An inventory of farming practices and their impacts on the environment and climate
The inventory of the impacts of farm practices on the environment and climate is stored in an extensive database that relates each farming practice with one or more identified impacts and each impact with one or more CAP specific objectives and the associated PMEF impact and result indicators.
Page contents
Output Description
The database currently includes 10 broad categories of farming practices. In the long term, the tool aims to include around 30 broad categories of farming practices.
-
- Organic farming
- Agroforestry
- Fertilisation strategies
- Organic fertilisation
- Green manure
- Enhanced efficiency fertilisers
- Nitrification inhibitors
- Low ammonia emission techniques
- Soil amendment
- Soil amendment with biochar
- Soil amendment with lime and gypsum
- Pesticide reduction strategies
- Landscape features
- Fallowing
- Manure management techniques
- Improved manure land application techniques
- Improved manure storage techniques
- Manure processing techniques
- Livestock housing techniques
- Livestock dietary manipulation techniques
The database utilises synthesis research papers. These papers synthesise the results of multiple individual research papers aimed at testing the same conceptual hypothesis. Synthesis studies may be:
-
A systematic review attempts to collate all the empirical evidence that fits pre-specified eligibility criteria to answer a specific research question. It uses explicit, systematic methods that are selected to minimise bias, thus providing more reliable findings from which conclusions can be drawn and decisions made.
-
Is the statistical analysis of the data from multiple, independent primary studies focused on the same question, which aims to generate a quantitative estimate of the studied phenomenon, for example, the effectiveness of a farming practice.
The database reports each farming practice or a sub-category of it, with three types of fiches. The first type of fiche is called general fiche and summarises all the environmental and climate impacts found in the review of research papers for this practice. The second type of fiche is the single-impact fiche, which provides a deeper insight into each of the impacts of the farm practice (e.g. carbon sequestration, biodiversity) with more detailed information. There are as many impact fiches as impacts reported in the general fiche. The third type of fiche are summaries of each synthesis paper (the meta-analysis or systematic reviews) and consist of individual reports providing more comprehensive information about the results reported in each synthesis paper, particularly concerning the effects of soil, climate, and management practices.
-
The general fiche provides the highest level of synthesis of the research papers included in the systematic review. The synthesis research papers include several individual papers that broadly range between 10 and 300. Therefore, the assessment of impacts relies on a considerable number of results obtained mainly in field experiments carried out in situations close to a natural farming environment and from lab experiments or model simulations.
-
The impact fiche summarises the impact of a farm practice on a specific environment or climate change issue (e.g. biodiversity, greenhouse gas emissions). It contains references to synthesis papers, main conclusions and assesses evidence robustness. It also assesses the papers’ quality, impacts and highlighted knowledge gaps. It also contains information about the systematic review strategy, i.e., what keywords were used, in which databases the search was performed, the selection criteria, and others.
-
Each summary report provides a quick and comprehensive summary of the systematic review or the meta-analysis on which the corresponding impact fiche was based.
The results of the literature review process are synthesised in three matrices. In the ‘matrix linking farming practices and PMEF impact indicators’ and the ‘matrix linking farming practices and PMEF result indicators’, each cell indicates the effect of each farming practice on the specific impact or result indicator correspondingly. The ‘overall matrix of the impacts’ indicates the effect of each farming practice on each specific issue of the CAP Specific Objectives 4, 5, 6 and 9. The effects are characterised as positive, negative, no effect, uncertain or no evidence based on the scientific evidence found in the synthesis paper review.
-
For Specific Objective 4, ‘Contribute to climate change mitigation and adaptation, as well as sustainable energy’, the specific issues include ‘Greenhouse gas emissions’, ‘Carbon sequestration/storage’, ‘Climate change adaptation’, and ‘Energy use’.
For Specific Objective 5, ‘Foster sustainable development and efficient management of natural resources such as water, soil and air’, the specific issues include ‘Air quality’, ‘Water quality’, ‘Water quantity and availability’, ‘Soil quality and fertility’, and ‘Soil erosion’.
For Specific Objective 6, ‘Contribute to the protection of biodiversity, enhance ecosystem services and preserve habitats and landscapes’, the specific issues include ‘Biodiversity’, ‘Pollination’, and ‘Landscape quality’.
For Specific Objective 9, ‘Improve the response of EU agriculture to societal demands on food and health, including safe, nutritious and sustainable food, and animal welfare’, the specific issue is ‘Pest and disease control’.
Relevance for monitoring and evaluation of the CAP
The database on the impacts of farming practices provides the evaluator with a fundamental scientific basis to design the evaluation of the expected impacts of measures that support/promote various farming practices that are supposed to be beneficial for the environment and the climate. Therefore, the database is a tool that can guide the planning stage of the evaluation. The information available in the database helps the evaluator to better frame the evaluation objectives and manage the evaluation resources towards the most critical effects.
The tool links the likely effects of farm practices with the following:
- the Specific Objectives 4, 5, 6, and 9 of the CAP
- the Impact Indicators of the PMEF
- the Result Indicators of the PMEF
This background work is helpful because the evaluator does not need to start from scratch. Having a reasonably good idea of which impacts are likely to be essential, the evaluator can manage the human and financial resources accordingly.
In addition, the database supports the evaluator by summarising the most crucial information from critical reviews and meta-analyses and provides a reference to the original scientific review papers.
Relevance of the output per CAP Objectives
- Specific Objective 4 - Climate change action
- Specific Objective 5 - Environmental care
- Specific Objective 6 - Preserve landscape and biodiversity
- Specific Objective 9 - Protect food and health quality
Additional output information
Data collection systems used:
- Ad-hoc data collection
Type of output:
- Database/ data registry
Associated evaluation approaches:
- Impact evaluation ex-ante
- Impact evaluation ex-post
Spatial scale:
- National
- EU level
Project information
Integrated Modelling platform for Agro-economic and resource Policy analysis
IMAP4AGRI objectives are to:
- Gather available scientific evidence on environmental and climate issues to build a common knowledge base with the aim to support the drafting of the CAP plan for the Member States and their assessment by the European Commission.
- Clarify the intervention logic, expected impacts, causal links, and quantification between environmental and climate farming practices (FP) and CAP objectives.
- Improve or develop indicators, methodologies for modelling, impact assessments, monitoring and evaluations.
Project’s timeframe: Activities lasted until the end of 2021. - New activities were programmed as part of a long-term project to take advantage of the material developed, and the experiences gathered, providing support throughout the programming period.
Contacts of project holder: All communication goes through a functional mailbox at: JRC-wiki-CAP-SP@ec.europa.eu
Website: IMAP: https://wikis.ec.europa.eu/display/IMAP
Territorial coverage: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, The Netherlands