project - Research and innovation

HOMED - Holistic management of emerging forest pests and diseases
HOlistic Management of Emerging forest pests and Diseases

Ongoing | 2018 - 2022 France
Ongoing | 2018 - 2022 France
Affichage actuel du contenu de la page dans la langue maternelle, si disponible

Objectives

HOMED aims to develop a full panel of science-based, innovative practical methods, tools and solutions for the management – from assessment to control – of emerging native and non-native pests and pathogens threatening European forests, following a holistic and multi-actor approach. The project will improve strategies of risk assessment and management by targeting the successive phases of invasion (transport, introduction, establishment, spread), and developing mitigation methods for each phase, i.e. prevention, detection and diagnosis, surveillance, eradication and control tools.

Objectives

see objectives in English

Activities

At a scientific level, HOMED will develop a new generation of semi-mechanistic models, based on a few generic integrative indicators, to provide quantitative and spatialized predictions on native and non-native pests and pathogens introduction, establishment and spread. At a technological level, the project will develop innovative tools for broad spectrum and specific detection, analysis and control of emerging or invasive native and non-native pests and pathogens. At a risk management level, HOMED will co-design with forest actors, tools, guidelines and recommendations for the prevention, detection, diagnosis, eradication or control of new non-native pests and pathogens.

Contexte

Forests are the highest ranked land cover type in Europe. Numbering at around 40% of the total land area, they provide numerous goods and services of benefit to people. These include, not only marketed products such as wood, but also ecosystem services of great value from an ecological, political, social and cultural perspective. Among the latter are water resource management, preservation of biodiversity, climate change mitigation, recreation and health benefits, cultural heritage and protection from soil erosion.

In the last decades, a growing list of introduced non-native pests and pathogens have been causing dramatic losses to European trees and forests. Most of these devastating PnPs, e.g. chestnut blight, ash dieback, Asian long-horned beetle and western conifer seed bug, were harmless or even unknown in their region of origin. The exponential rates of introduction and establishment of non-native pests and pathogens in Europe are clearly linked to increasing global trade.

Project details
Main funding source
Horizon 2020 (EU Research and Innovation Programme)
Horizon Project Type
Multi-actor project
Emplacement
Main geographical location
Gironde

€ 5754828.75

Total budget

Total contributions including EU funding.

Affichage actuel du contenu de la page dans la langue maternelle, si disponible

15 Practice Abstracts

The spotted wing drosophila Drosophila suzukii is a fruit fly native to Eastern Asia that was accidentally introduced to the Americas and Europe. Because this fly is able to attack undamaged ripening fruits, it became a major problem for fruit growers such as the cherry industry, but also wild fruit-bearing trees and shrubs. For the country-wide and long-term control of the fruit fly, the importation from Asia and release of the parasitoid wasp Ganaspis brasiliensis has been repeatedly suggested. However, uncertainty about the identity and specificity of the parasitoid has so far prevented its use for biological control in Europe.

We used a combination of molecular analyses and laboratory experiments to gather evidence that the parasitoid wasp Ganaspis brasiliensis is in fact a complex of at least two species. Individuals from one genetic group (called G3) readily parasitize several species of native drosophila fruit flies, which have important ecological functions. But individuals from the other group (called G1) are specific to D. suzukii larvae feeding on ripening fruits. Because only the invasive spotted wing drosophila attacks ripening fruits, parasitoids from the G1 group appear to be specific to the target pest and therefore well suited for biological control.

Decision-makers and biological control practitioners should consider that while the parasitoid wasps are still called the same and cannot be distinguished by their appearance, important genetic and behavioral differences exist, making especially G1 Ganaspis brasiliensis suitable and safe for biological control against the spotted wing drosophila.

