la raccolta di informazioni per la valutazione di AKIS e servizi di consulenza; eventi informativi e formativi congiunti relativi ad aspetti specifici tecnico-scientifici ed economici delle pratiche agricole e sulla PAC; webinar che permettono ai partecipanti di ottenere crediti formativi e sono integrati all'interno della formazione permanente obbligatoria. Un gruppo di lavoro congiunto conduce uno scambio sistematico di conoscenze ed esperienze per la co-definizione di un quadro metodologico per il monitoraggio e la valutazione della performance, di una metodologia per i costi semplificati e per l'identificazione di pratiche rilevanti di supporto all'innovazione e alla diffusione dei servizi di consulenza. Una rete di ricercatori e consulenti mira a raccogliere, sulla base di metodologie trasparenti e scientifiche, informazioni aggiornate sul patrimonio fondiario e sulle rendite per la stima e l'analisi degli indicatori strutturali e socio-economici rilevanti e per la fornitura di servizi di consulenza. I benefici per CREA e CONAF riguardano l'aumento dell'evidenza e l'orientamento basato sull'impatto della ricerca e le maggiori capacità dei consulenti di interagire meglio all'interno degli AKIS e della PAC.
Visiting study tours, international exchange programs, and digital meetings can be good opportunities to allow advisors and farmers to learn from the experience of peers in other countries and to exposure to new ideas and new ways of doing things that may be relevant to them.
In Finland, international discussion groups have been set up. When establishing this good practice, the main challenge the advisors/facilitators had to overcome was to identify contacts and build a network of advisors and discussion group facilitators in other countries. ProAgria facilitators looked for relevant contacts through internet and, also, through a travel agency. During the initial phase, the ProAgria facilitators spent a considerable amount of time travelling to other countries to meet advisors and discussion groups and to get inspiration to shape the concept for the international discussion groups. Facilitators must prepare a detailed plan and objective for the study trip, as well as providing the farmers with information on the farm before the study trip. Each member of the group has a friendship farmer in the host country. The friendship farmers visit each other’s farms to share knowledge and experience, and to spend some time working on their farms. The farmers and friendship farmers are matched based on similarities of their farms. Farmers visits their 'friendship farmer' more than once, getting the opportunity to build a reciprocal mentoring relationship that lasts beyond the duration of the study trip, to have more in-depth discussions and learn from each other. At the end of the study visit, the advisor facilitates a collaborative discussion with visiting and home farmers, to share their experience, new insight, and knowledge with the group.
Visite di studio, programmi di scambio internazionali e incontri digitali possono essere buone opportunità per permettere a consulenti e agricoltori di imparare dall'esperienza di altri colleghi di altri paesi ed approcciarsi a nuove idee e nuovi modi di fare le cose che possono essere rilevanti per loro.
In Finlandia, sono stati istituiti gruppi di discussione internazionale. Nello stabilire questa buona pratica, la sfida principale che i consulenti/facilitatori hanno dovuto superare è stata quella di identificare i contatti e costruire una rete di consulenti e facilitatori di gruppi di discussione in altri paesi. I facilitatori di ProAgria hanno cercato i contatti rilevanti attraverso internet e attraverso un'agenzia di viaggi agricoli. Durante la fase iniziale, i facilitatori di ProAgria hanno trascorso molto tempo viaggiando in altri paesi per incontrare i consulenti e i gruppi di discussione e disegnare un modello di gruppi di discussione internazionali.
I facilitatori preparano un piano dettagliato e un obiettivo per il viaggio di studio, oltre a fornire agli agricoltori informazioni sull'azienda prima del viaggio di studio. Ogni membro del gruppo ha un ‘agricoltore amico’ nel paese ospitante. Gli ‘agricoltori amici’ visitano le fattorie degli altri per condividere conoscenze ed esperienze e passare un po' di tempo a lavorare nelle loro fattorie. Le visite avvengono in più volte, in modo da facilitare la costruzione di un rapporto di mentoring reciproco duraturo, lo scambio in profondità e l’apprendimento reciproco. Gli ‘agricoltori amici’ sono abbinati in base alle somiglianze delle loro aziende. Al termine della visita il consulente facilita una discussione collaborativa con gli agricoltori in visita e in patria, per condividere la loro esperienza, le nuove conoscenze e il sapere con il gruppo.
The Italian AKIS is characterised by a multi-level governance and needs coordination bodies, at interregional and transregional level, aimed at defining common vision and support for policies implementation, mediating different positions and articulating demand about R&I policies and programs. The Interregional Network for Agricultural, Forestry, Aquaculture and Fisheries Research was set up spontaneously by regional bodies in 1998 and since then it has been playing an increasing crucial role in coordinating the design and implementation of European, national, and regional legislation, policies and programs regarding agricultural R&I and advisory services in Italy. It is composed by the representatives of the administrations who are responsible for the design and implementation of agricultural R&I and advisory policies at regional/A.P (Trento and Bolzano) level. It is organized by thematic groups (themes/value chains) and its secretariat is held by Tuscany Region. The activities are ensured by regular meetings, the organization of discussion events, frequently by involving other experts and representatives from the MIPAAF, and the drafting of notes and opinions. The Network has effectively carried out a meaningful work of coordination, promotion, and direction of public research, through the articulation of the demand, to better target the needs of the different territories, the definition of objectives and priority actions for research and experimentation.
L'AKIS italiano è caratterizzato da una governance multilivello e necessita di organismi di coordinamento, a livello interregionale e transregionale, finalizzati a definire una visione comune e a sostenere l'attuazione delle politiche, mediando le diverse posizioni e articolando la domanda sulle politiche e sui programmi di R&I. La Rete Interregionale per la Ricerca Agraria, Forestale, Acquacoltura e Pesca è stata istituita spontaneamente dagli organismi regionali nel 1998 e da allora ha svolto un ruolo sempre più cruciale nel coordinare la progettazione e l'attuazione della legislazione, delle politiche e dei programmi europei, nazionali e regionali in materia di R&I agricola e di servizi di consulenza in Italia. È composta dai rappresentanti delle amministrazioni responsabili della progettazione e dell'attuazione delle politiche di R&I e consulenza agricola a livello regionale/P.A. (Trento e Bolzano). È organizzato per gruppi tematici (temi/settori) e la sua segreteria è tenuta dalla Regione Toscana. Le attività sono garantite da incontri periodici, dall'organizzazione di eventi di discussione, spesso con il coinvolgimento di altri esperti e rappresentanti del MIPAAF e dalla redazione di note e pareri. La Rete ha svolto efficacemente un significativo lavoro di coordinamento, promozione e indirizzo della ricerca pubblica, attraverso l'articolazione della domanda, per meglio indirizzare i bisogni dei diversi territori, la definizione degli obiettivi e delle azioni prioritarie di ricerca e sperimentazione.
In this operational group, the advisor was the project manager. He was also the innovation broker, his presence through the project granted alignment with the initial proposal while undertaking the adjustments needed.
The operational group had a diverse composition: farmers, researchers, tech companies, advisor. In such complex structures is key to balance the different interests and perspectives. The advisor:
As an independent figure was an unbiased and reliable partner looking on everybody bests interests and mediated among conflicts and/or lack of trust among partners. For example, farmers were skeptical about the technology as they thought it was something to be sold to take advantage of them. With advisor intervention, farmers realized that technology was a useful tool.
Elicited effectively communication and understanding among partners. For example, the drone company spoke “telecommunication engineering” and citrus producers spoke “farmer”, the advisor “translated” them enabling fluid conversations.
Had technical knowledge and first-hand experience, so partners could relate to and identify with him. For example, the advisor is also a citrus farmer, so he is aware of the reality and potential problems.
Unexpected challenges arose during the project. For example, COVID-2019 onset led to misconceptions (some partners thought the funding body would put the project on hold and that the milestones would be delayed), it also imposed limitations on face-to-face interactions and work…The advisor kept partners motivated and ensured compliance to tasks and milestones.
The ultimate success of the support provided is that the relationship built among GO CITRICS partners keeps them engaged to work together in future projects.
In this operational group, the advisor was the project manager. He was also the innovation broker, his presence through the project granted alignment with the initial proposal while undertaking the adjustments needed.
The operational group had a diverse composition: farmers, researchers, tech companies, advisor. In such complex structures is key to balance the different interests and perspectives. The advisor:
As an independent figure was an unbiased and reliable partner looking on everybody bests interests and mediated among conflicts and/or lack of trust among partners. For example, farmers were skeptical about the technology as they thought it was something to be sold to take advantage of them. With advisor intervention, farmers realized that technology was a useful tool.
Elicited effectively communication and understanding among partners. For example, the drone company spoke “telecommunication engineering” and citrus producers spoke “farmer”, the advisor “translated” them enabling fluid conversations.
Had technical knowledge and first-hand experience, so partners could relate to and identify with him. For example, the advisor is also a citrus farmer, so he is aware of the reality and potential problems.
Unexpected challenges arose during the project. For example, COVID-2019 onset led to misconceptions (some partners thought the funding body would put the project on hold and that the milestones would be delayed), it also imposed limitations on face-to-face interactions and work…The advisor kept partners motivated and ensured compliance to tasks and milestones.
The ultimate success of the support provided is that the relationship built among GO CITRICS partners keeps them engaged to work together in future projects.
The proper writing of a proposal and identification of the best fitting funding schemes is an enabling condition for a sound project implementation and effectiveness. This implies the need of mediating the possible different views of the partners on the project and translating them into the proposal, as well as maintaining a dialogue between the writer and the farmers/other. Besides, crossing across different sources of funding, application arrangements and deadlines requires certain skills and ability. The advisors must be familiar with "several languages'': farmers, academic and project writers. Often it is difficult to transfer the knowledge/information between partners with different educational levels and experience for this reason a skilled person should be involved for the definition of the full proposal. By involving a writer to prepare the project proposal, the partnership could rely on the professional knowledge of the substantial, administrative and procedural requirements to apply the specific scheme. This could help them to navigate across the different opportunities for funding and properly complete the application in a timely manner. The writer should have the ability to listen to the emerging needs and expectations of farmers, advisors, and other partners, and to build- up a strong case around their ideas but also providing their own ideas, to design the sounding intervention logic of the project. Writing project proposals and access to funding is profession that requires special qualified and methodological knowledge, and having good proposal writing skills contributing to a well-designed and documented intervention logic of the project helps the implementation of the innovation process and expected results.
The proper writing of a proposal and identification of the best fitting funding schemes is an enabling condition for a sound project implementation and effectiveness. This implies the need of mediating the possible different views of the partners on the project and translating them into the proposal, as well as maintaining a dialogue between the writer and the farmers/other. Besides, crossing across different sources of funding, application arrangements and deadlines requires certain skills and ability. The advisors must be familiar with "several languages'': farmers, academic and project writers. Often it is difficult to transfer the knowledge/information between partners with different educational levels and experience for this reason a skilled person should be involved for the definition of the full proposal. By involving a writer to prepare the project proposal, the partnership could rely on the professional knowledge of the substantial, administrative and procedural requirements to apply the specific scheme. This could help them to navigate across the different opportunities for funding and properly complete the application in a timely manner. The writer should have the ability to listen to the emerging needs and expectations of farmers, advisors, and other partners, and to build- up a strong case around their ideas but also providing their own ideas, to design the sounding intervention logic of the project. Writing project proposals and access to funding is profession that requires special qualified and methodological knowledge, and having good proposal writing skills contributing to a well-designed and documented intervention logic of the project helps the implementation of the innovation process and expected results.
Within the AGROSYL operational group, headed by the Chamber of Agriculture, farmers were involved in the search for solutions, through scientific protocols and analyses, to integrate trees in livestock farming, and support feed autonomy and animal welfare, while improving the climate resilience.
The initial idea started from the ground, but the concept and the methodology were set up by research institutes, following a top- down approach. This gave rise to a lot of discussion among the partners, especially on the research protocols. Initially, the work on different tasks was very compartmentalised without exchange between the partners. There was misunderstanding among farmers and researchers. The biggest difficulty occurred when a breeder who was not equipped to follow the scientific indications (use the mechanisation for harvesting the mulberry production) changed the protocol to make it more feasible in the field. Researchers did not understand his initiative and this created a chill. The Chamber of Agriculture assumed the role of mediator, trying to make the researchers understand that the laboratory aspect does not fit the reality on the field. In 2019 an advisor/facilitator turned the approach to the project from top-down to bottom-up, introducing brief but frequent meetings, creating WhatsApp groups on different topics, inviting partners to do sessions and assist in experimentations in the field. In this way, the vision of each party changed and communication became more fluid and concrete. In the meantime, the initiative taken by the farmer not to follow the protocol and let the animals graze in mulberry plots proved to be very conclusive, determining the success of the project, whose results were widely recognised, also abroad.
Within the AGROSYL operational group, headed by the Chamber of Agriculture, farmers were involved in the search for solutions, through scientific protocols and analyses, to integrate trees in livestock farming, and support feed autonomy and animal welfare, while improving the climate resilience.
The initial idea started from the ground, but the concept and the methodology were set up by research institutes, following a top- down approach. This gave rise to a lot of discussion among the partners, especially on the research protocols. Initially, the work on different tasks was very compartmentalised without exchange between the partners. There was misunderstanding among farmers and researchers. The biggest difficulty occurred when a breeder who was not equipped to follow the scientific indications (use the mechanisation for harvesting the mulberry production) changed the protocol to make it more feasible in the field. Researchers did not understand his initiative and this created a chill. The Chamber of Agriculture assumed the role of mediator, trying to make the researchers understand that the laboratory aspect does not fit the reality on the field. In 2019 an advisor/facilitator turned the approach to the project from top-down to bottom-up, introducing brief but frequent meetings, creating WhatsApp groups on different topics, inviting partners to do sessions and assist in experimentations in the field. In this way, the vision of each party changed and communication became more fluid and concrete. In the meantime, the initiative taken by the farmer not to follow the protocol and let the animals graze in mulberry plots proved to be very conclusive, determining the success of the project, whose results were widely recognised, also abroad.
The Italian National Council for Agronomists and Professional Foresters Order (CONAF) currently represents about 20,000 agronomists and foresters with the aim of promoting the development and defense of the profession with a strategy based on knowledge and innovation through continuous professional training. It is organized at regional or sub-regional level, ensuring a complete coverage of the Italian territory.
The access to CONAF is regulated by national laws and it is subject to a specific examination; while the Order is responsible for setting up and maintaining the respective codes of conduct and lifelong learning programs.
Particularly, it promotes the training of its associates that must attend vocational training on regular basis by law (use of training credits). These credits can be achieved participating in courses, meetings, webinars, conferences validated by the Order. This requirement contributes to the continuous updating of skills of the members.
CONAF also carries on ad hoc studies, also in collaboration with other institutions, that could further support the development of the profession. Moreover, it supports the relationships with national and international institutions by implementing coordinated initiative, at the support of the development of the profession. The National Council promotes, realizes, and manages, directly or through the collaboration with other subject’s services and activities of interest to itself or to other professional orders.
Secondo la legislazione italiana, i professionisti che vogliono esercitare la libera professione devono essere iscritti ad un ordine professionale, a condizione che superino un esame nazionale che permetta loro di essere nominati agronomi dei forestali. Di solito queste associazioni sono organizzate a livello regionale o subregionale. Il CONAF le riunisce tutte e, secondo la legislazione nazionale, è il loro organo di autogoverno. Il suo mandato principale è quello di rappresentare gli interessi generali dei suoi associati. In un quadro così ampio porta avanti qualsiasi iniziativa che, coerentemente con i suoi obiettivi statutari, promuova lo sviluppo della professione. Ad esempio promuove la formazione dei propri associati e svolge studi, indagini e ricerche, anche in collaborazione con altre istituzioni pubbliche o private, che possano ulteriormente sostenere lo sviluppo professionale. Può prendere qualsiasi iniziativa, anche giudiziaria, per la tutela del titolo e delle prerogative della professione.
Spetta al Consiglio Nazionale definire le linee guida e i criteri per le attività delle associazioni regionali o subregionali, così come l'obiettivo da perseguire da parte dei dipartimenti che costituiscono la sua struttura organizzativa. Questi dipartimenti sono le unità organizzative del Consiglio Nazionale, sono coordinati da un Consigliere Nazionale ed elaborano la proposta di qualsiasi documento che riguarda l'attività del Consiglio. Ci sono 12 dipartimenti, ognuno dedicato ad un settore professionale. Il Consiglio Nazionale promuove, realizza e gestisce, direttamente o attraverso la collaborazione con altri soggetti pubblici o privati, servizi e attività di interesse proprio o di altri ordini professionali.
In Europe, ca 40.000 independent advisors play a major role in farmers decisions. In i2connect, a start was made to make a search engine for , based on advisors' competencies.
Although it was expected that advisors were happy to reach clients with such a database, the registration was below expectation, they perceive too much effort and too little effect. As solution to that, the Dutch database of the association of independent advsiors (VAB) is uploaded and later updated to the i2connect dbase: no effort for the advisor! The effect of double presentation (in NL and EU) was appreciated by the advisors; and it opens more possibilities, f.i. linking this dbase to more projects that support advisors. So a new approach with less/no effort and more effect. From june 2023, this approach is open for all EU organisations with independent advisors. Not only farmers, but also other stakeholders can use this tool to expore new ways of networking, in addtion to personal contacts.
In Europe, ca 40.000 independent advisors play a major role in farmers decisions. In i2connect, a start was made to make a search engine for , based on advisors' competencies.
Although it was expected that advisors were happy to reach clients with such a database, the registration was below expectation, they perceive too much effort and too little effect. As solution to that, the Dutch database of the association of independent advsiors (VAB) is uploaded and later updated to the i2connect dbase: no effort for the advisor! The effect of double presentation (in NL and EU) was appreciated by the advisors; and it opens more possibilities, f.i. linking this dbase to more projects that support advisors. So a new approach with less/no effort and more effect. From june 2023, this approach is open for all EU organisations with independent advisors. Not only farmers, but also other stakeholders can use this tool to expore new ways of networking, in addtion to personal contacts.
The Lithuanian Agricultural Advisory Service (LAAS) is the initiator of a project designed to promote and demonstrate precision technologies that could be used on farm. The project aims at giving farmers access to more information, be able to interact with some of the technologies and finally to see it in action on demonstration farms.
Since LAAS is an advisory organisation, a project team of researchers, experimental farms and specialists were put together to carry out the project, each one with a clear role to play.
A Centre of Precision Farming Services and Competencies supports farmers in learning about precision technology and provides key information such as soil analysis, somatic cell counts, animal health, etc. Within the centre there is a laboratory, which is used by farmers to carry out the various tests. A learning pavilion has been also built to be used for demonstration of innovative agricultural technologies and machinery. Here farmers can practice using the equipment and consequently become familiar with the uses of the technology and how they themselves can actually use it. In the pavillion they can also expose some of the machinery and technology. The pavilion has been a key resource for holding many demonstrations at different times of the year, particularly useful during the winter months. Mobile learning equipment has also been built to be used in different sites at various different types of events again with the aim of letting farmers experience the technology first-hand.
Il Lithuanian Agricultural Advisory Service (LAAS) è l'iniziatore di un progetto volto a promuovere e dimostrare le tecnologie di precisione che potrebbero essere utilizzate nelle aziende agricole. Il progetto mira a dare agli agricoltori la possibilità di accedere a maggiori informazioni, di interagire con alcune tecnologie e infine di vederle in azione in aziende agricole dimostrative.
Poiché LAAS è un'organizzazione di consulenza, per portare avanti il progetto è stato costituito un team di ricercatori, aziende agricole sperimentali e specialisti, ognuno dei quali ha un ruolo ben preciso da svolgere.
Un Centro di servizi e competenze per l'agricoltura di precisione supporta gli agricoltori nell'apprendimento della tecnologia di precisione e fornisce informazioni chiave come l'analisi del suolo, la conta delle cellule somatiche, la salute degli animali, ecc. All'interno del centro è presente un laboratorio che viene utilizzato dagli agricoltori per effettuare i vari test. È stato costruito anche un padiglione didattico per la dimostrazione di tecnologie e macchinari agricoli innovativi. Qui gli agricoltori possono esercitarsi nell'uso delle attrezzature e, di conseguenza, familiarizzare con gli usi della tecnologia e con il modo in cui essi stessi possono utilizzarla. Nel padiglione possono anche esporre alcuni macchinari e tecnologie. Il padiglione è stato una risorsa fondamentale per tenere molte dimostrazioni in diversi periodi dell'anno, particolarmente utili durante i mesi invernali. Sono state costruite anche attrezzature mobili per l'apprendimento da utilizzare in diversi siti in occasione di vari tipi di eventi, sempre con l'obiettivo di far sperimentare agli agricoltori la tecnologia in prima persona.
In the Leitrim area (Ireland), an advisor has worked with small drystock farmers, who are elderly and/or working off farm, and helped them to set up a contract rearing service group to increase stocking rate and the profitability of their farms. Contract heifer rearing is where a dairy farmer pays another farmer to rear his replacement heifers. The advisor helps them to take in young calves from larger dairy farms and rear them to an agreed age where they are taken back to their farm of origin.
The Sligo/Leitrim contract rearers group, born in 2015, has established benchmarking linkages with the Aurivo farm profitability programme and with the Teagasc Ballyhaise heifer rearing unit. The heifers reared by group members far exceed the performance of heifers reared on dairy farms nationally.
The discussion group format enables farmers to share experiences and knowledge; it also helps build confidence to initially take the first step and then develop the enterprise. In developing trust amongst discussion group members, social bonding (e.g. going to a pub together) seems to play a role.
Moreover, setting performance targets and presenting the farms’ results on reaching the targets seem to trigger farmers to perform better (you don’t want to be the farmer that ...).
The advisor plays the role of free actor, facilitating the network. He did that by using his gut feeling, overcome several bottlenecks, mediated between farmers.
Nella zona di Leitrim (Irlanda), un consulente ha lavorato con piccoli allevatori di bestiame, anziani e/o che lavorano fuori dall'azienda, aiutandoli a creare un gruppo di servizi di allevamento a contratto con lo scopo di aumentare il tasso di produzione e la redditività delle aziende. L'allevamento di giovenche a contratto consiste nell'allevare vacche per conto di un altro allevatore. Il consulente aiuta i membri del gruppo a prendere vitelli giovani da aziende lattiero-casearie più grandi e ad allevarli fino a un'età concordata, per poi riportarli all'azienda d'origine.
Il gruppo di allevatori a contratto di Sligo/Leitrim, nato nel 2015, ha stabilito collegamenti di benchmarking con il programma di redditività aziendale di Aurivo. Le giovenche allevate dai membri del gruppo superano di gran lunga le prestazioni delle giovenche allevate nelle aziende lattiero-casearie a livello nazionale.
Il formato del gruppo di discussione consente agli allevatori di condividere esperienze e conoscenze; aiuta inoltre a creare fiducia per compiere il primo passo e poi sviluppare l'impresa. Nello sviluppo della fiducia tra i membri del gruppo di discussione, il legame sociale (ad esempio, andare insieme al pub) sembra svolgere un ruolo importante.
Inoltre, la definizione di obiettivi di performance e la presentazione dei risultati delle aziende agricole sul raggiungimento degli obiettivi sembrano stimolare gli agricoltori a ottenere risultati migliori (non vuoi essere l'agricoltore che...).
Il consulente svolge il ruolo di attore libero, facilitando la rete. Lo ha fatto usando il suo istinto, superando diversi colli di bottiglia e facendo da mediatore tra gli agricoltori.
The EIP-Agri operational group "Citrus" (Spain) aimed at developing precision agriculture for citrus crops through the implementation of efficient water and fertilisation management. Since the problem affected multiple actors, from farmers to society in general, the challenge was addressed and through a multi-approach, considering different innovative technological tools, and involving a great diversity of actors: farmers, researchers, tech companies, advisor. The group had monthly gatherings at the same table and at the beginning, the people were really reluctant to such gatherings. Conversations among them were hard as they they talked in “different” languages and did not understand each other.Each of the partners had a different entry point on how to solve the problem.
The alignment in economic and environmental knowledge side was the key for having everyone eager to work together in this project. The advisor (manager of the project) played a crucial role in fostering the balance of different interests and perspectives, acting as an “interpreter” letting them be able to move forward. His task was to make a conversation happen, more than to arrive to the technical solution. Finally they all got emotionally involved in the project and said that they will all work systemically together. In a complex project like this one, with partners with different mindset, it has been very important to take care of all of them, to listen to all their needs.
Il gruppo operativo EIP-Agri "Citrus" (Spagna) mirava a sviluppare un'agricoltura di precisione per le colture di agrumi attraverso l'implementazione di una gestione efficiente dell'acqua e della fertilizzazione. Poiché il problema riguardava più attori, dagli agricoltori alla società in generale, la sfida è stata affrontata attraverso un approccio multiplo, considerando diversi strumenti tecnologici e coinvolgendo una grande diversità di attori: agricoltori, ricercatori, aziende tecnologiche, consulenti. Il gruppo si riuniva mensilmente ma, all'inizio, le persone erano molto riluttanti a partecipare a tali riunioni. Le conversazioni tra i partner erano difficili perché parlavano in lingue "diverse" e non capivano le esigenze l’un dell’altro. Ciascuno dei partner aveva un’idea diversa su come risolvere il problema.
L'allineamento delle conoscenze è stata la chiave per far sì che tutti fossero desiderosi di lavorare insieme in questo progetto. Il consulente (e responsabile del progetto) ha svolto un ruolo cruciale nel favorire l'equilibrio fra interessi e prospettive diverse, fungendo da "interprete" e consentendo al gruppo di andare avanti. Il suo compito è stato quello di far nascere una conversazione, più che di arrivare alla soluzione tecnica. Alla fine, tutti sono stati coinvolti emotivamente nel progetto e hanno dichiarato che avrebbero lavorato insieme in modo sistemico. In un progetto complesso come questo, con partner con mentalità e prospettive diverse, è stato molto importante prendersi cura di tutti loro e ascoltare tutte le esigenze.
The overall success of the EIP-Agri operational group 'Gate of innovation', led by the Lithuanian Agricultural Advisory Service (LAAS), can be attributed to the teamwork by the key individuals and the leadership of the Innovation Support Service.
The Innovation Support Service (ISS) was responsible for the running and development of the project and mainly consists of four people - the head of ISS, two project management experts and an interpreter -, but other experts were also involved when needed.
The main role of ISS is:
• to collect and store information;
• to organize various activities;
• to initiate writing of proposals and take part in implementation of projects;
• administer projects;
• find human resources needed for implementation of projects;
• co-ordinate dissemination of the results of innovation projects implemented;
• co-ordinate collaboration among institutions.
These ISS team was key in supporting all of the different actors in the project and ensuring that all goals and targets were met. Many different organisations with different expertise in different areas were involved, and it would have been very easy for the project to become disjointed. Some partners had expertise in a certain area, e.g. research, but had little expertise in dissemination methods and vice versa. As the project included a significant element of training and knowledge transfer, this could have been a major obstacle to the success of the project. Furthermore, many of the partners had never worked together before.