The serious and growing threat of biological invasions to biodiversity and livelihoods makes the public engagement in managing the problem of Invasive Alien Species (IAS) even more urgent and necessary, also given the key role of people in their unintentional transport, introduction and spread. A Citizen Science experiment was therefore conducted in collaboration with high schools to raise awareness of the distribution and potential impact of IAS threatening trees and forests and to conduct large-scale monitoring activities. Students and teachers were given general information on IAS and trained in the field data collection protocol. Ambrosia beetles were used as target species, as they can be easily detected with cheap traps (made of reused plastic bottles for water) and a freely available attractant (an ethanol-based hand sanitiser) and by a simple trapping protocol requiring limited efforts (traps exposed for 24h each of a few weeks in spring). The experiment, by linking environmental education and outdoor experiential learning opportunities, enhanced public participation and contributed greatly to research, primarily by avoiding costly and time-consuming activities such as large-scale surveys. Successful results of this collaboration are: i) a greater knowledge of the possible impact of invasive species and the important role played by ordinary citizens in monitoring them; ii) the first report of two non-native ambrosia beetles considered as quarantine pests for the European Union: Cnestus mutilatus, new for the European part of the EPPO region, and Anisandrus maiche, previously found only in Eastern European EPPO member countries.

La crescente minaccia che le invasioni biologiche rappresentano per la biodiversità e per l’economia, rende urgente il coinvolgimento dei comuni cittadini nella gestione delle specie aliene invasive (IAS), dato il ruolo che involontariamente rivestono nel trasporto, introduzione e diffusione di tali specie. Per aumentare la consapevolezza dell’impatto che le IAS hanno su alberi e foreste e per condurre un monitoraggio su larga scala, è stato condotto un esperimento di Citizen Science in collaborazione con le scuole superiori. A studenti e insegnanti sono state fornite le informazioni di base e le istruzioni per eseguire il monitoraggio. Come specie target sono stati scelti i coleotteri scolitidi xilematici che possono essere catturati con trappole economiche (realizzate con bottiglie di plastica riciclate e attivate con un gel igienizzante lavamani) e seguendo un semplice protocollo (trappole esposte settimanalmente per 24 ore in primavera). L'esperimento, unendo l'educazione ambientale con attività formative all'aperto, ha rafforzato l’interesse e la partecipazione degli studenti e ha contribuito notevolmente alla ricerca, semplificando attività costose e dispendiose in termini di tempo quali le indagini su larga scala. I risultati positivi di questa collaborazione sono stati: i) una maggiore conoscenza delle IAS e dell'importante ruolo svolto dai comuni cittadini nel loro monitoraggio; ii) la prima segnalazione di due scolitidi xilematici non autoctoni considerati specie da quarantena per l'Unione Europea: Cnestus mutilatus, segnalato per la prima volta nella parte europea della regione EPPO, e Anisandrus maiche, precedentemente rinvenuto solo nei paesi EPPO dell'Europa orientale.

Classical biological control (CBC) is the control of non-native (exotic) species by natural enemies from their native range. CBC projects are inherently complex and many factors can affect their success. Using a catalogue of outcomes of such programmes over the past >100 years, called BIOCAT, we analysed many variables that were related to the CBC agents (predators and parasitoids), their target insect pests, host plants of the target pest, and the number of repeated introductions of the CBC agents.



Remarkably few CBC agent-related variables influenced the success of control: insect predators were less likely to establish, and generalist parasitoids were less effective at controlling the target pest. Sap feeders such as aphids and mealybugs were more likely to be successfully controlled than other types of targets. The rate of success also increased with the number of introductions of a CBC agent species, in particular against target pests only undergoing one generation per year.



These findings suggest that the traditional focus on CBC agent-related traits to increase the chances of successful CBC is not fully justified and should be complemented with the consideration of the type of pest to be targeted, its host plant, and management decisions such as how many times an agent has to be released against the same target.

La lutte biologique classique (LBC) est la lutte contre les espèces non indigènes (exotiques) par des ennemis naturels de leur région d'origine. Les programmes de LBC sont intrinsèquement complexes et de nombreux facteurs peuvent affecter leur succès. À l'aide d'un catalogue des résultats de tels programmes au cours des 100 dernières années, appelé BIOCAT, nous avons analysé de nombreuses variables liées aux agents de LBC (prédateurs et parasitoïdes), aux insectes nuisibles cibles, aux plantes hôtes de l’insecte cible et au nombre d'introductions répétées des agents de LBC.