The ISS was able to keep a clear focus on the outcomes that were needed rather than the individual tasks that each actor was involved in.
Il successo complessivo del gruppo operativo EIP-Agri "Gate of innovation", guidato dal Lithuanian Agricultural Advisory Service (LAAS), può essere attribuito al lavoro di squadra delle persone chiave e alla leadership dell'Innovation Support Service.
Il Servizio di supporto all'innovazione (ISS), che ha gestito e sviluppato il progetto, è composto da quattro persone - il capo dell'ISS, due esperti di gestione del progetto e un interprete -, ma quando necessario sono coinvolti anche altri esperti.
Il ruolo principale dell'ISS è:
- raccogliere e archiviare le informazioni;
- organizzare le varie attività;
- avviare la stesura di proposte e partecipare all'attuazione dei progetti;
- amministrare i progetti;
- trovare le risorse umane necessarie per l'attuazione dei progetti;
- coordinare la diffusione dei risultati dei progetti di innovazione realizzati;
- coordinare la collaborazione tra le istituzioni.
Il team dell'ISS è stato fondamentale nel sostenere tutti i diversi attori del progetto e nel garantire il raggiungimento di tutti gli obiettivi. Il progetto aveva molte organizzazioni con competenze diverse: alcuni partner avevano competenze in una determinata area, ad esempio la ricerca, ma poca esperienza nei metodi di divulgazione e viceversa. Poiché il progetto era focalizzato su azioni di formazione e trasferimento di conoscenze, questo avrebbe potuto rappresentare un ostacolo importante per il suo successo. Inoltre, molti dei partner non avevano mai lavorato insieme prima.
L'ISS è stato in grado di mantenere una chiara focalizzazione sui risultati necessari piuttosto che sui singoli compiti in cui ciascun attore era coinvolto.
Within the "Gate of innovation" project, the Lithuanian Agricultural Advisory Service (LAAS) has acquired a mobile training unit which allowed trainers to go off site to various shows or exhibitions. The unit can be set up to show farmers the capabilities of a precision application equipment, how it needed to be set up and, then, it can simulate how the system would work on the field. The unit is set up in such a way so that the trainers can give a PowerPoint presentation using the on-board computer screen, while on the other side of the unit they can simulate the application.
Other mobile units has been used as laboratory and set up to run live tests which can give back results on forage analysis within a few minutes. While this unit is a working laboratory, it is also a very useful training tool to show farmers the value in testing soils, forage, bloods, water, pregnancy scanning, etc. This information can then be used, by the farmer, to make decisions on input requirements for animals or crops.
Mobile labs are an important advisory tool and are used everyday by the advisory service. They are hireed out to farmers or groups of farmers to carry out the necessary analysis on their own farms, where they can then get rapid feedback of the results without the need for the samples to be sent off to a central laboratory. According to LAAS, there is a very large demand from farmers, particularly livestock farmers, for the use of these labs.
Nell'ambito del progetto "Gate of innovation", il Lithuanian Agricultural Advisory Service (LAAS) ha utilizzato un'unità di formazione mobile che ha permesso ai formatori di recarsi fuori sede a varie mostre o esposizioni. L'unità può essere allestita per mostrare agli agricoltori le capacità di un'apparecchiatura per applicazioni di precisione, come deve essere impostata e, quindi, può simularne il funzionamento sul campo. L'unità è allestita in modo tale che i formatori possano tenere una presentazione in PowerPoint utilizzando lo schermo del computer di bordo, mentre dall'altro lato dell'unità possono effettuare la simulazione.
Altre unità mobili sono state utilizzate come laboratorio e allestite per eseguire analisi direttamente in azienda. Se da un lato questa unità è un laboratorio funzionante, dall'altro è anche uno strumento di formazione molto utile per mostrare agli agricoltori l'utilità di analizzare il terreno, il foraggio, il sangue, l'acqua, il test di gravidanza, ecc. Queste informazioni possono poi essere utilizzate dall'agricoltore per prendere decisioni relative all'utilizzo di input per gli animali o le colture.
I laboratori mobili sono un importante strumento di consulenza del servizio di consulenza lituano. I laboratori mobili vengono noleggiati agli agricoltori o a gruppi di agricoltori per effettuare le analisi necessarie nelle loro aziende, ottenendo un rapido riscontro senza dover inviare i campioni a un laboratorio centrale. Secondo il LAAS, c'è una grande richiesta da parte degli agricoltori, in particolare degli allevatori, per l'utilizzo di questi laboratori.
Controlled feeding of corn silage in cattle feed rations is a pilot project realised in Slovenia.
The initial idea comes from a very innovative and proactive farmer. He wondered whether it would be possible to transfer the concept of precise fertilisation of plants to the precise feeding of animals.
Since he has a broad knowledge on nutrient and energy needs, health and reproductive issues of lactating cows, as well as in technology, mechanical and electrical components, he designed an automatic feeding device capable of adjusting the ration to the needs of each animal (depending on milking yield, cow condition and corn silage availability, etc)
By self-initiative, the farmer attended meetings on EIP presentations by Slovenian Ministry of Agriculture that enabled him to share and discuss his vision and to actively search for partners and support. During these meetings, an advisor working for the Chamber of Agriculture and Forestry of Slovenia (CAFS) was impressed and inspired by his idea and took the lead of the innovation project. He identified the funding and the partners and supported the planning and the writing of the project proposal.
The main technical objectives of the project were set up by the farmer who also developed and built the device with the support of the other partners. It was very important for the farmer that someone was there to listen and support him meanwhile drafting.
The role of the advisor was also crucial in managing deadlines and getting the farmer to stop to stop sketching and start realising the feeding machine.
The EIP meetings, CAFS support and the advisor gave the push that made the idea progress from initiation to further development, making the technical solution real by enabling cooperation.
La somministrazione controllata di insilati di mais nelle razioni di alimentazione dei bovini è un progetto pilota realizzato in Slovenia.
L'idea iniziale è di un agricoltore molto innovativo e proattivo, che ha cercato di trasferire il concetto di “precisione” all'alimentazione degli animali, progettando un dispositivo di alimentazione automatica in grado di regolare la razione in base alle esigenze di ciascun animale (a seconda della resa di mungitura, delle condizioni della vacca e della disponibilità di insilato di mais, ecc).
Di propria iniziativa, ha partecipato agli incontri di presentazione del PEI organizzati dal Ministero dell'Agricoltura, che gli hanno permesso di condividere la sua visione e cercare attivamente partner e sostegno. Durante questi incontri, un consulente della Camera dell'Agricoltura e delle Foreste della Slovenia è rimasto colpito e ispirato dalla sua idea e ha preso la guida del progetto di innovazione. Il consulente ha individuato i finanziamenti e i partner e ha sostenuto la pianificazione e la stesura della proposta di progetto.
I principali obiettivi tecnici del progetto sono stati definiti dall'agricoltore che ha anche sviluppato e costruito il dispositivo con il supporto degli altri partner. Per l'agricoltore era molto importante che ci fosse qualcuno ad ascoltarlo e a sostenerlo.
Il ruolo del consulente è stato fondamentale anche per gestire le scadenze e convincere l'agricoltore a smettere di disegnare e iniziare a realizzare la macchina per l'alimentazione.
Gli incontri EIP organizzati dal Ministero dell'Agricoltura sloveno e il supporto del consulente hanno dato la spinta che ha fatto passare l'idea dall'avvio allo sviluppo successivo, rendendo reale la soluzione tecnica.
The initiative “Controlled feeding of corn silage in cattle feed rations”, funded under the EIP-AGRI sub-measure 16.2, was managed by an advisor of the Chamber of Agriculture and Forestry of Slovenia (CAFS) who took the lead and the coordination of the project. The project was born from an idea of a farmer, but the advisor gave the push that made the idea progress from initiation to its realization, starting from bringing together organisations with the competences needed to realise the farmer's idea.
He was in charge to look for information about the funding, write the proposal (with the continuous supervision and fine-tuning of all the partners) and try to secure the funds. He supported the group building a common view concerning the objectives of the project, as well as establishing the main goals to achieve and clearly defining the roles of the partners, which resulted in highly committed partners and in minimal conflicts among them.
The advisor played also a fundamental role in encouraging and motivating the partners to comply with deliverables and milestones.
The support offered by the advisor required a wide array of different skills from technical (professional, topic related), to “administrative” (proposal writing, knowledge on funds and application, report writing…) and “social” (trust, conflict solving, facilitation skills, connected to experts, funding bodies, public administration…). These are a lot of tasks/skills for one person. In this respect, belonging to a strong organization as CAFS allows for having support from other departments within the institution in administration or communication tasks as happened in this project. This enables to better balance technical skills, project management and soft skills required.
Il progetto "Alimentazione controllata di insilati di mais nelle razioni alimentari dei bovini", finanziata nell'ambito della sottomisura 16.2 dell'EIP-AGRI, è stato guidato e coordinato da un consulente della Camera dell'Agricoltura e delle Foreste della Slovenia (CAFS). Il progetto è nato da un'idea di un agricoltore, ma il consulente ha dato la spinta che ha fatto progredire l'idea fino alla sua realizzazione, iniziando dalla costituzione del partenariato.
Il consulente si è occupato dei finanziamenti e scritto la proposta (con la continua supervisione e messa a punto dei partner). Ha aiutato il gruppo a costruire una visione comune sugli obiettivi del progetto, a stabilire i principali obiettivi da raggiungere e a definire chiaramente i ruoli dei partner.
Egli ha svolto un ruolo fondamentale anche nell'incoraggiare e motivare i partner a rispettare gli obiettivi e le scadenze.
Il supporto offerto dal consulente ha richiesto un'ampia gamma di competenze diverse, da quelle tecniche (professionali, relative all'argomento) a quelle "amministrative" (scrittura della proposta, conoscenza dei fondi e della loro applicazione, stesura di relazioni...) e "sociali" (fiducia, risoluzione dei conflitti, capacità di facilitazione, collegamento con esperti, enti di finanziamento, pubblica amministrazione...). Si tratta di molti compiti/competenze per una sola persona. A questo proposito, l'appartenenza a un'organizzazione forte come il CAFS permette di avere il supporto di altri dipartimenti all'interno dell'istituzione in compiti di amministrazione o comunicazione, come è accaduto in questo progetto. Ciò consente di bilanciare meglio le competenze tecniche, la gestione del progetto e le competenze trasversali richieste.
As with all change management and strategic developments in the corporate world, effective communications both internally and externally in interactive innovation cases are vital and the good practice in interactive innovations projects is that this is planned and managed throughout the project. It is crucial to have a leader who can mobilize people, facilitate open discussion and ensure knowledge exchange among all involved parties. It enables the whole project community to move forward and ultimately achieve a greater impact as they share the same goal and are committed of using a variety of already well-established communication tools and channels. The risk of difficulties and conflicts arises when the involved actors do not share the same expectations and have insufficient or irregular communication. Different actors need to listen to each other, discuss their own ideas to find and agree on a common view and understanding. Framers make the difference since they have a real need to share ideas, experiment, communicate to find solutions. Researchers, advisors, and others have different interests when joining an innovation project. The main challenge still remains to find a common view/interest, redefine each actor's own expectations (less satisfying but can lead to something new). A clear benefit is that projects are more likely to overcome resistance when people share experiences they feel at the idea or solution came from themselves. There is nothing like a good debate among peers to help people change their minds. A good facilitator sets a higher standard of learning by listening, seeing, doing, and telling. Good communications also help actors to see their problems through others eyes which is part of the solution to most problems.
As with all change management and strategic developments in the corporate world, effective communications both internally and externally in interactive innovation cases are vital and the good practice in interactive innovations projects is that this is planned and managed throughout the project. It is crucial to have a leader who can mobilize people, facilitate open discussion and ensure knowledge exchange among all involved parties. It enables the whole project community to move forward and ultimately achieve a greater impact as they share the same goal and are committed of using a variety of already well-established communication tools and channels. The risk of difficulties and conflicts arises when the involved actors do not share the same expectations and have insufficient or irregular communication. Different actors need to listen to each other, discuss their own ideas to find and agree on a common view and understanding. Framers make the difference since they have a real need to share ideas, experiment, communicate to find solutions. Researchers, advisors, and others have different interests when joining an innovation project. The main challenge still remains to find a common view/interest, redefine each actor's own expectations (less satisfying but can lead to something new). A clear benefit is that projects are more likely to overcome resistance when people share experiences they feel at the idea or solution came from themselves. There is nothing like a good debate among peers to help people change their minds. A good facilitator sets a higher standard of learning by listening, seeing, doing, and telling. Good communications also help actors to see their problems through others eyes which is part of the solution to most problems.
The Italian National Rural Network (NRN) is well embedded within the AKISs as it plays a key role in innovation support services since the programming period 2007-2013. A working group of around 30 experts is organized by fields of expertise and territorial basis. This allows embracing several types of actions to support policy design and implementation along with promoting effective participation of the plurality of AKISs’ actors at different levels (national, regional and sub-regional). The promotion of innovation in agriculture, food, forestry and rural areas is one out of four priorities of the NRN and it strongly relates to the EIP-Agri implementation, particularly by:
• Networking, demand articulation and facilitation of knowledge flows and exchange among the different AKIS’s across rural areas and related sectors.
• methodological and operational support and institutional intermediation on policy design and implementation on AKIS- related interventions: training and information; cooperation for innovation and advisory services.
• information, communication and dissemination about research and innovation in agriculture, including the operational groups (OGs).