Il est remarquable que peu de variables liées aux agents de LBC ont influencé le succès du contrôle biologique: les prédateurs d'insectes étaient moins susceptibles de s'établir, et les parasitoïdes généralistes étaient moins efficaces pour contrôler le ravageur cible. Les insectes se nourrissant de sève, comme les pucerons et les cochenilles, étaient plus susceptibles d'être contrôlés avec succès que les autres types de cibles. Le taux de réussite augmentait avec le nombre d'introductions d'une espèce d'agent LBC, en particulier contre les ravageurs cibles ne produisant qu'une génération par an.



Ces résultats suggèrent que l'accent traditionnel mis sur les caractéristiques de l'agent de LBC pour augmenter les chances de succès de la LBC n'est pas entièrement justifié et devrait être complété par la prise en compte du type de ravageur à cibler, de sa plante hôte et des décisions de gestion telles que le nombre de fois qu'un agent doit être lâché contre la même cible.

Ceratocystis platani causes canker stain of plane tree and is a serious disease of Platanus spp. in both the United States and Europe. Current chemical or biological methods are not effective in controlling C. platani. Therefore new preventive methods must be developed to limit the spread of this pathogen. We characterized the main volatile organic compounds (VOC) emitted in vitro by pure cultures of C. platani and other common fungal pathogen species of hosts plants growing in the same ecosystems as plane trees. We found that C. platani emitted a similar blend of VOCs as the phylogenetically closed C. populicola. In particular, C. platani was characterized by the emission of isoamyl acetate and isobutyl acetate while C. populicola by ethyl acetate and isobutyl acetate, which were not released by any of the other fungal species grown on the same medium. Furthermore, following a targeted approach based on the main VOCs found in vitro, we were able to validate in vivo that VOCs uniquely emitted by C. platani (i.e. isobutyl acetate along with isoamyl alcohol) were released from the bark of plane trees after C. platani inoculation. Our results demonstrate the possibility of exploiting VOC emitted specifically by C. platani as biomarkers to recognize plane trees infected by this pathogen. We are now looking for technical applications of the results in order to detect the presence of infected seedlings in the ports of entry.

With increasing forest insect damage caused by climate change and biological invasions, effective preventive control methods are needed. Using a meta-analysis of ca. 600 case studies, we show that a given insect species inflicts, on average, 20% less damage on a given tree species in mixed forest stands than in pure stands. This species-mixing resistance was significant for different types of pest diets, from wood boring pests to leaf-eating insects. It was more notable for specialist insect pests (about -40% damage) than for polyphagous ones. It also increased with the phylogenetic diversity of the species in the mixture, being more important in the coniferous - deciduous species mixtures. The main reasons for the better resistance of mixed forests are the pests’ reduced ability to locate and infect host trees surrounded by non-host trees and a greater abundance of natural enemies. The species’ spatial arrangement within the mixed forest is also important. An intimate (tree-by-tree) species mixing scheme is the most efficient. However, it is more difficult to manage in mechanized production forests such as planted forests. An interesting alternative for mixed-species plantations is the row-wise intermingling pattern, as it allows differentiated silviculture while maintaining close proximity between the different tree species. Finally, a solution with less impact on forest managers is the establishment of mixed hedges surrounding a pure stand of the focal species.

Processionary caterpillars from Australia and Europe, Ochrogaster lunifer and Thaumetopoea pityocampa respectively, are social insects that live in semi-urban and rural environments near humans and domestic animals. Both species are tree defoliators expanding their natural range. They also carry millions of microscopic urticating hairs on abdominal segments which can easily be dispersed by wind and spread throughout the environment. Contact with such hairs in vertebrates, especially mammals and humans, can cause various inflammatory issues and allergy problems. The highest risk for humans and animals encountering these processionary caterpillars is commonly March to May every year, when caterpillars form a procession to locate a new host after defoliating the initial host and when they leave the nest to find a pupation site underground. O. lunifer and T. pityocampa processions travel on average 40 and 16 m per day from the infested tree, respectively. O. lunifer caterpillars procession towards shaded areas, whereas T. pityocampa move towards well-lit areas. With this information, we can forewarn people to avoid infested areas or stay at least 80 m and 30 m away from host trees with O. lunifer and T. pityocampa nests respectively, during the procession period. Protective clothing and eyewear are recommended if people are attending these areas of high concern.