• Provision of advisory and training tools and materials.
• Research, monitoring, statistics and evaluation of policy implementation, innovation approaches and cases.
For the CAP 2023-2027, the NRN played a crucial role in supporting policy makers through promoting common reflection, mediating dialogue, at national and regional level, in order to achieve a shared vision about the AKIS strategy and related intervention logics
La Rete Rurale Nazionale (RRN) italiana è ben inserita all'interno degli AKIS in quanto svolge un ruolo chiave nei servizi di supporto all'innovazione dalla programmazione 2007-2013. Un gruppo di circa 30 esperti è organizzato per settori di competenza e base territoriale. Ciò consente di abbracciare diversi tipi di azioni per sostenere la progettazione e l'attuazione delle politiche, oltre a promuovere l'effettiva partecipazione della pluralità di attori degli AKIS a diversi livelli (nazionale, regionale e sub-regionale). La promozione dell'innovazione nell'agricoltura, nell'alimentazione, nella silvicoltura e nelle aree rurali è una delle quattro priorità della RRN ed è fortemente correlata all'attuazione del PEI-Agri, in particolare attraverso:
- la creazione di reti, l'articolazione della domanda e la facilitazione dei flussi di conoscenza e dello scambio tra i diversi AKIS nelle aree rurali e nei settori correlati.
- supporto metodologico e operativo e intermediazione istituzionale per la progettazione e l'attuazione delle politiche AKIS: formazione e informazione; cooperazione per l'innovazione e servizi di consulenza.
- informazione, comunicazione e divulgazione sulla ricerca e l'innovazione in agricoltura, compresi i GO.
- Fornitura di strumenti e materiali di consulenza e formazione.
- Ricerca, monitoraggio, statistiche e valutazione dell'attuazione delle politiche, degli approcci e dei casi di innovazione.
Per la PAC 2023-27, la RRN ha svolto un ruolo cruciale nel sostenere i decisori politici attraverso la promozione di una riflessione comune, mediando il dialogo, a livello nazionale e regionale, al fine di raggiungere una visione condivisa della strategia AKIS e delle logiche di intervento.
One of the i2connect practical cases is the InnoTour Bayern, which aims to bring more practice into applied research and to highlight innovation in rural Bavaria. Through the tour, science, practice, entrepreneurs, and advisors are brought together in different Stations of an innovation roadshow, focusing on different challenging topics in the rural area. The topics and concrete practical innovation cases were selected in a Bavarian-wide competition. The layout of the InnoTour Station Events is a Co-Creation approach, where researchers are connected with practitioners, advisors, and enterprises in a new interactive workshop format. Researchers are asked to not present research results but to contribute in the interactive workshop at eye-level with farmers, advisors, and representatives of society. The first InnoTour Station was dealing with Humus build-up in the soil. The Agricultural Administration with its State Research and Advisory Service has been accepted as a neutral player free from commercial interest. Unfortunately, the Covid pandemia led to a 1-year delay in starting the InnoTour. The Advisory Service played an important role in this project because they participated in the selection of the practice cases for the InnoTour in a competition and is involved in organising the individual Station events. Moreover, advisors and Farmers’ School teachers became crucial in spreading results from the InnoTour Events.
One of the i2connect practical cases is the InnoTour Bayern, which aims to bring more practice into applied research and to highlight innovation in rural Bavaria. Through the tour, science, practice, entrepreneurs, and advisors are brought together in different Stations of an innovation roadshow, focusing on different challenging topics in the rural area. The topics and concrete practical innovation cases were selected in a Bavarian-wide competition. The layout of the InnoTour Station Events is a Co-Creation approach, where researchers are connected with practitioners, advisors, and enterprises in a new interactive workshop format. Researchers are asked to not present research results but to contribute in the interactive workshop at eye-level with farmers, advisors, and representatives of society. The first InnoTour Station was dealing with Humus build-up in the soil. The Agricultural Administration with its State Research and Advisory Service has been accepted as a neutral player free from commercial interest. Unfortunately, the Covid pandemia led to a 1-year delay in starting the InnoTour. The Advisory Service played an important role in this project because they participated in the selection of the practice cases for the InnoTour in a competition and is involved in organising the individual Station events. Moreover, advisors and Farmers’ School teachers became crucial in spreading results from the InnoTour Events.
One of the practical cases on which i2connect project focused on is the operational group ‘Mobile Slaughter Unit’ (MSU). The aim of the project was to create a mobile slaughter unit to improve animal welfare and strengthen short supply chain, considering the problems related to find an (organic-certified) slaughterhouse at an accessible distance. In fact, smaller slaughterhouses have closed and larger slaughterhouses are often not equipped to slaughter a smaller number of animals. The long distances that have to be covered with the animals are a sticking point for many farmers and consumers. The final meat quality is also negatively affected by the animals’ stress associated with transport. The interactive innovation process allowed to found a solution for slaughtering small quantities of poultry on the farm. This makes it possible for small farmers to grow and commercialize a small number of poultry, special strains, or production methods that do not fit in industrial poultry production and processing. There is a small but clear market demand for this type of product and short food supply chains. Based on the above results a MSU for poultry may seem the most feasible, both financially, technically, and within the regulatory framework. Therefore a technical and business plan has been developed by an investor and operator to put a MSU for poultry into practice in 2022 in Flanders. Probably the most important success factor of the project was that partners worked together with several institutions, companies and people, all of them with their own expertise. The shared knowledge was vital to find solutions. On the other hand, the most difficult aspect has been meeting the legal requirements mostly focused on large-scale and non-mobile slaughterhouses.
One of the practical cases on which i2connect project focused on is the operational group ‘Mobile Slaughter Unit’ (MSU). The aim of the project was to create a mobile slaughter unit to improve animal welfare and strengthen short supply chain, considering the problems related to find an (organic-certified) slaughterhouse at an accessible distance. In fact, smaller slaughterhouses have closed and larger slaughterhouses are often not equipped to slaughter a smaller number of animals. The long distances that have to be covered with the animals are a sticking point for many farmers and consumers. The final meat quality is also negatively affected by the animals’ stress associated with transport. The interactive innovation process allowed to found a solution for slaughtering small quantities of poultry on the farm. This makes it possible for small farmers to grow and commercialize a small number of poultry, special strains, or production methods that do not fit in industrial poultry production and processing. There is a small but clear market demand for this type of product and short food supply chains. Based on the above results a MSU for poultry may seem the most feasible, both financially, technically, and within the regulatory framework. Therefore a technical and business plan has been developed by an investor and operator to put a MSU for poultry into practice in 2022 in Flanders. Probably the most important success factor of the project was that partners worked together with several institutions, companies and people, all of them with their own expertise. The shared knowledge was vital to find solutions. On the other hand, the most difficult aspect has been meeting the legal requirements mostly focused on large-scale and non-mobile slaughterhouses.
One of the practical cases analyzed in i2connect project is the Round table for biodiversity in Landshut (Germany). The idea of a round table was initiated by the local field office of the Agricultural State Advisory Service (AELF Landshut), that play also the role of facilitator. The opportunity of the creation of such an initiative was given by the Agricultural Ministry that set “Biodiversity” as an advisory priority for 2019 and 2020. Considering this priority and the lack of debate and discussion between environmental activists and farmers, that tend to discuss the respective other parties instead of discussing with each other and working together to find solutions for the ongoing decline of biodiversity, it was set up the Round Table for biodiversity, as part of the local strategy of implementing the new advisory focus. In the meantime, the state-wide referendum “save the bees” dominated the debate. The advisors played a crucial role in establishing the trust among the usually opposing groups. The mission of the round table has been elaborated in a workshop and then, common activities have been developed and realized.
At the Round Table Biodiversity Landshut, for the first time, local environmental activists and farmers discuss together practical solutions for the decline of biodiversity and loss of species in the agricultural landscape, instead of blaming each other. The forum was initiated in 2019 and it is still “alive”, maybe because the actors valued the possibility to learn a lot from each other. The State Advisory Service is accepted as a competent and neutral partner from both sides – environmentalists and farmers.
One of the practical cases analyzed in i2connect project is the Round table for biodiversity in Landshut (Germany). The idea of a round table was initiated by the local field office of the Agricultural State Advisory Service (AELF Landshut), that play also the role of facilitator. The opportunity of the creation of such an initiative was given by the Agricultural Ministry that set “Biodiversity” as an advisory priority for 2019 and 2020. Considering this priority and the lack of debate and discussion between environmental activists and farmers, that tend to discuss the respective other parties instead of discussing with each other and working together to find solutions for the ongoing decline of biodiversity, it was set up the Round Table for biodiversity, as part of the local strategy of implementing the new advisory focus. In the meantime, the state-wide referendum “save the bees” dominated the debate. The advisors played a crucial role in establishing the trust among the usually opposing groups. The mission of the round table has been elaborated in a workshop and then, common activities have been developed and realized.
At the Round Table Biodiversity Landshut, for the first time, local environmental activists and farmers discuss together practical solutions for the decline of biodiversity and loss of species in the agricultural landscape, instead of blaming each other. The forum was initiated in 2019 and it is still “alive”, maybe because the actors valued the possibility to learn a lot from each other. The State Advisory Service is accepted as a competent and neutral partner from both sides – environmentalists and farmers.
The Schneiderbauer spice cinema is one of the selected i2connect practical cases. The innovative idea, maily supported by LEADER, was to integrate a spice cinema into an old stable vault, allowing to have a multimedia experience that focuses on the craft.
The aim of the project is to show visitors the exciting path from cultivation to harvesting to processing of the spice plants. A film and a photo documentary have been made for this purpose. In addition, showcases, display objects, special lighting effects and seating offer visitors a special experience.
Because of the new construction and extension of the warehouse and the production building, the vault in the old stable building has become free. Due to the increasing number of visitors (pensioners’ groups, student groups, farmers’ associations, women’s groups, company groups, etc.), the idea arose to increase the offer accordingly and to use the space to set up a spice cinema. The conversion of the excursion room into a spice cinema enabled the farm offering to visitors a unique experience. In addition to presenting the company, the focus is on the spices produced and raising awareness of the importance of agricultural work and the Austrian economy. The cinema has already been visited by many people and there continues to be a good booking situation, although the Spice Cinema project has not yet been very intensively promoted to the public.
In the future, the spice cinema will be an experience for even more visitors, which will also be promoted through intensive marketing measures in newspapers, on the homepage, with tour operators, technical schools and on social media platforms.
The Schneiderbauer spice cinema is one of the selected i2connect practical cases. The innovative idea, maily supported by LEADER, was to integrate a spice cinema into an old stable vault, allowing to have a multimedia experience that focuses on the craft.
The aim of the project is to show visitors the exciting path from cultivation to harvesting to processing of the spice plants. A film and a photo documentary have been made for this purpose. In addition, showcases, display objects, special lighting effects and seating offer visitors a special experience.
Because of the new construction and extension of the warehouse and the production building, the vault in the old stable building has become free. Due to the increasing number of visitors (pensioners’ groups, student groups, farmers’ associations, women’s groups, company groups, etc.), the idea arose to increase the offer accordingly and to use the space to set up a spice cinema. The conversion of the excursion room into a spice cinema enabled the farm offering to visitors a unique experience. In addition to presenting the company, the focus is on the spices produced and raising awareness of the importance of agricultural work and the Austrian economy. The cinema has already been visited by many people and there continues to be a good booking situation, although the Spice Cinema project has not yet been very intensively promoted to the public.
In the future, the spice cinema will be an experience for even more visitors, which will also be promoted through intensive marketing measures in newspapers, on the homepage, with tour operators, technical schools and on social media platforms.
The Haller Forest Nature Trail project is one of the practical case analyzed and selected in i2connect project. It is an example of multi-actor approach and co-creation process. The idea of a forest nature trail was initially built in 1992 through the initiative of the municipality of Adlwang, but after 23 years, a redesign process for the "Hallerwald" recreation area was initiated. Advisory services played a crucial role in exploring funding options, collaborating with stakeholders, and providing guidance throughout the project. Following discussions and brainstorming, the name "Hallerwald Erholung.Kraft.Weitblick" (Hallerwald Recreation.Strength.Vision) was chosen, and a search for a skilled planner was conducted. All landowners, neighbors, and project partners were invited to a presentation where ideas and suggestions were discussed and incorporated into the planning. Further preliminary planning and cost estimation took place over the summer of 2017. The project received funding approval, and construction proceeded in small-scale phases. Despite efforts, it became clear that completing the project by the end of 2019 was not realistic, but an extension was granted. As the popularity of visiting the Hallerwald grew, challenges emerged, such as the need for additional signage and facilities. The redesign focused on the concept of "forest bathing" to stimulate visitors' senses and strengthen their connection with nature. The project's success was driven by the increasing support and cooperation of the local community and various associations.
The Haller Forest Nature Trail project is one of the practical case analyzed and selected in i2connect project. It is an example of multi-actor approach and co-creation process. The idea of a forest nature trail was initially built in 1992 through the initiative of the municipality of Adlwang, but after 23 years, a redesign process for the "Hallerwald" recreation area was initiated. Advisory services played a crucial role in exploring funding options, collaborating with stakeholders, and providing guidance throughout the project. Following discussions and brainstorming, the name "Hallerwald Erholung.Kraft.Weitblick" (Hallerwald Recreation.Strength.Vision) was chosen, and a search for a skilled planner was conducted. All landowners, neighbors, and project partners were invited to a presentation where ideas and suggestions were discussed and incorporated into the planning. Further preliminary planning and cost estimation took place over the summer of 2017. The project received funding approval, and construction proceeded in small-scale phases. Despite efforts, it became clear that completing the project by the end of 2019 was not realistic, but an extension was granted. As the popularity of visiting the Hallerwald grew, challenges emerged, such as the need for additional signage and facilities. The redesign focused on the concept of "forest bathing" to stimulate visitors' senses and strengthen their connection with nature. The project's success was driven by the increasing support and cooperation of the local community and various associations.
At the end of April 2023, advisors from agriculture and forestry met for a i2connect Cross Visit in Bavaria. Using the example of the FInAL project "Promotion of Insects in Agricultural Landscapes", the participants carried out an innovation analysis. FInAL is a large nationwide project involving researchers of different scientific disciplines, farmers and other partners in three different regions in Germany. What is special about FInAL is that scientists and farmers develop the insect-promoting measures together in a co-design process and testing them in landscape labs. The video realized in i2connect project and available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rcZz30Z3d8A presents the project and the most important results of the project analysis by the participants of the Cross Visit.
At the end of April 2023, advisors from agriculture and forestry met for a i2connect Cross Visit in Bavaria. Using the example of the FInAL project "Promotion of Insects in Agricultural Landscapes", the participants carried out an innovation analysis. FInAL is a large nationwide project involving researchers of different scientific disciplines, farmers and other partners in three different regions in Germany. What is special about FInAL is that scientists and farmers develop the insect-promoting measures together in a co-design process and testing them in landscape labs. The video realized in i2connect project and available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rcZz30Z3d8A presents the project and the most important results of the project analysis by the participants of the Cross Visit.
With the relevant exception of the Alpine regions, forests has been long time neglected in Italy, since they have lost economic relevance. Nowadays, forests have gained importance, mostly for environmental reasons, thus there is the need of a qualified know how, that so far has been lacking, to support the rising of a new interest in their management.
The “For.Italy” project, developed as an action of the National Rural Network Programme, can be considered the first attempt of a unified training in the forestry sector, trying to standardize operators competences in a sector in which training in the field is very different from region to region (from nihil to excellence). It involves 9 Italian regions led by Piemonte (Piemonte, Basilicata, Calabria, Liguria, Lombardy, Sardinia, Sicily, Tuscany and Veneto), but has been developed with the active contribution of all the other Italian regions.
Its main result will be a getting to a bunch of people, ready for work in their regions, with a standardized set of competencies ready to be transferred to local workers that in the end will result in more qualified manpower.
As part of the project, starting from 2021, 6 demonstration and information sites on forestry training and 7 training courses for Forestry Instructors in felling and preparation will be carried out with the aim of training 90 new forestry instructors who can be employed throughout the country in the implementation of training courses in forestry promoted at regional level. Demonstration sites were aimed not only at forest workers (at all levels: lumberjacks, foresters, civil employees) but also public administrators, students of secondary and university level courses in agriculture and forestry sciences.
Il progetto For.Italy, sviluppato come azione del Programma Rete Rurale Nazionale, si basa sulla collaborazione tra le diverse Regioni italiane e rappresenta il primo e importante risultato della cooperazione interistituzionale attivata grazie al "Testo Unico sulle foreste e sulle filiere forestali" (D.Lgs. 34/2018).
Il progetto, che coinvolge 9 Regioni con capofila il Piemonte (Piemonte, Basilicata, Calabria, Liguria, Lombardia, Sardegna, Sicilia, Toscana e Veneto), ma è stato sviluppato con il contributo attivo di tutte le altre amministrazioni regionali che ne hanno condiviso le finalità, beneficeranno comunque dei suoi risultati, vuole proporre a livello nazionale i migliori e più efficaci strumenti e le migliori pratiche che hanno contribuito localmente alla definizione di una più efficiente e sostenibile organizzazione dei lavori forestali, con l'obiettivo di sostenere l'attuazione su tutto il territorio nazionale del Decreto Ministeriale sulla Formazione Forestale (D. D. 4472 del 29.04.2020) e promuovere la diffusa ed efficace attuazione delle misure cofinanziate con il fondo FEASR per il prossimo periodo di programmazione.
Nell'ambito del progetto, a partire dal 2021, saranno realizzati 6 cantieri dimostrativi e informativi sulla formazione forestale e 7 corsi di formazione per Istruttori forestali in abbattimento e preparazione (distribuiti uniformemente nel Nord, Centro, Sud Italia e Isole principali) con l'obiettivo di formare 90 nuovi istruttori forestali che potranno essere impiegati su tutto il territorio nazionale nella realizzazione di corsi di formazione in ambito forestale promossi a livello regionale.
Providing opportunities for social and informal interaction among partners is a good way to improve the performance of both advisors and farmers, reducing anxiety and fuelling the search for new and better idea. To reach this goal, advisors should create a safe, trustworthy environment to share in depth information and experiences (both successes and failures) and on farm practices. Key factors for a successful social interaction are i) the advisor’s sensitivity for group processes combined with general knowledge of the topic at hand, ii) knowing which people to invite and how they match within a group; iii) keeping the balance between the responsibility of the group members and the intervening as the advisor. There are challenges in making sure the information is relevant for every partner, and the timing of this information being shared. The correct time in which ‘new information’ is encountered, there is a certain level of symmetric information exchange between partners, creating an atmosphere of mutual respect. Farmers may also encounter challenges in discussing one's own experiences in a group scenario which can be helped where there is social dimension.
Providing opportunities for social and informal interaction among partners is a good way to improve the performance of both advisors and farmers, reducing anxiety and fuelling the search for new and better idea. To reach this goal, advisors should create a safe, trustworthy environment to share in depth information and experiences (both successes and failures) and on farm practices. Key factors for a successful social interaction are i) the advisor’s sensitivity for group processes combined with general knowledge of the topic at hand, ii) knowing which people to invite and how they match within a group; iii) keeping the balance between the responsibility of the group members and the intervening as the advisor. There are challenges in making sure the information is relevant for every partner, and the timing of this information being shared. The correct time in which ‘new information’ is encountered, there is a certain level of symmetric information exchange between partners, creating an atmosphere of mutual respect. Farmers may also encounter challenges in discussing one's own experiences in a group scenario which can be helped where there is social dimension.
During the Italian i2connect training course, it has been presented and analyzed the advisory services roadmap, organized jointly by the farmer based organization "CIA" and the Council for Agricultural Research and Economics. The project main goal is developing innovations in the agri-food, forestry and environmental system, favouring aggregation within the agri-food supply chain on one hand and the interaction of young entrepreneurs with the world of research on the other. In particular, the initiative aims at boosting the direct involvement of farmers and their cooperatives and organizations in the design process of innovations, as well as supporting farmers in management and economic assessment of operational choices. The young farmers of the Association have the opportunity to discuss with CREA researchers, during the visits in the various centres and experimental farms, to learn first-hand about available innovations in the various agricultural sectors and, at the same time, to express their research needs.This road map allowed to 41,000 young farmers of Agia-Cia to information and training activities, to create partnerships and to be inspired by the research activities carried out in the 72 CREA centers, based in 19 Italian regions. There have been realized events in several Italian regions (such as Emilia Romagna, Marche, Sicily) to direct involved young farmers in this process.
During the Italian i2connect training course, it has been presented and analyzed the advisory services roadmap, organized jointly by the farmer based organization "CIA" and the Council for Agricultural Research and Economics. The project main goal is developing innovations in the agri-food, forestry and environmental system, favouring aggregation within the agri-food supply chain on one hand and the interaction of young entrepreneurs with the world of research on the other. In particular, the initiative aims at boosting the direct involvement of farmers and their cooperatives and organizations in the design process of innovations, as well as supporting farmers in management and economic assessment of operational choices. The young farmers of the Association have the opportunity to discuss with CREA researchers, during the visits in the various centres and experimental farms, to learn first-hand about available innovations in the various agricultural sectors and, at the same time, to express their research needs.This road map allowed to 41,000 young farmers of Agia-Cia to information and training activities, to create partnerships and to be inspired by the research activities carried out in the 72 CREA centers, based in 19 Italian regions. There have been realized events in several Italian regions (such as Emilia Romagna, Marche, Sicily) to direct involved young farmers in this process.
Continuous Professional Development (CPD) is essential as basic training and learning is not sufficient to support a long-term career due to the frequency of change in both hard and soft skills. Advisors may not only need technological or practical skills (hard skills), but may need training in the area of soft skills such as facilitation practices, networking, problem solving etc. Advisors who are professionally and methodologically trained with the basic knowledge, skills and attitude may enhance relationship building and trust within his or her environment. Within peer reviews, advisors identified the lack of training or support resources available, and actively pursued their own self development through training and access to information. This knowledge and or methodological skills may build confidence of the advisor. Through upskilling, advisors were able to provide farmers with the technical information needed for the innovation project, as well as the soft skills needed to facilitate this which was hugely satisfying. When managing and disseminating interactive innovations, it may be important for advisors to be skilled and confident in facilitation techniques. This may be implemented through training workshops and courses, self-directed learning, institutional support materials, practice, networking and many other ways.
Continuous Professional Development (CPD) is essential as basic training and learning is not sufficient to support a long-term career due to the frequency of change in both hard and soft skills. Advisors may not only need technological or practical skills (hard skills), but may need training in the area of soft skills such as facilitation practices, networking, problem solving etc. Advisors who are professionally and methodologically trained with the basic knowledge, skills and attitude may enhance relationship building and trust within his or her environment. Within peer reviews, advisors identified the lack of training or support resources available, and actively pursued their own self development through training and access to information. This knowledge and or methodological skills may build confidence of the advisor. Through upskilling, advisors were able to provide farmers with the technical information needed for the innovation project, as well as the soft skills needed to facilitate this which was hugely satisfying. When managing and disseminating interactive innovations, it may be important for advisors to be skilled and confident in facilitation techniques. This may be implemented through training workshops and courses, self-directed learning, institutional support materials, practice, networking and many other ways.
What does cross-visit mean exactly, and how does it differ from an exchange of experiences? Of course, participants in this case also share their experiences and engage in active discussions. However, the idea of a cross-visit is that during this experience, participants reinforce the knowledge they acquired during their training about interactive innovation methods. This means that while visiting various projects, participants put their heads together to think about interesting solutions to existing challenges within presented initiatives. The Latvian cross visit was hosted by LRATC, the biggest rural advisory organization in Latvia that provides support, guidance, and training to farmers, rural entrepreneurs, and other individuals involved in rural development. At the moment LRATC employs around 430 employees who work all across the country in 26 branch offices and in the central office in Ozolnieki. The Latvian cross visit was focus on the main agricultural crops grown in Latvia, that include grains such as wheat, barley, oats, and rye. Other important crops include potatoes, rapeseed, and various vegetables. Latvia is also known for its high-quality organic farming and the production of organic crops. Livestock farming is an essential component of Latvia’s agricultural sector. Dairy farming is particularly prominent, with Latvian dairy products being well-regarded. Other livestock raised in the country include pigs, poultry, sheep, and cattle. In addition, the Latvian government places importance on rural development, aiming to support sustainable agriculture, improve infrastructure, and promote innovation in the sector. Funding programs and subsidies are available to support farmers, enhance productivity, and protect the environment.
What does cross-visit mean exactly, and how does it differ from an exchange of experiences? Of course, participants in this case also share their experiences and engage in active discussions. However, the idea of a cross-visit is that during this experience, participants reinforce the knowledge they acquired during their training about interactive innovation methods. This means that while visiting various projects, participants put their heads together to think about interesting solutions to existing challenges within presented initiatives. The Latvian cross visit was hosted by LRATC, the biggest rural advisory organization in Latvia that provides support, guidance, and training to farmers, rural entrepreneurs, and other individuals involved in rural development. At the moment LRATC employs around 430 employees who work all across the country in 26 branch offices and in the central office in Ozolnieki. The Latvian cross visit was focus on the main agricultural crops grown in Latvia, that include grains such as wheat, barley, oats, and rye. Other important crops include potatoes, rapeseed, and various vegetables. Latvia is also known for its high-quality organic farming and the production of organic crops. Livestock farming is an essential component of Latvia’s agricultural sector. Dairy farming is particularly prominent, with Latvian dairy products being well-regarded. Other livestock raised in the country include pigs, poultry, sheep, and cattle. In addition, the Latvian government places importance on rural development, aiming to support sustainable agriculture, improve infrastructure, and promote innovation in the sector. Funding programs and subsidies are available to support farmers, enhance productivity, and protect the environment.
There is a changing structure of the agricultural sector that also makes new demands on farmers’ entrepreneurial skills. As a result, the way of thinking about innovation and knowledge transfer started to change, and thus also the view on agricultural extension and advisory services. The purpose of this document is to identify the ‘innovation advisor’ and provide a repository of required skills and competencies. A thorough literature study formed the starting point but also an interview guide for semi-structured interviews was created and sent to members of the consortium for their input and feedback. Interviews were conducted with both members from inside the i2connect consortium, as well as with external experts.
As a wide array of terminology is being used to what we, in i2connect, refer to as ‘the innovation advisor’, several different views in terminology are presented. An overview is given of the functions and contributions, as well as the various types and paradoxes in the functioning of innovation intermediaries. The identified personal competences of the innovation advisor were analysed and sorted using the structure ‘Qualifications of an advisor’ by Gerster-Bentaya et al. (2009).
Apart from the competencies of innovation advisors on the personal level, responsibilities and requirements for the organisational level were also identified. Three responsibilities emerged (creating a safe space, creating a challenging space and stimulate learning and looking beyond borders.), under which several requirements were clustered.
Finally, the implications for policy making were described.