Cities are home to the majority of the Earth's population and concentrate large movement of goods, facilitating the entry of invasive species. They also contain a great diversity of tree species in urban parks, many of which are exotic species and may provide suitable habitats for non-native forest pests.

To understand the importance of urban areas in the establishment of invasive forest pests, we conducted a study of the sites where these species were first found in Europe. The study included 133 non-native insect species from the DAISIE database. In total 508 first country-specific records were retrieved. In 89% of the cases, the first detection occurred in cities and suburban areas. At the European level, hotspots were concentrated in regions with large intercontinental transport hubs. The colonized urban habitats reported were very diverse, including isolated trees in airports, seaport and railway stations, industrial areas, schoolyards, public parks, and street trees. Yet, arboreta and botanical gardens were the most frequently reported establishment sites. Nearly 90% of first detections were the result of opportunistic visual observations.

Early detection efforts should therefore focus on urban or peri-urban arboreta, botanical gardens, and parks, especially those near large transport hubs. Technicians working on urban forests should be trained to recognize unusual symptoms on trees, especially for insect species of high risk of arrival, and should have access to easy reporting systems, such as smartphone apps. Urban trees should be mapped and identified in databases, facilitating reporting systems. In addition, city communities and governments should benefit from expert monitoring units to anticipate these problems.

Cities are home to the majority of the Earth's population and concentrate large movement of goods, facilitating the entry of invasive species. They also contain a great diversity of tree species in urban parks, many of which are exotic species and may provide suitable habitats for non-native forest pests.

To understand the importance of urban areas in the establishment of invasive forest pests, we conducted a study of the sites where these species were first found in Europe. The study included 133 non-native insect species from the DAISIE database. In total 508 first country-specific records were retrieved. In 89% of the cases, the first detection occurred in cities and suburban areas. At the European level, hotspots were concentrated in regions with large intercontinental transport hubs. The colonized urban habitats reported were very diverse, including isolated trees in airports, seaport and railway stations, industrial areas, schoolyards, public parks, and street trees. Yet, arboreta and botanical gardens were the most frequently reported establishment sites. Nearly 90% of first detections were the result of opportunistic visual observations.

Early detection efforts should therefore focus on urban or peri-urban arboreta, botanical gardens, and parks, especially those near large transport hubs. Technicians working on urban forests should be trained to recognize unusual symptoms on trees, especially for insect species of high risk of arrival, and should have access to easy reporting systems, such as smartphone apps. Urban trees should be mapped and identified in databases, facilitating reporting systems. In addition, city communities and governments should benefit from expert monitoring units to anticipate these problems.

Tree pandemics are a major cause of economic and ecological loss in forest and urban ecosystems. They often depend on the introduction of a non-native pathogen, which is occupying the niche of a native, non-aggressive organism.

Three major pandemics of forest and urban trees in European ecosystems are considered: the Dutch elm disease, the cypress canker, and the pine wilt disease.

Results suggest that these pandemics rely on the introduction of a non-native pathogen that exploits well-developed interactions between native non-aggressive organisms and insect vectors associated with trees. The success of the invaders depends on the morphological, physiological and behavioural proximity of the players and on the mutual benefits resulting from the associations.

Deciphering such interactions in native systems may help to predict the outcome of the introduction of new pathogens and the development of new tree pandemics. It is recommended to explore carefully the relationships among the organisms in the native ecosystems and to analyse the potential recipient environments. The approach should be included in the pest risk assessment procedures.