Er is een veranderende structuur van de landbouwsector die ook nieuwe eisen stelt aan de ondernemersvaardigheden van landbouwers. Als gevolg daarvan veranderde de manier van denken over innovatie en kennisoverdracht, en dus ook de kijk op landbouwvoorlichting en -adviesdiensten. Het doel van dit document is om de 'innovatieadviseur' te identificeren en een overzicht van vereiste vaardigheden en competenties te bieden.
Een grondige literatuurstudie vormde het uitgangspunt, maar er werd ook een interviewgids voor semi-gestructureerde interviews opgesteld en naar de leden van het consortium gestuurd voor hun input en feedback. Interviews werden gehouden met zowel leden binnen het i2connect consortium, als met externe experts.
Aangezien er een breed scala aan terminologie wordt gebruikt voor wat we in i2connect 'de innovatieadviseur' noemen, worden er verschillende visies op terminologie gepresenteerd. Er wordt een overzicht gegeven van de functies en bijdragen, alsook van de verschillende types en paradoxen in het functioneren van innovatie-intermediairs. De geïdentificeerde persoonlijke competenties van de innovatieadviseur zijn geanalyseerd en gesorteerd aan de hand van de structuur 'Kwalificaties van een adviseur' van Gerster-Bentaya et al. (2009).
Naast de competenties van innovatieadviseurs op persoonlijk niveau, werden ook verantwoordelijkheden en eisen voor het organisatieniveau geïdentificeerd. Drie verantwoordelijkheden kwamen naar voren (het creëren van een veilige ruimte, het creëren van een uitdagende ruimte en het stimuleren van leren en over grenzen kijken), waaronder verschillende vereisten werden geclusterd.
Tot slot werden de implicaties voor de beleidsvorming beschreven.
Interactive innovation needs to be adapted to the context of each country. This is because each country has a different AKIS, institutions, extension services and culture. This is the general idea of Nevena Alexandrova Stepanova (from FAO) which shares her experience in a i2connect project video, that deals with strengthening agricultural extension services in Azerbaijan. The FAO team decided to start with a simple approach called commodity-based extension platforms. These platforms were based, for example, on tomatoes, sunflowers, or various fruits. Then they asked farmers about their problems. They focused on a specific problem that the group had to solve together with a facilitator. The facilitator was not an official advisor, but an experienced farmer who had sufficient knowledge, was well connected and was accepted by the group. As part of the project, the farmers received training as facilitators. After solving one problem, the groups turned to a new problem to solve. The lessons from the interactive innovation cases in Azerbaijan were: the need to consider the context, to start small and simple, to cultivate the spirit of collaboration, to slowly increase the capacity of farmers and extension workers, and to focus especially on training facilitators. It was also important to act at the policy level to institutionalize the interactive innovation methods used.
The participating farmers were able to significantly increase their income and enjoyed participating in the platforms and creating something together. Interactive innovation groups were set up in pilot regions to improve access to services and enable rapid implementation.
Interactive innovation needs to be adapted to the context of each country. This is because each country has a different AKIS, institutions, extension services and culture. This is the general idea of Nevena Alexandrova Stepanova (from FAO) which shares her experience in a i2connect project video, that deals with strengthening agricultural extension services in Azerbaijan. The FAO team decided to start with a simple approach called commodity-based extension platforms. These platforms were based, for example, on tomatoes, sunflowers, or various fruits. Then they asked farmers about their problems. They focused on a specific problem that the group had to solve together with a facilitator. The facilitator was not an official advisor, but an experienced farmer who had sufficient knowledge, was well connected and was accepted by the group. As part of the project, the farmers received training as facilitators. After solving one problem, the groups turned to a new problem to solve. The lessons from the interactive innovation cases in Azerbaijan were: the need to consider the context, to start small and simple, to cultivate the spirit of collaboration, to slowly increase the capacity of farmers and extension workers, and to focus especially on training facilitators. It was also important to act at the policy level to institutionalize the interactive innovation methods used.
The participating farmers were able to significantly increase their income and enjoyed participating in the platforms and creating something together. Interactive innovation groups were set up in pilot regions to improve access to services and enable rapid implementation.
RAMONES-PL (Rural Advisory Monitoring and Evaluation System linked to Precision Learning) is an ERASMUS+ project that aims to strengthen rural advisory services based on management, monitoring and evaluation methods and tool designed to support performance assessment and precision learning until the definition of total quality certification scheme. The project is characterized by an overall end-user driven and transdisciplinary approach reflected by a partnership mostly composed by advisory organizations and using cross-fertilization of tacit and codified knowledge to design robust and evidence-based assessment methodologies on advisors’ performances and competences.
The project is on-going and it already delivered some useful and ready-to-be-put-in-use tools for advisors:
• a Rural Advisory Services dictionary of competences: a tool that covers competences needed to perform specific tasks and CAP topics, based on capacities that are common to an organization and the related indicators to monitor such competences;
• an e-Learning Platform containing a series of e-learning packages tailored to the need of field advisors, according to the preliminary data collection steps of the project, such as the identification of the most frequent activities, the dictionary of competence, and the questionnaire to access importance and proficiency level of advisors regarding certain service areas;
• a tracking and monitoring platform of advisory activities, a tool to timely keep log, monitor and assess performances of advisors based on robust scientific quality standards. It enables clients feedback, work-based learning and knowledge-based development of precision e-learning programmes.
RAMONES-PL (Rural Advisory Monitoring and Evaluation System linked to Precision Learning) is an ERASMUS+ project that aims to strengthen rural advisory services based on management, monitoring and evaluation methods and tool designed to support performance assessment and precision learning until the definition of total quality certification scheme. The project is characterized by an overall end-user driven and transdisciplinary approach reflected by a partnership mostly composed by advisory organizations and using cross-fertilization of tacit and codified knowledge to design robust and evidence-based assessment methodologies on advisors’ performances and competences.
The project is on-going and it already delivered some useful and ready-to-be-put-in-use tools for advisors:
• a Rural Advisory Services dictionary of competences: a tool that covers competences needed to perform specific tasks and CAP topics, based on capacities that are common to an organization and the related indicators to monitor such competences;
• an e-Learning Platform containing a series of e-learning packages tailored to the need of field advisors, according to the preliminary data collection steps of the project, such as the identification of the most frequent activities, the dictionary of competence, and the questionnaire to access importance and proficiency level of advisors regarding certain service areas;
• a tracking and monitoring platform of advisory activities, a tool to timely keep log, monitor and assess performances of advisors based on robust scientific quality standards. It enables clients feedback, work-based learning and knowledge-based development of precision e-learning programmes.
The Innovation Support Team consists of four experts with complementary knowledge in Green Industries. Expertise in horticulture, plant cultivation, animal production, technology, and energy. When the EIP-Agri support was new, the Team played a more active role by meeting potential innovators and providing information about the support and the application process. This included marketing, particularly the support at various events, agricultural meetings, and fairs.
The current priority is to provide skills and knowledge to support actors in their application process and the development of their idea from the ground. The Innovation Team assists applicants in finding available research results, knowledge, and experiences concerning the innovative idea. The Team promotes knowledge exchange, creates synergies, and facilitates collaboration by suggesting potential partners and innovators. Among other things, connecting actors by supporting the universities in getting in touch with practitioners, and practitioners finding economic and technical collaborators for executing their innovative idea. The Team handles all received material and information about innovative ideas with confidentiality.
The Team supports applicants by answering incoming questions, providing information about the selection criteria, and what application requirements to meet. Finally, it assists applicants in formulating the application, but not in writing it (as a matter of fairness). The Team guides the application process, thus ensuring the project plan's credibility, and guaranteeing a competent group qualified to administrate, execute, and finance the project plan.
The Innovation Support Team consists of four experts with complementary knowledge in Green Industries. Expertise in horticulture, plant cultivation, animal production, technology, and energy. When the EIP-Agri support was new, the Team played a more active role by meeting potential innovators and providing information about the support and the application process. This included marketing, particularly the support at various events, agricultural meetings, and fairs.
The current priority is to provide skills and knowledge to support actors in their application process and the development of their idea from the ground. The Innovation Team assists applicants in finding available research results, knowledge, and experiences concerning the innovative idea. The Team promotes knowledge exchange, creates synergies, and facilitates collaboration by suggesting potential partners and innovators. Among other things, connecting actors by supporting the universities in getting in touch with practitioners, and practitioners finding economic and technical collaborators for executing their innovative idea. The Team handles all received material and information about innovative ideas with confidentiality.
The Team supports applicants by answering incoming questions, providing information about the selection criteria, and what application requirements to meet. Finally, it assists applicants in formulating the application, but not in writing it (as a matter of fairness). The Team guides the application process, thus ensuring the project plan's credibility, and guaranteeing a competent group qualified to administrate, execute, and finance the project plan.
SUAS is one of the 12 successful groups chosen from across Ireland under the new EIP initiative. The key objective of the five- year pilot is to develop practical and innovative solutions that will address the complex agricultural, environmental and socio- economic challenges associated with the land management of commonages and hill farms in the Wicklow/Dublin upland. The enclosed land in the Wicklow Dublin uplands is of high value for biodiversity and is of European conservation importance for habitats and birds.
The SUAS project is based around the idea of commonage management groups, which can be effective to deliver best practice management, a sustainable stocking rate and appropriate timing of grazing using proper breeds are needed to deliver best practice management of the uplands. To achieve this, ongoing knowledge exchange between advisors and farmers is needed for successful upland management. The main principles and ideas of the project are integrated into two SUAS Actions. 1) The establishment of Commonage Groups (CGs), with their own constitutions, which will take responsibility for the development, implementation and delivery of their own Commonage Management Plans (CMP); Development of CMPs, with the integration of environmental (biodiversity and water) and farming activities into a single document/guide. 2) The implementation, monitoring, updating and reporting of the CMP and Farm Management Plans, including the review of annual biodiversity performance data, the review of annual farm performance data and the review of water quality programme. The use of an auction-based payment scheme to incentivise the CGs to develop their own solutions to problems they identify on their commonage.
SUAS is one of the 12 successful groups chosen from across Ireland under the new EIP initiative. The key objective of the five- year pilot is to develop practical and innovative solutions that will address the complex agricultural, environmental and socio- economic challenges associated with the land management of commonages and hill farms in the Wicklow/Dublin upland. The enclosed land in the Wicklow Dublin uplands is of high value for biodiversity and is of European conservation importance for habitats and birds.
The SUAS project is based around the idea of commonage management groups, which can be effective to deliver best practice management, a sustainable stocking rate and appropriate timing of grazing using proper breeds are needed to deliver best practice management of the uplands. To achieve this, ongoing knowledge exchange between advisors and farmers is needed for successful upland management. The main principles and ideas of the project are integrated into two SUAS Actions. 1) The establishment of Commonage Groups (CGs), with their own constitutions, which will take responsibility for the development, implementation and delivery of their own Commonage Management Plans (CMP); Development of CMPs, with the integration of environmental (biodiversity and water) and farming activities into a single document/guide. 2) The implementation, monitoring, updating and reporting of the CMP and Farm Management Plans, including the review of annual biodiversity performance data, the review of annual farm performance data and the review of water quality programme. The use of an auction-based payment scheme to incentivise the CGs to develop their own solutions to problems they identify on their commonage.
Dan Technikes is an annual event, entirely managed by advisors, that was born from the idea of two people, an advisor and a farmer who are linked by a long-standing friendship. Travelling to neighbouring countries to learn about new technologies and keep their knowledge up to date, they came up with the idea of organising an event in Slovenia that would allow farmers to socialise, attend demonstrations and receive independent advice to know how (and which) technologies can improve farm performance and sustainability, before buying them. The idea was immediately supported, even financially, by the head manager of the public advisory service and the local municipal authority, as it met the community on the topic of environmental sustainability.
To achieve the defined goals, a variety of actors with different practical expertise and knowledge (farmers, researchers /academics and equipment suppliers/producers) has been involved, allowing multiple needs of farmers to be addressed. The novelty lies in that all of them are independent, meaning that no one is linked to companies producing equipment being demonstrated, and that the event is mainly focusd on peer-to-peer exchange. In this way, relationships of trust that go further than the demonstration event can be developed. This also allows farmers to actively contribute to the organisation of the event, expressing needs and ideas, even through advisors, and providing their own experience and equipment.
Dan Technikes è un evento annuale, interamente gestito da consulenti, che nasce dall'idea di due persone, un consulente e un agricoltore legati da una lunga amicizia. Viaggiando nei paesi vicini per conoscere le nuove tecnologie e mantenere aggiornate le loro conoscenze, hanno avuto l'idea di organizzare un evento in Slovenia che permettesse agli agricoltori di socializzare, assistere a dimostrazioni e ricevere una consulenza indipendente per sapere come (e quali) tecnologie possono migliorare le prestazioni e la sostenibilità della propria azienda, prima di acquistarle. L'idea è stata subito sostenuta, anche finanziariamente, dal responsabile del servizio pubblico di consulenza e dall'autorità comunale locale, in quanto incontra l'opinione pubblica sul tema della sostenibilità ambientale.
Per raggiungere gli obiettivi definiti, è stata coinvolta una varietà di attori con diverse conoscenze e competenze pratiche (agricoltori, ricercatori/accademici e fornitori/produttori di attrezzature), che consente di far fronte a molteplici esigenze degli agricoltori. La novità sta nel fatto che questi soggetti sono indipendenti, il che significa che nessuno è legato alle aziende che producono le attrezzature che sono oggetto di dimostrazione, e che l'evento è principalmente incentrato sullo scambio tra pari. Questo consente di sviluppare relazioni di fiducia che vanno oltre l'evento dimostrativo e permette agli agricoltori di contribuire attivamente all'organizzazione dell'evento, esprimendo esigenze e idee, direttamente o attraverso i consulenti, e mettendo a disposizione la propria esperienza e le proprie attrezzature.
In Sweden, applications for Project Support by operational groups are evaluated approximately 4-6 times per year by an External Advisory Committee (RÅK). The Committee consists of 7 external reviewers with different skills and complementary knowledge within Green Industries and the Innovation System. Under the leadership of the Swedish Board of Agriculture, RÅK reviews applications for Project Support and provides the Swedish Board of Agriculture with its recommendation for decision. RÅK does not have a decision-making mandate but gives advice. Experts can be member of the Committee as long as they want to, and their skills and knowledge are of use in the assessment process. Over the years, experts can leave, and new experts come for various reasons. The Swedish Board of Agriculture is also looking into the possibilities of procuring companies or organizations (which send a suitable person for the assessment).
Each member of RÅK performs an individual assessment of all the applications, without being in contact with other experts. Then, RÅK and the Swedish Board of Agriculture meet and discuss the individual assessments, and each member of RÅK explain and justify the assessments. Dialogues and discussions result in a joint assessment of each application.
The Committee rejects applications that lack of information about entering the market, that is a clear marketing plan, business plan, and potential customers description. If the Innovation Group does not have a marketing plan, the Committee assesses the project as an idea, not as an innovation. RÅK members examine the criteria concretely based on their expertise in the field and the submitted material and provide their perspectives on the application and innovation.
In Sweden, applications for Project Support by operational groups are evaluated approximately 4-6 times per year by an External Advisory Committee (RÅK). The Committee consists of 7 external reviewers with different skills and complementary knowledge within Green Industries and the Innovation System. Under the leadership of the Swedish Board of Agriculture, RÅK reviews applications for Project Support and provides the Swedish Board of Agriculture with its recommendation for decision. RÅK does not have a decision-making mandate but gives advice. Experts can be member of the Committee as long as they want to, and their skills and knowledge are of use in the assessment process. Over the years, experts can leave, and new experts come for various reasons. The Swedish Board of Agriculture is also looking into the possibilities of procuring companies or organizations (which send a suitable person for the assessment).
Each member of RÅK performs an individual assessment of all the applications, without being in contact with other experts. Then, RÅK and the Swedish Board of Agriculture meet and discuss the individual assessments, and each member of RÅK explain and justify the assessments. Dialogues and discussions result in a joint assessment of each application.
The Committee rejects applications that lack of information about entering the market, that is a clear marketing plan, business plan, and potential customers description. If the Innovation Group does not have a marketing plan, the Committee assesses the project as an idea, not as an innovation. RÅK members examine the criteria concretely based on their expertise in the field and the submitted material and provide their perspectives on the application and innovation.
The "Egg Drop Challenge" is a great team activity that involves collaboration, creativity and problem solving. The objective is to protect an egg from breaking when dropped from a high elevation (several meters). Each team by using only the limited materials provided, builds a structure to protect the egg so that it withstands such a fall. The materials required include: raw eggs, plastic straws, masking tape, newspaper and any other suitable material of choice.
This exercise was introduced in the context of a workshop on interactive innovation during the Kick-Off meeting of the i2connect consortium. After the exercise, a debriefing session was conducted during which members discussed what went well and what went wrong during the team exercise. Members were able to relate the group activity to an interactive innovation process and identified several key elements vital to successful outcome of the process such as shared understanding and vision of the goal and the task, mutual trust, commitment, facilitation, cooperation etc.
The activity was very useful to illustrate the interactive innovation process, to facilitate a creative working atmosphere and to enhance team spirit. The activity could be adapted and used in diverse contexts as a simple yet demonstrative exercise to facilitate understanding of the interactive innovation process.
Die "Eierfall-Herausforderung" ist eine großartige Teamaktivität, die Zusammenarbeit, Kreativität und Problemlösung erfordert. Die Aufgabe besteht darin, ein Ei vor dem Zerbrechen zu schützen, wenn es aus einer großen Höhe (mehrere Meter) fallen gelassen wird. Jedes Team baut mit den wenigen zur Verfügung gestellten Materialien eine Konstruktion, die das Ei so schützt, dass es einen solchen Fall übersteht. Zu den benötigten Materialien gehören: rohe Eier, Plastikstrohhalme, Klebeband, Zeitungspapier und andere geeignete Materialien nach Wahl.
Diese Übung wurde im Rahmen eines Workshops über interaktive Innovation während des Kick-Off-Meetings des i2connect-Konsortiums vorgestellt. Nach der Übung wurde eine Nachbesprechung durchgeführt, in der die Mitglieder erörterten, was während der Teamübung gut und was schlecht gelaufen war. Die Mitglieder waren in der Lage, die Gruppenaktivität mit einem interaktiven Innovationsprozess in Verbindung zu bringen und identifizierten mehrere Schlüsselelemente, die für ein erfolgreiches Ergebnis des Prozesses entscheidend sind, wie z. B. ein gemeinsames Verständnis und eine gemeinsame Vision des Ziels und der Aufgabe, gegenseitiges Vertrauen, Engagement, Moderation, Zusammenarbeit usw.
Die Aktivität war sehr nützlich, um den interaktiven Innovationsprozess zu veranschaulichen, eine kreative Arbeitsatmosphäre zu fördern und den Teamgeist zu stärken. Die Aktivität könnte angepasst und in verschiedenen Kontexten als einfache, aber anschauliche Übung eingesetzt werden, um das Verständnis für den interaktiven Innovationsprozess zu fördern.
i2connect coaching activity has been particularly successful in France. It is a complementary activity to the i2connect 3 day innovation support method training, that lasts a period of 6 months after the training, with the aim of offering a target-tailored support to the rural advisors in their individual innovation projects and processes. The i2connect coaching in France involved a group of 9 advisors, previously trained, and it was coordinated and facilitated by Idele, an applied research institute partner of i2connect project. The coaching meetings were helded online, at the beginning due to the pandemic restrinctions. However, also after that period the participants preferred to have online meetings, that enabled people to attend them easily keeping an high quality of the discussion. After each meeting, the coordinators provided some brief minutes to the group. Participants particularly appreciated the possibility to discuss in a safe environment and to learn from other advisors that faced their same problems and challenges in a peer-to-peer approach. After two years from the first coaching meeting, 5 advisors of the group have been keeping on asking for meetings, even if the coaching period was supposted to last only 6 months. This is a clear sign that the activity was succesfull and that coachs and participants have been able to create a long lasting and strong network.
i2connect coaching activity has been particularly successful in France. It is a complementary activity to the i2connect 3 day innovation support method training, that lasts a period of 6 months after the training, with the aim of offering a target-tailored support to the rural advisors in their individual innovation projects and processes. The i2connect coaching in France involved a group of 9 advisors, previously trained, and it was coordinated and facilitated by Idele, an applied research institute partner of i2connect project. The coaching meetings were helded online, at the beginning due to the pandemic restrinctions. However, also after that period the participants preferred to have online meetings, that enabled people to attend them easily keeping an high quality of the discussion. After each meeting, the coordinators provided some brief minutes to the group. Participants particularly appreciated the possibility to discuss in a safe environment and to learn from other advisors that faced their same problems and challenges in a peer-to-peer approach. After two years from the first coaching meeting, 5 advisors of the group have been keeping on asking for meetings, even if the coaching period was supposted to last only 6 months. This is a clear sign that the activity was succesfull and that coachs and participants have been able to create a long lasting and strong network.
Since the 1st of December 2021, the Rural Network provides an Innovation Coach (IC) service. This new position has never previously been used as a method of boosting interactive innovation. The fundamental idea of using an IC is to encourage and support the AKIS. Role definition and responsibilities were broad and freely designed, leaving the IC the opportunity to act.
The IC attends the Innovation Support Team’s meetings, as well as meetings between this Team and the External Advisory Selection Committee, to understand the assessments and reasons for rejections. The innovative ideas not fitting EIP-Agri support are the target group: the IC assists and supports them in finding other types of funding or collaborative partners for their innovative idea.
The research struggles to liaise with practitioners, because of the different ways of communicating and their inability relating and understanding each other. The same applies to the research and advisory sectors since they lack close ties. The IC is a neutral party between the various actors, able to bring them together in interactive activities, initiate collaborations, and communicate their knowledge and needs. To play this role effectively, the IC should possess knowledge of the sectors, have a practical background in the different parts of the innovation system, and know how to communicate with the various actors. The key to the success of the IC in Sweden is due to her complementary and multi-sectoral background in Innovation Science research, the 10 years of experience in advisory, and her practical experience running agriculture enterprises. The result is a good understanding how the various sectors are organised, why the actors act the way they do, and how they think and communicate.
Since the 1st of December 2021, the Rural Network provides an Innovation Coach (IC) service. This new position has never previously been used as a method of boosting interactive innovation. The fundamental idea of using an IC is to encourage and support the AKIS. Role definition and responsibilities were broad and freely designed, leaving the IC the opportunity to act.
The IC attends the Innovation Support Team’s meetings, as well as meetings between this Team and the External Advisory Selection Committee, to understand the assessments and reasons for rejections. The innovative ideas not fitting EIP-Agri support are the target group: the IC assists and supports them in finding other types of funding or collaborative partners for their innovative idea.
The research struggles to liaise with practitioners, because of the different ways of communicating and their inability relating and understanding each other. The same applies to the research and advisory sectors since they lack close ties. The IC is a neutral party between the various actors, able to bring them together in interactive activities, initiate collaborations, and communicate their knowledge and needs. To play this role effectively, the IC should possess knowledge of the sectors, have a practical background in the different parts of the innovation system, and know how to communicate with the various actors. The key to the success of the IC in Sweden is due to her complementary and multi-sectoral background in Innovation Science research, the 10 years of experience in advisory, and her practical experience running agriculture enterprises. The result is a good understanding how the various sectors are organised, why the actors act the way they do, and how they think and communicate.
The vast quantity of information which is embedded in diverse actors in a Multi-actor (MA) project provide a basis for continuous flow of relevant information to inform decision making, improve relevance and motivation of actors and participants in their numerous activities and tasks. The i2connect project supports advisors to help farmers and rural enterprises through interactive innovation or a more effective bottom-up approach. Over the five years of the project a lot of activities are planned and implemented through the various Work Package Tasks. As the i2connect project is participatory and its actors and participants are people with diverse backgrounds and experiences.
These experiences which are relevant to interactive innovation support by farm advisors provide many topical insights and are recorded every 4 months on the i2connect share drive are documented in an annual report as a project deliverable.
These topical insights may come from other projects, activities, experiences or events and reflect the huge knowledge reservoir and flow of information that exists with the project partners. Over 100 topical insights were collected in the first 2 years and 40 have been published.
The vast quantity of information which is embedded in diverse actors in a Multi-actor (MA) project provide a basis for continuous flow of relevant information to inform decision making, improve relevance and motivation of actors and participants in their numerous activities and tasks. The i2connect project supports advisors to help farmers and rural enterprises through interactive innovation or a more effective bottom-up approach. Over the five years of the project a lot of activities are planned and implemented through the various Work Package Tasks. As the i2connect project is participatory and its actors and participants are people with diverse backgrounds and experiences.
These experiences which are relevant to interactive innovation support by farm advisors provide many topical insights and are recorded every 4 months on the i2connect share drive are documented in an annual report as a project deliverable.
These topical insights may come from other projects, activities, experiences or events and reflect the huge knowledge reservoir and flow of information that exists with the project partners. Over 100 topical insights were collected in the first 2 years and 40 have been published.
During the i2connect training course in Italy, a very simple 3-minute activity was tried out that allows participants to explore what makes a task highly motivating.
Seven to eight large cards with the letters that make up a word written in bold type are needed.
This activity can be used to open a course/workshop. On the letters can also be written the topic of a presentation or the objective of the course. In this way participants can be made to think about how they could use this activity with their 'audience' when introducing a new concept to engage them.
The trainer:
1. Asks seven to eight people to come to the front of the room and stand in a straight line in front of the audience.
2. Distributes the letter cards, one for each participant and asks each person to hold their letter card above their head so that the audience can read it easily.
3. Explains that the letters form a seven-letter word.
4. Asks members of the audience to give directions to the letter bearers to rearrange them in the correct order to spell the word. (Examples: One of the people with the letter "X" please move to the beginning of the word. The person with the letter "Y", please move to the end).
5. Ask the letter-holders to follow the directions of the audience.
6. When the word is correctly formed, asks everyone to read it aloud on the count of three.
The game ends with thanks to the letter bearers and applause to the whole group for quickly solving the anagram.
The trainer can give a debriefing by asking the group if they were enthusiastic about the activity and what made it exciting.
Durante il corso di formazione i2connect in Italia è stata sperimentata un'attività molto semplice, da svolgersi in 3 minuti, che permette ai partecipanti di esplorare ciò che rende un compito altamente motivante.
Occorrono sette/otto cartoncini grandi con le lettere che compongono una parola scritta in grassetto.
Questa attività può essere usata per aprire un corso/workshop. Sulle lettere può anche essere scritto l'argomento di una presentazione o l’obiettivo del corso. In questo modo i partecipanti riflettono su come coinvolgere le persone.
Il trainer:
1. Chiede a sette/otto persone di venire davanti alla sala e di mettersi in piedi in linea retta di fronte al pubblico.
2. Distribuisce le carte delle lettere, una per ogni partecipante e chiede a ciascuno di tenere la propria carta delle lettere sopra la testa, in modo che il pubblico possa leggerla facilmente.