An effective framework for early warning and rapid response is a crucial element to prevent or mitigate the impact of biological invasions of tree pathogens, especially at ports of entry. Molecular detection of pathogens by using PCR-based methods usually requires a well-equipped laboratory. Rapid detection tools that can be applied as point-of-care diagnostics are highly desirable, especially to intercept quarantine plant pathogens such as Xylella fastidiosa, Ceratocystis platani and Phytophthora ramorum, three of the most devastating pathogens of trees and ornamental plants in Europe. To this aim, three different LAMP (Loop mediated isothermal amplification) assays able to detect each target pathogen both in DNA extracted infected plant tissues were developed. By using the portable instrument Genie ® II, the LAMP assay was able to recognize X. fastidiosa, C. platani and P. ramorum DNA within 30 minutes of isothermal amplification reaction, with high levels of specificity and sensitivity. These new LAMP-based tools, allowing on-site rapid detection of pathogens, are especially suited for being used at ports of entry, but they can be also profitably used to monitor and prevent the possible spread of invasive pathogens in natural ecosystems or in tree nurseries.

Fusarium circinatum is the causal agent of pitch canker, a lethal disease of pine and other conifers. Since F. circinatum is a quarantine organism, its timely detection could efficiently prevent its introduction in new areas or facilitate its management in already infected sites. In this aim, a sequence-specific probe has been developed and used in a LAMP assay for F. circinatum using a field-deployable portable instrument. The assay was able to recognize the pathogen in host tissues in just 30 minutes and the sensitivity of assay makes it possible to detect even small amounts of F. circinatum DNA. The high specificity and efficiency of this method suggests its use as a standard diagnostic tool during phytosanitary controls.

The Caliciopsis canker on pines is caused by Caliciopsis pinea , In Europe, the disease has only occasionally been reported causing cankers, mostly on Pinus radiata in stressed plantations. The aim of this study was to clarify the taxonomy of Caliciopsis specimens collected from infected Pinus spp. in Europe to improve their detection and identification . The pathogenicity of the fungus was also considered. Two distinct species were identified based on morphology and multilocus phylogenetic analyses: Caliciopsis pinea that occurs in North America and a morphologically similar but phylogenetically distinct species described here as Caliciopsis moriondi sp. nov., found in Europe. The correct identification of the pathogen species is fundamental in case of need of regulation.

Insects are one of the most successful groups of non-native invasive species, and the number of new introductions has been increasing in the last decades. Insect invasions are favored mainly by the increase in international trade, as most of them travel across the world inside shipping containers. For this reason, the interception of hitchhiker insects transported inside containers is one of the most important actions to prevent the introduction of new alien species. The effectiveness of sticky light traps was tested for the interception of pests inside the containers during shipment using four model species: Cadra cautella (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), Drosophila melanogaster (Diptera: Drosophilidae), Sitophilus zeamais and Ips typographus (Coleoptera: Curculionidae). This trap consists in a carton box made attractive by a white LED light powered by a long-life AA battery. We found that light has a positive effect for the capture of C. cautella and D. melanogaster: in fact, activated traps (with light on) captured significantly more than control traps (with light off). Moreover, the number of captures for these two species was similar in both empty and full containers. Instead, Coleoptera (S. zeamais and I. typographus) were rarely caught, probably because of their ability to escape from traps. Finally, results show that increasing trap density in the container (from 1 to 8) increases the probability of insect capture. Given the results, we conclude that sticky light traps can be an effective tool for the early-detection of alien insect species travelling inside container, but they need some improvements. We suggest increasing the effectiveness of the trap by adding a stronger glue to reduce insect escape from traps. Finally, another possible improvement deals with the use of different color lights (i.e. wavelength) that can increase the attractiveness of the trap to a larger number of species.