3. Spiega che le lettere formano una parola di sette lettere.
4. Chiede ai membri del pubblico di dare indicazioni ai portatori di lettere per riordinarle nell'ordine corretto per scrivere la parola. (Esempi: Una delle persone con la lettera “X”, per favore, si sposti all'inizio della parola. La persona con la lettera “Y”, si sposti alla fine).
5. Chiede ai detentori delle lettere di seguire le indicazioni del pubblico.
6. Quando la parola è formata correttamente, chiede a tutti di leggerla ad alta voce al suo di tre.
Il gioco si conclude con i ringraziamenti ai portatori di lettere e gli applausi a tutto il gruppo per aver risolto rapidamente l'anagramma. Il trainer può fare un resoconto chiedendo al gruppo se è stato entusiasta dell'attività e quali sono i motivi che hanno reso l'attività entusiasmante.
During the i2connect training course in Italy, a simple but effective closing activity was used, which is useful to lead to identify the learning point or outcome for participants and to measure the change in their behaviour, mindset or opinion on the topic.
Post-its and pens are needed for the activity
Depending on the size of the group, the classroom should be arranged with chairs in a circle or tables for allowing small groups to interact.
Participants are asked to answer two questions in silence (in writing if the group is large or if the activity was long and eventful) 1. 'I used to think'... 2. 'But now I think'... Allow two to five minutes for reflection or writing, depending on the duration of the activity and the expected learning. Then people can share their answers with the group. You can collect them on flip chart paper or even write them down to share later with participants or others. If the group is large, it is advisable to divide it into smaller groups so that everyone can share their answers.
Durante il corso di formazione i2connect in Italia è stata utilizzata un'attività di chiusura semplice ma efficace, che è utile per portare a identificare il punto di apprendimento o i risultati per i partecipanti e a misurare il cambiamento nel loro comportamento, nella loro mentalità o nella loro opinione riguardo all'argomento.
per l'attività servono post-it e penne
A seconda delle dimensioni del gruppo, l'aula deve essere sistemata con sedie in cerchio o con dei tavoli per far interagire i piccoli gruppi.
Ai partecipanti viene chiesto di rispondere a due domande in silenzio (per iscritto se il gruppo è numeroso o se l'attività è stata lunga e ricca di eventi). 1. "Prima pensavo"... 2. "Ma ora penso"... Lasciate da due a cinque minuti per riflettere o scrivere, a seconda della durata dell'attività e dell'apprendimento previsto. Poi le persone possono condividere le loro risposte con il gruppo. Potete raccoglierle su carta a fogli mobili o anche scriverle per condividerle in seguito con i partecipanti o con altri. Se il gruppo è numeroso, si consiglia di suddividerlo in gruppi più piccoli, in modo che ciascuno possa condividere le proprie risposte.
During the i2connect training course in Italy, the following activity was used to explore overall team building issues to see how the participants get on.
Before the exercise begins, the trainer tie a length of rope (about 20m) into a circle and provide blindfolds for everyone.
The trainer explains that to complete this activity, all the team has to do is to form the rope into the shape of a perfect square.
They will have 15 minutes planning time, during which no one may touch the rope.
At the end of this time, everyone will be blindfolded and the rope will be placed in their hands.
They will have 10 minutes to form the square.
All the team members must be holding the rope.
Once they think that the square is complete, lay the rope on the floor.
At the end of the game there is a debriefing. The trainer asks questions to draw out responses that focus on any of these types of topics: Attention to detail, Collaboration, Communication, Evaluation, Planning, Problem solving, Variations.
Don't tie the rope into a circle at the start.
Durante il corso di formazione i2connect in Italia, la seguente attività è stata utilizzata per esplorare questioni generali di team building e vedere come i partecipanti se la cavano.
Prima di iniziare l'esercizio, il formatore deve legare una corda (circa 20 metri) in un cerchio e bendare tutti i partecipanti.
Il formatore spiega che per completare questa attività, tutto ciò che la squadra deve fare è formare la corda a forma di quadrato perfetto.
Avranno 15 minuti di tempo per la pianificazione, durante i quali nessuno potrà toccare la corda.
Al termine di questo tempo, tutti saranno bendati e la corda sarà messa nelle loro mani.
Avranno 10 minuti per formare il quadrato.
Tutti i membri della squadra devono tenere la corda.
Quando pensano che il quadrato sia completo, posano la corda sul pavimento.
Alla fine del gioco è previsto un debriefing. Il formatore pone delle domande per far emergere le risposte che si concentrano su uno di questi tipi di argomenti: Attenzione ai dettagli, Collaborazione, Comunicazione, Valutazione, Pianificazione, Risoluzione dei problemi, Variazioni. Si suggerisce di non legare la corda in cerchio all'inizio.
The "Name Game" approach was used during i2connect training of trainers course in Italy, to break the ice during meetings and create a more relaxed and friendly discussion environment.
The exercise consists in saying your name to the person next to you who will have to repeat her/his name and the names of those who preceded her/him, until the end of the group. The last one will have to remember the names of all. The idea is to verify, through the participants in the game, the speed and ability to memorize the names previously heard by the group. This communication tool allows you to generate knowledge and increase relational contact.
L'esercizio del "gioco dei nomi" è stato utilizzato durante il corso di formazione per formatori di i2connect tenutosi in Italia, per rompere il ghiaccio durante le riunioni e creare un ambiente di discussione più rilassato e amichevole.
L'esercizio consiste nel dire il proprio nome alla persona accanto che dovrà ripetere il proprio e quello di chi l'ha preceduta, fino alla fine del gruppo. L'ultimo dovrà ricordare i nomi di tutti. L'idea è quella di verificare, attraverso i partecipanti al gioco, la velocità e la capacità di memorizzare i nomi precedentemente ascoltati dal gruppo. Ma soprattutto, questo strumento di comunicazione permette di generare conoscenza e aumentare il contatto relazionale.
The "Head Game" approach was used during i2connect training of trainers courses in Rome to test people's difficulty to follow instructions on which direction to look; especially following instructions when the meaning of words has been changed. The game consist on givin to the participants some instructions about the directions in which they have to look at (i.e.: with the word "up" they must to look up; with the word "down" they have to look down; with the word "right "they have to turn their face at the right side and with the word "left" they have to turn their face at the left side) After some minutes, the facilitator of the excercise have to change the meaning of the instructions ( i.e.: with the word "up" they must not to look up but down; and viceversa with the word "down" they have to look up. The words "right " and "left" keep the same meaning).
The idea was to verify, through the participants in the game, the propensity and adaptation to change. In fact, this simple excercise prooves that it is hard to learn new concepts without unlearning some old concepts. Therefore, one has to unlearn something old in order to learn something new. This communication tool makes it possible to reach a large number of actors and aims to define the capacity for comparison with different words between different actors to be involved, such as farmers, civil society and young people in innovation projects.
Questo esercizio, che è stato eseguito nel corso i2connect ‘Train the trainer’ in Vienna, è un vero e proprio gioco che può essere usato durante un corso o un workshop come attività di team-building poiché aiuta i partecipanti a relazionarsi e costruire insieme una strategia.
Istruzioni per il gioco:
Si dispongono nell’aula un numero di sedie pari al numero dei partecipanti + 1 in due cerchi concentrici, con le sedute poste l’una di fronte all’altra (i partecipanti seduti sui due cerchi possono vedersi in faccia). Fra i due cerchi dovrà esserci lo spazio per consentire il passaggio di una persona (il formatore). Il cerchio esterno non sarà completamente chiuso, ma dovrà avere un passaggio per permettere a questa persona di entrare.
Il formatore fa sedere i partecipanti: una sedia rimarrà libera (in un punto opposto al passaggio).
Il formatore spiega che il suo compito è quello di occupare la sedia vuota e che le persone sedute dovranno impedirglielo studiando una strategia.
Il gruppo avrà a disposizione un paio di minuti per accordarsi.
Passato il tempo, il formatore entra nel cerchio camminando normalmente, dirigendosi verso la sedia. Le persone sedute si sposteranno per impedirgli di sedere, fra le risate generali, ma lasceranno sempre una sedia vuota che potrà essere occupata.
Se, trascorsi 1/ 2 minuti il formatore non sarà riuscito a sedere, farà un bell’applauso al gruppo, che è riuscito a trovare una strategia.
Se, invece, il gruppo non sarà riuscito ad impedire al formatore di sedere, potranno essere date 1 / 2 ulteriori occasioni per ripetere il gioco. Il gioco può essere svolto con un numero di circa 20/30 partecipanti.
Among the interconections of i2connect project there is the experience of an ERASMUS+ project, namely RAMONES-PL. One of the main result of the project there is a tracking and monitoring systems in farm advisory services.
The RAMONES-PL project customized and tested an open source issue tracking tool for the needs of monitoring the delivery of farm advisory services in Norh Macedonia and Hungary between 2021 and 2023.
We deliberately opted for open-source, free to use monitoring tool to record, track and evaluate the details of advisory service provision in the project, with the intention of making our methodology and results more adoptable and exploitable EU wide by other actors interested in utilizing our workflow.
Mantis Bug Tracker is a free and open source web bug tracking system.
The main customization steps included:
• Creating projects containing national user groups (by countries/partner organizations) and users (farm advisors - reporters, supervisors - managers).
• Assigning the language variants by the users’ needs.
• Setting up categorizations and a system of keywords to indicate the type of service activity and other details, which makes it possible to filter the entered data by these items.
• Defining custom fields: adding single option selects for service activities, or multiple selects for the different countries of participants which statically lists the farmer clients that can be assigned to the specific users (farm advisors), so they can only see their own partners.
Among the interconections of i2connect project there is the experience of an ERASMUS+ project, namely RAMONES-PL. One of the main result of the project there is a tracking and monitoring systems in farm advisory services.
The RAMONES-PL project customized and tested an open source issue tracking tool for the needs of monitoring the delivery of farm advisory services in Norh Macedonia and Hungary between 2021 and 2023.
We deliberately opted for open-source, free to use monitoring tool to record, track and evaluate the details of advisory service provision in the project, with the intention of making our methodology and results more adoptable and exploitable EU wide by other actors interested in utilizing our workflow.
Mantis Bug Tracker is a free and open source web bug tracking system.
The main customization steps included:
• Creating projects containing national user groups (by countries/partner organizations) and users (farm advisors - reporters, supervisors - managers).
• Assigning the language variants by the users’ needs.
• Setting up categorizations and a system of keywords to indicate the type of service activity and other details, which makes it possible to filter the entered data by these items.
• Defining custom fields: adding single option selects for service activities, or multiple selects for the different countries of participants which statically lists the farmer clients that can be assigned to the specific users (farm advisors), so they can only see their own partners.
Contacts
Project coordinator
-
APCA - ASSEMBLEE PERMANENTE DES CHAMBRES D'AGRICULTURE
Project coordinator
sylvain.sturel@apca.chambagri.fr Advisor
Project partners
-
AUA - AGRICULTURAL UNIVERSITY OF ATHENS
Project partner
Research institute -
ILVO - EIGEN VERMOGEN VAN HET INSTITUUT VOOR LANDBOUW- EN VISSERIJONDERZOEK
Project partner
Research institute -
NAAS - NATIONAL AGRICULTURAL ADVISORY SERVICE
Project partner
Advisor -
EUFRAS - EIROPAS LAUKSAIMNIECIBAS UN LAUKU KONSULTANTU ASOCIACIJA
Project partner
Advisor -
FiBL Europe - Forschungsinstitut für biologischen Landbau in Europa
Project partner
Research institute -
IALB - INTERNATIONALE AKADEMIE LAND- UND HAUSWIRTSCHAFTLICHER BERATERINNEN UND BERATER EV
Project partner
Advisor -
SEASN - MREZA SAVJETODAVNIH SLUZBI JUGOISTOCNE EUROPE
Project partner
Advisor -
ProAgria - PROAGRIA KESKUSTEN LIITTO RY
Project partner
Advisor -
ACTA - Association de Coordination Technique Agricole
Project partner
Research institute -
UHOH - UNIVERSITAET HOHENHEIM
Project partner
Research institute -
NAK - MAGYAR AGRAR-, ELELMISZERGAZDASAGI ES VIDEKFEJLESZTESI KAMARA
Project partner
Advisor -
CIRCA - THE CIRCA GROUP EUROPE LIMITED
Project partner
SME -
TEAGASC - AGRICULTURE AND FOOD DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
Project partner
Advisor -
CREA - CONSIGLIO PER LA RICERCA IN AGRICOLTURA E L'ANALISI DELL'ECONOMIA AGRARIA
Project partner
Research institute -
LLKC - LATVIJAS LAUKU KONSULTACIJU UN IZGLITIBAS CENTRS
Project partner
Advisor -
LAAS - VIESOJI ISTAIGA LIETUVOS ZEMES UKIO KONSULTAVIMO TARNYBA
Project partner
Advisor -
CDR - CENTRUM DORADZTWA ROLNICZEGO W BRWINOWIE
Project partner
Advisor -
CONSULAI - CONSULTORIA AGRO INDUSTRIATRIAL LDA
Project partner
SME -
MAPA - MINISTERIO DE AGRICULTURA, PESCA Y ALIMENTACION
Project partner
Other -
AGRIDEA - DEVELOPPEMENT DE L'AGRICULTURE ET DE L'ESPACE RURAL : AGRIDEA
Project partner
Other -
ZLTO - ZUIDELIJKE LAND- EN TUINBOUWORGANISATIE VERENIGING
Project partner
Other -
WR - STICHTING WAGENINGEN RESEARCH
Project partner
Research institute -
SZE - SZECHENYI ISTVAN UNIVERSITY
Project partner
Research institute