A massive urban forestry project has been initiated and will eventually cover over 600 km2 by 2030, providing 30% forest cover in a 2000 km2 area 120 km southwest of Beijing in a new development zone called the Xiongan New Area (XNA), which will serve as the second capital of China. 100 km2 have been already planted in a network of parks and landscaped green areas. Using science to inform policy, one major goal of the tree planting program was to make urban forests more resistant and resilient to potential invasive species threats. To accomplish this best management practice, planted tree species were carefully selected, existing established pests were delineated, and potential new forest invasive species of concern threatening the new area were identified. The framework for the invasive pests management strategy was based on a “big data” approach, with each tree receiving a QR code to facilitate real time monitoring and mapping of pests and diseases, coupled with a decision system to implement appropriate control methods. This new approach to urban forestry has the potential to become an exemplary model for urban forestry planning, by integrating forest health surveys and pest control operations with sustainable forestry management.

When non-native invasive pest or pathogens of trees are first detected on a new site, forest managers and practitioners are faced with difficult decisions. The first one is whether or not to attempt eradication action. And if so, which methods should be used.

But these questions must be answered quickly, as the effectiveness of eradication depends on the responsiveness of practitioners. The longer the wait, the higher the costs and the greater the probability of failure. Indeed, the probability of establishment of a population of invasive species increases with its size and geographical extent.

A new decision tool will be created, in the form of a decision-tree, based on scores, that is easy to implement. The tool will enable prioritization of decisions on eradication strategies, based on several decision criteria, such as: i) hazards intensity or frequency and likelihood of exposure to hazard, ii) probability of detection and monitoring precision, iii) invasive species biological traits, iv) host tree species traits, v) available control strategies, vi) area and landscape affected. The overall integration of scores or decision equations, to be defined, will determine a decision. Guidelines on eradication methods will be also presented.

Quando as medidas de prevenção falham, e uma nova praga ou uma doença invasora florestal é detetada num novo local, os proprietários, gestores e profissionais da floresta são confrontados com duras decisões. A primeira das quais é se se deve tentar, ou não, a erradicação. E se sim, que métodos usar.

No entanto as respostas a estas questões não podem demorar, pois a viabilidade da erradicação depende de uma resposta rápida. Quanto mais longa a espera, maiores os custos e maior a probabilidade de falhar. De facto a probabilidade de estabelecimento de uma população de uma espécie invasora aumenta com o seu tamanho e da área geográfica afetada.

Uma nova ferramenta de decisão será criada, na forma de uma árvore de decisão, baseada em pontuações, simples de implementar. A ferramenta priorizará as decisões da estratégia de erradicação de acordo com vários critérios de decisão, como: i) intensidade de riscos ou sua frequência e probabilidade de exposição a riscos ii) probabilidade de deteção e precisão da monitorização; iii) aspetos biológicos das espécies inavasoras; iv) aspetos das espécies hospedeiras; v) estratégias de controlo disponíveis; vi) características da área e da paisagem. A integração geral das pontuações, ou equações a ser definidas, determinará uma decisão. Diretrizes sobre ações de gestão, ou seja, decidir sobre quais métodos a usar, serão apresentadas.

HOMED conducted a survey of more than 240 practitioners across Europe to learn more about their practices and needs in terms of tools and methods for the detection and identification of invasive forest pests and pathogens.

They suggested developing or improving the following methods of surveillance:

- Broad-spectrum traps to detect non-native insect pests in containers transporting live plants or wood packaging

- Drones to monitor forest defoliation.

- Smartphone applications and citizen science programmes to help detect new invasive pest of pathogens on trees (incl. in urban settings)

- Posters informing a wide audience of the risks of transporting tree pest contaminated material in airport lobbies and garden centers.

- Continuous training of personnel in charge of forest surveillance on new detection and identification techniques.

They suggested developing or improving the following methods of management:

- Use of locally sourced trees and tree seeds to avoid imports.

- Use of quarantine areas for imported plants for planting.

- Reinforced inspection of exported trees, imported trees and newly planted trees.

- Development of mixed species forests that are more resistant to invasion

- Fumigation procedure of imported potted trees, according to local legislation.

Affichage actuel du contenu de la page dans la langue maternelle, si disponible

Contacts

Project coordinator

Project partners

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner

  • Project partner